← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/31002/2018disposed of

Baljit Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab And Others

2019-04-23Mr. Justice Kuldip Singh,Mr. Justice Hari Pal Verma30 pages

  

       

 

          

   !"

"#

           

  $ #

$

            

  %&' '()*)+, -.)/ 0

$ !"

#$!%&'( )*+,( "$($!( $!%&'( )*+,('"',+"+"

 # - 

."

/   ."

/     01  2."

/      

."

/        % 3345633478835791  -:$;-."

"   <) ."

     ,   "   .     .

 *  ,  

  120  < 

-     % =7553

8,'% 4>4? 357> % 97?5 3579 +    . -    .



  -    @   <  -  +   @   -8=7553 357> +          <  

    -     

   

 /

.  < -@-:    

    <  /  -; @ A+        

     +   / 

        <357B  /     -      /                         /           -   /   !  395B357C                  

  -   /

<   / -        A           +   

          <  <    873??48357C  

  < +   -   

  /   

-     7357357>  

         

/ - + -      $ &

 -  '% 7C9> 357>    -        +  '  

          A -- <      

/ -    

  <      

 ;  -    

 < 3B5B357>+ 

   / <  / <.  .

   -   + 



  -  8      - 

               -     /    

    /  <     $ &  -         <       



/                                <         -        /< -   -<.     

-    $ &-           + -  /<     < 

  <  / -  3?75357> /     -  - <<    ;     /

   ;    /-  /,  

  - /   .           -  ; ;+       

" @ 9 8  033B 8+ 1       ! =75>357>         <<                  7473357>     A <@ <<   - 3C73357>+

    

        -         / 

         $ &  -    <  <  -          <    ;   - + 

   / -  -  <  / -       #8 1 +            

         <

  3?75357>   /<        

    -   <       /   <  1 "        ; 

  <  -     -       ; .

     / /    /   

 -      $ &-    1 ,           <        /   -        <  /

  -     /1 % - - @        /-      -     / -  

3   -     -  " <  8   ;    

 - - .     /   

- @   !        .       A               

         

   



 ,          </        

   A  /  

   

       

    <;      / %    < /  < /   - /   ,       

  <   <-- -:



  :  A  <   



  /           !       /         <.    -.           

              

      

-/<   /<   -     +    3?75357>  /

      -  #8  



  

   

 

 

      

  

  





        

  

  

  

 

 

# 

!

 

 

 "

       

 

 

$  % &



 

 



   '

 



  

 (       #   

  

  

       *       

 

+ 

 



       ,&-    %.

/ 0

 1 

2 #  

 

  

  "  

      

     

*  

  

  



*       

 

'

" @87   /     ;    /             A <      /  + /    < 8   

=775357>   -/ @  /  

       ;  #8   

   

   !

"

# $ % & '



(   ) * + ),   

-  . !

 "



-  /    4* $ 

5 2  3   0   

     

 

 !

!

 

"

$  

%& 

  "

&

'

!

(!

!(   

%&



"

) * &

&+'

) *   +  )

+ !

!!



 (   

) * &

4   

   

   !

"

# $ % & '



(   ) * + ),   

-  . !

 "



-  /    4* $ 

5 2  3   0   ,'

& & ' &

  ( 

  

 

,'

&

  - & +  .

+

# /0 +'

! !!!

  (   

/0 +'

 + +

!!  ( !(  

 

& ' &



 # +  ) +"

'

  !(

(

 

 ,  <       -  



 /      -   ; 

 ; 

 /

  /< 

     / <  





  /        +         

  /       /  <     /                  < A        

  -        <-;

<  + -        

  -     +    - 

    

/ 

          

 /

   -   /  /         /  -      -  A  -    < -  / -   A 8  

  /    -/ 



-<   -  < -  /   

<-     <  /<   <                  ,   <   /   <  <    <. --   -<  -   <. <     

 A      ; < - A     -    <    - 

  @   -  <  .        (/  .   A  -   

    <    .

 <       

                    /@    < /    .  . /    

--     ;    /   - <   < -   @-   @      / +            

        

       

 8          

          <     

-        @-   <  

    @      /

$ +     .  @-    < '         A       -                   -         

    -   .357?+    < 

 <      -  -  

     0 1   "     /     #8 4 5 

     &  

 

'

'        8@ 

   -   -  -   

8    

   -  .

  -    .                         <      

 /   -         / -   +     - <    < -  77  73 -    3?75357>   #8  







7    # 

 

  



  "      



 

    

 



 " 



 

       

  







  

    %  

 #



#   

     

         

   



 # 84





  "     

#

 

     

   9

 

   

  



:



 7

;

5  

  



  <

#

        

  *

   

 

7

;

5 

  - 

 



    

#         

 *   

'

" 73     <

    <-    ;  -.

          

 .             A- ;

 <            -        -     /    

       -  C  <     /         (  .2    <          / - - ;- +   

             @ /        <       /  (  .2  ' -    <  / - . <-< /

 

   -; -    -   @    -   D -  &,&    /        

 

-8<  -    -   7B-  37   < /  8

- .  3= 



/ -   ; 8      #8  

 

  ( . &

     #   

 

  

          

./$  



   

  #  





      

<   

   ! "

#$  ( .          & 

0 

  



 

 

#          



 &  

      '

34<

   - -   

   .  357>       -   <  "

< - -   /    -       =>.  =9.  43    4=.   - .@   #8  %    

    (      

     

    



 # 84





  "     

#

 

     

   9

 

   

  



:



 7

;

5  

  



  <

#

     

    

  *

   

 

7

;

5 

  - 

 



    

#         

 *   



& $      

  

 

 

*  

 

 

*

   #

*  '

'( 

   ! "

#$  (           & 

0 

  



 

 

#

         



 &  

       (  - 

 

     

#

         

  

#



 .   #  



. 

 *   

'

=>        < 

      <-    ;

  - <   /       A

  

 01=9    

    <  -   @  -;     @ /  4= / 

-    <

/ - . <.  /

     

  -    ;     -      .

                   / - 

   <<   -  / - 

8,               .  357=

  4C 4>. @  8 . /   -    '() * & =

 7  

     







 

   /   .  

*   

 



  "   

 



  (%  +"  

    * & 84



   

 

!     > 

  

23





1 

?3      

 

>

 



. 

> 



# 6& 

    #

 *

  

 

#  *







 *

    & 

    



*

 

     

    

 #





 7   @

  

 



   

     

 @

*

 





 

    

   @ 4 

    #

 #   



     

   

 





 

  



 #  

  

 "  

 

 

 

  





    

       

  

. 

  @'

!                 -       <    /  49 /   -     /    < :   '         /        / -      < 

         -        / -   -  - </ <  

 3.=.B ? %    7459355?

 #8 ' +"  

    ,



      -, .6&

# 0     " 

   

    



#           . 



;

 , 

 

   7 

<<

$   $    $ ;

 >   

8$;>4

 

   7 

< <

 $ 



#

 



0     * 

  

 

0   

0    

$ 



 @

;*

 

!

*  0    

$ 









 3   

   

0   #     

$ 

  *

 

! @



 ( *

*   

 

$   

  

 / ,



  "!

0 6& 84 $ -   ;

 >   

       $;>    

 .    & 

84

 

;

 8/  

?A3 

  

 7 

  ( $  

  

$ . 

)  





   84  &$  

  

 

  $ . 

)  





 

  # 84   #   

     * 





  

 * C>



 '

1  2   

 6&  ;*    7   8;74  .  $;7 8       8;74 $;74  $

  

    

  0  

7 

<< 7 

< <       ;7 $;7<        

 '

3 

* ,



   -, .6&

 

  

   

    

    , 

*    # $  

, >

 



 * >>

 



   84

0    #   

  





 # 

 





     





  



 &



0    * 





0    

$  4



,  $  

, >



  

   

 

 & 

 '

$/   /<   /

./   .         / <     

 

A  .  @A   -      /  @       < + - 

   <  /   <     / -  -    <. -   < 

-   <    

    <    ;

   <-

         -   < 

/

 -  $ &-   

        

. 

15-.'6'5.&%*'*0/   @    #8  > #   

  

.

   

 

.  

   0    # >



7       

   7

 ,

 

      

  >           

 4 7

 

0   



  '

% 



0  7  

   

/ 

 #





7 *

#   

 

  

 5  # 

7 #   

 





 

  " 

$ 

,  !  ,

#  # #

/ $   

     

7

,  !  7

D

81 4

$ 

E  

> E 

8?A4  $77 +3A   +A%

#   

 

   

# 6&

F9  

 0 

  





   

  "

 

 

#  7 

   

  

0      

  *   >

 

.  

  





  

 

 



  & 





  

    #   

 



 

      





   

 

 

 F

3

>

$

/ E   =  G # E 

8?A34 % $77 +33 



 



$

 /  



  

  

 

" *   #    5  # 

7

  



 

    

#      32+ 

# 6&

  F%



#    

  %

 

  

  



  

7 # #

  

 #

$ . 



 

  

" 7 #

  

 







#   

  $ . 

  

 

 

  

"   



 

  

" #  

 

 

#  7 #   

 

  #

# $ .   

 

  

 

  

   

  

 

7     % #   #    

1D . 

>     

 #      #       

#    

 

 

 

        #   

0   

    *   #  

 





  &0 



 





  

    

# 

  



   "    

   

0   #      "  

# 

,   

G

 5 >



*   

 

     

0    & 

 0     0        

    7 

# 

 $  

    9

      *

  

 





 #  

* 

 

  0  

  

   & 



 0  

      < 9 



    

      

"

  *  



 

 *   



  

          0

   0 

   



 

 *     

 

 



 

*  

#



 < <   <

 

 



   

<  <  

 

 &0 

 7  # 0    

*   

       

 

  <

0 < *    F)  

  F     

$  7

  $ 

 )  7  $

7  <   

0



  "

 

 









   

 

*   9

 

  





 

     

  

 0   0    # >

 

 

*    #  

    < . 

 # 

/ 



  1  

    0  #  

 

     7 

   #





  



$ .    

 

   

 

# 

     

  7 

 



 

 

 

 



  >

  

       



#    

    

  %

7   F %:

/ 

 



 

  * 

 7   





     



 

   * 

 0  

    

 

 * 

     

     

#     

7 #  

    >

    

 

.  

#   

 F  F         



  ) 

  

   

 

-7E

#

 

 

 

  ;

 #  



  



#  7



  

 

 

 







# < 

   

 



   

 #  

 



# 

 

# ;

   

  



   % 3

7  

 

  



   

    , *



  

  



   

     

   

     >

 



     

 >>>

7  

  



   

   

 

&   #



# 

 

0      

    $



 >>>

7  



       

   



< 

 >





 

    

  

 0 

   9

*  

       

 

 #  

 



 

 





    

  

 

  '

?

>

 

 

    . 

#

< #

 



.  

 



 

  

  

 

  

   

    

 

  

* 







# 

 

   

  

   

7'

?   

    

   0     



    







7    >

  #



7       

    #       



  ,     



 



/ 

 7 H  

#    

 

- $

 

22'

?: G 

 

#

/>-

 

 

0

  

  

7    

 



   H 

 

 

 

 7

  

 ; 

 



    







 0   

/>- 7 



 



 



   7 

 

 

  

7    



&

$

< 7    

  =

  

   '

?? -

*&  

#

0



  

    0              >

#

7



   

  

 

    

0

         ;

/   

      

 

 "      

/>-

 

  '

    -  /       /             <  

         

        -    <      <  -    +    

  



   ; <<  /  

     +         <  -;   <  /        <   <     / 



   /   -    .

                             +  .            < %  <    /    

 <    <  -;

  -  <@      ;    <@         <     <      . -  

   -. / / 

     - +    

    < /  

 -    /  /     -  ,  . <   <    </ -/ -   "      <                /  

/      



   <          

          <    <          

       A -/ 

  -      <  8 

 + -   <// A          <  + 8 

    --        - -    "     

 < ( / - =?@   #8 34 

"

 & 





&

  &

 

    

#

#  

  # 

 

  

# 

/ 0 @

/ 0 .  .!    



 " 

  



   

 0 

    # 

 

 @

#   

 @

4





 



  

  

 



  



" 

  

 

    

  



 

 @

84

      

 

 

      

 

 

   

#   

 '

+        -

/ 



    /   - -  / -  

                .- -

  . -  A   . 

  ./ /. - < - -

   

        .-



      - +  &   & -  A           -     D @-.     -       -    -  A         ;.          A - -  /   <  /           -      ,-  <         

 3        -;                  ,   

    

 

"15-.'6'5.&%*'*# $ $ &- 

-      < ( / - 

0

(D1     -- :

79 

-    --  - <

(D  4> 49@   #8 '(%5

  



 "6

 

 * 

 

      ?I

 

 #  

&      AI D 

 *





     



        

  

 

  #   

0      

 

# 

#  

 0     

(&  6  6 %? ;

   

      



!

 

   





#

      

  

6

84 >



  

   

 

     

         #

  "       

    

 



 

   1 

 

84  



    #    

 # #   

 

84 , 



*

    

  

!

 #  

 && 



    

   

# 



  



!

 #  

  35    34         

-       @ 

 #8 2    

   



 0     

   

0  > # 



 

  & 

F '

   

 

 

F  

   

   

   $ .   



    

 

 7  

1 

?32



'

% 

 $ .  B

)         

;, #   



 $ .  

)      1 

22

 



  





 

  &  



  $ .   

    

   

  $ 

+

 85   1  

?+: ,   49701   

- 

 /  -       

     -  -     ; ,  

      !

   

 4 

 0

31+!)+' 

 2/  

  -/ -    

 =3 

-   #8  >



    #    

"

     22:2% 8

* /24  

  =   "      

  

"  

     $

H

  

    

 

      

  

 

  

    



  

 

    





 #

 

    

 # >

  

   22:2% 8

* /&24 

 &

 0

     

 

     22:2% 8

* /&24    &      

#    # '

';. #

 

30 

"#

 !

 $#%&  

'

  355B355B      # 9  *



  

 

  

 

&'

 

  

  

 

1 / 

  

    #  "

    -    

   

  

7 >  =

 1

# 

&'



 =2     

  $

 >

 *

 

&'

  



 

       ,   &'

=2

    

"

2   " 

 

  

# #  #

    

&'

=2

 

2   

 

 



 

  & '

 J >

 

 

#

 



  #  "

   

 

*   

   

    

      



"

 

      

 

    

  

  

&'

# 

"

# 

  

#  

  

 

#



 '

 



 

1 / 

# 



   



  

#       6& = 6 

 

 

 

 1 

.

  

 >  





 

 

 

 /  

.

  

 >  

$  1

/ 

#  '

+ -     / -      

 0

(

    !

    

1.   345>357>#8 E>



$

 # 









   

  

    

 

 

   &

 

 $ 

$

  

 >

 

$



 *

  #    

 '

, 8     @   /

/ .  ;   -  D @-. ;7     A <. /        A <     ';. ; 3     % . )

.

'

 .   .   .   .   ;  = 

.  D :.

;.  D:;.   .  D ;

.   ;  4  $   

 . ;B  .+   "-. ;?

  ;

  ;C

. D

   /    -    / / ,   -

-     

-;        -   /    

   < </   -   +         

        A  



  -    <  .A/ -    @  8 -  A - / - +    

    ;  < -  A @   

<-;  </   /   @  -    '       <             -    357?$ /.      

    -            /  +       

   -               <       --        / -     , /  /.

   <   

 ;

     

 /

 

/. <  < -    <  

A 8    </    / 

 

 </    / /

  

(D

A <.              <   -  +  

  

-      ;    + -  

 -    -  <  -    <             /    "      < "   - -  % > 3345 3579

       /   A   <   "        0 "$($!(1 )*2( "3=.35790'"',+"+"1

 )*2( 3+ '   "  ' 4' 3+   + 2 4'