Chandigarh Housing Board v. M/S Hans Raj Kohli & Company And ANR
!""#$%$&'()$*+ !,- , &.$/ ),0%$&/ ).-1"#!)+-, &.$/ ), (("** &!
2")%0%
3% &% 45,*$ 6( &7 &!,") "%(&."&!%
!
!
"#
$%
8,"!,") "()!")%*# *( (")%6 79" **:".!%""!,"40./6"&!; 9")""))".!!," "()!")%)&!;
< 8,"!,")!,"40./6"&!%,0*.9")"()!".$&!,"$/"%!;
)"%"&!'
)2$%, *1.,$-.=# !"- )!," (("** &! >>>>> !
"
," (("** &!?, &.$/ ),0%$&/ ).$% //)$"=".!," .$%6$%% *!,"94"#!$&%$*".)%""@$&/%"!!$&/? %$."!," : ).. !". +( %%".97!,"$),$"&/$&"") #$&/ % &)9$!) !)
)2$%, *1.,$-*" )&".#0&%"* ((" )$&/&9", *!," (("** &!#&$&"%,$% )/06"&!:$!,)"/ ).!!," 60&!( 7 9*"& ##0&!" )!,:)@0&.")! @"&97!,"&!) #!)9"7&.A!," = )$ !$& %6"&!$&".$&!," /)""6"&!B+3?(")#09$#6"!")$&%!" . 3?"%096$!%!, !#&.$!$&()=$.".!," ((*$# 9$*$!7!," 40%!$$".) !"%!9":)@".0!97!,", &.$/ ),0%$&/ ). )%,)!
CD & !," . !" !"&.") (*0% &7 "%# * !$& % ()=$.". $& !," !"&.")3 /)""6"&! &.- !,")")"- !," 40%!$$". ) !"%- ##).$&/ ! !," ! 90* !".)6"E!) #!".$&!,"6"6) &.06 ((" *-%,0*.9" 3? (")#09$#6"!")$&%!" .+3? &. !!, !) !"-!,"( 76"&!, % *)" .7
9""&6 .","!")6% &.#&.$!$&%" #,#&!) #!, ="!9"%""&," ()"%"&!#&!) #!: %) !! **06(?%06#))"% %!,") !" : ).". $%&,$/,")%$."-$"- <3?(")#09$#6"!") #,#&!) #!$%, =$&/ .$")"&!!")6% &.#&.$!$&%-!,")")"-!,"&!) #!).$.&!* 760#, "6(, %$%-60#,*"%%)"*70(&!,"."#$%$&%!,""& 9*$&/!," )9$!) !) ! )6 & ($&$& / $&%! !,"!")6% &. #&.$!$&% !," #&!) #! &.-!,")")"- : ).: %&! %(")!,"()=$%$&%1"#!$&F < !,")9$!) !$& &.&#$*$ !$&#!-++ )%,)!C!,"#!D **!,"%"
($&!%:")"%")$0%*794"#!".!$&!,"94"#!$&("!$!$&-90!!," 94"#!$&/ 0)!, %."#*$&".!$&!")")"&!,"/)0&.!, !!,", %&!9""& 9*"!*" ."=$."&#"#&!) )7!:, !, %9""&6 ."97!,"&!) #!) &.- !,0%-0)/"%!,$%0)!)%"!!$&/? %$."!," : ). &.!,"$6(0/&".).") , ="," ).!,"*" )&".#0&%"*)!," (("** &! &. (() $%". !,"( (")9@
) !," % @" 9)"=$!7- $! :0*. 9" (! ! )"().0#" !," )"*"= &!()!$&!," : ).-:,$#,)" .%!,0%'?
!
"
#
$
" %
!
& '
&
( # ( )%*+ ,% -%"%.
+
# ) , % /
& %%/
.
(
# 0
/+ *+-
12,
2 )% 3"
4 ) 2
. &
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
$& !," )"6"&!$&". ((" *-, % *)" .79""& &%:")".97!,"&I9*"10()"6" 0)!$&# !"& 40./6"&!%-:,")"$&$!, %9""&* $..:&!, !0&!$* &. 0&*"%% !," : ). %0")% )6$**"/ *$!7 % %! 0!)$*7()"%#)$9". 0&.") 1"#!$&<!,"#!-!,"% 6"# &&!9"$&!")")".:$!,&!,$%#&!"E!- $&!"&. ! )"") !," 40./6"&!% &I9*" 10()"6" 0)! $& ''()*+, -).
1' $,.2) $,3,.45,6+ -+20)+7
& 8 *6/ *3/*7* *''
6+,0+*)65,6+ +/ 1'
59)6,'
8: &!," )"6"&!$&".40./6"&!%-!,"&I9*"10()"6"0)!, . #0**".0!!,") !$."#$."&.$97,*.$&/!, !0&!$* &.0&*"%%!,")"$%"))) (( )"&!&!," #")"#).)!," )9$!) !), %&!**:".%! !0!)7
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
%0"))6 &7$**"/ *$!7$& %60#, %!,")9$!) )-:,$%"E(")!-, %." *!:$!,!," 6 !!") &.."#$."!,"#* $6%)"%("#!$="( )!$"%!!," & 67 =$":- !," : ). )" . % :,*" $% 40%!- $) &. )" %& 9*"!$%&: %"!!*".* :!, !!,")9$!) )$%!,"%*"40./" G0 *$!7 &.G0 &!$!7!,""=$."&#"9")",$6 &.."#$."&!,"9 %$% !," = $* 9*""=$."&#" &67=$":-&")))* : )$%"%)6!," : ).,"% 6"$% (")"#! &.40%!$$". ,")" $% & 6")$! $& !," ((" * ," % 6" $% ##).$&/*7 .$%6$%%". 40).
8+2#
!
" 0*5,'2
$%