← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5588/2017dismissed

Dinesh Kumar & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2021-10-25Mr. Justice Arun Monga14 pages

   

  !"#"$"%""" "$ " & ' 

$ (() * +

 

           & ' ,

,

& -.'



           &/'  ,/

& -.' 

          &0' ,/ /

& -.'  

           &' 

& -.' 



        

 &,'  1,

& -.'

           & ' 

& -.' !"   #            &' 

, ,

& -.'  $          &1'  ,///

& -.' #           &

'   

& -.' !

           &

'   0//

& -.'  % 

          

/ &

'  

1

& -.' 

          & /'  

& -.' !           & 0'   //,,

& -.' 

          & '  

,1

& -.'          & ,'   /1,

& -.'  "

             ".) 2#3.4!

5"

.

 " &' ( %) *! + * ( 

*! + * (  *! + * (!

 *! + *   (

 ! *! + * ( ) *! + * (!

 *! + * ($    *! + *

0 (! ) *! + * ( %  *! + * (( % ) *! + * ( ( %*! +  (, 

*! + * (,

" *! + *  -. (

" (  *!)*   ( ( %*! +    ( 

 *! + *  -/0'1232'345/0'4613'34.* ,736/0'7788'34 (!  )  *! + * ,1/0'4613'34 ,9 4/0'316'34 (! 

*! + * ,/0'7788'34 (   

*! + * ,3 /0'7788'34 66666 "

.

 "+!    +

 :

* /0 ,7788* 131 -;5(.*1232*439*4261*4613*8312*31222*316*3311*3348*32211* 3984*39272*378 364634 " *  +     

 < 

+ * +

  =      "   +     

      *    > +    > '

+ ! + 2  +++ ++       /0, 778834 23  ,       + /

 -        /

.*      3337

 !?

'3 328! +  +    62'298@2 )        <   "+  & .

A'     + B A :C       + C  (+ " "

C + B" )   .

( +< 

* .

    : %:E    ( +       +  ; .



  ! + 

+   + B A :C       D +   C      (+  "  " 

  C  + B "   )   .

3@?

   "    +*/     .

    : %:E    ( +       +  ! &'9  2   "*  0?

 

  23431  +       ?

 * +   * + + +

   ?  31234  38234  + !?

 '2    +   +

*    +   

 !(   +  +   

*  '

 A'

 *    %    ?

   +      "

+    + !?

 '9" +  /

   !(  +    +   " +      ! +  =     '

A'

 +    " +  *  !?

 '7  +    "< 

    > "   !(+   

,

"+   :



'

+*      "  <  22   !(  

  "

  +  ?   +  +    !  !(  ++ B(+   *"

     <    +  +      '

! += 

! +

+ +     

      <    +

 +  ! +  *  +<

     

 +    <

:+ *

  +   

     "       "        +   :   +      + !(    +     "    <

 #"  *

+   *



*       +*    +               +   "+  " "<   *  + +   "       *    * +       + +  "     + + +* 

      +     "      + *    ! < + B  

'

A'

 +  <   " ! +!(+  +  %  +  +   +   " +         % <

     +  +    + 

 !( 

 ! +  "          + F  +         +    ! + 9 ;+ ,3 9   *      "   "

+ "  / 4

/1

 895:;4 5<+ 5  5=( ::((+ < +  33:3737*        +       <

+  + "    < <

+  7 

              

 *    !(  *  <     

 <

+                '

 A'

   + *    +  +  ! +  1 !     8634

   "      +    B    +  "       " +  "     

 !(+ + +   

+    +    + *      )   ! + / *

%    

     +    + A

  + 

! +

+ +     +  +  "       !(*           !( + "+  "   <

  "     ! +(+ * 

 4  

 *  

 1334

"A * + *      )   ! + / *

%      &

    

 

 ! "# $!    %$ &

  

         

 %  ' (# )  $  * #* )  +   ,  !      ) ! # (#  ) ! #,    ) !  ,   ,      

) 

 !"#  $!    $ !!    %$ &  -  . %$ &%$ &/ #$!      #   $!      &  + 0! $!1 /+,  

    %$ &

     $! #3        4

  5$5*67  ! 5$5*68    %$ & $! #3    /       !   ! /     %$ &        $! #3    9        !  : 8 $ *   83334

 "    +        ,  -  /  / +  C  (+*,  .   +  

    

1      !( + "+ "

  <

  "     ! + (+ *  6 !++ *,    -

 

. 

 34   &

;7.

11$;<7=/  5/      %$ &        9 #$!    

 .   #  $! /   %$ &   99/     #$!  : 3 D +*+34 "  +

&' 





           >;&   ! $/ 9 &/

? &  9  &* .   @&!!@8/   .    9 &*  1* .

/>   '/& /, ;A B   ! 0!     )  . &)                 9   9 )   !!9 5 - .C!$/;87@; ;87@/  .   DE  6@ />  

.  &* . .  &    / 

  $/    9)  !   

 

             .    &

     .     & *   . )  

. &

 /    

     $/  & *   .

    /    

 /     .  !)  

 . 1 $/ ;<-2 ;=@  ;<-2A    

     @ $B/ 9 &  $   $     !   !  6 @        5   /       5     / 

:

33 

    

+*C  +     

 + + :  3 $ +  +   "       +  +          

  ! + 

+:A'

  +  + +    !(:)!(*       + F    !(:)!(   :<   + B +:  ! +:A'

 F      %  "    :   "+ :    +  32  + *   +             + =     !(:)!(   +  A

5

! +

++    

   C (+F    +  !(:)!(

+    + +               

 +   ! + 

+:A'

 F !(:)!( <

+  +  

   +      

  ! + 

+ +   =  <

+           

  ! + 

+:A'

     

      <

+  

:  "



   +           ! + * + <  <

+  

: 

+      "+  ++       ?+  !(:)!( +   +     :

  " ! + 39   "

 + + *              !(:)!( +    <

+  

 ! +

+:A'

 G 37 ! * !(  )!( +   < 

   + 

 

+ ! +

+:A'

  

   C    (+ =        +  

+     

+ C  !(      +  +       

 +   ! + 

+:A'

   *   +   "

?     

+  

 C  (+ 31 C  + *   <         C +   +   /0 , 326:33   89 5:  ;45<+5 5=(::((+8>= +33:3737" / C + * *

* +   +  ,9

 77 !   %  + *  "  !



#-   

* + .*  &

$ /E - /---23 ! %$ & /   

   / /  ! %$ &       9     

 !          #      !/    

!   

      

  

: C

+      "



 "      %"  +' "+ 895:?-  . 34 !     "

 " !? / 

  5   <;4"*>=  @+

,&

'5

/*    

   " <          A  

  A     A'

    + B A :   C     (+ !     ? ?+         A  (+     =    "   

  

&' H2 F !  

1 $ 

     

 1     $!3     01&!*/ ;<<7/ 55     &        #  $ /   !   99   G !3.% / /          #  $  !         9 9  F/  /          

 1     6&   !   #         1   !    !I

/ 38 !(            

  ! + 

+:A'

   " !?/ 

  "*>=

 @ 36 C* * +     

 

  +     +  +             !(:)!( +  'J'

  

! + 

+:A'

     +    

 <    ! 

 +<

 

  "   *  % *<  

"   ! * %  ?

 * +    + +  + "

  +      < =    + * +  " 

"   *    + 3 C %A @>:  4 B4 ;:     4

/& '5  + "   +   *   <  <

+  "   ! = + 

 + 

==ED +

 " &' H$  . 

 &  3 !  !  !  ..

      (* %. .   9!      3 ! ! 9   

!  .. (    1    

  $    H  !!   ! I

0    "     * "  E 

:   +  " +      !  = + *  <  + 

+ "   =   E  ==E      E 

:  +  " +"

   <

+ "+

 ! = +    ==E

  "  E +  =    + "+ = 

*  *   +     = "  *+ "   

        +     +      

  ! + +  +          +    

  ! + 2 !   " + *    9 , + 7  + " +  +++  &"

.

 "' !

$ 

* +

 :

 0   % : &K:, 0   "&K:,