High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/565/2017allowed

Kanwaljit Singh Swani v. Senior Superintendent Of Police U T Chandigarh & ORS

2017-02-27Mr. Justice Krishna Murari8 pages

!"!#$ &( ) * #+ ,-!

.!#/0.+ #! 1

2" ..

0 #3&" 1 "4#3# 5$ 675 .55. 88

&"# $8 5" #'3!)39

& !#& 5&.':

)39

&&"4#3# 5&#3&"0( ,)39

&&"4#3# ; 88

0&'/0!#"

!#) !#":" +&!

!# 0#

'& < #3 <'"3!& 04,! 3<!#!"

"'%<!

&& 4,! 9&!!

!#&4& &"4#3# #;)

! &) !#&3& # %,0!< / 0!"4 &<

! &) &0 &!

"&,9 & 03 !"!# 04&"# " &

3.4 <%&)+ "&/!"

&3 #2!4

*'< &'#3&.

!#";); # ,,/

!#"'%"

!#/#/!#

#3 0 ""!" '<%&"

, ,"" 90! ," "

,# 90! ," 0 "# # <3!# ) 4(+0! 00 "%# ##>3

8 '&!#/ 0 '&" !#9"

!#) !#&6" # < <&/3 "'"4 #3 0 + &&"

3 %'

+ " &, "3 # % !, # 9<%&?)0!#9"

!#!# 0 &!<!# "+ " <4, # %&;) #3!# ,&4& ""'%<!

304 "# &/8"0 3!"# <)0+9&)+ ":4 !# ,'<#+!

0&4&

8+0&!#!

!"<# !#3

0&!"#9!3# !#&)0 #.!#/0 #3&'#*'< &)+& 04&"# !#/ 0

0<0!&# <"0 9%#:4 !# ,'<# &3!" '""!#+!

&#(.

,# &"0 3%#& 9&3&<2!4!#*'< &9!#3&.!#/0) ""' 0!#3!#/"'! !# 9!3# 0<) 0 + "4&"# 0< #'#=)=) 0'3! !

,5 /!"

, ""0 3!""'3# ! 4 !#&)0 #-!

.!#/0 #3&'#*'< &)%'

#9<%&;)=) 0,,+!#/"

"< 3%(.0 #"0 < &!<& # 0).

&$8 @ '"3 * < ,- ) 0 #-!

#3 &'# *'< +& &&"

3 !# 0!" " %'

0 # 0 " # %# 4&"# 0< "#9!3# + "'#3

0< 3'&!#/ !#9"

!# !# 0 4&"# " %9 !#3 '"30 9%#:4 !# ,'<# #A

#9<%&B)=) !#&<93

0 ..

) 0 &0 & && !# 0 4,! & &3 !# ,! .

!#) .

& =?) 0 &0) <# !#!#/ 0&!#

0 <!/0 #3 C ,! ,

6&0!"!<<!/&

!## 0"4#"&"0!40!""#+0 + " ,!9!#/ !# ! !4

39&" &< &:" &&"

!#&4( 0"

!#!" 8;04

39!"3%( 04,! "'%<!

&D'"

! &) &0 & C ,! , # &

6 " "' 0 0 !,3

8 # 9<%& B) = 2!3 0 4,! "'%<!

&4& +!

#%"&9

4& 3!#/" &4#3!#/

!#& !# &!<!# , '& # 4,! 9&!!

!# &4& ) !# ,'<# 8 & 3!#/@& #(4& 3!#/" 4#3!#/ !# #( &!<!# ,'& )!

"&< &:3 "C("6+9&)!# ,'<#?) "<# !#3 ",,+"$8 @" 4& 4,! & &3) " = 3

? 'E" ;) ; ) ;B) ;

) ;

=) ;

;) ) ;) 8 ) .5 #!< -& )0 &0'#3&/!"

04"!

!# "< (% %

!#3 &< 0 # # 4&3' 3 !# '& * < ,-!

.!#/0 #3&3& 0 '& "

E .0 #"0( <!"

030&+!

0A 0

! &#/

!39&!!

&4& "# ,

!#&":!#/ , &!!

!#<# !#!#/ 0&!#

!#&0 3"'44&""3 0<

,!#&<

!#!# +0! 0 + "!""'3 0!< !# 0 ( & ? ""' 0

!# +',3%

!#&&!<4'#3!#/0!"4 4( 0"

!3,

"%# 44#33+!

8B04 3!& "'&&#3&0!"4 !# 0!

! & ,#/ +!

0>4,

!#04 !#&9!3 8?!#&<3

! &

4,! 0 3# "'%<!

#( 0 0!< ""' 00+ # #3+ "# &!

,!# #('& ,"!#&<3

! &

0 3%#!""'3 0!<#'/'"

=)?

0 &!<!# "+ "&/!"

&3#.4 <%&?) ""' 000 # 4&9!33 #( ,"!#&<

!#!# 0( &?4( 0!# ,&4& + ,""#

! & ,#/+!

0&4,(2!3 <<'#!

8) 3

&( ) ;) !# &"4#"

!#3

3 #'

&(B);)!

"!#&<3%( ,! 4

&!"4#3!#/!# 0&&)#4,! !#D'!&(!"#33#9!+ 0 # 3!

!#"!#

,>!"

!#/

&# ,(<!", 3!#/4,! 9&!!

!#&4& !#&!,3

0..

)0 &0) 8)'#3&4'%,! +!#3+ "("

<) &D'"

&& 4,! 9&!!

!# &4& % "#

! & 0 &4& 3!3 # , &!(

!#& !" #

'"3!# #(<& #3!"# &!

,)0 9!#/%#:4 !# ,'<# 04 !#&%(<9!#/

!#'#3& !/0 #&<

"'/0 0 "

'" 0!"

8 &<

!#&<

!# "'44,!3) !#& + " !#&<3

. ',3 # .!#/0)

,! .

!#5 #!5 -& 0 &00 3 #3'

#!#D'!&( "'%<!

3#4&!,);

4,! :4 !#&!# ,'<#

#33"#

: #(

+<&

0 , , 4,! 0 " # %- !# ! 0 #6%, '& 3!" 0 &/" !#& # 0 "

< 3 () 0 #"4 &E . ,! .

!# 5 #! 5 -& 0 &0) #3&"3

.6" &4& # %- !#!#3!" 0 &/!#/ .

+0! 0+ 44&93%( 0!<) /!9!#/ !#3!#/ '#3& "!/#

'&"

, , 4,! 0 3 # %- !#&3!" 0 &/ !#&&< "4( 0&4& !"

44#33+!

0+&!

8 #'#);)

! &) 0 !# "# ,

& ":!#/ , &!!

!# &/ &3!#/ !""'

# 4 !#& +0!, ":!#/ 0!< '&#!"0 !# ,-'3/<# E &3&" 0 '& !# " +0! 0 + &/!"

&3 0!< + ," <# !#3 !#

!#& + " 4""""!#/ # 0& 4 #3 0 3 %

!#3 & '3',# ,(+!

0 :# <0,

! &!"

8= 0!, &!#/ # %0 ,

! &) '#", &

! & , &!!3

!#&0 "# %# '#3 4""""!#/ #( 0& 4 & /!9!#/ : # < !# 4&"# ! ', &"04 !#&0 3)9!3,

3',( );) , &!!3

0+ "0,3!#/#,(#4 !""'3 0!<#'/'"

=)?

"'&&#3&!#/ 0!" &,!& 4 % &!#/ ;B;?= & 33!#/ "'&# <.+ #! 4("0+!#/ # ,,

!# &,!&4

03+!

0&4,( ,#/+!

0&4& ,! F ;G04 !#& , !<"

0 ,#/+!

00!"+!0 39!"!

3 &<4&!, ) #'

&() !#&<',( ) <%& ?) 0 !<<!/&

!# 4 ) 0 " +&!

#30!"+! 4&9!3C ,! ,

6 %( &(=) )9!3,

8) 0 3!

#!<<!/&

! &,

C ,! ,

60 %%

!#3&< ..

! #

# &#)" &#"0 "' 0!#"

!#"%

!#3%( !#&0 "%#4, 3#& &3 8 # 9!+ %9 "

!3 !& '<"

# ") !#& 0

44& 03 0!" '& & # ""

&( 3!& !# & !""'

# && ,! , # &

6 %( &"4#3# " = #3 "'%<!

&"4#3# ; #3&'& 0&

!#%(

! & &#3 '#",& 3<!#!"

!#5&.':

0 44"3 !## 0/&'#3

# '"

!#0 &'3 44& 0!"'&

#&,! #%/& 0!< 0!" , &,( "'"4 !# &!<!# "3'% !#&0 "%# /!9# , & 0!

!< 4&"#

!# 0 # %'

0 # % "'<<#3 33!

!# '"3%( 0

'< , #

0 9!#/ %# !""'3 !#&) 0 " %# 3<!

3 %'

!""'

# C ,! , # &

6 0 " %# %- !#&!""

!,, "'"4 0 9 0 &3 , &#3 '#", &

,#/ /# 0&'/0 ,, 0 3 '<# " ,,

" 9&#<# '

0&!

( "0',34 "" "

& "# %,#"" 0

!#& !" # <3!# 8!"'#3!"4'

3 !<4&"#

!# # '#3& .

!# = FG & ) !#& + " # 0 #3 0'/0 0 '& 0 3 !""'3 # ! !#& %'

+ < 3!# 8=)#9<%&;)=

0 #0 3# %# 4&"# " # 9!3# + " '#3 !#& 3'&!#/ !#9"

!# 0 # ! 8=) 3

3 '# ) ; & , &!!

!#!""'3 "&4,!3%( !#& , &!(!#/

,, 0

"%'

0#,(3!! ', (+!

!#&!"

0!"# %!#/ /& 0C ,! ,

6!#&<!#/

! &

!#& !"#!

0& !,, 3

#& 0 0 " %# "'<<#3 0& !" # <

, # 0 & &3 !#3!

!#&"'<<#!#/ '"30 "%#< 3%(

0 4&" '

/# ( # "

!3 !& '<"

# ") '&

!,!#/ 0 &!/0 / ,! ,

# 0% "!" 0#!

!" !" %",'

,('#& "# %,!#&!#/!#/ 0&!/0 " !#&":!#/

#3%

!#!#/ 3 '<# ,!: , # &

+0! 0+',3# %,0!<

9,!,,3

# #3!

!#0 "%#!<4"3'4# !#&%( #( '& #& #("' 0 #3!

!#0 "%#"'/0 &%( #(# "

40!<

&< 9,,!#/ %& 3 # 0% "!" %9"

!3 !& '<"

# ")!

!" ,

!#&# %!#/ !,,3

#30 9!#/%#/!9# , 0!

%( 0 !#9"

!#/ ! & %( < :!#/ "

!# 0 '& # 9<%&;)=) 0+&!

!#3"&9" % ,,+3 04 !#!" ,,+33!& !#!"!""'3 0..

!""'C ,! ,

6+!

0!# 4&!33 (" # 0% "!"#%- ,& 3('&#!"03%(0 &04,! #4&!, )&3!" 0 &/!#/ !#&F 8F,,(G) 9!#/ # %# !""'3 #( 0 &/8"0 H # 0 &/" 0 9 %# & <3

0!< !,,3

!#'#3&.

!#=?& 0 9!#/%# !,3 0!< !,, 3

H # #3!

!# 0 9!#/ %# !<4"3 '4# 0!< &"

!#!#/0!<&<, 9!#/#3!

%(.

& , + "!

+!,,% '#& "# %, '&

!,0!" &!/0 / , # &

+!,,% 4# &"4#3# ; !""' # 0 % "!" C ,! ,

6 0!"&3&0 "%#4 ""3+!

4&-'3! 0,/ ,&!/0 04&" '

/# (

&( ) F55.G "

#- ( 0 0&"4 :!#/E& "#3$ "E 0 0&&4&

%,$ "E