Savinder Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!
""
# $ " !" #$%&' ()*+,' -').+#/ & % & ' !( ) & !( & "%! (& *& ( & + (+ , (& '-( & + ,!"(& . /' ( & /. 0( ( & $, & 1 !( ( ) ""
! 2
& "%! (& '-( & + , ( (
) ""
!
& . ,
( , (# $) & ) "( , (# $
-').+#/ &0
4 ) " ) "" 5 ( (3623 ( 36 7(2 7 (2 2 6(2 632 67(237 (267 2 7(266 267(222
8 7 26(23 236(22 (2
( 7( (
3
( ( 7( 63( 637( 6 6 ( 7 ( 7 ( 3 37(6367(3
(3 23 2 (66 66 ( 33 6 ( 2(2 33(2 7(2 2
8 3 33 ( 3(67(62(6 (6 6
3(
0 ! 009! *$ "" ( ) / 0 0" 9! () 5$ "" ( / ! 3 * $( !
(! 19!( 6 ( : ;( # $!
9! 0!
6 7 !) ! ' "!
(#52( . .) 4 ( 00 7 ) !
3 ) 3 237 )
9! 4 ! ) !53 66 4 1 9! < ( <
) 0"= 7(
) ) < ( ) 5+@ !
( !
5 ) )
0 / 9! = >?" $
' "!
6 >? " 9! $ .) 6 . !3
6(! 6 ( # $!
9! 0!
7
!) ! ' "!
(#52( 4 ( 00
7 )!
) 3 ) 9!4 ! ) !56 4 19!< ( < ) 2
2 0"=
(
0!0/ " / ) ) < ( ) 5+@ ! ( !
5 ) )
0 / ! 9! = $
3 4 ) 50"!
5 !
5$ 5 " 7 1 ! ) !50 !
5 ) ) +! 0" 9! /" ) " ! A! ) 0!" 0 ) 00 ?
(% ?A( #A< $ + 9! & ( -! 0" B( 5/( 9! 4 50) 5 9! 4 5) 9! "
0C'& '04 9! ) 5)# ? ) # )$
?* %!+5) )$
0<< $>%D !
0* # 5
!! ) 0 9! 5! *!( (
$0 /0)$
0 9! * !0(< ! $ 1 E $( (
$ 9! A $
!!
" $ 2 A!""
!0 0"5$ <!
5 ) +! ( ! )
?( FB%3( FB%( FB%7( FB%2( FB% FB%
+! 0" 9! F 5
!0()
?" (FB% 1<
7()!50 ?(FB%%7() )
( 0!
/ ) "
3>?" $ ?(FB%7() 0 " 9! 4 9! /" 0 ) $ ( 6G ! 5
0" 5 $ 0(!
G
G5"" /" ) 0 A !""
!0( )" !"
6 << 3
?(FB%2FB% ( ( 0 ) " 70 0 ) ) "
6>? ( 2>? " 9! $
2
( " $. ? 7(FB%3(6/ ) 6(
>?( "
7>?" $ () " 9! . ?( FB%
( 0!
/ 0 ) "
2(76>?" $ 6
2 ) 0+! 0 <!
"67
!"(
6() 5$ )
!
5 ) 0"=2
$
' "!
9! 6 (! 2
"0!
)!" < "" 72?7
#
!" +! 0 <!
) 0
5$#;5 !"
0<!
1 !
3 H # $ !"( 6
( ) !
0 / ' "!
9! ! 6 2 6(=
$ !" "
$
0 # )$ >?" $ 0
9!
( 0 / !) $
!" "
$
0 # )$
9! $ 0
!
) 0) !5$ <
" 9! .) ' "!
0"=
(
) )!
00 ?
( %( 4 <!
0"= 3(
(""
) 5"
@ ( ! !50 !5 " ?(FB%3( 0 " 9! ( ) ( ) 9! 0 0" 9!0!
5!3 ( 05 !"4 " 0!
70 ) ) FB%2() ) / $""! 00 4 " ) FB% ) 0 () # )$
#( ?
"!
" 0 0"A ( ) !5$ < )+! ? "
! 5$ ) 0 ?( FB
(FB 6(FB A)!50 ?
"
!5$ " !( ) )9! #) ( ! ! $ " " ) ?# !
!50 ? " ? $ ) < 59! 5 ) 0"( ( 0 9! $
5$ <!
D "! 0
0" 9! $ 6( ! !50 0 0" 50 5 0 9! 0 "
$ 5)
A "( ! ) !50 ?"
!5$ ) ) <
5 0
3 # ! " " !
6 A "
( ) !
4 , 0!
9! 3 66 4 < ) 7
0"=7(
() ) = >?
7 " $ ' "!
6 $ .) 5$ <!
9! 3
6( < ) 0"= (
0!0/
/ () ) 5$ <!
$
A 0 " 9! !) 0!" 0 ) ?
(% ?A( #A< $ + 9! , 0
/(& (<!
0" B(5/( 9! 4 50) 5 9! A ) 5)# ? #
?* %!+5( )$*!( ( *
!0(< ! $ 1 E $( ( $ 9!
7 (0$"( ?(FB%3( 0 5
( ) $ "
!
0 $( ?
(FB%2( 0 " !
B
0 .)
0 4 " ?(FB% ( # )$
)$
0 9! ( ( 0" 5 ) 9! ?(FB%
()
6
2( 5! $
0 6 0" 5 ( ) # )$
#( 0
2 4 9! )0 $ ) )! 2
A )" )" (+ 9!( ) )0 " 9! B
!" # )$
() ) !
/ $""! 4 0" 5 !/ 5$ <!
2 % !"
( ) ) 9! "!
" "0! ()=
>?"
9! $ 3>?" $ 5+ 90 5 (/ () 5),4 (9! "!
" ( !) =2
$ A# $;!"
( <!
0" ' "!
9!
2 6
A
!!
"0< ( ( "
A! " > 0 ! ) 0
!!
=
$ !" "
$
0 # )$ >?" $ 0
4 ) ) (0 $( 0)
?
$ "
9!9! !
? 5 !59!" 9!
)) ) ?(FB%FB%7*
' "!
4 ?(FB%FB%7()
0!
/ "
3>?" $ ()$ "
6
A"! ) ?(FB%7( 0 " 9! 1" ?(FB% 9! 4 ) 5 ?
/ 4 " 3>?"
9! $ < ) "0 (0$"( )
5
=
G" !0 0 " )$ 6G (
! 0!
$
) 9! )0! !5""
9! ) ?()0 $ / 9! 5 !/ 5!3 4 ! ""
5 !) ?" 0 " ) 5$#;5 !"
0<!
& '
( )
<< 7 4 "" !) ) 0 $ 9! 5! "0) /
!!
"04 "
" "!
" )*$( )
<<27 ) ? 5$#;5 !"
0<!
& '
%!"
% 6 B 5 )?
I6 ! !) "0 "" 5 ! *! "0! $ ( 0 ! $ ! () ) " $! "!" (
0$5! J 0 $!( ( " / 00 0 %
! "0 50
0 ! $! ) !$" $!)! $ 5$ <!
1 < E AK (
<<27 5
! ) "0
0 G2G "
" ("
3 ( <!
! ? I 3 4 " I! "0L 50
0 /
! "
! !
) "
"0( ) "
0 "" ( 5) G2G
"
! " " ( " " !" !
"0 $!) B0" " !
6 4 I! "0L
)0"4 ) 9! 5! J "0 ) /
"0) / B0" ( $! 05$ 0 ! $! $(0$! J ! G $!( ( ( " /(" $
! 000!$
(
4 "0 ! $ ) !
5 B"!
"0
! " " $!( ) ! (
"
(!
! )
( $ ) ( $ " " / 0() )! 55!3G "" 4 ) / )! 5 I!
"0L! 0! 2G ""
7 @ ( " !! J "
$!( " I! "0L0$5
4 5!!! J $!( !! $ ) 5 " " /( " $
!00!$ F $ " ( / $500 4 ) 5
) (+!9!
0 0 4 0! " "0) /)! 50" $ 00 4 ! !! ) " " !! J $!()! 5 $5! G" ! G G 2G "
2 4 I! "0L )
"
" ! J "
$!0$ 5) G7G " !" 9! $ $!
4 " ) ! $!) 5
! " ) 5
$ J ) 0 ) J " 0!
90
90( ) 5 $ 0 0" $
!( 5" "0 ( " /(" $
! 0) 5
8 5!
"0) 50
$ () ! ! 50
0 ! " 0$
$5)6GG
0 7G2G "
9! 0? " !
5 (! " !
( ! "00$50! ( ( G 6 G( 0 5
!!
) $5 5 4 " 05 !5+"
$
4 ! I "0
L50) "
0 " " $!(
! " ( ) 5 0 !) "
0 " !! J"
$! ! $! A ) /) "0 !
5$! $ 0! !
5$"
" ( B"!
0 $! 05$( " ! J ( 0( " /" $
!0$ $) !
$!?) ( ?
!0?00 ! 8 0
$!( " )
J " () ( B 00!$ (" /" $
! "
0 $! 05$ ! $ "0 ! 0$
0 / ) >) 0" ()
/( !5( !! 0 / ( ( " / " $
! 00!$> 0 4 "!
" B0" $ ) I! "0L
5 " "
5 $)
0 G2GL1 < M ) 9! 5$! #! 0 ) 6 ! ) 0 ) 5 ! J $ ) ( !
! 3G "" ) ( "
( !
! ( $ ) )
( $ )0L A ( ! ? "!4 ! " ) / )"!
5$ ?(FB% FB%7() "
" $ " ( (5 5"
$ " $) 0" 5
!!
0!" "0"
" 0 "" !( 0$ "( 6 G 5 !! 0!
0
>?( 0!
0""$5 ) )! 07 $ 9!
3 4 5$ !
! ) ?(FB%
(FB% FB% ( ( 00 $5 + 5 " 9! 6 4 5$ ! )
5$ () )
! 5$ < 5 5
+ 0 $"
<!
0" ) 5 ) 5$ < 4 5 ?(
5$ ( 4 <!
)$
! 0! 0""$5 ) 0 ) < 5! 0!) 5$ < 5 ! 50+! 0
#;5 !"
0<!
+, # "* * -./
0
.
2 3<< 6% 2 B 5 )?
2 0 $"
5 0! )
5$ < 5
! ) !
00 $ 6( !(0 $ $) 0! 0" ) 5$
!
5 0! ) 5$ < ( !0 0!) 5$ < 5 !D ) !0
) 05$ <
3 0
A $ 0! 5 !L ,1(+)+*+#/ *'/23 4 0 " !59! $ 9! ) )!3
6A + 9!
"0 ( 7 < "0 !
! 5 (0$"( )
9!
5
= G" !0 ) !0!
0 " )$ ! 9!
!
A = G" !0) !0!
7 >?( 0!02727() !
27 >? 2 0 5 ( "" 5$ ) )4 "" 5$ 0 4!0!"? ) 9! !
0"=7 $ ) 9! ! 3
6 0"=27 $ $ 5 ! $5 0 "
-').+#/ &
4) (/5'
"