High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4993/2014allowed

M/S Jaiprakash Associates Ltd v. Nhpc Limited & ORS

2016-03-29Mr. Justice Arun Monga22 pages

!"#$% !!&& '"( )*+% " ,! -$$""!"" && .!!"/01&&. 2(3/ 4

51" """!""" 4

-$$"$2(3/ $(&1"!" $34 *"

"%6#$7.$ 086 "* #29(!86 "$!!&& "2*(("086.$ "9("6+$!"86 "$"! ::::

5$!!&& "33"6 $""

8 .$"1012 &10$"! 3 $"1" ."

;

$1 ! $."! $" 6("

$1 <.(&1!361" !" $ "6"0& $&!($"1""!"$3"/

8 " " "( ( "3"( !."$(8("3$ 8*"(" $ 8*"),5(

& &( 3'87.$0" 5,5

"5)0"&"*"273' .$)*+.." $!!&& 5$!(& /!& ."#!"$ ".

=.$"8."#$1 /!&

; 7 !("1. $!"(" 3$>( 6"( /! 3"."# $ " 63"&( !( $"(3$"1" $/"." ""$"1""5$1 &/1 "$"1"".$ &8 $ &/ /!&/ 3$."#. " $/ /(/.3( $ !"/(&31096"

/ 7##/8$ 1

# ( .$& " 3 $ / $ & 1

/! # 3 " $ !" 2(/ "/(& !"7(1+&( +&(?

$+ "

+ *"(&"!!& $" "1&&@+ " +*A$($&/ &>! ("&1&1! !"(1&(?

; +*'"(&" $"3"." "

($ &1($"B(."2 "&0

&&0

?5$ "/ &/. 10$ "! "/$ $."(" 3$("

"1" &1" 8 (/1" $"(/ 8/

>(" 6"(2(3/ )3$+(" 7(!"/+("."(1/10 1$$!"5$!" 12$!"("!10$ "1""5"1( & ."36 /!&!!"( <.(&1! "!"($+&(?

& 3.$$$ 3 &3&

! "

& '

(

+ "

(

, , ( (

- " -%./ 0/.1 01.

0 . , "

, 2 34, 23 2 , 5 ,$

& ' (

,( (

(

! ( 3

& ' / 1

(

)7 +

& &

808 ,

" 8

&! & 8

(

= & !"# $

& '

( +

" & ( !

,( (

+ %

& ' ,

( %&' ( #

( 9:

, + " +

( ,

) " *

+ #$ ,

(

( , &

( ;;

& & +

,( (

( %

& '

(

7 ,-

, ,$ ( & ( < = 5 /, ( ,

= 5/,>( , ,

(

? &

(

" (

( ,

< ,

( ( (

$ & (

" %

? ,

" ) ))@ "%6#$7$ 8 "* #29(!8&"

( & !!" 3 1$& !!&& &/ (1/$+&(?

;

+* ""6 (""$" ./!&(8 63 $"/1("/ $+ " "! >! (" (""10 .$6"10+&(?

8 8 1"$$"3 3

$ (""1( ("0$# $/ /(/.3( "$ /(/-38 ; $"3"8& 3(3 7(1+&(?

;

&" ( /13(( ( $ $/$ 1

"!" $ < > 3 0 !( 5$ &/ (3$ "/1("/ ($ " / /(/ .3 6" 16 $ !" 3 " +*< + *" < > (/1" C$ $ !" (1/$""!6(1/ 66$&/ & $&/5$"1""5"1( & " " 3$ "/

;

8 "/ 6 &&. 3( A3 #

3 # & (0 ( ,( ! (

(

): ="% 3 + ,

3 + ,

& 3 =

@ )(1/$"" $12 3+(" 3$ ."&# 3" $12 ." && 3.$ $"&/ 7 $<&&.$12 3+("

!!&&+(" "!!"$6 6&1&""."$ + "8$(8>2(" 10" "!" 3$+ " "/5$"1""5"1( & "($ "3"/ !"

$(17 7 ; $."$" "

1 $6 1 (

" 3 "/ $ &&( 8 /($ &8 &&3&0 !"6"0 6 8 $ "1"" 5"1( & $ /"

"!" 3$"/ $+ " ) ("$" (1/ $ $ ." " $ 1

&6" "$" 3$!"& 3$.$& " 3&&$"" &( 3 !& 38 ." "3(/ 8 (/ "/ $+ "8 8"1""5"1( & / ("/ "!"$!"6 $+ "5$"!

&!"681 "$12 3+("8$$." $5"1( & .!"6" $"6..!1&1( 1 &0 $&1!"6"5$"" $12 3+(" /( /" 3 +&(?

;".$+&(?

.$$$"(& 3" !"2( $ &/ $ !!&& . " " "

& 1! "&1("/! 81( ""/1("/ $ &>! (" ("" ( "6 $ /(/ -3 "$" $$ ".$$"." 6"10$ +*< (/1" ( " ( " "/(& ( " +&( ?

12 3+(""" $& 3$.31!$&1(". "! 1&0 $+ """"!6 $ $$.3 " ( $ 3 &. + ""$&& 1! &>! 10$/!&0"($ 33 $+&(?

& !"(&"&0+&(?

;C&&08+&(?

; 3(" 3 $ ".$$."10 $ "& $+ "" $

(/ " $ /(/-3. !($ ."/1("10$%1("< !" $7##/ )(1/$& (1/ 1.

!"+&(?

8 ;0!""$.

$ .(&1/$1 " !"5$+ ". >(

$ ".36

&1&& $+ ".(1/10$&/ "$8

.$$. & " > 3$/ /(/.3. =

" !" " "/, !"0,= = !"0 ,;;!"0) ("$"(1/

$!"$7 $ /(/-38 . /! 5$1" .3 >/! &(( /! !&&&. $"1""5"1( & "

3&&$!"6 8$9D 8/($&8!"6

7(1+&(?

;1$&$$$ 3 $/ /(/.3$#

( . " +$ 3 $1" .3 +$ 3 $+*<(/1" 7(1+&(?

# ( &0$ 3 $+*< (/1" 1$ 3 " .35$1" .3

# ( +*<(/1" " $("1 (! $$" "$ $+*<(/1"

>(" (1/& .$ / $ & /!( $ /(

2(/ $( 5$&(& ."1(! $ !" 3 " $/ /(/.3.$" " 1 $/. !(10$$" "!&0!" 6 ."B("8$

>(" $& /!&0 6" ! 10$%1("< !"8$(10# 3 " $"6 / /(/.38$

" ./ $&(/ .$$ "/$&/8$" "8 & $ /($ $"! $$&/ &$"3$ ( "$!("! (1 3#5$(3$8$"1""

5"1( & "$ " " "/ = 1($#

" $ " = ;;5$12 3+(".$& ! 3$12 8&"0168 3 " 8

$(8"" ( 1& $0 &.)$".

$+("$""( "$&& 38 (1/$ "/!" $( "!"( $+&(8/($&8 (1/ $( & $ 3 &0 !"3"!$ =

?<.(&1!"!"( 3" "10$12 3+("

"/!" =!" ?

A*7

( , ,

2 $ ,( 3 '

$ , (

(, % ,

)* ,( (

(

2 ! ( 3 #

( ( , )9

, ): (

0 *

, B,

,( ' ( ( + ,

$ , ,( ,$ $$C *)

, ( , ,(

, , ( (

( +

= (

@ < (!!" $ 8$$"&(! 2(3/

) E1&7(!"/+(" < B(, %

+ D 10

+5 + /

972*3>%E%

<F)FF 9

9;;978.$" &&(.(12/" $ !(1 "$"1"" $." $"1""$1

(!$&10$) E1&7(!"/+("10! 3$" & $

"/(&/ $&( &2(3/ ) E1& 7(!"/ +(" 1 D B

92;37: $$" 33 10 $12 3+(".(&&0 # $!!& ( "7

"2*(("086& 3.$"9("6+$!"8 &"

( &!!" 3 1$& "! (1/8$$"

"""8 &&3&0 !"6"0 $ "" ( " $&& 3 5$ 2(3/ 1$& !!&& "$"$&!"! !"

1"6 !" < B(, %

+ D 10

+5 + /

2 3$1 $&$ "1""

5"1( & B( 0$/( !" &&3& .!"6 1($" "/! .2(8.$"8 $ $ !!&& && 06 (!!" $"&/>!10 (1/ 3$"&/8/($&8 B( $&/ 8$" "8 &/. / 1& "3$&08"1" ."$1 -$&"1( 3$"3(/ !!&& 8 $"3"& " ""!" $12 $12 # " $12 66 >/ 0>!""/ $/! $(8$".

$+("!" $12 8.$$"$( A +

<)*

" %

2="%3

(

, ( ( ( <B"

( >E+ >E++

, (

4 , ( ( (

@ )&"&(! $!"6 +&(= !"(&"&0 = .$$&.$ "$&/ 8$.$" ""

&/!&0.$$!"6 $&( "! 0&/ .$$$#/#$ &/ !0/ "!$" $&&

>($/( $F 3 "" 0"1""""1""

!! !("( (1+&( ? &/816" 10 /!""0""8.$"($""."1"(3$$F 3 "

5$12 $6"3$&01 !$0." && .$ $"&/ 7 5$&/.10 $ !"6 $+ "$+ ""/!6 "/$ "/ .$$!"$3"8 "8!"$3"/ 1. $!"8$ .$"!$&/

&1("/! .1$+ (/"*"< >+*<8$" "8 & $/($ $&/ !!&& 8&/$!" 2(/ # 3 " $ .&/ ($&/8 &0/( 1"$ "1(.3 $ ( / & $ + " 5$+ ""$ $ 3$(" > $" "" " !" + ""$6"3 + (/"*"< >$(" < > "&1("/!

!" " / /(/.3 !"/"& "/$3" "/ $ + " 8 $" "8 &/ . ( 1& 0 &" 7" 8"" 0$"&.8 "&( "10&. 0&&"$"(&0 (($"0 ( 3 0 & " ( $ + "" " ( " .$$/!&0"1"/ 10F 3 " $&& 1"( "/$+ ""!"+&(?

;!"6$ ($ &"($&& !"&01!""

$/$&"01 # ( > 3" 0 !( $!"2(/ "/(& " .$$!"6 7(1 +&(??

?< 8$ " $ $&1("/! $&"01 # ( $3"+ (/"*"< >

= $*"2(/ "/(&.$$ >(12$$ 3"

"6 6"0/ $5$"& "!" $+&(?

; /!&&($ !!& $ "(/

$!" 5$5"1( &$." 3&0."(/ , =

&/( 1&/ ,?

& "$"

G "/$ !0/ ( ((" "$" 8$" "8/2"0 .".( 2(8( " 1& 3 $ !(1&!&0($/!$."&(! +&(?

81( !"$!"6 !"2(/ &1("/! 1 (! """ +*< 8$" "8$&/ & " $/" &1("/! $(!"0 "/& $!!&< (!!" $ 8$$"&(! 2(3/ " "10) E1&7(!"/+(" >

D ?

" /

29F39 <$6$"&"

( & "$!" !!"$ !!"1# $6.$$" " (1 $!&

"7$ "* #2C$$( &$6&$60/!$ $ "!" $+&(" ""16101"6 38$>" 10$"1""5"1( &.""8.$"!"$"! 8 "!" $+&(10$12 3+(" .""

" 5$ "/ $! 12 ( "7 8 /0 6. !"$&&.86"0&/12 3+("

$12 .$&" 3!!& (/"& >!" 10"!!" 3$ "6 F6 $".8

" !

1 "/$"$ $5"1( &$! 12 6"0

&/ 5$ "! $6 & /# ( $ $ $" 12 ." && 3.$ $!"6 7 $ 5$ 12 16 6 # " 66 !!& $&/ 8$" "8

1!"/" "$ "/ $!" !!&06.

" 10$" (&&( 1 D B

2 35$!"6 +&(=

$+ ".(& 1!!&1&$ "(/ $ 1(?

;.(&!!&05$ 336 10$12 3+("

16 /06.&6 /

" (1$ " 3$ 1 3 3 .&&" ." $ "1""

5"1( & 5&& !" 8 $ 12 3 +(" & .$ $ "6& $!"$& !""!"(16" " $ 3(/ 3$"& !!&&+("-$" $ ""08$6.>!"10$"1""5"1( & /06. """$# 1"608"&6 !" $ 3" "10 $"1""5"1( &"$( A3 % + ,

( ),

(

$ , &

? (

( )* ! &

,0 ( (

,0 ( ( !

( )*

! ( ( )*

, $

(

( )*

( ( , 1 #(

, &

( "+ !

% 9;

, =

+ ( 1 ,( ,

( "+

( "+ ,

( )*

;

, (

1 #( ,

% 9;

9) > ;;9: 79 =

( "+< (

)* ="%

& ,(

% ,

( ,( ,$

&9; = ,$

> 9* %

( ,( > ;*0 > 7*0 2 & C $$

7*FF7 & * 4

)79 & 7 =

,( ,

( ,( "+ ,

! > ;*0 > 7*0

,( > 7*0

* **9; %

,( > ;*0 > 7*0,

> ;);*7 % (

(

( "+ % 9; 9),$ ,- 3= '=H >%*7 >%) > *::;;) 3= & >%*7 >%) 23> *))F) 3

> *7*9)7 2 > *7*9 3 % (

> *7*9

,( ,$ &

9)%

, ,$ &

9) ,$ 99:

(

$ ,

> *7*9 ,$ &

% 9; , = ,$

,$99:@ !"(& 3" "10$"1""5"1( &8 6 $"1""$ "/! $$ &6 3 >

(/1" (/" !" > 63 &0 &(( 3 $ /! / /(/" .38$( "&& !("!8$

1" .3

+*< "(& &0 ""

" $1" .3 " &"# " +*<

(/1"-$& 3$/ /(/.38+*< $6"(

"1 ".$".$& 3+*<(/1"8$/ /(/ .3 " 6. / "6 "/$!(0 ""8 %1(" C("(8 "0 %1("8 96"

/ < " "" $&/! .$$$1

>(" .$ $/ &/5$(8 /06.+*< (/1" &0 $

"( 6"&.$$ "1( " $/ /(/.3 5$ (/(&6 " 3 $ "/ !"6 8 /($ &8

3" "10$"1""5"1( &&""1& &(

$" $/ /(/.3. 3$$ 3 $&.1

$ "$"$ $+*<$6 1 # ( $ >

"/(&!"7(1+&(?

8$(8$+ "" &&/$ !"+&(?

;< /06.8$." $"1""

"/0 .$$!"6 7(17 = 7 5$" $"! $/" &(

" $/"" ""2(3/ &)3$.07(!"8 .$" ) E1&7(!"/("8 " " 3$/86"0&( 36$ 3 6(" $+ """$# 1"608$

3" "10$) E1&7(!"/+(" !" 8"$( A9 # , (( % 9 9* , !

, )

)) ( ,

(

( ! (

( + ,

(

, ):

> ( (

, ) ))

): ,

, !

, ,

$ ,

, $ , ( #"+ + #"+ &

, ( ( ?,

+ ,

<B%+

! ( ,

(

*F9* % + $

, ,

, , I

(

): ="%+

<B%+

, , $

(

# 5 ' ,,

(

( (@

H! 3 6.$ "/ "(/ 8 $""!10$12 3+("$"10 ." $ "1""$"10"" " 3&08$!" !!& &&.

! "