Umed Singh v. Shyam Singh & ANR

 
     

 !"# $#%&'&()*

  +#$,&(-. //#00!(" 1#2'3' ,.4!+,&(-.!($!(".#2 #'/($#("' 



 


2#'#(") ' .!5(!2#6!07$5%!"# 2 2,8 !$!57$5%!"# 2".#!//#00!(" (# 22#'/($#(" 2!9#'. !('!07$5%!"# 22#'/($#(" :('32!(%# +/!(4






.&'!//#!0.!';##( &0#$;4".#%0!&+!("'##<&(-#(.!(%#+#(" ".#%+/#('!"&(!6!2$#$".&+;4".#0#!2(#$"2%%&$#("0!&+' 2&;3(!07 !2(!30 =2&;3(!0> 2 '.2" 5&$# !6!2$ $!"#$

*

 ( !%%3(" &(932&#'!($$&'!;&0&"4'3

#2#$;4.&+&(!+"25#.&%0#!%%&$#(" ( 



2&# !%"' (#%#''!24 2 !$93$&%!"&(   ".# %!'# !2# ".!" ! /#"&"&( 3($#2 ,#%"&( ??   "2 1#.&%0#' %" 6!' /2# #22#$ ;4 ".# !//#00!(" '##<&(- %+/#('!"&( ( !%%3("   ".# &(932&#' !($ $&'!;&0&"4 '3

#2#$;4.&+.#!//#00!("6!'&(505#$&(!+"25#.&%0#!%%&$#("(  

6.#(.#6!'-&(- 2+1&00!-# .9!6!'"6!2$8!(&(!(.&' +"2%4%0# ;#!2&(- @ @ *  A.#( ".# !//#00!(" 2#!%.#$ "#0&@ 8!(&(! 2!$ (#!2 1&00!-# .9!6!'7 ".# 

#($&(- +"2@%4%0# ;#!2&(- 2#-&'"2!"&(@
@ B;#&(-$2&5#(;42#'/($#("&(!2!'.!($ (#-0&-#("+!((#2%!+# 2+".# 2("!($'"23%<!-!&('".&'+"2%4%0#(

 !%%3(" ".#'!&$!%%&$#("7!//#00!("'3'"!&(#$-2&#53'&(932&#'2&5#2 ".# 

#($&(- +"2@%4%0#:2#'/($#("  0#$ 2+ ".# '/"
 6!' 2#-&'"#2#$!" 0&%#,"!"&(8!(&(!!-!&('"2#'/($#("( 

" 6!'/0#!$#$".!"".#%0!&+!("!"".#"&+# !%%&$#("6!'

4#!2'0$!($ 6!'62<&(-!'&2%0#(%.!2-#&(8C+/!(4C"$7$2!6&(-!'!0!24 '

:@/#2+(".+/#('!"&(6!'7".3'7/2!4#$ 2 .#0#!2(#$2&;3(!0(%('&$#2!"&( ".# !%"'!($#5&$#(%# (2#%2$.#0$".!"".#!%%&$#("&(D3#'"&("</0!%#$3#"".#2!'.!($ (#-0&-#(" $2&5&(-   ".# 

#($&(- 5#.&%0# ;4 &"' $2&5#2 .#2# &' ( $&'/3"# 2#-!2$&(-".#!;5#'!&$ &($&(- ".#0#!2(#$2&;3(!0(".&'&''3#76.&%. .!'!""!&(#$ &(!0&"4 .#0#!2(#$2&;3(!0%(%03$#$".#!-# ".#!//#00!("";# 4#!2'!"".#"&+# !%%&$#("!($.&'&(%+#!'' 

:@/#2+("..# 0#!2(#$2&;3(!0 32".#2!''#''#$".#/#2+!(#(" 3(%"&(!0$&'!;&0&"4 ".# !//#00!("!' E.#2# 2#7".#""!0&(%+# ".#!//#00!("6!'!''#''#$ !" ' 7? 7

:@  

F F? C#!2(#$ 2&;3(!07 !

"#2 "!<&(- &(" %('&$#2!"&( E/#2+!(#(" 3(%"&(!0$&'!;&0&"4 ".#!//#00!("7!''#''#$ ".#0'' 3"32#&(%+#!'' 7

:@.#""!0!+3(" %+/#('!"&( !6!2$#$"".#!//#00!("&'"!;30!"#$!'3($#2)@
 

     #$&%!0#F/#('#' ' 7 :@

!&(!($'3

#2&(- '

 ,/#%&!0$&#" '

2!('/2"!"&( ' 7

 3"32#&(%+# ' 7

? !+#(&"&#' '7

 * &(%+# '




7B*7   '3+   ' 7B*7 :@ 6!' !6!2$#$ !' %+/#('!"&( " ".# %0!&+!("!0(-6&".&("#2#'"G?E/#2!((3+ 2+".#$!"# &0&(- %0!&+ /#"&"&( "&00 2#!0&'!"&( .# /2#'#(" !//#!0 .!' ;##( &0#$ '##<&(- #(.!(%#+#(" ".#!

2#'!&$%+/#('!"&( C#!2(#$ %3('#0 2 ".# !//#00!(" '3;+&"' ".!" 3(%"&(!0 $&'!;&0&"4 ".#!//#00!("'.30$;#!''#''#$!'

E!'.#0'"5&'&( ;". .&' #4#' C#!2(#$ 2&;3(!0 .!' #22#$ &( !''#''&(- ".# 3(%"&(!0 $&'!;&0&"4   ".# !//#00!(" !'  E .# !//#00!(" 0'" .&' 9; $3# " ".# $&'!;&0&"4 '3

#2#$ 2#5#27 +#!-2# %+/#('!"&( .!' ;##( !6!2$#$ ( !%%3("   /!&( !($ '3

#2&(-' #"% " &' ".3' /2!4#$ ".!" %+/#('!"&( !6!2$#$"".#!//#00!(";##(.!(%#$ C#!2(#$%3('#0 2".#('32!(%#+/!(4/2!4' 23/.0$&(- ".#%+/#('!"&(;#&(-93'"& &#$&(".# !%"'!($%&2%3+'"!(%#' ".#%!'#  .!5# .#!2$ 0#!2(#$ %3('#0 2 ".# /!2"&#' !($ .!5# -(# ".23-.".# &0# .#2# &' ( $&'/3"# ".!" $3# " ".# !%%&$#(" &( D3#'"&(7 ".# !//#00!(" '3

#2#$ 

E $&'!;&0&"4 D3! .&' 5&'&( A? 2 ,!(9!4 &'.(& /25#$".#$&'!;&0&"4%#2"& &%!"#F A?:C#!2(#$%3('#0 2".#('32!(%# +/!(4&'3(!;0#"$#(4".!"".#%0!&+!(":!//#00!("6!'5&'3!004$&'!;0#$

2+;".#4#'$3#"".#!%%&$#("&(D3#'"&(6#5#27".#2#&'(".&(-( 2#%2$" &($&%!"#".!"".#!//#00!(" 6!'#!2(&(- !'3+   '

:@/#2 +(". 6.&0# 62<&(- !' &2%0# (%.!2-# 6&". 8C +/!(4 C"$ 32-!( C#!2(#$ %3('#0 2 ".# !//#00!(" &' 3(!;0# " /&(" 3" !(4 #5&$#(%# " &($&%!"# ".!" !//#00!(":%0!&+!(" 6!' #!2(&(- !( !+3(" .&-.#2 ".!( ".#

  &(%+#!'!''#''#$;4".#0#!2(#$2&;3(!0&#' 

:@/#2+("./!2"

2+ 5&'3!0&+/!&2+#("7".# !//#00!("7&"&' !&204'"!"#$ $#'("'3

#2!(4 ".#2/.4'&%!0$&'!;&0&"4%!3'#$$3#"".#&(932&#''3

#2#$&(".#!%%&$#("( ".#!;5#'!&$ !%"'!($%&2%3+'"!(%#'7&"&'%('&$#2#$!//2/2&!"#"!''#'' ".# 3(%"&(!0$&'!;&0&"4 ".#!//#00!("";#*E C''  &(%+#&'".3' !''#''#$ !' 

F*EH '*:@ /#2 +(". +/#('!"&( " ".# !//#00!("&'2#D3&2#$";#2#62<#$&("#2+' ".#-3&$#0&(#'0!&$$6(;4 ".#(I;0#,3/2#+#32"&(,4#$,!$&D#"%5&5&'&(!0!(!-#27(&"#$ ($&!('32!(%#+/!(47  

(%2#!'#&(&(%+#(!%%3(" 3"32#/2'/#%"'!"".#2!"#

E7"!<#'".#&(%+#"J*K
*F ELH' * :@/#2+(".&#7 '?7*

:@ /#2 !((3+ -#   ".# !//#00!(" 6!'   4#!2' !" ".# 2#0#5!(" "&+#7".#2# 2#7+30"&/0&#2 ?&'";#!//0&#$C'' #!2(&(-'&'7".3'7 !''#''#$!''B7 *7

:@JB7 *7

F
?L #$&%!0 #F/#('#'   ' 7 :@ !' !6!2$#$ ;4 ".# 0#!2(#$ 2&;3(!0(".#;!'&' #5&$#(%#/2$3%#$(2#%2$7!2#+!&("!&(#$'3+  '7

:@ &('"#!$   '

:@ &' !

2$#$ ( !%%3("   /!&( !($ '3

#2&(-' +/#('!"&( !6!2$#$ "6!2$' '/#%&!0 $&#"7 "2!('/2"!"&( &' +!&("!&(#$'7

:@&'!

2$#$(!%%3(" 0'' !+#(&"&#'&('"#!$  '7

:@  '3+   '7

:@ &' !6!2$#$ "6!2$' !""#($!(" %.!2-#'C'' &(%+# '

:@&'!0'+!&("!&(#$ .3'7 ".# %0!&+!(" &' #("&"0#$ " %+/#('!"&( !' $#"!&0#$ .#2#3($#2)@
 

    #$&%!0#F/#('#' ' 7 :@

!+#(&"&#' '7

 ""#($!("%.!2-#' '7

 ,/#%&!0$&#" '

 2!('/2"!"&( ' 7

?

!&(!($'3

#2&(- '7

* &(%+# '

3"32#&(%+# 'B7 *7




7* 7? :@  .#!+3(" %+/#('!"&(!02#!$4!6!2$#$"".#!//#00!("7 (##$0#''"'!47'.!00'"!($$#$3%"#$ 2+".#!+3("%!0%30!"#$!'!;5# //#00!("'.!00;##("&"0#$"&("#2#'"!"".#2!"# *E/#2!((3+(".# #("&2# %+/#('!"&( !+3(" 2+ ".# $!"#  &0&(-   ".# /#"&"&( "&00 2#!0&M!"&( A&".".#!;5#'!&$+$& &%!"&(&(".#!6!2$$!"#$

*

7 /2#'#("!//#!0&'$&'/'#$




 %";#2*7

 '.6!2 A.#".#2'/#!<&(-:2#!'(#$)@ #': A.#".#22#/2"!;0#)@ #':