High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2221/2016allowed

Sarabjit Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2023-12-05Mrs. Justice Archana Puri7 pages

!$%&%"' !$!()!* + ,*)-% ,%'./

00011!22'

3,, , !

4'-) " /!*& 000!&1"'5!' & 67

,0 ,

*!&!'

*0,4&/%2 ,%'%+ 58"$ !

11!22' 0

*0&2!!'

94* ,%5/4+ + 4'-)0 ::::

)!!'

#%2!5 11!22' $2%(' + /!*!);+ &!!<%'.

!'/'$!(!'

$"(1!'& %"'+ =*5!5 2!*'!5

" "* $$%5!'

2%(&

*%)4'2+ &"'

)/%-"

,%'./+ .!5 ;!*&+

(" "* 8!/%$42* $$%5!' + =/%$/ 12$!

000 11*%&2 !8%5!'$!

)*"4./ *!$"*5+ 2!*'!5

/5 .*' !5 $"(1!'& %"'+ !> !'

&0++? 2"'.

=% / %' !*!& @ A ,"

#* #$ (''!* % & 12$!+ =!22 2%)%2% ;

#& !'!5 *!&1"'5!' &+ $"'$!*'!5+ 1!* %'!'

(!' %"'

11!2+ &4$/+ )!!'

#%2!5 1!*&"'&+ &"

2%)2!

$/22!'.!

=*5 /4&+ #%'5%'.& &"

*!$"*5!5 $"4' + 5"!& =**'

#4* /!* &$*4 %';0

)$<5*"1+ 2!*'!5 $"4'&!2 11!22' $2%('

&4)(% !5 .*' !5 11!22' + &"'

)/%-"

,%'./+ $$%5!' + (!.*!+ =/%$/ $22& !> !'&%8!

!'/'$!(!' 0 " /!* /'5+ 2!*'!5 $"4'&!2

$"(1';

*!#4 !5 $2%( 11!22' $2%(' + =/%2!

&&!* %'.

& %&#$ "*;

!8%5!'$!

)!!'

2!5 &!!< $"(1!'& %"'+ '"= %(1*!&&!5 /4&+ &4)(% & &'& (!*% 5!&!*8!& 5%&(%&&!50 ,4##%$!

$"'&%5!*+ 5%&1"&2 5!$!&!5 )/%-"

,%'./ &&!* !5 ;!*&+

%(!

$$%5!' 0

B/%2!

/"25%'.

5!$!&!5 '"'!*'%'.

1!*&"'+ )!%'.

$/%25 /8%'.

5%!5

/*!!

;!*&+ /"4./+ !*'%'.& /8!

)!!'

<!'

&0 +? ''4(+ )4 ?*5 5!54$ !5 $"4'

1!*&"'2 %'$"(!

<!'

&0+? ;

112;%'.

C D+ ("4'

)!!'

="*<!5 &0+ +?0

55% %"'

/!*! "+ '" /!* ("4'

&0+ ? .*' !5 !>1!'&!&+ &0 +? .*' !5+ "=*5& '" /!* &0+ ? .*' !5+ "=*5& !& !0

4 ';/"=+ &! 2!5 1*!82!'

&$!'*%"+ $"(1!'& %"'+ &"

="*<!5 2!*'!5

$22& !'/'$!(!' 0

*!.*5+

8!*;

"4 &! + 1!* %'!'

(!' %"'

"'6)2!

,41*!(!

"4* % 2!5 69%&/'

"12 '" /!* 8?& 72 " /!*&+ E

%8%2

F6+ =/%2!

$"'&%5!*%'.

$/%25+ .!5 '" %"'2 %'$"(!

5!$!&!5 &0+? 112%!5 6 6 $(!

&0E0 2</0

'" /!* &0 +? .%8!'

"=*5& 2"8!+ ##!$ %"'+ 2& *% !&0

$&!+ *!2 !5 ;!* GG0

8!'+ "'6)2!

,41*!(!

"4* % 2!5 H94*8'

'&*% 2%& 94*8'

2% '" /!* 8?& ,/;( 9%&/"*!

4*(4 '" /!*+ %8%2 11!2

"0G 5!$%5!5 00I $"'&%5!*!5 "25 $/%25+

(" "* 8!/%$42* $$%5!' + =/%$/ 12$!

;!* E $!* %'

")&!*8 %"'&+ =/%$/ 4'5!* H0 & $2%( 4'5!* ,!$ %"'

" "* 3!/%$2!& $ GJJ+ &%'$!

5!$!&!5 $/%25 !*'%'.

(!()!*+

$"'&%5!*!5 '" %"'2 %'$"(!

,$/!542!K

14*1"&!

#%>%'.

$"(1!'& %"'0

=*5!5 '" %"'2 %'$"(!

5!$!&!5

&0 +? ''4( 112;%'.

C D+ =*5!5 &0+ +? "=*5& 5!1!'5!'$;

=% / %' !*!& @ A ''4( #*"( 5 !

E , E

, EE

, -45.(!' 0 B/!'

11!2& 1*!#!**!5

"(1';

=!22 11!22' & /!*!%'+ %(14.'!5 $"(("'

-45.(!' + %./ "4* 5%&(%&&!5 1*!#!**!5

"(1';+ 1*!#!**!5 $2%(' &+ =/%2!

$"'#%*(%'.

=*5!5 5!1!'5!'$;

&0+ +?+ =*5!5

#4* /!* &4( &0 +? "=*5& $$"*5%'.2;

.*' !5

&0+E+? =% / %' !*!& @A ''4( 1;)2!

*!&1"'5!'

"(1';

1!*(% %'.

*!$"8!* &(!

#*"( !&1"'5!'

"0 "='!* (" "*$;$2!0 0

-45.(!'

4 ((

*&0+ "4* ")&!*8!5 !' *2 "8!*'(!'

)!& "=!5 =% / 54 %!& (!'5 ,$/!542!

8%!= ,!$ %"'

" "* 3!/%$2!& $ GJJ+ )4 #%2!5 5"

&"0

8%!= &(!+ &1!$%#%$ 5%*!$ %"'& =!*!

%&&4!5 !' *2

E "8!*'(!'

(<!

11*"1*% !

(!'5(!' & ,$/!542!

<!!1%'.

(%'5 $"& 2%8%'.0

&%5 -45.(!' + %22 &4$/ (!'5(!' & (5!+ 5%*!$ %"'& =!*!

%&&4!5 =*5 #%>%'.

&4( &0++? 41!!& "'!

2</ "'2;

"=*5& '"' !*'%'.

$/%25*!'

#%8!

"25

&4( &0+ +? 41!!& "'!

2</ #%# ;

/"4&'5 "'2;

'"' !*'%'.

1!*&"'& ("*!

#%8!

"250 0

090

2%<

'*0 2&"+ "4* ")&!*8!5 '" %"'2 %'$"(!

#%>!5 4'5!* ,!$ %"'

" "* 3!/%$2!& $ + GJJ &0 +? ''4( &/"425 !'/'$!5 %'$*!&!5 &(!

$"' %'4!5 !>%& =% /"4 ';

(!'5(!'

&%'$!

E00GGE0

9%&/'

"12

'*0 =/!*!

5!$!&!5

"25 $/%25+ "4* #%>!5 '" %"'2 %'$"(!

&0+? E0

$&!+ '" !5 0G0E0

&1% !

*!1! !5 5%*!$ %"'&+ ,$/!542!

(!'5!50

/!*!#"*!+ #%>%'.

'" %"'2 %'$"(!

&0 +? ''4( '"' !*'%'.

(!()!*& -4& *!&"')2!0 0

8%!= -45.(!' & $&!& 4 ((

*&0+ 090

2%<

'*0 9%&/'

"12

'*0+ =!

8%!=

#% %'$*!&!

'" %"'2 %'$"(!

%' "

%'#2 %"'+ 5!824 %"'

*41!!

$"& 2%8%'.0

8%!= &(!+ -45.(!'

-!'5* ,%'./

*&0 *!2%!5 2!*'!5 $"4'&!2 *!&1"'5!'

"0 "(1';

="425 *!'5!* ';

&&%& '$!

%'&4*'$!

$"(1';0I

8%!= #"*!&%5 ")&!*8 %"'&+ "4* '" %"'2 %'$"(!

5!$!&!5 $/%25 &0 +? ''4( 112%!5 6 6 1*!&$*%)!5 ,$/!542!

$2%(& 4'5!* ,!$ %"'

" "* 3!/%$2!& $ + GJJ ="*<!5 ("4'

&00F 2</+ "=*5& 5!1!'5!'$;0

!&%5!& &(!+ &0E+? !$/ .%8!'

$2%(' &+ =/"

=!*!

'4()!*+ "=*5& #%2%2 &0 +? .%8!'

"=*5& !>1!'&!&0

="*<!5 &0E+F+?0 &4)-!$ + % 2!5 !!'

!8% 8?&

4'4 /'5

/ "

!($/'5

/ "

" /!*&+ E

%8%2

6 "'6)2!

,41*!(!

"4* /5 $"'&%5!*!5 "25 $/%25+

(" "* 8!/%$42* =/%2!

.*' %'.

/5 ")&!*8!5 1*%'$%12!

2%5 5"='

9%&/'

"126& &41* 1 2;

112%$)2!

#$ & %'

/'5 /4&+ '" %"'2 !*'%'.& &0+? %'$245%'.

#4 4*!

1*"&1!$ & 112;%'.

6 6+ 8%!= 5!$%&%"'

"4* 1&&!5 66,( 0,*2 3!*( 8&0 !2/%

*'&1"* "*1"* %"'

'*0+ G

%8%2

FF6+ 5!1!'5!'$;

="*<!5 &0E+ +? 55% %"'

&0 +? 4'5!* $"'8!' %"'2 /!5& /4&+ ="*<!5 &0 ++? "'&%5!*%'.

#"*!&%5+ '"= *!8!* %'.

/'50 !

'" !5

"(1';

/5 $/22!'.!5 =*50

$&!+ /'5+ /5 <!'

12$!

00 2&"

$"'&%5!*%'.

5 !

9%&/'

"126& &41* 824!

*41!!

$"(!

5"='

5*& %$22;0

%' "

$"'&%5!* %"'+ #"*!&%5 #$ "*&+ ("5!& !& %( !+ '" %"'2 !*'%'.& 5!$!&!5+ /'5+ $'

&#!2;

<!'

&0+?

/4&+ $"'&%5!*%'.

5!$!&!5+ 112%!5 $&!+ /'5+ 6 6 &"

$2$42 %'.+ 5!1!'5!'$;

$"(!& &0E+ +?0

!&%5!& #"*!&%5+ ("4' & 1%5 $"'8!' %"'2 /!5&+ &4$/ 2%<!+ !& !+ /!25 *';

,! /%6& &41*

.( !'!*2

"(1';

7%(% !5 8&0

'4 ( @ /4/*4 ( " /!*&+ J J

, 6+

$"'$!1 $"'&"* %4(+ )!!'

5%2 !5 5! %2+ =/!*!%'+ )!!'

/!25 #%2%2 *%./ 1*!' & $"(1!'& %"'+ $$%5!' 2

$/%250

$"'&"''$!

=% / ")&!*8 %"'& *';

,! /%6& &41* # !* (<%'.

55% %"'

A+ # !* /*!!

#*"( 5 !

1&&%'.

-45.(!' + ("4'

1;)2!+

1*!&!' + $"4'

C2"&& $"'&"* %4(D !> !'

&0EJ+E? !$/ $2%('

C2"&& !& !D =!22 C#4'!*2 !>1!'&!&D+ &0J+ ?+ !$/ $"4' 0 "'&%5!*%'.

&(!+ 1;)2!

11!22' $2%(' + )/%-"

,%'./+ *!11*%&!5+ /!*!%'

.%8!' 7"&& 5!1!'5!'$;

&0E+ +? 7"&&

&0EJ+E? 7"&& !& !

&0J+ ?

4'!*2 &0J+ ?

&0 +E+F? & &4$/+ !'/'$!5 $"(1!'& %"'+ # !* 5!54$ %"'

=*5!5

$"(!& &0 +E+F ++L&0+FE+F?0

!'/'$!5 ("4'

%0!0 &0+FE+F?+ 11!22' $2%('

&/22 !' % 2!5 %' !*!& +

* !

A ''4(+ #*"( 5 !

#%2%'.

11!2+ %22 *!2%M %"'

!'/'$!5 ("4'

$"(1!'& %"'0

%(14.'!5 =*5 5 !5 F0E0E & '5& ("5%#%!5+ !> !' + %'5%$ !5 #"*!&%5 *!(%'%'.

!*(& =*5 &/22 *!(%'

&(!0

F B% / )"8!

")&!*8 %"'&+ & '5& 22"=!50 !$!()!* +

3.42 % B/! /!* &1!<%'.?*!&"'!5 !& B/! /!* *!1"* )2!