← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5084/2014disposed of

Soni & ANR v. Ram Mehar & ORS

2018-11-20Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill4 pages

      



!" #"$%&%'(   )*!)'% '# '!+", --".. '!& /",&0&  *"+ , '#!+",& "&-'#"'!&  

 

,"&"'!( , 0, 1)"!+%2#1$ !" ,!+" --".. '!& ,'#",3%!)%'4+2#1$ !" ,,"&-'#"'! ,) '3""1+ %2#1$ !" ,,"&-'#"'!& 5



 

56 , 7", %' !+" --.%$ !%' %& , -",*%&&%' ! * 8" 4# #"

%$%"'$7%'$0,! "" "

%$%"'!$0,! ""&! '#&#"-&%!"#!+04+ !",!+" &!%-0. !"#!%*" '1%"9 $!& '#$%,$0*&! '$"& !+"$ &"2!%*"!

%: !+"& *"%&":!"'#"#!%..!+"' --.%$ !%'%&#%&-&"#  

6 " ,# ,!+"," &'&*"'!%'"#%'!+" --.%$ !%' '#!+" ,40*"'!& ##,"&&"#2#". 7 ;<# 7&%' !+" --" .%&$'#'"# --.%$ !%'%& ..9"#

+%& --" . + & =""' %."# =7 !+" $. %* '!& &""8%'4 "'+ '$"*"'!   !+" $*-"'& !%' 9 ,#"# ! !+"* =7 !+" ." ,'"# !, $$%#"'! . %*& ,%=0' .2 *= .  >,%=0' .? , &+,! 1%#" 9 ,# # !"#  ; 5' $$0'! #" !+ !+"%,&'/%-%'%' *!,1"+%$." $$%#"'! '  

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

"'#%'4 1"+%$." =7 %!& #,%1", +"," %& ' #%&-0!" ,"4 ,#%'4!+" =1"& %# %'#%'4 !+"." ,'"#,%=0' .'!+%&%&&0"29+%$+ + & !! %'"# %' .%!7 C" ,'"#,%=0' . 0,!+",$'$.0#"#!+"#"$" &"#!="<7" ,& .# !!+"!%*" +%&#" !+ '# &&"&&"#+%&%'$*" && A6-",*'!+

"#0$!%'  D9 &"

"$!"#!9 ,#&-",&' .":-"'&"& &#"$" &"#9 & 0'* ,,%"# 0.!%-.%",    9 & --.%"# +0&2 !! . #"-"'#"'$7 9 & &&"&&"# !& 2 2 A6  : :&0* & 2 A69 & 9 ,#"# ' $$0'! !, '&-,! !%'2 0'", . '#. &!,%!"&+0&2$. %* '!&9","+".# "'!%!."#! !! .$*-"'& !%' & 2; 2 A6 .'49%!+%'!","&!E;D -", ''0* ,*!+"# !" $. %*-"!%!%'!%..," .%& !%' C" ,'"# $0'&". , !+" --".. '!& &0=*%!& !+ ! *" 4," $*-"'& !%'+ &=""' 9 ,#"#2!+04++"#"&'!#%&-0!"!+"%'$*" !+"#"$" &"# & &&"&&"#=7!+"." ,'"#,%=0' .,"1",2'%'$,"*"'! + & =""'

,#"# ' $$0'!  0!0," -,&-"$!&0.!%-.%", + & 9,'4.7 =""' --.%"# =7 !+" ." ,'"# ,%=0' . 8""-%'4 %' 1%"9 !+" 4"   $. %* '!

5  ! %& !+0& -, 7"# !+ ! !+%& --" . =" ..9"# '# $*-"'& !%' 9 ,#"#=""'+ '$"# C" ,'"# $0'&". , !+" ,"&-'#"'!& + 1" ,"

0!"# !+" =1" & %# ,40*"'!&9+%."&0=*%!!%'4!+ !!+"%*-04'"# 9 ,#+ &=""'- &&"# $,,"$!.7 '#'4,0'# , '7"'+ '$"*"'!%&* #"0!  + 1" +" ,# ." ,'"# $0'&". , !+" - ,!%"& '# + 1" 4'" !+,04+!+","$,#9%!+!+"%, =." &&%&! '$" !%&'!%'#%&-0!"!+ !/%-%'.&!+%&.% "#0"!%'30,%"&,"$"%1"#%' *!,1"+%$." $$%#"'!9+%$+!8-. $"'  #0"!!+", &+ '# '"4.%4"'! #,%1%'4   !+" 

"'#%'4 1"+%$." =7 ,"&-'#"'!  " 9 & < 7" ,& .# ! !+ ! !%*" +"," %& ' #%&-0!" ,"4 ,#%'4 !+" %'$*"   !+" #"$" &"# & &&"&&"# =7 !+" ." ,'"# ,%=0' . ! & A6 -", *'!+#*%!!"#.72 ' --" . + & =""'

%."# =7 !+" + '#%4 ,+ , '&-,! !%''#",! 8%'4, '7!+",,"&-'#"'!'1%"9 !+"30#4*"'!  '?=."!+")0-,"*"0,!- &&"#%' !%' .'&0, '$"*- '7C!# /& , ' 7 )"!+% '# !+",&2 ;    %1%.  <2 D %'$," &" %' %'$*"+ &!="

,#"#' $$0'! 0!0,"-,&-"$!& "#0$!%'  D !9 ,#&-",&' .":-"'&"&+ &,%4+!.7=""'"

"$!"#+"'F=.")0-,"*" 0,!%' 0'' C . %'1/%-%'G0* ,)+ ,* 2 

+ & &-"$% %$ ..7+".#!+ !!+"*0.!%-.%",%&!=" --.%"#9%!+," ","'$"!!+" 4" !+"#"$" &"#+"#"$" &"#9 & #*%!!"#.7<7" ,&.# !!+"!%*" $$%#"'!+","

,"2*0.!%-.%",  %'&!" # %&,"B0%,"#!=" --.%"#' 1%"9   !+" 30#4*"'!   '?=." !+" )0-,"*" 0,! - &&"# %'  4*  "'", . '&0, '$" *- '7 C!# /&  '0  * .% & +0+,0  * '# !+",&2%'%1%.--" .<   #"$%#"#'  < 2 --".. '!& ,""'!%!."#!& 2 A6" $+' $$0'! .&& %.% .$'&,!%0*+" --".. '!& ," "'!%!."# ! &2 A6 " $+ , .&&   "&! !" '# 0'", .

 ":-"'&"&%'&!" # & 2 A6

,#"#=7!+"." ,'"#,%=0' . !9 ,#& !, '&-,! !%'2 0'", .":-"'&"& '#. &!,%!"&":-"'&"& --".. '!&6$. %* '!& ,"2!+0&2 "'!%!."#!$*-"'& !%'2 9+%$+ %&,"69,8"# &0'#",(6  

     '$*"  A6-* %"2@ 2 A6-", ''0*

 ! . %'$*" !", ##%!%' ! !+" , !"  D ' $$0'!  0!0," -,&-"$!& @ 2 H

2 @ 2 :

D I

2 A6 5 '$*" !",#"#0$!%'  D' $$0'! -",&' .":-"'&"&

2 J

2 

2 A  I

2 A6

 ! . #"-"'#"'$7 !", --.7%'4  *0.!%-.%",  

2  I;2@2 A6  C&& "&! !" 2 A6 @ 0'", .":-"'&"& 2 A6 ; C&& $'&,!%0*!!+" --".. '!&

2 A6 E 2 A6 2 :

I 2 A6 , '#! . & 2@@2 A6 +" *0'! $*-"'& !%' .," #7 9 ,#"#!!+" --".. '!&2 '""#."&&!& 72&+ ..&! '##"#0$!"# ,*!+" *0'!$ .$0. !"# & =1" --,!%'*"'! '# #%&=0,&"*"'!   !+" $*-"'& !%' &+ .. =" & -", #%,"$!%'& !+"." ,'"#,%=0' .%' 9 ,## !"#  ; 5--".. '!&&+ .. =""'!%!."#!%'!","&! !!+", !" ;D-", ''0*'!+""'!%," *0'!

,*!+"# !" !+"-"!%!%'!%..," .%K !%' L%!+!+" =1"& %#*#% %$ !%'%'!+" 9 ,## !"#  ; 52 -,"&"'! --" .%&#%&-&"#   

  

 &+9 , L+"!+",&-" 8%'4A," &'"#(6"&A L+"!+",,"-,! =."(6"&A