Bhagat Singh v. Hdfc Ergo Etc
!" #$% !& % !
% %''(#)*+ ,
-
'.
/0-1 $23'2 44** 5
% !
*) 64+7 !4
- 8 9
'. 8
/0-1 $23'2 44** 5
% !
*) 64+7 !4 - 888
'. 8
/0-1 $23'2 44** 5
% !
*) 64+7 !4 - :
'.
/0-1 $'6*%;' 44** ; !6<)6 !4
!-(
=$7 -!# 3 -7!3
!"#
!"# #"$%&
#"$ &
'()
$*+(
*( ),
#"$ & ----- -7!3
,# -
'
/0-1
- 8 9
'8
/0-1
- 888
'8
/0-1 . /0 , 0 ),
2 (
-
'.
/0-1 + , #% , 0 ),0
- 8 9
'.8
/0-1 + , # , 0 ),0
- 888
'.8
/0-1 + , !#3 , 0 ),0
,
0 ) /0 , / ( 0
+ 2 2 $! "# #"$
!"
#"$%& # "% #"$ & 0 ( ) 2 ( ) ( 2 2 () 10 0
*!
*3#!!
/0 2 )(0 2 0( ) 1 ) 0 () ( 2 00 , 0 ( ), 0( 2 ( ( ) 0 2, ( 0
4 /0 2 2 $! "# #"$
/0 2 2 # "% #"$ 2 ) ) ## "$ #"$ 0 0( 2 ) ( 1( 2 2 1 1 2 (0 ( , ,0
+ ( 40
0 2 10 0
*!#*$% % 5& , 2 0 0 6() ) / , / ) ,
/0 , ( ( ) 0 6(() 2 , (, ) )
. (0 5( 0 ( , ) ( 2 , 0 5 10 0
*!#*$% % 0 0 ( ) 6(
.( , (0 0 5( 6( 2 , 0 0 2 0 , ) ( ) ) ( + ( ( ( 1 0( / ) 5( 0 , ) ) 1 ) 5( 6(, , 7( 0 )(0 2
( * ( 1/0( 2 80 )9 , ( 0 ),0 (
(
) ( ( :(0)
() 7( 7( (1) 2 0 0
, (
, :(0)
() 7( $*>' -<'6)+ +
$;;3
### 2 ,
, (0 ) 1( 0 ( /0 &
. ) ( ( :(0)
() 7(
?)';
', '+) @ "+
)6)26/%1A+7! 7
3% #"$ $% "% #"$%
( :(0) 7( 4& 3'&;
@') 64+7,
$;"
#"$ $" "3 #"$! 2 , $$!3 ,
(1) 0 1(0 , 2 2 0 (, , 5( 0 0 6(, ( 1/0( ,
0 '() ( 0 ( ), & (1) ( , 0
( :(0) * 1 !'
->3'2
"
#"$# #! "3 #"$! 2 , 3$"
, 0 0
8 2 7) 0( :( ( / ( /0 ,
<) $;!
( 0 ,
0 0() ( ( , 0 * ( 1/0( ( * ( ), 1(, 2 )) 1 .1( 2 0 / =2 >
2
+ 1/0( 0 2, 0 0 1( 0 ) 1 .1( (0 ) 1( 2 & 00 1 5( 0 , 0 ),0 (0 , 0 7( 1( ,) *( ), &
.(0 7( 3'&;= (& 0 , $$!3 , 0 2( , 22 5*) 2 2 (1) ) * ( 7( , 1(
,) *),
76(, , #% , 0
, # , 0
8
!#3 , 0 8
, 1, (1: ,0
$""""?*
7 2( (0 ( 5( 0 0 2 5(0 ( 2( ),0 ) 2( ) ) )(0 2
- :
'
4, , ### , *0 ),0 ) (0 2 ) #" "% #"$ 1( (
0, 7( 0 ) 1: "
"! #"$ * 1: 2 ) , 0 ,
0 ) ),0 1/ 0 )5 ( ) 1 ( 0 (
0, 7( , $" "# #"$ .(0 2 0 , ( ) ( ) 2 * 22 2 ) + ) , 1(, ( (0 0 1)
9 5(
(0 ( 1, ( ( 2 , ### , *0 ),0
-' . ( 1(
!"# #"$%
$
#"$ & ( 0 2 7) .1( =(0 $! "# #"$ 2 7.
7 ;
;% 2 0
!"
#"$% 00 2 7.
7
$!
# "% #"$
) .1( 6( ) )
.
!"#
!"
#"$%& 2 2 / $ "
#"$# . , 0 2 0( "@ 2 2( 1 ( ), A >7 =
= +( 7), < &
(
$
#"$ 5 ) 1 7.
7
;
" "% #"$# 2 ( ) /0
,
,) 6( . *) / )
!%""""?* 2 )
:
, :(0) ( 2 0 1, *2 5
*!#*$% % )1( ( 5 "@
,8
8
# 4 0 ( 2( , 2 ) , 10 0
*#!* *% 3 2
,
,) 0 0 C '() & ) ,
( ')1
5 10 0
*!#*$% % 2 $$
#"$% 2 !
!"
!"# #"$%
) '()& ) 1 ) , 0, 0 00 ) ) ,
E 0 )*, A()A 10 0
*!
**3#!! ) 1 00 ) 2 )*,
,
,) (0 2 ) ,
( C '() ( )( :(
B(, (
( 00 0 5 #"@ 5 () 0(, 5 "@
0, ) ) 12 ( 00 0
( ) 5 () 2 , , )( ) 1( ) 2 0 1, ) # 1 .1(&
2 () 2 % 1
+ ,
) 2 5
*!#*$% % ( 2 , 0 ) 2 :( (
( ')1 2 0 0& ) , 0 2 5 ) (/
+ 0
( ')1 ) ( 5 ()
2 ) ) 2 ) ,
( ')1 ) 7.
;
;% 0 ), & C '() 0 ) 2, 20 , 0 ( ), 0( ( ) 20 ,
( ( *( ), , , )
""""
/0 0 ( ) 2( 6( 0
0 ) ( (, 2 )(0 2 .1( $% "# #"$
# "% #"$ ) 5 ) 1 .1( ) 2 0 , ) (16(, 7( 2( ,1 $* ( ), ( 2 ,0 0 ) ( , 2 1 7( ( ), , 0 , 0 6( 2 2
2 1 %
2 0 1(
$""""?* 0 , 0 2 (0 2 (
!
( , 0 0 , , ( 0 0 ) , ( ')1& 2 5
() 00 #" " " 0
( ')1 ( ,0 2 0 1 ) 2 2 0(, 00 5 #"@
2 5 0 ( ) ) , 1 () 0 ( ) , 1, (0
,
,) :(
( C '() 2 2 ( 6(, 0(, 5 "@ 0 (0
( ),
( 0 0 00 1(0 7( ),0 2 0 00 0
F 7( ) , 2( 0(, A 0A 2 2 ) , 0 A0A 2 2 , 2 0
.( 7( 0 #"@ 00
( ) 00 2 2( 1(
,
,) ) 7( ) ( 2 .1(
!%""""?* 6(
+ )
,
,)
;
, 0 B (0 ( ) ?
B G/
() (/0 =(0
0
#""""?* ) * ) 2, ) , 2 )
+ (
%""""?* ( 6(,
#"
/ (0
. ) 2
:( C '()
( ')1 (, 7( 6( 0 6(, 2 ) ) & ;
0 ( )
%""""?* ( ) 0
#""""?* ) ) ) 0, 500 . ( ) 1: / ( ), 0 00 0 ( H 1( ( 0 ( ), 2 0 0 ( 00 , 1
+ , ( :(0) )(0 2 + 0 00
$"
0 0
,
,) ), ) 4) > G*% (
;
, 0H 2 0 ( ), B5
F (
# , 0 0 12 % , )
$$ 0 ) ( (0 0 4) > 0
#""""?* ) 2 ) , ( 1/ ( 6(, ) /
%"""?* )
0 2 5 5 ) & / $? ) ) ( ) 5
%"?* )
%"""?* ()
$#
0 0 12 % , )( ) .1( 0 :(0) 36 3* 56 %*' 4 4'#"";& !
$#$
) )
! " """?* ()
$""""?* 2 2 ()
%"""?* 2 5 .( 2
!%""""?* 12 ( 00 0
+ %@ () 2 ,1 .1( (0 0 ) I )(
22
$%""""?* ( ) )
$#%"""?* )0 6(, 12
!
:(0) ( 1( / ( 0 2 0 ( $3 $" #"$! 2 ) 2( / ( 0 0
76(, 0( 2 2 6(
+ 2 0 ( 2 00 00 )*, 0 ) , ')1
( 0(, 5 #"@ (0
+ 5 )( $% ( 2 0 (,
;
, )
5 0( ) /
%"""?* 2, (,
F (
$"""""?* ( 2 2, () 6( ) (
8
<, ;@ () ( 2 %@ ()
$% + 0( '() ( 0 * ( ), $ (1) ) , / )
%"""?* ) 0, ( ) 2
.(0 ( 0( ( 2 () 6( ) ( 6(, 7( 2 )( 2 6( ) 2 ( (, (
$!
0 )0 ( 0 )) B5 *$"
1 .1( 2 #% , 0
2 )
;
, 0 1(, ( #% , 0 0 $% ,
, $"
, 1 .1( )) 1 ()
G
;
, % , .1( ) 1 0 2 ,0 ), *) 4) > 0 ( *( ), 0
B5
), ) 0 # , 2 )) #% , 0 .( 0 1 , (), 0
. 0 0 2
, $% , ) 0 0
12 %
, 0
7)0 ( )
B 0( 0 2 ) (,
#""""?* ) ( 1/ ( ) 2,
+ ( (), .1( 2 1? )) (
))() 20
, =) 6( #"$#
3 $ (/ , 20 ( + ), (1 0 0
%"""?* )
$3 F 3%;'
'*) 64+7'6' #"$#& !
#$ 2 ) 2( 1 ) 0 )( )
( 5
(
9 , $?! ) ) )
+ 5 (0 / 1 0 2 !% ,
0 2 (1 ) 0 % , 0 7( 2( 0 )
.( /0 2( 1( $?! ) $?!
( )
!""""?* D
%"""?* )& ) ( , /
%""""?*
%"""?* /
. 7( 0 0 ) .1( )( )( 1, )0 )
"""""?* $;
+ 0 2 0( )( 2 2 () 2 2, 6( ) 2 2 J 5'6*<@ <'% #"$ &
!
(16( :(0)K 76(, $ 22
$"""""?* 2 ()
#%"""?* 2 ( 5 0 #
2 2 $% ,
, $"
, , ,
%"""?* 2 # $% , 2
$"""""?* 2
: $"
, (0
0 + 2, , 2 6(,
%""""?* 2 ) (
#"
.( 2 2 2* & . )
%""""?* $#L
"""""?*&
"""""?* & () $
$"""""?* & ( 5 $
#%"""?* & #
%"""?* &
D
$"""""?* &
#"""""?* &
% !
%""""?* &
$"""""?* .
! ,
,
. 2 7(
%%""""?* ) 2 2
#$ 0 5 0( 2 .1( 0 + %@ 1 ) 7( 0, 20 ,
!@ () )(& (0 2 I )(
0, 2 2( , %@ () 0 ) 2 !@ ()
2(
)(
%"""?* ## ( 2 1
#)*+ ,
/-7!3
? # %
G /0? F G
1 F