High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5098/2014allowed

Balbir Singh & ANR v. Union Of India & ORS

2016-02-03Mr. Justice Arun Monga7 pages

! " #$ %

% !

% '

(( * * +

,-./

!.)

0$1

.!* # 2

. !31

%&'

# (

! *+,

- ./0* 12,3456,04.7+

- ./0 * 8!12,3456,04.7+ 9999 . :

!$ "

$ ;

0 ;

< :

;

. !31

#* ,!1/ . 5

! $ ( ,$ % !

$ " (

$ %

$ $$ ! !

= .

! $ ( '"

$ " ( '"

$ $$ ! !

= . +

! $ ( )$# !

$ " ( )$#

$ $$ ! !

= . +

555 ! "

$ " .45

= . 2 $

12,3456,04.7 >( -?@ / - A -2- 21 -%/2B12,C54C,04.7>-%D# -%2A -2-21-%/2B12,640<,04.7 >@?-?@ -%-A-2-21-%/2B12,646C,04.7 >'?')-?@A-2-21-%/2B12,645.,04.7

>#@-# A-2-21-%-%2B12,6.36, 04.7 ># (#@--%-A-2-21-%/ 2B 12,6704,04.7 >- ( -?@ A -2- 21 -%/2B12,6C6E,04.7 >@DD)(#/2A -2-21-%/2B12,6547,04.7 >:--?@ A -2- 21 -% / 2B 12,5.3<,04.7 >)(2=@--?@A-2-21-%/2B12,5030,04.7 >@?@-F=@)(D))A-2-21-% /2B12,5E30,04.7 >'-%D#A-2-21 -%/2B12,5E33,04.7 >')-?@A-221 -% / 2B 12,5E3C,04.7 >%(') -?@ A -2-21-%/2B12,5E3E,04.7 >? DD)# -%-A-2-21-%/2B12,5EC3,04.7 >@@'--?@A-2-21-%/2B12,.4.35, 04.7 >)(-?@A-2-21-%/2B12, .4.E6,04.7 >(:-) -?@ / - A -2- 21 -% / 2B 12,.4<7C,04.7 >#@:-%D -?@

A-2-21-%/2B12,.4<CE,04.7 >)D'# -%2A-2-21-%/2B12,54C4,04.7 >-G=2(%D)D%D)()%A-2-21-%/2B 12,70<4,04.3 >22-?@-%2A2-% 2B12,7606,04.3 >)-?@A2-%2B 12,3C46,04.7 >')-?@A-2-21-%/ 2B 12,C5CC,04.3 ># (%DA-2-21 -%-%2B !

" &

" $ $

)

" " ! - ! ! <

- @

"!H "

- @

! #

! %& '

! )&

! *+,

" $ $ $ !

$$! " 034444A, $ ! .7C344A, - @

! "

" ! $ !

. 1 !

$$! .E4444A,$ 0 1 ! .44444A,$

" * 12,6C6E,04.712,6547, 04.7 12,5E30,04.7 12,5E33,04.7 12,5E3C,04.7 12, 5E3E,04.7 12,5EC3,04.7 12,.4<7C,04.7 12,.4<CE,04.7 12,70<4,04.312,7606,04.312,3C46,04.7 12,C5CC, 04.3+$ !

" $

- @

& !

! $

" ! " ! <7

.55E!"

" $ )

" !

= = !

$ $ !& $ 2 ! = 2 ! = @ $

! ! 8!$&

- ! $ ! @$ $

$ !&

" !

" $& "

! $

! ,! 3 ! <? -

+ @

! ! "

)

$ ! " " " ! <7 .55E! $ !

4643044C !

! .7C344A, $ !

$$! 034444A,$"

" ! $ !

$$! $034444A, .E4444A,$ I,, I ! $.7C444A,$ .44444A,$ " ! = $

! !

! 034444A, !

$$!

.7C344A, ! " !! ! .E4444A, !

$$!

.44444A, !) $ $ & !

$ @ G $=

!""# $

%& '(() "

$ !

$ "

= ! !!$ ! $ " = ! ! !

$ $ "

! I,, I$ !& $ !$ $$!

344444A,$

& ! ! <?*3+ - @

!$!

$!!

! # " $ ! " !

I,, I ! .7C444A,$ !

$$! 034444A,$

! 0<*0+ 06 (

!H *$ $ + ! .567 "

$ % !

= * + , -

. / , !"00'

% %& $#(1 * * +

, . !31 / # %