← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/5266/2011dismissed

Mohender Singh Etc. v. State Of Haryana & ORS.

2017-02-07Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih10 pages

      



   



"" # $%& %'

()  (



   *  

        

 *            

 +*  

        

 ,*            

 *             

 *   

        

 (*       

  

 -*     !   

  

 .*    "    

  

 * #    $  %  $   

  

 *    &

        

 *   



  

  

 +*  #   $  

  

  

 ,*     $  

  

  

 * # 

   

  

 * # 

 

  

  

 (* #  

" 

  

  

 -* #  

 

  

  



 .* ##  &

  

  

  

 * ##   !   

  

  

  * ##     

  

 * ###  

 

  

  

 +* ##    &  

  

  

 ,* ##  $  

  

 * #   $$  

  

  

 *     $   

  

 (*    $  

  

 -*   

  

 

 .*   

 

  

  

 +*  



 

  

  

 + *     

  

  

 +*    &   

   

 ++*     

  

 +,*    $  

  

  

 +*   &  

  

  

 +*  

 

  

  

 +(*    

'   

 

 +-*    $ !    

  

  

 +.*     &   

  

 ,* # 

&  

  

  

 , *   # 

$

  

  

  

 ,*  # #

 

  $ 

 ,+*  #  #

 



 

 ,,*   #

 

 $ ,*   #

 

 

" 

 ,*   #

 

 &

 

 ,(*  # #

 

 $  

 ,-*   #

 

   

 ,.*   #

 



 

 *   #

 

     *   #

 

      

 *   #

 



&    

 +*   #

 

   

 ,*   #

 

 &  

 *    #

 

  &    

 *   #

 

 & $  (*  # #

 

 

 

 -*    #

 

 &

  

 .*   #

 

  $  *   #

 

   

  *   #

 

  !  

 *   #

 

  

  

 +*    #

 

  " 

 ,*   #

 



  *    #

 

   *   #

 

  &    

 (*  # #

 



'   -*    #

 

   

 .*   #

 

  $ 

 (*   #

 

 

  



 ( *   #

 

     

 (*   #

 

   (+*    #

 

 

 

 (,*   #

 

   

 (*  #  #

 

  &  

 (*  # #

 

   

 ((*  ## #

 

  $  

 (-*  #  #

 

 $

" 

 (.*   #

 

  & -*   #

 



  

 - *   #

 

 $ !    

 -*   #

 

 $$  

 -+*    #

 



  

 -,*   #

 

  $  

 -*    #

 

 

" 

 -*   #

 

 $   -(*  # #

 

 &  

 --*    #

 





 

 -.*   #

 

   

 .*   #

 

 &   . *   #

 

 

 

 .*   #

 

  & 

 .+*    #

 

 ! $ 

 .,*   # ! $ 

  

  

 .*    #

    

  

  

 .*   #   

  

  



 .(*   #  $  

  

  

 .-*   #  &  

  

  

 ..*     "       

 *    $$  

       

 



 

 ! 

!

% #

"

# $%&  

'# ( )* /"

 *  ( ) , ,-) (+.

(,

 0 

+

#,+ ( )*( - 

., $ +( )* /"

 * , ,,

((  1

+  +0 

., *#/( )* /"

 * ( ( (

-  0 



,( )*( 

' 0 '+ ( )*(  

., 1+( )* /"

 * + ++) +.) - -) . (

+(

 1 ,  +1

.  ,0 

) 2#( )* /"

 * (() - ) --

,  1  -  +1

.(  ,0 "

# /-*

!!5 

$ ( )* 

!(

 2"

3" 4& 56 ) 3

"

$ 3 

88 7)

93"3 

88 7 : $

!"7 $'

 %'

;

&%"

!% %&&% :786 %8%

/;0) $ !""

%'

<&""" )

% ,-

88 7 : $

8%!%% $'

7 "6

=7

9 %*

%) %

%" & 6

<&"""

 <&"

3 %<&"%

%6"

"

3

88 7 " 66 )

3

% $"

"8 $'

66

% %

4& 56 *

9:%) $'

 & !



% $"

&77 & !%6  *  

/#

 # :*  -

3  # 0* "!"

"& &

% ;"

, >

<&"""

) -., /!% $%:"') ?3 @0 8&$7"3

+*.*,) :"

93"3

"& "

3%

"!!% :"77 5) "** &%A8&%) 3

% ) 3"7 B3 %A3

) "

"%" ; 8 ) &53 $

<&"%

!% %&"

:786 D8% "539 '





"539 '

* ) ; 8 ) 3%9"3*

3 >

<&"""

77%) 3&53 :"

8 %

% )

 %A :

7&

<&"%

"& "

:"77 5

* ))= 8%

%*

3

7 "6

=7

9 % 9%

7

%  &%'

$ !"

6""$7

"

9*

"

55%":

6

7 68

%

$'

77%) 7 "6

=7

9 % !"7 $4" &

% ;"

-



"8& %!%  ":"7 &%*

"

%

%

%"

%% )

!%  &% % 3

7&"

3 7 "6

=7

9 % !

"7

8%:

'

7

 = 7 "



) 93"3 "3% 8% "

"&

"

6 :"77 5 % "

" :""

"') &$

"

3"% 7 "6 !% !&%3%

6 * 9:%)

%5 %

"& "

:"77 5

% )

7$" &% % 3 6 7&" ) $& '

 :

7&

<&"%

* +))= 8%

% "**

*)= 8%

%

3"53% 3

68

% $'

77%) 9"

D%

 % "

%'

% 3"8 8&%8% : $

&!!% $'

7 "6

=7

9 %*

 !

%

7 "6 7 "6

=7

9 %

%5 % 68

& :%

) " 37 3 "

$ 

'

5 %

% "$7 %"

7)

&3 7 "6 &7 $ 5%

* F3% % "

3%

7 "6

7

9 %) 93

"& "

:"77 5 3

)

8%: 3 9"

<&"""

3"%

37 "

5  :% *

%&7

7') 3'

9%

% 68 =:%

 3 %5 G

:

7&

<&"%

*

 '

$ 7 %"!" 3 3

88 7 : $

8%!%%

"

 !": "

"

% ) 3&53

7":%

"!!%

) "**

,*+* ) *.* )  *.* ) .*,* ,

+ ** ,*

!

&%)

; 8%!%%

88 7 7'

"

3 93%

9 %

: $

% 68

* +))= 8%

%)

G

:

7&

<&"%

& :%

 3"% 37 "

5*



88 7 : $

8%!%% $'

7 "6

=7

9 %*

: 3 % 7 % & 7 !% %"

8%&

%% *

3 7

 /D*  D* .0 9% %&7 &

"

% ) !%) 3 %

" 8% "

3% :"77 5)

"** B&

7")  "

$ 8&%) 93% )

<&"%

"&

"

% $7

"

 !%6 3 :"77 5*

3 !%  &%

" %

:

7

 /D* (0) !%) " 8% "

D%67'

6 %

57"5"$7

% *

>"A9") !% 7

 /D*   D*  0 9%

D& 8 "&



"!"

&

% ;"

, ) 3 9%

7

 !

% "

*

!

) 8"!" !"

"

%% $'

!% 

&% " 3

7 "





%

:"77 5 &%A8&%) 93"3

5%6

)

8%"% 8&$7"

"!"

&

% ;"

,)

8% &

%% *

% %') %8



8%:

7

"



 /D* +0) 39"

3 8%"% "&



"!"

&

%

;"

,)

"& "

:"77 5 &%A8&% "7!

7

*+) )= 8%

%*

;"6"7 %7') 77% %  /D*  0) !% ' %

,) !%

3 !%6 % %: &  :"77 5

&%A8&%) 9%

7 *+) )= 8%

%*

!

)

7'"

&6 /D* ,0) %: 7 3 ":""

>:7 66"

"& $'

5:% 6 !%

6 :

7&

<&"%

) 7'

%66

* ,))= 8%

% $

%

68 *

&) "77 77%

 :

7&

<&"%

* ))= 8%

%*

3&)

6&

% $'

>

<&"""

77% !

% 6% 3

%& :

7&

<&"%

*

;"5 "!"

7') !%  &%

"7!

%%

!"

"

3 7 "6

=7

9 % !

"7 39 :

"

57 "



 :"

93"3

"&

:"77 5

%

7

3"53% % 3

68

% $'

77% "** * ))= 8%

%*

) '

 :

7&

* +))= 8%

%1  

     

     



    

 

 

           

                   

             

   



   

            

      7')

"3% 3" 7 "6

7 "6

=7

9 % $!% !%  &% 3 3'

&!!%

'

D% % "

%'

% 3"8

%

'

:"

 7 "

3" %5 % *

$"

8"!" 77'

A ) 7 % & 7 !% 7 "6

=7

9 % &7



8"

& $ " !% "

!"

"

5)

39 " &7 $ 4&"!" *

& 377) 7 "6

=7

9 % "

3 % !

"7 7

'

5 :"

 &$

"

3"% 7 "6*

3&) 7'

"

:" $7 7&"

&7 =

$ % 3 " 3 3'

9%

 "7

'

!&%3%

6 *  %5 % 3 ) 93% 7 "6

=7

9 % 7

8"!" :"

 8%: 3 3"%

37 "

"

  $"!&%

9"

<&""" )

!%  &%

%

68 )

D8"

$ A

"

!"

"

5*

!

) C%*

%" ;

"

") 7 % & 7 !% ;) !

"%7'

&$6" 3

:"



%% !&77'

&$

"

 7&"

%%":

!%  &% "

3" %5 % *

8& 8""

A3 &

$:)

88 7

8%!%% $'

7 "6

=7

9 %

%

"6" *

% "

57') :

88 7 !"7 $'

;

"



% /0) :"

93"3 7 "6

 9%

% G :

7&

<&"%

:%

 3 %5

%

7

"6" * 9:%)

88 7 !"7

"



% /0) :"

93"3

!%  &%

 68

* +))= 8%

%)

%

8 )

9 % "

3 3

7 $ "7

 68

* ))= 8%

%)

$

%

!!"%6

"

% 8% "

"

:"77 5 &%A8&%

3

*



!  51 "/ + 6( 7896

8%=

F33% ;8 A"

5=  #

;

=  F33% 8% $7#

;

=