Shikha Pathania v. Punjab And Sind Bank And Others
! "!"# CWP-31127-2018
$ %" !&%"!
' ()'
*+ * $ ,,,,, !
"# $%" &'
() ! "* +"# $%" " ! *"*'"# $%" &'
"* ,,,,, + * $- . /01
- &&%". -' '"$ /
%'"0 '
& "1
"1 ".."
'"$ &.
/''
-
"0"'
""
1 0 2'1 #'
% #'
+" / 0
%
0 '
3 '
&"%.+ & & % &"% " '- /
4"%
&1 5 6778&79.
-
"". '
:2+
"
7 78# '
% :2 ".
& 2'1 "
8 78 -'
/+1";
".+&
2%& "0 '
1 %".
& "+-" 1
/+'
% ."+2'+"- .."'
"
7 6 79 -'
/+ '
.." 2'+ 1
'
"
". &
/+ '
< = "
2 ."
"0/ '".&&'
% '"'
-"-*0"" /""+&&% ""%'&&% # #=2 '"" 20'
7 7<6 7> '
-" $
-'"%'"0 '
7> 6 78.
..0'
&..-0"..
0"
!"# $
%& ' ( ) !! )*
!! ) ((
+, -
$+
((
$ , ,+ ./ 0)1*2"+ - $ .'
3
3
$)! 4 , ( , 5
6! )"
(( +, -
$+ 3 ( ,
+
)#
#
3 0 $+ !*# 7
8(,+5
. #0 $+ )62)
6
)#8
5
(,+5
++ ++ ( ++,+ ,
,
-
3 (
5
5
+$
$3 ( $
(,+5
#9
(,+5
++ ,
( -
+ :
,3
(-
3 -
$(
: , 3
- $
-
,
+ 3
+
( + ( 3 $5,
+ !* /
5 , $+ ++
( ( , +
7
8(,+5
; &,+
/,, +#0 $+ )62) && ( <8980/'/9/<80 =0&#
&%.%'%9/0>/?@=0%@>#
3+ 3 $ %& ' ( ) !! )* !! ) (( ++3 $ +, -
$+
((
$ , ,+ ./ 0)1*2"+ - $ .' AB )
((
, ,+ $ 5 9 !6)!! )" ,
3
$ )! 4 ( $
< 0" " + , ( , 5
6! )" ! (
$+ 5 9 !6)!! )" 9%'
, 53(
?
'
%'"0 '
# '
2/1
"
".
.+ - # -'" 0 '
"
.+# '
"2'
"
" " " 02."
"1 ". :2+ 22" '
#'
:2+&&% #"& % 2%0'
%
0#2/1
'
"
7 7 78# -'
-" '
.
'" '
%'"0 .
..
"0"'
&2..+ $
> % & '
" :2+
# " '- %"2 % -" 2
'
# "&& 0 "
2+ 2/1 '
%11
# %2 # &2'
'
" "".0'
& 0 %
/+'
:2+&&%
% ."+ 2'+# "& %
0 '
"1 #
%
""
"
8 78#1 02 '
'
1";
".+&
2%".- "0 '
1 %".
& "+/+ "0 & "
& + " 00
'
/+# '
&
" "
". / & '
.." 2'+#
# '
4 %2$ % ()# ?
7 79 " "
".# '- # %"1 /
1
$
"
7 6 79 % #'
= "
%2 .&'
% '"'
-"'
;2 1&&% '
"%'" -".+"'
"."0 &
? $% %"
" '
1 & / 0
" '
"%' &&% # # =2 '""
2/1
'" '
&&% "
@ 7 7?# %11 0'
0"& '
4 &₹78< 9?."*'&"$2& !A !"2&"%20 1 "+ -" &"%
"
/+ '
'"";
$'#'
5 99<&79#-'-"'
$0 " !""0 # " '" 2%'
"" -" 2
"* 2
'
%2%" 02 "% &'
"%'!""0
# "02
# 1 .+ "
'
0"2 '
'
"*0 & '
" &&% # 0 &"' " -'2 "+
.
'
""&'
%11 " &2'
"02
'"#-'.
"0 '
&&% & "%0 # '
/.+ &
0
%
"% # & "+#
-' '
"%'
"..
&".2 & '
1 0'
$ "0&1'
2&- .$ %'
:2 "120 ?> ?."*'#2/1
#-"". "
+-' '
*-.
&'
"%'!""0 % #%"/ "..
'"'
-""+1" %% ".1 '
"&'
2 .
'" '" '
"%' !""0 '1 .& '"
2%'"
%'
:2 "120 >."*'6 @ 7?2
'-" "- # " '"2%'%'
:2 -
%.
"0" - *
'%2 +2
.%*" * + '
%%21"% #2/1
# %% ".1 %" / "/2
'
". "02
'" '
"2' '" "
"+ "% "0" '
' & !""0 ""1;0'#"-' "% '
B0"2 - /"
" '
% # " %1"+ / '"$ -"
/+ '
>
"*
".C0'
&"1."
" '" 0 &"'
@ 0 '
"/$ # .
"
%2 . "
"0 & '
2/1 '" '
-" 0'.+ $
-' " %'"0
'
"%%2 & '
."
%11
/+ '
%11 0 '
".&"%& '
4 & 78< 9?."*''
"%%2 &!A !"2&"%20 1 "+=1
#-'2 %0 %" " %"2 "02
'"'
&".
%. '
02."
"0'
$ '
"%%2"0&1'
2&- .$ %'
:2 "00 0"0 ?> ? ."*' '
%"+# '
%.21
%&%"..+ :20 %.2 & 02." #'
'"
%
D. %
"%+ E&2'
2/1
'"#$ -&'
" 1#
% ."+ %
0- $". .+" 0'.+"
%'"0 '
-" 2.+ $
2 '
#-'%''
&.
"
.+ %1 .
" &"
2+
& '
.& -" "&&
'
- #'
%' "
2% "+ $
% 2
&'
& % 2/"" '
"..
0""- .."'
& % -/ 0 ;
%
%
" & '
1" ". % # '
:2+ &&% %
%" 0%".& 0'.
0'"'
'"
%11
'
".'
"%0"2'+$
&&% "
@ 7 7?#
'
"%%2 / 0 $ "%%2 & '
2 & - .$ %'
:2 "120 ?> ? ."*'# 2%'"
&1 '
"+ 6 @ 7?
0" '
& % "
/+'
'"'
&"%& %'
:2 2%'" -" -' '
*-.
& '
&&%".# '
8 :2+&&% #"& "".+0'
%
0#
'"'
.& -" "-" & '
'2 & '
%'
:2 -'" 0 2%' *-.
#'
&".
'
02."+#'
/+
0'
%'"0 "0"'
&2..+ "/.'
& 0 %
/+'
:2+&&%
4"%
"2
) @ $ . 3
((
, ,+ 5
!6-)!-! )" ,
3
$)! 4 ( $ 0" " ', ( , 5 - 6-! )"@ .(
,+5 3 ,
,
5 .
C $
( '+. $
,
/ $
+5 $ 3(
+/ 4 , 3
5 3 3+ $
+ ( '+3, 4
%& 7 ,3 7 ,
( + $ (( +5 @ . ( &8D 3
)2-)!-! )" 5,
5
,
++
,
++3 , ++( $ 0! 6)1' , 5%
++3 + 5
, + ( ++
++ (5+ ( ,
$ +
7
,+5 ( 5 . (,+5 +
$+ 5
$ 4 3 3 3+ $ . 3 ++
+
9
+
+ 5
, $
( ,
,
!6)!! )" $ . ++5 ,
!E ( ,
$ +
7.
,+5 +
$+ 5 3 3 3+ $
+ ( '+ . $
( + , 4 7 ,
( + $ 3
.+ 5 , 5 ++ +3
( %& ' 3 ,, ( %& ' + ,
$+ 5 5 ,
$ +
+ , ( ,
,
!6-)!-! )" ,
( .3
7.+ (
( ,
,
!6-)!-! )"
, $9%'
, 5$ . ++5,
7 &2'
2/1
'"#2 % &'
:2+
# '
"1 -" 2.+&2'
'
" '
%11 - $
'
& %
"&'
.+2/1
#'
% ."+ 2'+ %
" '
& 2'1 "
-" '
"& "".
/+'
"
".
.." 2'+#2
4"10 ".. 2/1 "
$"%
/+ '
# &2 1 '
" "%% 0.+ 2 .
'
"
/+ '
% ."+ 2'+
"$ "&'
"
/+'
.." 2'+ "
'2
@ F@ /,, ++
5 $ % 4 $ / 5 %/# , 5&,+ 5/ 53 ,,+ ( 7G 5 /( 8
&
( 5 /,, ++ % 4 5 , /,, ++ 3
$ / 5 - %&B' ++ ++ +, (
)
H (
3
+
5 3 $ / 5 3 ++ ++
+3$
++ @ /,, ++
4 5 3
3 ,
B( (
+5 $
,, 5 /,, ++ , + + +
5 3 $
@ /,, ++
$ 3 ++ !6)!! )" 3
,
,
5
((
, ,+5
+5$
5 @ /,, ++
,
, B9 )2-)!-! )" 3
5 ( '+B .7+ $B/< , 5
(( )2-)!-! )"
!6-)!-! )" ++3
./ 0)1*2"'3+
,,
% $ /,, ++ / 5
% 4 53 $
$+ , ,+ + 3
@ &,+ 5/ 5
$
3 % 4 5 E $ ((
/,, ++
+
$ +
$ /,, ++ @ /,, ++ ;
7 ( ++ +, (
.
3
3+ $
+
+ ( +
/,, ++
, + @ /,, ++ ;
4 53
3 ,
B( (
+5 $
,, 5 /,, ++ , + + +
5 3 $
+ , , % 4 5 ++ $
, % 4 5 @ /,, ++ ;
, ,+3
,
,
5
((
, ,+ 5
+5 $
5 $ $ $ 5(
+( + $
$
( (
(
@ /,, ++ !6)!! )"
((
, ,+ $ 5
+ ./ 0 )1*2" ' ,
$+ 5
$ )! 4 ( $ 0" " + , ( , 5 6! )"33 3+ $ /,, ++ E
/,, ++
,
9%'
, 5 !6)!! )" , 3 $
$+ ,
$ - $. % $ /,, ++ / 5 5
, 5 &,+ 5 / 5 @ ,, + (
5
+ %
,+
, 5 &,+ 5 / 5
,, +F
77 = "
%2 . & '
% '" '
%
2 %/
."- '" /
1 %2.2.+ "
2/1
'"'B/.
2# % &-;2 %#-2.
".+ $ "
".$ '
& 0
&'
% ."+2'+#2.
'
"
1"/.
$ +#..
0".+#
%
2". 1 +# "/.'
1".% /" %
'"C
'" 2%' "..
0" '"$ /
1"
'
%"
2 . &2'
2/1 '" '
% & '
0" 0 "..
%1"+ "1 &"%2"..+2 "/.
2'" "1";
".+&
2%".- "0 '
1 %".
& "+/+- "0 #-'"&2'
%'"2%'
2%-2.
"
.+"&& %
" 1"./ &#'"
/
1
2 '
' &!""0 # ' ""1; 0'# /+ '
% ."+ 2'+ @ 78 %% 0.+#2/1
'"'
'"/
4 "&'
!""0 # -' -" '
"
$0 "2'+# " '
& # '
%."1 &
%1""0"'
."%*1 2'1 '""./
1
'
!""0 '"";
$' 7 &2'
2/1
'" "".02 % '"$ /
"
$"%
'
1" &' '"";
$'#-''
.
% '"'''
.
'
&!""0 "'
.
$"1
'"$ '
" .
"
2 . "
"0 / '".& & '
%$ " " '"$ 0 '20''
%21 "
".0-' '
-
7 7<
' 2/ $ '""2/"". '"'"/
."%
/+ '
'
% '" " %1"+ "
"%' -" "
/+'
#"12%'"'
". -" %
"0" -'.
'
' & !""0 " '
!""0 - %
"0" " %" &2. 4"1" & '
% #
'" 2%' %
$ &1 # "%2.".+.0'&'
%&%
"
@ 78#-'
/+'
' &!""0 -"2/;
%
"1";
".+ ".0-'
"0" !""0 " - ..
&2'
/ $
'" '
B .
"'"'
1 .+%2 0
'
"."'
"% & ' ""1; =". %" "/.$ '
& /.+ :2+ &&% #"- .."'
% ."+"
.." 2' #'"$ 0'.+ %
'"'
-" :2
2/1"
"'
-.
.#
%0
;2 "% & "
0 '
0"2 %2 00'
"."'
:2 &"+'
#-'2
.0 % # $"/.+%2 "
.%& 2+'
" "1&'
$ - '" % '
%
2". :2 1" " '" " &&% %%
12
.+$ &+'
.
$"&"%/ & 1"*0"+ %11 "#""%&'
0&&% &".0 %'"0 2%'
2+#-'
'
"'
/ & &&% '
- #%"#/+ .&# %2 2&&% 02 &% "&2%'% 2% %
2". &"1 -*0$ 0/"*0
"#" '
%'" .'20'-'%'
". 12 " "%# "
./ " .+ 2%2
"
2 '" 12. .
$ 2". '"$ '
2+ 4"1 '
".
.+#
% "+ %
"% &1 '
% # "
76
'
"1
2%' " + 1
0
&"%." &1
" %%2
% 1"*0 7?
'
" %" # '
&".
&1 '
/.0" "%% "% -' '
%/
%
2
'
* % " & '
.% .
.+ '
02 '" '
"%
" '
% & '
2
- #
'" 20 '
:2+
%
0# '
.
"
"+ $
% 2/"" ' " # '
"/.' '" '
-" %1
..
/+ "+ 2
&&% %2 0 '
32'
1 # '
". % 200 '" '
* "+
" " %% . " %1 ."#/ & "
0'
0"2 '
%11 "#
/ 0"-" &'
%
"% %% 0.+# $
'"'
"%& %2 00 '
-" " %
% '
" & '
% :2 % '" &.- &1 2%' % 2% " # '
& # :2" .+"/2"/.
'
/ "0'"'
- &;2 %". $ - 1" & % ."+ %
0 %%21%/
B/.
2 2'"
"
.+'
.
'"%2-2.
".+ & -' '
& 0 & " % ."+ "2'+ 2.
'
$
% &
$ +#..
0".+# %
2".1 + '% 4# & % 1"
'
;2 234 /0 ' 5/ 6 74 839/ */66#
"!"
."1*:"
#" // /0 0-
0;4 / /< / 6 7 #"!"!* 0 *=#&# -'
-""&&1
'";2 %". $ .1
" '2.
/
%
-' "# "%2.".+-'
'
% ."+"2'+'"
7< "%
"%% "% -' "/.'
%
2 " '
1"/.
1"."&
.
$" 4"%&'
;2
// /0 0 0;4 6 7 / 839/ 3>4 .32/1
4"%
"2
!))G 3++ ,
5 =$. :
3 3
, ,+ 5 ,
$ % 3 ++ + =$ . ( ,, ++ 5
,,
+
4 5
G 3++
( . 3
,
5 =$. 3 $ , (
+
4 5$ ,+
!)!% /
0( 0I /
0( 0 /%0 )6 . )1!
J
C$
. + =$.
/ + !! . ,, +
+ $ , (
+
4 5$ ,+
% =$.
3
3
,
$
@ =$. (53
3
, (
+ 5 3 + ,
$ $ + 4
3 , ,+
+ 3
$
3 (5
+5 ,, + + 4
$+ 5 + 5 + ,
$ (
4 5 3
5( :
+
++3 ( +
+
5
+
3
+
5 3++5 5
7? ,
+ ,
+
+ % 3
4 5 , ,
+5 + , (
+ 5 + $
( + $+
3 $ 45
++ 5
(
3 ,
(
=$. 3 , K !) @ , ,+ 3
/ . L
0I / . L
0 )61"# ! .. ""1 A )61" .. '7# *6J @ 3
/ + !! ,
5 @ :
,3
,, ++ @ $
5
+ ,,
B,
4
3 ,
$ /
+33,,
5 3
3
$
(5 /3 3
$ $ +
+5
( (+ (
+
+5 ( (+
/ $
5 +
++
$ (
+
+
4 $ @ 45
5
+ ,
3 ( $
3 :+
+ ::::::::::::::::::::::::::: !) % ?
% < I?
% < ! )"# ! .. ) J . + =$ . :
,3
7> / + !! !!1 . % ++
B,,
@ =$. 3+
(
3
A ..,, ) B)1, )!# #
4 5 +5 (,
5M
#
4 5 + $ ,
,
+M
#
+ , ,+ + $ ,
$M
#
+ ( +
(
$ + 5(
3
:
(
M
#
++3 ( +
+
5
+
:
M
# +
5 3++5 5 ,
+ ,
+
+ M
$# ,+ 5 5
+5 + ( (+ (
+
M
# ,+ 5 5
+5 ( (+
3 +
$M
# $
!)1% , ) $(
I?
% < ! )"#!.. ) J . + A ) ?
/ + !! -!!1 . % =$. ++ A
#
,,
M
#
3 +
4 5 (
3 +3M
#$ 45
M
#$
++ 5
M
78
#
( + $+
3 $ M
#
3
$
(5,, M
# $ , , + 5, (
+
'
%" #.0'&'
B"
1
&".2
%'"0 '
2+
.+#%2 .
-''
"/ % &"+ $
% 2/"" % %/+2
&&% #'
02 &;2 %". & % '
% ."+"%1
7>
2 &2'
/ $ '" '
"..
0" -'" 200 01".% /"'
"&'
&&%".#%.2 0 '
:2+&&% #"0"'
'
"+" '"'
1" "+ %
2". :2 #" %/
2
'
0$ 02.
# - 2.+ %1 .
-'
'
"/ % & 2%' "..
0"# '
%%.2 %
/+ '
:2+ &&% %" / %'""% C
" / 0 /"
$
% " 2.0 &1 "+01 "
0 1 "&'
$
% %
- .. .
'"" .
"
& % "
/+ " .+
% ."+ %
0 12 / 2/""
/+ $
% .
/+'
.+
%%
%"/
21 &"$2&'
.+
1 .+"%%2&" .& $0 " " 1"
'
%2 &'
%
0 '
%" #'
% %. "+1" ".'
/"&-'%'%" / '
.
'"'
'"2%% &2..+ $ '
& % /+.
"
0& %0 $
%
:2 .+#/ && 2/%"/ 4
'
79
32'
1 # ". '
.
'" '
".+ 1
2 '
#"
2%".- "0 '
1 %".
& "+&"
& + "%"/ " / '%*0.+ " '
"2 " 0"$+&'
1% 2% "/.'
% #& 1 '
-
"1 " "%% 0.+ 1
.+ * $1 * -"!"# L+ ( 5'
'
"*0A "
A 5'
'
"/.
A