← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2263/2010dismissed

Risal Singh v. Khem Chand

2015-12-17Mr. Justice Arun Palli5 pages

       

 !"# $#%&'&() * 

+ &'!,&(-. /00#,,!(" 1#2'3' 4.#5.!($ /#'0($#(" ) 6 7  77

2#'#(") 21&8!9&(-.4!8,!:$;%!"# 2".#!00#,,!(" 2 !25&($#2&(-.:$;%!"# 2".#2#'0($#(" <<<

 =.#".#2 2#02"#2'   ,%!, 0!0#2' 5!9 ># !,,?#$ " '##".#83$-5#("@  >#2# #22#$"".#2#02"#2'2("@

 =.#".#2 ".# 83$-5#(" '.3,$ ># 2#02"#$ &( ".# $&-#'"@ <<<  77 2!, 3&" &,#$>9".#0,!&("&

?!'$&'5&''#$>9".#"2&!, %32";&$#83$-5#("!($$#%2##$!"#$+ 

'#;#(!( !00#!, 02# #22#$ !-!&('" ".# '!&$ $#%2## !&,#$ !($ ?!' $&'5&''#$;&$#83$-5#("$!"#$ A



B:0,!&("&

&'># 2# ".&'%32";&$#".&'2#-3,!2'#%($!00#!, !2"&#'"".#,&': .#2#&(!

"#2:?3,$>#2# #22#$">9".#&22&-&(!,0'&"&('&( ".#'3&"

,!&("&

02!9#$ 2!$#%2## 2'0#%& &%0#2 25!(%#   ".# !-2##5#(" " '#,, $!"#$  BB+: C3! ! ,!($ 5#!'32&(-A>&-.!' >&'?!"?!'5!&("!&(#$".!"!'35 

D?!'0!&$"".#$# #($!(">9?!9 #!2(#'"5(#9 !($ ".# >!,!(%#  +:

D ?!' " ># 0!&$ !" ".# "&5# 

 #E#%3"&(   ".# '!,# $##$ .# $!"# &E#$ 2 #E#%3"&( !($ 2#-&'"2!"&( ".#'!,#$##$?!'  BB ($:032'3!("" ".#!-2##5#(""'#,,:0,!&("&

?!'#;#(03"&(0''#''&( ".# '3&" 020#2"9 '   BB  ?!' ! !"32$!9: 0,!&("&

?#(" " ".# 

&%#   3> #-&'"2!2: &,F.#2& (   BB : >3"".#$# #($!("$&$(""32(30"0#2 ".# %("2!%" ($: ".3': 0,!&("&

 .!' !,?!9' >##( 2#!$9 !($ ?&,,&(-"0#2 ".#%("2!%" ( $# #(%#: &" ?!' 0,#!$#$: &("#2 !,&!: ".!" ".# !-2##5#(" >#&(- 0203($#$ >9 ".# 0,!&("&

 ?!' ! 2-#$ $%35#(": !' ( '3%. !-2##5#(" ?!' #("#2#$ &(" >#"?##( ".#0!2"&#'.#2# 2#:".#2#?!'(%%!'&("2#%#&;#!'35   

D >9 ?!9   #!2(#'" 5(#9 !($ " 03" ".# 0,!&("&

&(0''#''&( ".#'3&"020#2"9 ( ! %('&$#2!"&(   ".# 5!""#2 &( &''3# !($ ".# #;&$#(%# ( 2#%2$: >". ".# %32"' %(%322#(",9 %(%,3$#$ ".!"G 0,!&("&

 02$3%#$ !,! !5  = : ?. .!$ !,,#-#$,9 '%2&>#$".#!-2##5#(":>3".#.!$(#&".#203".&''&-(!"32#' (2 !(9 '#!, ( ".# !-2##5#(" &( C3#'"&( # 0,#!$#$ &-(2!(%#: &( .&' %2''#E!5&(!"&(: !' 2#-!2$' ".# 0!95#("  #!2(#'"5(#9"".#$# #($!("#&".#2&(%!'.:>9%.#C3#2 #;#(>9$2!

"7&F#?&'#:!5!F.! = :?..!00#(#$" ># (#   ".# !""#'"&(- ?&"(#''#'   ".# !,,#-#$ !-2##5#(": %(%#$#$ &( .&' %2''#E!5&(!"&( ".!" ".# !-2##5#(" &( C3#'"&(.!$!,2#!$9>##(?2&""#(!($?!'("'&-(#$>9".#

  0!2"&#'&(.&'02#'#(%#32".#2:#;#(".##!2(#'"5(#9?!' (" 0!&$ " ".# $# #($!(" &( .&' 02#'#(%# 3($#2 &(-.  =H: !(".#2 !""#'"&(- ?&"(#''   ".# !-2##5#(": $#0'#$ ".!"".#!-2##5#("&(C3#'"&(?!'?2&""#(>9 !,!&(#.'&,!" ".# '#!"   .2&  22!: $;%!"#: ?.#2#!' ".# ".#2 !""#'"&(- ?&"(#''#'   ".# !-2##5#(" "#'"& &#$ ".!" ".# !-2##5#(" ?!' -" "90#$ &( ".# '.0  !,! &( ".# 5!2F#"

,!&("&

 %,!&5#$ " .!;# >##( 03" &( 0''#''&(   ".# '3&" 020#2"9 032'3!(" " ".# !-2##5#(" ?#;#2: (".&(- ?!' >23-." ( 2#%2$ " '.? ".!" ".# 0,!&("&

 ?!' #;#2 &( 0''#''&( ".#'3&"020#2"9(".#%("2!29:#;&$#(%#,#$ >9 ".# $# #($!(" 02;#$ ".!" ".# '3&" ,!($ ?!' !,?!9' &( 0''#''&(   ".# $# #($!(" ( !%": ".# 0,!&("&

 ?!' #;#( 2#'"2!&(#$ 25&("#2 #2&(-&(.&'0''#''&(;&$#!%&;&,%32" $#%2##"83'"".!":!%2&5&(!,%!'#3($#2#%"&('H

!($ +    ".# ($&!( #(!, $# ?!' 2#-&'"#2#$ !-!&('" ".# 0,!&("&

!($.&''(:!'".#9!""#50"#$" 2%&>,9$&'0''#'' ".#0,!&("&

;&$#(%#(2#%2$02;#$".!"0,!&("&

!($.&' '( ?#2# %55&''&( !-#("' !($ $# #($!(" 3'#$ " '#,, .&' %20'".23-.".#&2!-#(%9!($".#2#?!'!$&'03"#C3!'5# 5(#9"2!('!%"&(>#"?##(".#"?5#".&(-:".!"?!' 3,,9 %22>2!"#$ >9 "#'"&5(9  !,>&2 &(-. = : ?. .!00#(#$ " ># ".# '(   ".# 0,!&("&

 3": 0,!&("&

 &( .&' %2''#E!5&(!"&( %!"#-2&%!,,9 $#0'#$ ".!" .# ?!' (#&".#2 ".#%55&''&(!-#("(2?!'#(-!-#$&(!(9'3%.>3'&(#''

H ($: ".3': ".#2# ?!' ( $&'03"# !' 2#-!2$' !(9 5(#9 "2!('!%"&(?&".".#$# #($!(""&,, 32".#2:".#%!'#'#"3" >9 ".# 0,!&("&

 ?!' ".!" 02&2 " ".# #E#%3"&(   ".# !-2##5#(": ".# (!5#   ".# $# #($!(" ?!' $3,9 2# ,#%"#$ &( ".# 2#%2$   2&-."': >3" ".# $#0'&"&(   &25!, &(-.:

!"?!2&=+%50,#"#,9 !,'& &#$".#'!&$;#2'&(:!'(!5# $# #($!("?!'#("#2#$&(".#2#;#(3#2#%2$ 2".# &2'""&5# (  BB &#!

"#2#E#%3"&( ".#!,,#-#$!-2##5#("" ?3,$>#!00'&"#"0&("3"!"".&'83(%"32#".!"".#""!, '!,#%('&$#2!"&(?!' :B :

D3" ?.&%.:!'0#2".# %!'#'#"3">9".#0,!&("&

:!'35 

D?!'0!&$>9 ?!9   #!2(#'" 5(#9: 5#!(&(- ".#2#>9: (,9  +:

D 2#5!&(#$ " ># 0!&$ !($ ".# 0,!&("&

 ?!' #;#( 03" &( 0''#''&( ".#'3&"020#2"9"$# &#',-&%".!".!;&(-0!&$ !,5'" ".# #("&2# '!,# %('&$#2!"&( !($ .!;&(- >##( 03" &( 0''#''&(: 0,!&("&

 ?3,$ .!;# '"&,, $# #22#$ ".# $!"# 2 #E#%3"&( ".#'!,#$##$ 2!9#!2(!(9%!'#:.# !&,#$" 02;#".!".#?!'#;#203"&(0''#''&( ".#'3&"020#2"9 "&,, 32".#2:0,!&("&

%,!&5#$".!;#;&'&"#$".#

&%# 3> #-&'"2!2 2#E#%3"&( ".#'!,#$##$(  BB :>3"".# $# #($!("$&$(""32(30"0#2 ".#%("2!%" -!&(:?.!"(##$'">#("&%#$&'".!" 2!0#2&$ ;#2(# 9#!2 "&,, &,&(-   ".# '3&" ( +

 BBA: 0,!&("&

 (#;#2 #;#( '#2;#$".#$# #($!("?&".!(9("&%#"#E#%3"#".#'!,#$##$

+ 2#E02#''.&'-2&#;!(%# 2.&' !&,32#"0#2 ".#%("2!%" 7#!2(#$ %3('#, 2 ".# !00#,,!(" %3,$ (" 0&(" 3" !' " .? ".# %(%,3'&(' ".!" .!$ %(%322#(",9 >##( 2#%2$#$ >9 >". ".# %32"' ?#2# #&".#2 %("2!29 " ".# 0'&"&((2#%2$2'3

#2#$ 25!(95!"#2&!,&,,#-!,&"9 ( ".# ?!F#   ".# 0'&"&( !' '#" !>;#: ".#2# .!2$,9 #E&'"' !(9 -23($: ,#!'" 0,!3'&>,# &( ,!?: " &("#2 #2# ?&".".#$#%2##>#&(-!''!&,#$C3#'"&( ,!?:53%.,#'' !(9 '3>'"!("&!, C3#'"&(   ,!?: !2&'#' 2 %('&$#2!"&( 00#!,>#&(-$#;&$ 5#2&"&'!%%2$&(-,9$&'5&''#$ #%#5>#2 *:

+ !8!( 23( !,,&  3$-#