Dimpal Bhardwarja And ANR. v. Haryana Staff Selection Commission
!"# $%&
'( )* +
+# !!
,"
+% +!
'( )* +
+# !!
,"
-./
+ 01
'(
)*
," .
.
/
*1 +!
'(
)*
,"
.
/
$
'(
)*
,"
-
+(! 0
'(
)*
," ---
&( 2(!
'(
)*
," /
33 /
/
!"# $%&
'( 4 2( 1
," -
. -
$
'( 5("
,"
+4 5*#6 74
"
.
/ .
/
/ . -6 -
, # 16 +
74
+( # )6 746
+! # 16 74
"
---
#6 +
74
84 + 9 7 %#6 74
+ 9 : 6 74
"
7 $#*6 74
"
-./
+! +96 7#
)*
,9(; 8&"#6 74
"35:<
+# # +;#16 74
" : .
-
" :
.
/
.
7(9 5*#6 74
" : 6
6 6 .6 /
---
=
5*#6 74
" : -
---
,4 # 16 74
" :
---
+ ( 6 74
" :
--- >>>>
$* 6
% " ; 9 : 6
6 -./ .
/6 .
/6 - ---
% !" " ; 9 33 /
/6 . -6 ## "
0 (#
" !
% %## !" " 4 #* ; "
!!
9 6 ?(
?( 4#
?(#
"("
"" ! ;
8
% " 4
# # ! 9 ?(# ?( 4# +
)! + 6 * # ;
"" ! "
5( 8
)! +
)*
/
6 )* +
+# !! ( ( ! 4 9 ""#
## 9 ("
- "
5( 8
)! +
5("$ +4
)* "
%
8 # ?(# " ( ! (
! "# $ !%& '()!* "*!*+,-* ./ @ " "
%6 ! !(!
?(# ?( 6 % !
8 (#
( ! A! #
:
" " 9
+
)! +
" " 9 +
@ :( % + 01 " 9 +
BA B( 6 +(! 0 $ " 9 +
@ +4 9!6 &( 2(! ( , " 9 +
@ + 8#9* % 8(& " 9 +
@ 8#9*
8 " 4 ## (" # ?(#
?( 4# +
)! +
8 4
5( 8
)* 94 )* +# B(
5(" +4 ,(#6
7 " ,(#6 ! !(!
?(#
"
5( 8
)! + % 4 C
7## % " ; 9 "
3 "# ?(#
" ?( 4#
@(6 "# 4 ! 9 C * ?( 4# ?(# 6 (# * ( A
) # (#
" ;# "( "" ;1
0 (#
" *
6 " ! ?(# % 4 +
@ :( ?( 4# ?(# % # ""
3
( 6 % # % 9
7A( .
: ---
(*
4 0# < 4 *6 + 6 " ?(# ?( 4#
3
( +!
(" , ! # ?(# 6 "" %
+
#6 +
74 " 9 +% +!6 BA" !! ( " 4 9 4 "
4(
)
( 4 ( ( # 1 2((1 < 4 *6 < 4 * 5 !!
9 C ; ?(# ?( 4#
8 ! 9 (# 4 " 9(!
,
# 16
#6 +
74
6 +
+! +96 7#
)*6 A
"%
&( # 4 %6 9 ( A" 9 ?(
?( 4#
?(#
) (;! ?(
?( 4#
?(#
( ! ! % (# ; # !"#*6 ( ! 9* A"
) # (" % &(9! " )D;# +("!
!
"#
$%&'((
+
7(9 5*#6 746 (;! " " ?(# ?(
) (;! " +4 ,(#6 ?( ! 9 +
)! + "4
9 C 9 * ?( 4# ?(#
) # " " 9
+
)! + 6 6 * 4 #* 9
)
( (;! 4
% 6 %9#* "" 6 #
%(# # " 9 # !
"" !6 " (##* % 4 ! " ##* "4 %
) (;! %9 !! ,( ! 79* !* (# !4#
# 9 ;# 6 %46 %(# * 9
4(
" 1 "" !
4 9 # (#
" #96
4 % =(9 $
)D;# +("! 9 ## "
! # ?( 4# ?(# !
"" ! (# ; # B!"#* (;& A"
6 )D;# +("! 9 ( ! "
7
B(
8 ?( ! (# ;
B(
8 ?( % B
?( 4#
B(
8 ,( 9 79* 1 9 "
A"6 #
B( B
?( 4#
/ "("
( !
"
7
8 ( (##* ##9 ; ) 9
)%46 +("! 4
) 9
" 6
! % ?( % ?( %6 ;( # ( 01!. &*!
*
22& !
.*!.3&3 4%& &3
&&% *
5%& & &
6 * !! -% & * * !&
&! &6 *!!
**! !
& !!2*6!2 -*& 3.&
2*
5 !
.* * %& & ! & !!7 8 *.*&
*& *
&%%&!* * &332%&&%!&!3 *
!3.*
5
'1& & *-%&!
.* *
5 &. 9&.* 33.&*!
&, :&* &**23&&*2&* 33&$" *3 **2-%.
%&&, 3* 23&- *!& *-; *3 5( ( !*!
! ! &
<- & 3 *&.
* 3. & " %& * !
%&* 2& *. & *&43:
*
* " 23&* 3
=1 . -%&&!* ! 3 2* 343
- -*3.&*- * 8 && * 6 *3.-*& &6 * 2
.%&&6 * * !
**!&! &
& *-4!
*!*-** &%* . !&%1!.**&
*! >&* :&! ;&* & 3& %&& & %& &
? * & !
.* *%&.< * %&< 3<@3 &!* ! 3 /
6 )D;# +("! (# !#* # ) 9 !! 9
!"#* ( 9 9*
+ ##
(6 E 7! ,D
+("6 +("! # ( 51**
*!%&&* * %&&& 3 &4!A.BB&
3 < : & A.BB *& *- ; ( :3 & *2%3 *!
3*%*& &&*<
*. *9
&< &*23%*2< & * * < * !***! . & & !
.* * *3 & < 3.8 *& **4*-%6 &!3 & * *3< !*.2<- < !*%&&3*! 6* & %* 4 *-% 1&&*
**< &* &3** <- !* * & 2 & ** &*.2*! & A.BB*
*.**%&&&&&&* < *
&< %* < &3 &*& * ! **&!!8& -%&!*2&C- && &*% 4 *-* &4!&* A!& &&
!& * *3< 1*** & &C- &/ 2" 9 4 %
6
4 % "( ?( ; ! !"#* 54! ,( 9 79*6 1
# "
: (;6 !!
A" ! "
- "(
8 BA" !!
( ?(#
&( 2(! 6 ( , 8(& ?( 4# ?(#
)%46 % ;#%6 " 9 +
)! +
@ :( 6 +
)! +
@6 :(
6 +
)! +
)(!
4#"! @! #* ,#
?( 4# 9 +
)! + " <5 :!
6 !" 9 "
!
< 4 * 5 !! " ;(
#6 ;(9 !!
1 "# * 9 4 ( "
2" 9 4 %
6 "
% " " ! " 9 "1 9 9 9 ""( *
9 " "* ##* 4 (##*
3 A" %(# "(
#6 #4#
+* B( #9% (;& BA" ! % "
!
8 % !" "
6 :
/ % %
.
/
)%46 6 ""#
4 4# ## " 9
; !" " 6 " !"# !
% % ( 4 !"#
+ 6 % " #
; 9 " 6 !
% !9
# &(9!
)6
""" "
( !" "
7 9#*6 ## " "
7## " 9 ! ##( ""# 6
*6 " 4 %
&(9!
% !"#!"$%&"'()*+,$"'%-*"./ "%,- !"#!"$$"&-$#'01"/ "%,-