High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5009/2014disposed of

Oriental Insurance Comp Ltd v. Amandeep Kaur & ORS

2020-02-13Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh8 pages

!"#$!

%&

''

$$ ( )*$+ $$ %&

' ,&$")

!"#$!

%&

''

$$ ( )*$+ $$ %&

' ,&$") -----

!

( )*$+ $$ %&

''

$$ !"#$!

%&

&)'/ ----- !"

#$%&' "()*(+,!'"'-# ,++&

"'-# ,++&.)/0 # "

!"$$"'

%

.

) &&" 1'$&

"! "& 23%"

("0 "

)

. " "3.

% 5

"$ 5/ $ 6.

7)'/ *

"

5

8".

&)'/9!

5

"$ 5/)

' 4.

0 "

"$&)'

"&&. 23%"

("0

! $

".

&)'/ !.$ &

''

$ 5

"$ "$""0

"5.$".

:. .)&)'

" &&" 7$") # "5.$

( "5 "

8

"5.$9! 2

,;

"$

.

; $/"&)

2

< "

$

, .$ "'$"

* &/ 2 >

*

2

*$% " $&

".) 2

$

".

&)'/ !.$

")/ )

' 4.

7?;

" ."&"

5$" &&" 1 '$& &. 0$"0 "%"0 "0

% "&$ " #1

@;;> 6 " )

"

=)" ""& "

' "0% "&$ &) )$ "

)'

%

5/23%"

("0 "! "& , '

!

A.

.! ( "5 ! "'6"

" "

" )

'

)"

&'&"

/

)'

!

% $$"0 &

"5.

/ 0$"0 "$"5$ 5

"5.

?"

:. .) &)'

" "

" "&) " "0

" $

"0

&

/ .''

""0

"5.$".

?"

"&)

" !! 1"0

'

'

/ $

"0 2

,; '

) "&) )/ 5 && "0$/ @ '

/ =

"0 5 "

"

" " "&) .

'

5/

$/"0.'3.0) @95$

(.'

7.

"#$%&'()*+,"

- &+.("/# "/(&0 . $

&)'/ "

'$/ !.$&

)

"

& =)" " )"

" "'

"%"

B=7?

,

5

0"%"02

,;'

) . $

6 ".

"&.) /

%& " "&)

)

' 4.

. " "3.

"

&&.

' "5 /.'"&"62B=7!"

B0$"

$ " B=7 ! '

5

# "5.$ ! "& ! $0 5/ # 3"

4.

)

' 4.

"

")/ 5/ !/

=)" ""& "

%

" !

/!

0"0 ) A 0

& " %"$$0 @.) < 5 )

$ " 1

@;;> &) )$ 0 %

/ "0 '

" 0$"0 )

.&10"

)'

% $$

0

.$

)'

% $$

!

""

6 =)" "

"0% "&$ &) )

" % "&$ 5/

.5# ! ).& !" 5.

&&.

1'$&

)

$$

"0% "&$ " ''

"

5= &.

")/ )

' 4.

.& & 5

$"&"

"& =)" ")

&&" "

.$ 0$"0

"5.

5$

&. )

'

"0&&.'

)'

% $$

"/)

"5.

''

"0

&&.

6 "%"

!

)

6")/ $.5$ && &

"

&)'/ ""0

"5.$".

.!

"

% "6 "&

=

& ) 3.0) @95$

(.'

7.

1/)) .#

#2%#( "/(& - "#$ %&'( ,"

"/(&0 34 3#5#$4 67 # " 5 "0

7.

&)'

" 5/

"5.$)

"

")/ '

.5 !"0

5." '

/ $"0

'

"0 2

,;'

) # " /&.) % /% "&$ !!

5

"

"0 % "&$

"0

5."

'

(")"$ $/

" "

'

&.) / !"0

/ $"05." # ")/)

%& ""&)

"&

5 " ) " .

6

0"% &"

&.) "

& $/5 $ &$") "$ .& ."&"

).& $ &0 '

% %& ""&)

.5

"'

"%"

)

"

0"%"02

,;'

) 5.

"0 "' ! $ )1 "

"'$& .5

! 8

9 5

. "

'

0"%"02

. $ 7$") '

&'/%"051&&. "

) 23%"

("0 4.$!"

("0 4 ("0 ) B=7 !

"

$ .)5

!"

'"

!"

!$ ("&

&&. " "

3" ) 23%"

("0 4.$!"

("0 &$ '"&

!

'"

!

) # " =)" 4.$!"

("0 '

% ) / '"

"

" &&.

"0

#1"0 &.).$ %"

! )

"$

& &.'$ !"

)"").)!0 %"$5$

%

")

"&)

" 2

,; '

) 7$") $$5 "

"""&) .

'

C

&$") 5

"$

!"!)"

)""5$ "

$$"%"0 !.$ , 6 " )

$ &/ &) 2

D2

,; 2

= = E 2

,; C "

"

! .

'

'

F 2

,; , " !

$ G

H

&% "$ &)'

"$$!

")""

$$ 5 2

,;

"$

.

; *&

".) 2

.

$ 2

*

2

6 %"

!

5%

$ &)'

" " 2

&)'

""

=

2

,;2

,; ;2

,;# &)'/ $$5

&%

=& ).

"$

/'"

5/"$"0''

"

''$"& "5

"5.$ ''

$"$

&)'/"'

$/$$!

''

$"$

"")" "

"

)

7 ! $

&)'/!.$" ) ''

$ 5

"$ "$$/:. .)&)'

" "5.$! 2

,;

"$

.

; *"&) 2

(.

"0

.) 2

"&$ 2

*) "

3/) $" 2

$

''

$$ !.$ ) )

# "5.$ " 5$.

$/ 5"

/ ! ")"&$ # # "5.$ '"

"&"0 /"5"$"

/&

""&

"5 / '"

$"I "

"3.

'

&

$ "0

. 2

5/''$/"0).$ "'$"

)

6 ".

"&

" .& ."&"

).& $ &0 '

% $.

&)'

"$$!

"5.$& . " $

"0

,

' !.$

!

&&.' % "&$ 5/

.5 23%"

("0 ! "

"

&&"

.$

! !.$

% $ " ' >

"

&.) '

5/&$") ) $/) "&$

5/ I .$ "'

&"$"

/ @'"

$ 7 "&$ 7

7

@$/& 7% 2 1$B=77" ) "&$

& ".

5/< ( .9 $0/6)0"07

7 "0 &'"

) +"& $"'<&.) B=7

% $/ "0!"

"3.

B=77'

" ) 5$

&.&

"/

5.

" "0 '

%

!

0 &.&

&&. . ""0"3.

"

&&" (")"$ $/

&.) 1 + & &

!"

"

'

"3.

" / )

&

"

& !"

/ "3.

) "&$

"&.

" "

# "5.$

5 1! % '

&

$ "&) 5/ ''$/"0 ).$ "'$"

6 5 / &$

& &)'

"

"5.$"

2

,;'/5$ "

C'

.) )

'

" "$$

$"I "# ".

&)'/ $$5

&%

=& ).

"/

> $

/'"

5/"$"0''

"

''$"& "5

"5.$ <"' && "0$/ &'/

! 5

""0 "&

&&

1"0&

".

0 81,4 8<A.$ "9 ?

'

1"0,

/ , ?

'

5$ / ,