← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2091/2012disposed of

Sukhbir & Others v. State Of Haryana And Another

2015-11-05Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain6 pages

 

       

 

     

 !"#!# $$%% &

'#(!# $   ! "#$%&

'()*+& ,&(-*".% )#

*# !!#+&+ #!%,# *#"!!-+&.#%+'#(

,&(-*".%/

/!012,%%$ 

 +3+ 4

/ 43 45+344345 0/!2#

226 7(  %1  !  $#  $$%+  !  %,#  #   1 !2 2$ #!6#%  7# %(+!  !#!&   5+# !6+ 3

#!#+ 8!8+ '#(1!6#%2#1

#

&%%1#($#!#&%%1+/!%7!#1#!+#-!00#+

## 9# $$%(!% #2:*5 43 4  4 !, 4 5/! 6%%#

#!#+8!%%#8&,# 3   52$;   4+ + <=$##  ,!!,#  !%%#+!% ,# % "0> # ##   !+!%##"%,&,#   +$!%!,# !%%#?!,#,!!

!"2$1" #!#"(!%,#!$#

$$%

 #% #!%,#"2!!%# #  "%,  !  ,#1%(  #0  !  %2   !  %,#    ! %%#!,#0 #2$ #!6#% 9!%1!2$+!%%#!#! %$%( !%/!%  #22#% #%$#$?%#!" !&%%1? #-!00#=@ 1#! '1!,(#!"## %!

?$$# !$%!!&% !%"( !  %%#  "%,  ,    0    #+  %#  %  #  ! %,#$%#%$%=+AB) AB)+,!!,# #1#  

 5+#$&%(C%=+AB) +

#!%2#1

 % 52#% &%%1#($#+!% #  $  ,  + + + <=  C  %=+  AB)+  % 2#1 "1! ", &%%1!+/!%@ 1#!+, %

 5 #!%#  +35++ <='% # ##%+B#= +&,!! %2#% % $#1&%%1#($#+,% #43+ + <=   4 *<%'#( AD22$(' #!#"2! !1!!%$#1! #%= #21$#

!6#%+"%%,%%"( %#$ !#%#%("%!!&% !%!# ' #!# "2!& %=+AB) +,#1# #!

 !+!2&#(,%%"#% $ #!$#$ 2 2$ #$$%  #"%+!1!# $ 4 9!%# ##1!$%"(!.&#2

'#(+%#% #!%,#"2!!$#   !  ,#    !  %%#  ,         222# #6 %!#6,##

#2  4+ + <=$##   + + <=$##&$%(

+$$%"% #25 ',&#+%%!%,#! $#    !&  "  ,#  %(  4+ + <=  $#  #   2$',&#+!%##"%,!%%!

 #$#$#%( 5 >!!#!+%#% #! "2! !2 2$,#!%,#"(!%%# !$#0 #/!#,1&%"(! %,# #!2 2$ #!6#% $%!,1!% !%!%=,$#

%=  +AB) +!#1!%("1#"(!%# #"%,,$ %/!%$#1 %=+AB)+ !%#1!%("1#,"%11 &%%1  !+  /!%  @ 1#!  9!%  # 1  !  "2  ,!

#1#%   4+B#= + *<% '#( AD22$(+!"2!!%$#!,

#11!% #&%$2 $%A2D ,#2%#?,#"1!  %',&#+ !$! !!222#$#& #6 %!#,##& #2 4+ + <=$## + + <= $##&$%(

  '#%#% #!$#$#!$$#= " 

$%!"$#"(!# !$#!, !% !6#%!%$#1%=#% $ "(!2? !" !# +%  !%    " 2$#/!%=$###"(!%,#AB)

  "#%$ #!$#$ 2

2$!2,#1#"6!

 !  5 #%=+ AB)+#+!%$#1!#"%1&%%1!+ /!%@ 1#!'+!2"#%$

 #%=+B#    4+&,!!

%,$#!"(*<%'#( AD2$(+&!2 "#%$"1#2%# #!#!! 2$(!$#!"1!  % #11!% # &%$2 $%A2D?(+!%#

3 $!#,+ + <=$##%(

?    2  !  !  .&#2    '#(  !   $% +43 5

B1222# # 6 %! '#(/!$%( , #&43 5/!#%&B# $%(+43 5+ # = "

B %## #!6 % #$"%$#$! '#( 

/!$#2*2  == = <  3

+3           C!$#2*2## #+ 222 %## #6#1% #$"%$#$

#&#$#2,%%!# 1 ,# B"(!'#(.&#2 %%,

*22 %## ##""%# .#1 

 %$##   *22  %#  #  #  #    ! '#(  "=1      %1 )! %# !1#!$#$!#( !'#(   %$## *22 %## #!# ! '#(    %$##

/! %##%!%2# $("%#!$#& !6+

3 ,!""#&!,!!$1

22# # !%!&#"%%( /!# #+  '#(  .&#2  !  #=#  ! 2#!#= B! %## %%,

*22 %## ##""%# .#1   %$##   *22  %#  #  #  #    ! '#(  "=1      %1 )! %    #    !1#!

$#$!#(!'#(   4 %$## *22 %## #!# ! '#(    %$##

   /! %##%!%2 #  $("%  #  !  $#&    !   6+ /!#&#,%%"$$%"%%%! 6,!#,#!&"# #  5  ##$&    !         #

!6+ 3E

$#! #%#43 5+!222 %# #!#6, B; 4+ + <=$##!# #$$%"% #%%!6,!#,#!&" # # 5+##$&  

!

 /! #$%(43 5, #!##&"(! .&#2 '(&.@ 

B1 222 %## % ##21!2$!  '#(/!#%&B# !$%(# =  

                        ,!! %2

.#1*$%#$#    !

3   !

,! ! %2 #"*$%#$#+  ! %2 )! %*$% #$#      5 +   &%$2  )%     .#1= *#  F#"  2$%B  B%1  ! # %%1,!!%2 *$% #$#.#1 " !+ 

$=:%F#"2$%B  4  !

   !

 #    ,!  !  &%$2 )%    7!#1#!+  ! +  ,#+ !#!#+7,%)$,  4  !

   !

 !%$%1+# !%2 )! % *$%#$#  5  )! %#+!% ,!!&%$2)% %%!# #!6##!  4  !

   !

  !

21)# !    !

   !

4

$#%  #$%!,! #2!(# 5 ! '#(% !#!&% !%! #6 #2 4+ + <= + + <=$##?# $#2! #!21$,$%,%%2 +4

/! 21$!$#"&2!? ! #2  #!21$+!2$2 4+45+34  +,!!

#

 4+4+ <=$##

#!#2"&+!$$%#%%,/! %,##,#2$; 4+4+ <=$##/!(!%% %"%%%!#(" &%"%!2#!

  ,&(-*".%

1(   '.2&