High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5728/2013disposed of

Surjit Singh v. Sukhdev Isngh And ORS

2018-11-13Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill6 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

*+,-&"*&(./ 00#11!(" 2#,'+' *+3/$#4*&(./!($"/#,' #'0($#("'

,#'#(") , */!,5!6$4%!"# ,"/#!00#11!(" ,!4&(7!0+,6$4%!"# ,,#'0($#("8('+,!(%# 50!(9

/&'!00#!1/!':##( &1#$:9"/#%1!&5!("'##3&(.#(/!(%#5#(" "/#%50#('!"&(!;!,$#$"/&5:9"/#1#!,(#$",%%&$#("1!&5' ,&:+(!16 7!0+,"/!1! <,&:+(!1= , '/," 4&$# !;!,$ $!"#$

( !%%+(" &(-+,&#'!($$&'!:&1&"9'+

#,#$:9/&5&(!5",4#/&%1#!%%&$#(" (

,&# !%"' (#%#''!,9 , !$-+$&%!"&( "/# %!'# !,# "/!" ! 0#"&"&( +($#, *#%"&( >> ", 2#/&%1#' %" ;!' 0,# #,,#$ :9 "/# !00#11!(" '##3&(. %50#('!"&( ( !%%+(" "/# &(-+,&#' !($ $&'!:&1&"9 '+

#,#$:9/&5/#!00#11!(";!'&(414#$&(!5",4#/&%1#!%%&$#("(

;/#( /# ;#(" " !"/+ /&(.! ( /&' 5",?%9%1# :#!,&(.

@??A A B/#( /# ;!' ,#"+,(&(. " /&' /+'#6 ! ",!%", ",11#9 :#!,&(.

?> ?

6 ;/&%/ ;!' :#&(. $,&4#( :9 ,#'0($#(" ? *+3/$#4*&(./&(!,!'/!($(#.1&.#("5!((#,6%!5# ,5"/# ,("'&$#!($ '",+%3!.!&('""/#5",?%9%1# "/#!00#11!("'!,#'+1" "/&'!%%&$#("6 %1!&5!(" !($ /&' 5",?%9%1# %!5# +($#, "/# ",!%", ,&4#, "/# ",!%", ",11#9 $,!..#$ /&5 !1(. ;&"/ 5",?%9%1# !($ '"00#$ !" '5# $&'"!(%# 1!&5!(",#%#&4#$&(-+,&#'(:"//&'1#.'6/#!$6/!($'!($"/#,0!,"'

"/# :$9 &(%1+$&(. ,&:'6 (#%3 !($ %/&( ($#,-&" *&(./ !1&!' &""+ !($ '5# "/#, 0#,'(' %!5# " "/# '0" /# %1!&5!(" !($ /&' 5",%9%1# ;#,# ,#54#$ ,5+($#,(#!"/"/#

#($&(.4#/&%1#>A$!"#$

;!',#.&'"#,#$!" 1&%#*"!"&(!"/+/&(.!6&'",&%"7!0+,"/!1!00#11!(" ;!' "!3#( " *!"9!5 '0&"!16 !1!($/!,6 ;/#,# /# ,#5!&(#$ !$5&""#$ !:+"(#5("//#,#!

"#,6/#;!''/& "#$"!.,#'0&"!16 !1!($/!,6 ;/#,#/#;!'0#,!"#$+0(( @

,!%"+,# ,&./"1;#,1&5: !($1# "1;#,1&5:6&#/&06"/&./!($1;#,1#.("/#,'+,.#,9;!'$(#(

1# " "/&./ !($ :(#' !,+($ "/# 3(## /#(6 /# $#4#10#$ $##04#&("/,5:'&' 1# "1;#,1&5:6 ,;/&%/"/#!00#11!(";!',# #,,#$ " !.,# '0&"!16 !1!($/!, , 0+""&(. 2 &1"#, " 0,#4#(" $#!"/ $+# " 0+15(!,9 #5:1&'5 # ;!' $&'%/!,.#$ (

00#11!(" ;!' !.!&( !$5&""#$ " "/# /'0&"!1 ( @

!($ &(!119 $&'%/!,.#$ (

";!'01#!$#$"/!"(#&"/#,"/#!00#11!("%!(;!13/&5'#1 (,/# %!( $ !(9 ;,3 $+# " "/# &(-+,&#' ,#%#&4#$ :9 /&5 &( "/# '!&$ !%%&$#(" 00#11!(";!',#?!$5&""#$&("/#/'0&"!1(

!($/#;!'0#,!"#$ +0( ,""!13(##,#01!%#5#(" ";!'01#!$#$"/!""/#%1!&5!("!""/#"&5# !%%&$#(";!'> 9#!,'1$#;!'!(!.,&%+1"+,&'"6:#'&$#',+((&(.!$!&,9!($/&'5("/19 &(%5# ;!' '

8? /# %1!&5!(" ;!' %+1"&4!"&(. !%,#' 1!($ :#1(.&(."/&5:#'&$#'%+1"&4!"&(.!("/#,!%,#'1!($(1#!'#!';#11 !' ,+((&(. ! $!&,9 ( !%%+(" &(-+,&#' '+

#,#$ :9 "/# !00#11!("6 /&' &(%5#/!':##(,#$+%#$00#11!("&";!''"!"#$#5019#$"/,##'#,4!("'

,%+1"&4!"&(!($13&(.!

"#,"/#:+

!1#';/&1#0!9&(.!'+5 '>

8? 0#,5("/"#!%/ "/#5#/!'!1':#%5#$&'!:1#$0#,5!(#("19 /&' ,&./"1#.50#('!"&(;!'6"/+'60,!9#$ ,

/#1#!,(#$,&:+(!1(%('&$#,!"&( "/# !%"'!($#4&$#(%# (,#%,$/#1$"/!""/#!%%&$#("&(C+#'"&("301!%#$+#""/#,!'/!($ (#.1&.#(" $,&4&(. "/#

#($&(. 4#/&%1# :9 &"' $,&4#, /#,# &' ( $&'0+"# ,#.!,$&(."/#!:4#'!&$ &($&(. "/#1#!,(#$,&:+(!1("/&'&''+#6;/&%/ /!'!""!&(#$ &(!1&"9 /#1#!,(#$,&:+(!1/!'%(%1+$#$"/!""/#!00#11!("'0#("! ""!1 '+5 ' 6A6

8? ( /&' 5#$&%!1 ",#!"5#(" D#!,(#$ ,&:+(!1 /!' !''#''#$"/#1'' &(%5# "/#!00#11!(" !''

8? #'&$#'"/&'6 !("/#, '+5 '

8? #!%/ ;!' .,!("#$ ( !%%+(" '0#%&!1 $&#"6 5#("!1!($0/9'&%!10!&(!($ +"+,#",#!"5#("/+'6"/#!00#11!(";!'/#1$ #("&"1#$ " ""!1 %50#('!"&( '@6A6

8? 6A6

!1(.;&"/&("#,#'"F@G0#,!((+5 ,5"/#$!"# &1&(. "/#0#"&"&("&11&"',#!1&H!"&( D#!,(#$ %+('#1 , "/# !00#11!(" 4#/#5#("19 !,.+#' "/!" "/+./"/#,#&'('0#%& &%5#$&%!18$&'!:&1&"9%#,"& &%!"#(,#%,$"'/;"/!" "/#%1!&5!("'+

#,#$!(90#,5!(#("$&'!:&1&"9$+#""/#&(-+,&#''+

#,#$:9 /&5&("/#!%%&$#("6&"&'!5!""#, ,#%,$"/!""/#%1!&5!("+($#,;#("""!1 3(##,#01!%#5#(" "/#1# "3(##(

/#,# ,#6&"&'0,4#$( ,#%,$"/!"#4#(& &"&'":#!%%#0"#$"/!"/#$&$("'+

#,!(90#,5!(#(" $&'!:&1&"96 "/# %1!&5!(" '+

#,#$ 1'' &(%5# , !" 1#!'" (# 9#!, !' /# %+1$ (" /!4# !""#($#$ " /&' ;,3 /# %1!&5!(" %1!&5#$ " :# !( !.,&%+1"+,&'":#'&$#',+((&(.!$!&,9 !,5"&' +,"/#,01#!$#$"/!"!5#!.,# %50#('!"&( /!' :##( !

,$#$ " "/# !00#11!(" ( !%%+(" 1'' &(%5# !' ;#11 D#'' %50#('!"&( /!' :##( !

,$#$ ( !%%+(" 0!&( !($'+

#,&(.'!';#11!''0#%&!1$&#"!($ +"+,#",#!"5#(""&'"/+'0,!9#$ "/!"%50#('!"&(!;!,$#$""/#!00#11!(":##(/!(%#$

A D#!,(#$%+('#1 ,"/#('+,!(%#50!(90,!9' ,+0/1$&(. "/#%50#('!"&(:#&(.-+'"& &#$&("/# !%"'!($%&,%+5'"!(%#' "/#%!'# /!4# /#!,$ 1#!,(#$ %+('#1 , "/# 0!,"&#' !($ /!4# .(# "/,+./"/# &1# /#,# &' ( $&'0+"# ,#.!,$&(. "/# !00#11!(" /!4&(. '+

#,#$ &(-+,&#'&("/#!%%&$#(";/&%/"301!%#(

$+#""/#,!'/!($ (#.1&.#("$,&4&(. "/#

#($&(.4#/&%1#B,*/+:/!(...!,;!1/!' "#'"& &#$!'+($#,)? I(

*+,-&" *&(./ '( &!,! *&(./ ,#'&$#(" 2&11!.#7/##,!(;!1&67!0+,"/!1!;!':,+./""+,/'0&"!1;&"/ !11#.#$/&'",9 ,!$",!

&%!%%&$#("!"!:+"

05#;!' $&!.('#$":#&(/#5,,/!.&%'/%3$+#"5+1"&01# ,!%"+,# ,&./" 1;#, 1&5: !($ 1# " 1;#, 1&5: # ;!' 0#,!"#$ +0( (

,!%"+,# ,&./"1;#,&#/&06"/&./!($1;#,1#. /# (#J" '+,.#,9 ;!' $(# (

,!%"+,# 1# " "/&./!($1#.:(#'!,+($"/#3(##/#(/#$#4#10#$$##0 4#&( "/,5:'&' 1# " 1;#, 1&5: , ;/&%/ /# ;!' ,# #,,#$ " !.,#'0&"!16 !1!($/!, ,0+""&(.2 &1"#,"0,#4#("$#!"/ $+#"0+15(!,9#5:1&'5#;!'$&'%/!,.#$(

" !.,# '0&"!16 !1!($/!, !($ ,#!$5&""#$ " +' (

!($ &(!119$&'%/!,.#$(

/!4#:,+./" "/#,&.&(!1,#%,$ "/#0!"&#("*+,-&"*&(./6"/#0/"%09 "/#'!5#!,#J A!($J ,+($";'+,.#,9!,#":# 0#, ,5#$("/#1# " "!($1# "3(## *+,-&"*&(./!($"/# #'"&5!"#$ #J0#($&"+,#' "/#'# 0#,!"&(' &' !:+" ' 6 6

8? ,#.!,$&(. ;/&%/ /!4# &''+#$ ! %#,"& &%!"# J >K B +,"/#,"#'"& &#$"/!"""!13(##,#01!%#5#("'+,.#,9;!'%!,,&#$+"( "/# 0!"&#(" (

!($ /# ,#5!&(#$ !$5&""#$ &( "/# /'0&"!1 "&11

/#:&11'&(C+#'"&(/!4#:##(0,4#$:9B,*/+:/!(. ..!,;!1 +,"/#, '"!"#$ "/!" !

"#, "/# 3(## ,#01!%#5#(" '+,.#,96 "/# !00#11!(";+1$(";!13;&"/+"'+00,"!($ "$,0(1# "'&$#/#;!' .&4#(!'+00,"&("/# ,5 !( ,5($1&"#50!(9/#!00#11!(" &'%1!&5#$":#!(!.,&%+1"+,&'":#'&$#',+((&(.!$!&,9 !,5"&' !&,19'"!"#$ :9 1#!,(#$ %+('#1 "/!" "/#,# &' ( #4&$#(%# ( ,#%,$ " 0,4# "/# '!5# #J%#0""/#'"!"#5#(" "/#!00#11!("("/&'4&#; "/#5!""#,6&"%!((":#

'!&$"/!""/#!00#11!("'+

#,#$!(9 +(%"&(!1$&'!:&1&"9!($&'#("&"1#$"1'' +"+,#&(%5#""/#'!5#"&5#6&"%!((":#1'"'&./" "/# !%""/!" (#!,19!:+"(#9#!,6"/#!00#11!("%+1$("/!4#:##(!:1#"%!,,9+"/&' 4%!"&( /# 5&(&5+5 ;!.# &( "/# *"!"# +(-!: !" "/# "&5# "/# !%%&$#(" ;!' !:+" '

8?6 ;/&%/ %!( ,#!'(!:19 :# !''#''#$ !' "/# &(%5# "/# %1!&5!(" /#,# ,#6 &" &' %('&$#,#$ -+'" !($ !00,0,&!"# " !;!,$!'+5 '>

J &('"#!$ '

8?(!%%+(" 1'' &(%5#'+5 ' 6A6

8?/!':##(,&./"19!;!,$#$(!%%+(" 5#$&%!1#J0#('#'("/#:!'&' :&11'0,4#$(,#%,$/#!00#11!("&' #("&"1#$"!'+5 '6

8?&('"#!$ '

8?(!%%+(" 0!&( !($'+

#,&(.'#&'!1'#("&"1#$!'+5 '

8?(!%%+(" '0#%&!1 $&#" &('"#!$ '

8? ("/#, '+5 '

8? &' !;!,$#$ !""#($!(" %/!,.#' /# !00#11!(" &' !1' #("&"1#$ " '

8? , 1'' !5#(&"&#'!'&"&'!5!""#, ,#%,$"/!"/#;!''+

#,#$ ,51# "'&$#*+5 '

8? +"+,#",#!"5#("&'5!&("!&(#$ /+'6 "/# %1!&5!(" &' #("&"1#$ " %50#('!"&( !' $#"!&1#$ /#,#+($#,)?

D'' &(%5# '>

!&(!($'+

#,&(.' '6

8? *0#%&!1$&#" '

8? A ""#($!("%/!,.#' '

8? D'' !5#(&"&#' '

8? > +"+,#",#!"5#(" '

#$&%!1#J0#('#' ' 6A6

!!"#

> /#!5+(" %50#('!"&(!1,#!$9!;!,$#$""/#!00#11!("6 (##$1#''"'!96'/!11'"!($$#$+%"#$ ,5"/#!5+("%!1%+1!"#$!'!:4# 00#11!("'/!11:##("&"1#$"&("#,#'"!""/#,!"# G0#,!((+5("/# #(/!(%#$ %50#('!"&( !5+(" ,5 "/# $!"# &1&(. "/# 0#"&"&( "&11 ,#!1&H!"&( B&"/"/#!:4#'!&$5$& &%!"&(&("/#!;!,$$!"#$

6 0,#'#("!00#!1&'$&'0'#$ $

% & 4#5:#,6

'/;!, B/#"/#,'0#!3&(.8,#!'(#$)? #'8 B/#"/#,,#0,"!:1#)? #'8