High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17799/2023dismissed

The Wild Life Harike And Another v. Shamsher Singh And Others

2023-08-23Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger19 pages

!"# $% #&'('$) * +*

,# '-# .'%#/ !0'1# !)- !)$",#0 **2 #"'"'$)#0( 3#0(4(

5,!6(,#0 5')7, !)- $",#0( ***2 #(8$)-#)"(

9 . *

5 5

0#(#)" 0* 3'8') !:

!-!;/

--'"'$)!:

** 4)<!= %$0 ",# 8#"'"'$)#0(#8!0"6#)"* * * 5

* #"'"'$)#0#8!0"6#)"

,!( %':#- ",# ')("!)"

>0'"

8#"'"'$) 4)-#0

0"'&:#( $% ",# $)("'"4"'$) $% )-'!

%$0 '((4!)&# $% !

>0'"

') ",# )!"40# $% &#0"'$0!0'

%$0 ?4!(,')7 ",# '6847)#-

>!0- -!"#-

* *

))#@40# / 8!((#- =A ",# .-* )-4("0'!:

0'=4)!:/

60'"(!0

,#0#')!%"#0 0#%#00#- "$ !( B",# 0'=4)!:B/ >,#0#=A ",# 0#%#0#)&# $% ')-4("0'!:

-'(84"# 0!'(#- =A 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!)

5,!6(,#0 5')7, 0#7!0-')7 "#06')!"'$) $% ,'( (#0;'&#(C ,!( =##)

!)(>#0#- ') ,'( %!;$40 =A ,$:-')7 ",!"

"#06')!"'$) $% ,'( (#0;'&# >!( =!- !)- ,# ,!( =##) 70!)"#- !

:468 (46 &$68#)(!"'$)

$% (* / / * *

0'#%:A/ ",# 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) 0!'(#- !) ')-4("0'!:

-'(84"# 0#7!0-')7 "#06')!"'$) $% ,'( (#0;'&#(/ =A %':')7 !

&:!'6 8#"'"'$) 4)-#0 5#&"'$)

$% ",# )-4("0'!:

'(84"#(

&"/ D

,#0#')!%"#0 0#%#00#- "$ !( BD

&"B/ >,#0#') ,# &:!'6#- ",!"

,# >!( !88$')"#- !( !

'0#:#((

8#0!"$0 =A #"'"'$)#0#8!0"6#)"

$) * *++ !)- ,# >$01#- &$)"')4$4(:A "'::

,# >!( '::#7!::A "#06')!"#- $)

* E* * "

>!( &:!'6#- =A 0#(8$)-#)"

$* ",!"

<4)'$0( "$ ,'6 >#0# 0#"!')#- ') (#0;'&# =A #"'"'$)#0

#8!0"6#)"

!)- $",#0 >$016#) ') ",# (!6# &!"#7$0A >#0# !88$')"#- !%"#0 "#06')!"'$) $% ,'( (#0;'&#(* #(8$)-#)"

$* &:!'6#- ",!"

,'( (#0;'&#( >#0# "#06')!"#- ') ;'$:!"'$) $%

",# 80$;'('$)( $% 5#&"'$) E/ 5#&"'$) E !)- 5#&"'$) E $% D

&"*

>!( !:($ ("!"#- ",!"

0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) &$4:- )$"

(#&40# !)A $",#0 <$= ')(8'"# $% ,'( =#("

#%%$0"(/ !&&$0-')7:A/ 0#(8$)-#)"

$* 80!A#- %$0 0#')("!"#6#)"

!)- &$)"')4'"A $% (#0;'&#( >'", %4::

=!&1 >!7#(*

* #"'"'$)#0#8!0"6#)"

&$)"#("#- ",# &:!'6 $% 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) =A %':')7 '"( >0'""#) ("!"#6#)"

>,#0#') 80#:'6')!0A $=<#&"'$) >!( 0!'(#- 0#7!0-')7 6!')"!')!=':'"A $% 0#%#0#)&# !)- ",# &:!'6 $% ",# 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) =#')7 "'6# =!00#-* "

>!( ("!"#- ",!"

",# 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) >!( )$"

#68:$A#- $) 0#74:!0 =!('(/ ,$>#;#0/ ,# >$01#- !( !

'0#:#((

8#0!"$0 $) 0#?4'0#6#)"

=!('( !)- !( 8#0 ",# !;!':!=':'"A $% >$01 !( >#::

!( %4)-(* "

>!( ("!"#- ",!"

",# >$01 $% ",# #"'"'$)#0#8!0"6#)"

'( (#!($)!:

') )!"40# !)- ",# :!=$40#0(>$01#0( >#0# #)7!7#- =A ",# %$0#("

74!0- $) -!A "$ -!A =!('( %$0 ",# >$01 $% 8:!)"!"'$) !)- ",# >!7#( !0# 8!'- $) 0!"#(*

>!( ("!"#- ",!"

>,#) ",# >$01 '( %')'(,#-C ",# (#0;'&#( $% ",# :!=$40#0(>$01#0( !4"$6!"'&!::A &$6# "$ !) #)-*

>!( -#)'#- ",!"

0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) ,!- >$01#- %$0 D -!A( ') !

A#!0*

&&$0-')7:A/ 80!A#0 %$0 -'(6'((!:

$% &:!'6 $% 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) >!( 6!-#* D* 0$6 ",# 8:#!-')7( $% ",# 8!0"'#(/ '((4#( >#0# %0!6#- !)- ",# 8!0"'#( :#- ",#'0 0#(8#&"';# #;'-#)&#* E* $)('-#0')7 ",# 6!"#0'!:#;'-#)&# $) 0#&$0-/ ",# 0'=4)!:

=#:$>/ ;'-# '6847)#-

>!0-/ !)(>#0#- ",# 0#%#0#)&# ') %!;$40 $% 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) !)- 70!)"#- 0#:'#% $% &$68#)(!"'$) $%

(* / / ') :'#4 $% 0#')("!"#6#)"*

* ) ",# !%$0#(!'- &'0&46("!)&#(/ ",# 8#"'"'$)#0#8!0"6#)"

,!( %':#- ",# ')("!)"

>0'"

8#"'"'$) =#%$0# ",'( $40"*

* .#!0)#- &$4)(#:

%$0 8#"'"'$)#0 (4=6'"( ",!"

",# :#!0)#- 0'=4)!:

=#:$> ,!( #00#- ') :!> !)- %!&"( ') 8!((')7 ",# '6847)#-

>!0-*

'( (4=6'""#- ",!"

",# &:!'6 $% 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) >!( "'6# =!00#- !)- #;#) $",#0>'(# ",# >$016!) ,!( )$"

0#)-#0#- D -!A( $% (#0;'&# ') 6$)",( 80'$0 "$ ,'( !::#7#- "#06')!"'$)* .#!0)#- &$4)(#:

%$0 ",# 8#"'"'$)#0 #8!0"6#)"

("!"#- ",!"

>,':# &$)('-#0')7 ",# &:!'6 $% 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) %$0 0#74:!0'F!"'$)/ !

(8#!1')7 $0-#0 -!"#- E** >!( 8!((#-C ') >,'&, ",# "$"!:

)46=#0 $% >$01')7 -!A( $% ",# 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) >#0# &$)('-#0#- !)- '"

>!( $=(#0;#- ",!"

",# 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) -'- )$"

0#)-#0 D -!A( $% (#0;'&#(*

&&$0-')7:A/ &:!'6 $% 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >!( 0#<#&"#- $) ",# 70$4)- ",!"

",# 0#(8$)-#)">$016!) -'- )$"

&$68:#"# A#!0( $% (#0;'&#( "$

** * "

'( )#@"

(4=6'""#- ",!"

",# >$016!) >!( #)7!7#- $) 0#?4'0#6#)"

=!('( =A ",# %$0#("

74!0-C !)- 48$) &$68:#"'$) $% >$01/ ",# (#0;'&#( $% ",# >$016!) !4"$6!"'&!::A &!6# "$ !) #)-* "

>!( %40",#0 (4=6'""#- ",!"

",#0# '( )$ (!)&"'$)#- 8$("

$% !

'0#:#((

8#0!"$0 ') ",# #"'"'$)#0#8!0"6#)"* "

'( &$)"#)-#- ",!"

0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) ,!- %!':#- "$ 80$;# '"( 8:#!-#- &!(# !( ,# -'- )$"

80$-4&# !)A -$&46#)"

0#7!0-')7 ,'( <$')')7/ !""#)-!)&#/ (!:!0A #"&* ,#0#%$0#/ '"

'( 80!A#- ",!"

'6847)#-

>!0- =# ?4!(,#-*

+* ,!;# ,#!0- &$4)(#:

%$0 ",# 8#"'"'$)#0#8!0"6#)"

!)- ,!;# 8#04(#- ",# 8!8!#0=$$1 >'", ,'( !=:# !(('("!)&#*

* ) ",# ')("!)"

&!(#/ ",# 0'=4)!:

=#:$> ,!( 0#"40)#- ",# %$::$>')7 %')-')7(

! "

# $!% & ' (' ) *!+, !

- ./ 012 .10123',4+5(!

6*!('' 7 ' * !+ , !

- 34 819 01/ 0910103',4+!: + %# ( ; ' + , !

- </2

0118 .101. 3',4 3' 4

# +

0/1

0 +

1018<< .11201 = +

:> 6 6 %

! +

.11201

# 6?) ' >

0118

01101 @ :>6+

0118 01+

& 011+ 011& 01

%6A

(!:> : 011 34 !

> , & 9+ ) B !

> , ' ;

+ C +

+ 020010 3:>6A4+

> 88<888+ 0/1 889011 1018<< .11201+ )+

0/1

' 02@ !

' 02@ ! )+

>>>>> >>>>> >>>>> 8 + + 0. .11201+ 019)

5 +

%0$

0 ?

- .

% 01 0+

%+0$ 0

D +

D %

! ! $ , F $ , =+ ! + 2 ! - - '= F,!/F8/9F'9F011< 11011< ,

& 3' 4+ ! + ' 314 !@

C *

8#04(!:

$% !=$;# #@"0!&"#- %')-')7( 0#"40)#- =A 0'=4)!:

=#:$> >$4:- (,$> ",!"

0#:!"'$)(,'8 $% #68:$A#0 !)- #68:$A## =#">##) 8#"'"'$)#0#8!0"6#)"

!)- 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) >!( !-6'""#-* ,# 0'=4)!:

=#:$> ,!( 0#&$0-#- !

%')-')7 $% %!&"

",!"

0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!) ,!( >$01#- %$0 D -!A( ') :!("

&!:#)-!0 A#!0 %0$6 -!"# $% "#06')!"'$) =A $=(#0;')7 ",!"

",# >$016!) ,!- (8#&'%'&!::A ("!"#- ",!"

,# >$01#-

%0$6 * *++ "$

* E* !)- ",# !)!7#6#)"

,!( %!':#- "$ (,$> %0$6 !)A 0#&$0- ",!"

(#0;'&#( $% >$016!) >#0# #;#0 "#06')!"#- -40')7 ",# !%$0#(!'- 8#0'$- $0 ",!"

>$016!) >!( #;#0 0##68:$A#- -40')7 ",# (!'- 8#0'$-*

,# 0'=4)!:

=#:$> ,!( $=(#0;#- ",!"

",# !)!7#6#)"

,!- %!':#- "$ 80$-4&# &$68:#"# 64("#0 0$::( !)- '"

>'",,#:- ",# =#("

#;'-#)&# %$0 ",# 0#!($)( =#("

1)$>) "$ '"*

,# 0'=4)!:

=#:$> ,!( %40",#0 &$)('-#0#- ",# $0-#0 -!"#- E**

@* "$ ,$:- ",!"

#@&#8"

A#!0 +/ ",# >$016!) ,!- >$01#- %$0 6$0# ",!) D -!A( #!&, A#!0 %0$6 *

,!( !:($ =##) ,#:- ",!"

",#0# '( )$",')7 $) 0#&$0- "$ (,$> ",!"

>,':# "#06')!"')7 ",# (#0;'&#( $% >$016!)/ ",# 80$;'('$)( $% 5#&"'$) E $% D

,!;# =##) &$68:'#- >'",*

* .#!0)#- &$4)(#:

%$0 8#"'"'$)#0#8!0"6#)"

,!( %!':#- "$ -'(:$-7# ",# %')-')7( 0#"40)#- =A ",# 0'=4)!:

=#:$>*

!",#0/ ",# 0'=4)!:

=#:$> ,!( &$)('-#0#- ",# %!&"

",!"

0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$01#- >'", 8#"'"'$)#0#8!0"6#)"

%$0

A#!0( !( ,# (#0;#- >'", ",# !)!7#6#)"

!( !

-!':A >!7#0/ !&&$0-')7:A/ ",# 0'=4)!:

=#:$> ,!( )$"

70!)"#- ",# 0#:'#% $% 0#')("!"#6#)"

!)- $",#0 =#)#%'"( "$ 0#(8$)-#)"

$* / =4"

70!)"#- $):A &$68#)(!"'$) $% (* / / "$ 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >$016!)*

* ) 6A &$)('-#0#- ;'#>/ ",# 0#:'#% 70!)"#- =A 0'=4)!:

=#:$> '( ') &$)($)!)&# >'", ",# :!> :!'- -$>) =A $)B=:# ",# 5480#6# $40"

') ",# &!(#( $%

!)-

!!"# $ %* * )

/ $)B=:# 5480#6# $40"

,#:- !( 4)-#0 0GG &'

( ) !#! * +, , ) %$

-% . %/ 0)& /$ . % / $- # , + 3%6$ +&4

+ 12 3 +4+ + , , ) 1, 2, -- . -%51# 6+ 7 #+4" +4+ + * &+ - / . - % $/$5 + *2 , # 8!" 9" - . - /-/5*, 2, )," '!' - -$: . - % -: 0" , *+ # # ! 6" ! :

. :$ 0)& / . : / -/5 & 4! 7 #+4" )!+ 0" , ) -- . :5 ;< ', 7 #+4" )!+ , ) ) + 8!" , ) : *'++'

74 2 ;=!# , ) : $ . : 0)& %/ . : /-/

H I ,

) + +

# JJJJJJJJJJJ ++ +,

' 02@ + +

0/1

I KKK KKK KKK 2?

& ' ,

) ,

89< 9

' +8<2 02 +

%+11+111F 3% = 4

+# ?

GC D* )

!!"# $ %/ $)9=:#

8#@ $40"

,#:- !( 4)-#0 0 #+" 7 * 8 '

7' : $ . --$+,

) B

B 2

' 02@ !) F

' , ) 1"

0 ++4 + -: . : : + + 8 1",

)

, +# , ,

) / + *+4+# 4+ +4+ + 9 9 %$ -% . % % 0. #

F F D +

) +

' 02@

!+,

#% 0/ %

' 02@ !+ +

+ 3'H + 8

1" 7

, +

+ +

( 0#7!0-( ",# (4=6'(('$) $% :#!0)#- 5"!"# &$4)(#:

",!"

",# &:!'6 $% 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >!( "'6# =!00#-/ '"

'( $=(#0;#- ",!"

",'( '( )$"

&!(# >,#0# ",# 0#(8$)-#)"

$* ,!- (:#8"

$;#0 ,'( 0'7,"(*

) ",# A#!0 / ",# 0#(8$)-#)"

$* ,!- %':#- !

>0'"

8#"'"'$)

$* + $% !( ,'( (#0;'&#( ,!- )$"

=##) 0#74:!0'F#-* 54=(#?4#)":A/ 0#(8$)-#)"

$* %':#- !)$",#0 >0'"

8#"'"'$) '*#* $* E $% %$0 0#74:!0'F!"'$) $% ,'( (#0;'&#(/ >,'&, >!( (4=(#?4#)":A >'",-0!>) =A ,'6 $) E* * +* 40",#06$0# ') 0!'

;# * ( 0+,3 ( / $)B=:# 5480#6# $40"

$=(#0;#- !( 4)-#0 G! ' 134 !+

;

L B # +

' 134

H I134M?

;

+ N+

34 O

P 34

+ + + ' ' + $ , # P

+ + + ' ' ' + # I +

L B +

$ , #

, ) +

2+,! + ) 2 , ,! # '!# ( ,

%-% + L B' 134 !+ H I9' 134

;

) ;

' 134 ;

;

# # I +

;

' 134 !

+ $ , +

@+ 4 8!" 2, 12 >#

+, , $ : .

+ , H I2

> O

# ;

# ' /5 7Q ! ) ,

= +

# #

)

;

# $ #

I 3:

4 0 + +

3 4

! !

;

' )

+ $ ,

# #

, + ,

$ !! .9

;

$ , F

# >

. +

P$ ,

! # + $ , # + >

;

' 13434 !

+ + +

# $ , F

, !

' +' ;

' 13434 !

$ , , ) +

, 4 8!" 2, GC ,#) ",# &!(# ') ,!)- '( "#("#- $) ",# !);':

$% ",# :#7!:

8$('"'$) ')-'&!"#- ') ",# &!(# $% 0!'

(480!/ '"

&!))$"

=# (!'- ",!"

",# &:!'6 $% 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >!( "'6# =!00#-/ ",#0#%$0#/ ",# (4=6'(('$) $% .-* 5"!"# &$4)(#:

",!"

&:!'6 $% 0#(8$)-#)"

$* >!( "'6# =!00#-/ '( 0#<#&"#-*

* 40",#06$0#/ ",# 8!0!6#"#0( %$0 #@#0&'(# $% <40'(-'&"'$) =A ",# '7, $40"

4)-#0

0"'&:# $% ",# $)("'"4"'$) $% )-'!

') &!(#( ');$:;')7 &,!::#)7# "$ ",# !>!08!((#- =A ",# .!=$40 $40")-4("0'!:

0'=4)!:

!)- $0-#0( 8!((#- =A $",#0 <4-'&'!:

!)- ?4!('<4-'&'!:

=$-'#( !0# >#::

-#%')#-*

>0'"

$% &#0"'$0!0'

&!) =# '((4#- %$0 &$00#&"')7 #00$0( $% <40'(-'&"'$) &$66'""#- =A ')%#0'$0 $40"( $0 0'=4)!:(*

>0'"

&!) !:($ =# '((4#- >,#0# ') #@#0&'(# $% <40'(-'&"'$) &$)%#00#- $) '"/ ",# $40"

$0 ",# 0'=4)!:

!&"( '::#7!::A $0 '680$8#0:A '*#* '"

-#&'-#( !

?4#("'$) >'",$4"

7';')7 !) $88$0"4)'"A "$ =# ,#!0- "$ ",# 8!0"A !%%#&"#- =A ",# $0-#0 $0 >,#0# ",# 80$&#-40# !-$8"#- =A '"

'( $88$(#- "$ ",# 80')&'8:#( $% )!"40!:

<4("'&#* $>#;#0/ '"

64("

=# 0#6#6=#0#- ",!"

",# <40'(-'&"'$) $% ",# '7, $40"

"$ '((4# !

>0'"

$% &#0"'$0!0'

'( !

(48#0;'($0A <40'(-'&"'$) !)- )$"

!88#::!"# $)#* ,'( )#&#((!0':A 6#!)( ",!"

",# %')-')7 $% %!&"

0#!&,#- =A ",# ')%#0'$0 $40"

$0 0'=4)!:/ !( !

0#(4:"

$% ",# !880#&'!"'$) $% #;'-#)&#/ &!))$"

=# 0#$8#)#- $0 ?4#("'$)#- ')

>0'"

80$&##-')7( #@&#8"

>,#) ",# <4-76#)"/ $0-#0 $0 !>!0- (4%%#0( %0$6 !) #00$0 $% :!> !88!0#)"

$) ",# %!&# $% ",# 0#&$0-* ,'( '( ",# !=("0!&"

("!"#6#)"

$% :!>/ =4"

",# ;#@#- ?4#("'$) '( !( "$ >,!"

'( !) #00$0 $% :!> !88!0#)"

$) ",# %!&# $% ",# 0#&$0- !)- ') >,!"

&'0&46("!)&#( !

%')-')7 $% %!&"

0#&$0-#- =A !) ')%#0'$0 $40"

$0 0'=4)!:

$0 !

?4!('<4-'&'!:

!4",$0'"A &!) =# &$00#&"#-*

0$!-:A (8#!1')7/ !) #00$0 $% :!> '( $)# >,'&, &!) =# -'(&$;#0#- $) !

=!0# 0#!-')7 $% ",# <4-76#)"/ $0-#0 $0 !>!04)-#0 &,!::#)7# !:$)7 >'", ",# -$&46#)"( >,'&, ,!;# =##) 0#:'#- 48$) =A ",# ')%#0'$0 $40"/ 0'=4)!:

$0 ?4!('<4-'&'!:

!4",$0'"A*

) #00$0/ ",# -'(&$;#0A $% >,'&, '( 8$(('=:# $):A !%"#0 !

-#"!':#- (&04"')A $% ",# #;'-#)&# 80$-4&#- =A ",# 8!0"'#( !)- :#)7",A -#=!"# !"

",# =!0 &!))$"

=# 0#7!0-#- !( !) #00$0 $% :!> %$0 ",# 8408$(# $% !

>0'"

$% &#0"'$0!0'*

%')-')7 $% %!&"

0#&$0-#- =A !) ')%#0'$0 $40"

$0 0'=4)!:

&!) =# &$00#&"#- $):A '% '"

'( (,$>) ",!"

') 0#&$0-')7 ",# (!'- %')-')7 ",# $40"

$0 ",# 0'=4)!:

,!- #00$)#$4(:A 0#%4(#- "$ !-6'"

!-6'(('=:# !)- 6!"#0'!:

#;'-#)&# $0 ,!- #00$)#$4(:A !-6'""#- ')!-6'(('=:# #;'-#)&# !)- ",# (!6# ,!( ')%:4#)&#- ",# '6847)#- %')-')7* 5'6':!0:A/ !

%')-')7 $% %!&"

=!(#- $) )$ #;'-#)&# >$4:- =# 0#7!0-#- !( !) #00$0 $% :!> >,'&, &!) =# &$00#&"#- =A !

>0'"

$% &#0"'$0!0'* $>#;#0/ (4%%'&'#)&A $0 !-#?4!&A $% ",# #;'-#)&# 0#:'#- 48$) =A ",# ')%#0'$0 $40"

$0 0'=4)!:

$0 ",# ?4!('<4-'&'!:

!4",$0'"A &!))$"

=# 7$)# ')"$ =A ",# '7, $40"

>,':# &$)('-#0')7 ",# 80!A#0 %$0 '((4# $% !

>0'"

$% &#0"'$0!0'* .'1#>'(#/ ",# 6#0#/ 8$(('=':'"A $% %$06')7 !

-'%%#0#)"

$8')'$) $) 0#!880#&'!"'$) $% #;'-#)&# =A ",# 8!0"'#( '( )$"

(4%%'&'#)"

%$0 '((4# $% !

>0'"

$% &#0"'$0!0'

, ?++'

8 0, , + )0 % !4" +! --5 *"", 1" '

8,# ( " 8 " ' , + )0 %- !4" +! 5 & , 0+ , )! , 3 , ,

+ )0 %: !4" +! %- 5 0

+ 2!=' , + %%% 00

# /$ . & %%% /- , *+, 3< ) , + )7& 9 , + & : % * $)('-#0')7 ",# "$"!:'"A $% &'0&46("!)&#( ') ",# :'7,"

$% :#7!:

80')&'8:#( ')-'&!"#- !=$;#/ ",#0# '( )$ (&$8# %$0 !)A ')"#0%#0#)&# =A ",'( $40"

') ",# %')-')7( >!00#)-#0#- =A ",# 0'=4)!:

=#:$>/ ') #@#0&'(# $% >0'"

<40'(-'&"'$)* ,#0#%$0#/ ",# ')("!)"

>0'"

8#"'"'$) %!':( !)- ",# (!6# '( !&&$0-')7:A -'(6'((#-* +*

8#)-')7 !88:'&!"'$) (/ '% !)A/ (,!::

("!)- &:$(#-* * +*

(<1(

,#",#0 (8#!1')70#!($)#-

$ ,#",#0 0#8$0"!=:# #(