← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCEA/15/2022dismissed

Principal Commissioner Of Central Excise, Gurgaon v. M/S Honda Motorcycles And Scooters India Pvt. Ltd.

2024-09-23Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Mr. Justice Sanjay Vashisth3 pages

   

     

A(B "  !  ,:-6-::7 

%& '

   "  # $

"  # 

  "

C

" ;- () *( ( "

+ *.

" *2 2"-<"*- C  * "      ", ( (  

 

  

 

   (-.%/* /$.-."*& &

% !

"/ 

"- (- * .&/$*2 " !

!

"/   * "- === 

- / 0% "  11///2 3    *3+"/ 

"

" "/   "    %* ,'  -4/ "/ "/  2" *" ! "/ *%"+* "/  " 

 * "  &

* % * !

 !3" $  "  * *  

 & !3 "/"/ "

"/  "%5 +3$1// / 3+2"%  !"/  3 &

2 3   "+ 3 ** *"

 "/ /  *   &    " #3  & &

* %*  "/  "  # "$677*"/ % * "/  %* *"/  "  # !!"$6>?$!

"/ 

" *

"

+  "1 1 & +"5 * &%  +%"  8 *3+"/ 9 :

:- 4/ "/  "  " " "/    "  "   23  "/  

%" 2 * 1 & + * % %" 8 *  &%  + * 1/ "/   "

/ +   3  !

    "  !

 "/  "

  * *  

 %* "/  2

!"/  "  # "$677 7  *"/ % * "/  %* 9

D:E

A(B :- <  * % !

"/ 

"/"" *"/" 2" *"  *"  *  %" !%" ""

F 31 5  "  2 * 351"/"/ "% " *" $/ "3   *3+"/   * "* "/    / 3   2  *-  .

 !  "/  0% " 1    *   "  "

  *" "   * "  &

* % * !

 "/   "  * 

 & ! "/  " /  !

 

"  *2  *

"

+ *2 $1 !*"/""/ 0% "  1  +1"/  ""

0% "  -*:

 - - /     * 0% "  1$ / 1 2 $ "* !

+ *F%*" *** * *!2 % !"/   3+"/

%"2* F%*& " *" * :--::7$    !!

"# #"$ %& !#   !!

"#$#  "#'$(#) * +!,!$#&)##"$ $-./.01 232$ 1/  $"/

%"// *%* ,'    

               

 

         

      

       

      

 !"#$%  &"

'   

    

  ( )*+ , -  .$  / 

     

0 !12# $% 3 " ! ( #'      %+  4  $ *   $%4% +

3 !100#  % 131 !, #'

   

 !

        



 





         

 

 " # $%%&           %'%'$%%(          

 

  

            

 

        

    

 

    

       

    

       )     

    ++

*+ )*+   $ - !# 56 7

    

DE

A(B  $%!$%# ,8 $+79 :

'   *   +

  

#       ,$%'$%,- &"

 #



  







    #    

    

 # 



#

 

 

 #        



   

   

 

 

  #       

     "

   

          . - "/ !

 *F%*& "$"/

%"/ F " *"/  

 "" - 1 2 $ 1 /2   *+ *  *"/ * +$1 1 % * "* "/    "" - %3"" 0% " 11 "/ # & !""/   "  $"/   *& +*  *- 7-

 *& " 

"**  * ! *& +-  

 (4    (4 :-6-::7 F / -4/ "/  5&)   *9 ,  ) :-4/ "/   "3 9 ,  )