Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited v. M/S Akash Optifibre Limited And Another










 

 

 



 !"

"#$%$&'
(")!"*+",
-
.

/ , !
( &#/ ,
$0 *
1$*$!"2-
("#!,
3-
/ &2$0 ,/ ))"44 &!

5",%6%

7%
8%/
)!$$+,"
1$*$!"2-
6,0 &

&!/",  "%)&2"&!%  



 !

!

"#

$%

,"%"&!'

,%/9 &$
 49 ,-
2:# !"- ,
!/"
))"44 &!

,0"%/
; 4-
2:# !"
,

, ,$! *
( $&$-
2:# !"- ,
,"%)&2"&!
 <<<<<







































!

"#

 &'( ))"44 &!=(1
$%
00,$":"2

!/"
2$%*$%% 4

!/" +>"#!$&%
$4"2
6&2",
("#!$&
3

!/"
,+$!, !$&
&2
&#$4$ !$&
#!- ??.
,
%/,!
@??.
#!A
0 $&%!
!/"
9 ,2
2 !"2

?

,%/9 &$
 49 ,-
4" ,&"2
#6&%"4
,
!/"
))"44 &! %6+*$!%
!/ !
))"44 &!=(1
/ 2
)4 #"2
&
,2",
6)&
!/"
$,*
!
%6))4; )!$$+,"
# +4"

,
!/"
)",$2
=
&2
!/"
, !"
9 %

?-?.7=
)",

&2
64!$* !"4;
9/"&
!/"
!"&2",
9 %
$%%6"2-
!/"
, !"
9 %
&"0!$ !"2 &2
$& 4$%"2
!

-C7=
)",
B -
+6!
+;
!/"
!$*"
!/"
#&!, #!
9 % $& 4$%"2
9$!/
,"0 ,2
!
!/",
)",$2-
!/"
"&!$,"
%6))4$"%
/ :"
+""&
* 2" &2-
!/",","-
$&
:$"9

4 6%"
3-
!/"
,+$!, !$&
#4 6%"
9 %
$&:8"2- +6!
!/"
,+$!, !,
&2
%
9"44
%
!/"
+>"#!$&0
6,!
2"#4$&"2
! $&!",","
"
%6+*$!%
!/ !
!/"
+>"#!$&%
9","
 44$&0
9$!/
!/"
," 4*
 ("#!$&
3

??.
#!
/"
#4 $*
9 %
%6%! $& +4"
%
(1
/ 2
+""& )6!
!
4%%


#&%$2", +4"
*6&!
/"
(! !"
"D#/"E6",
# &&!
+"
)6!
! 4%%

",
#&!, -
,0"%/
; 4
2:# !"
,
, ,$! *
( $&$- 2:# !"
,
,"%)&2"&!
=#&!, #!,

%6+*$!%
!/ !
&#"
!/"
, !"
9 % $& 4$%"2
!

?-?.7=
)",
B
&2
!/"
"&!$,"
%6))4$"%
9","
* 2"-
!/"

(1
# &&!
! 8"
!/"
)4"

4"%%",
, !"

%*"
!/",
9,8 
/ :"
/" ,2
!/"
4" ,&"2
#6&%"4
,
!/"
) ,!$"%-
)), $%"2 !/"
) )",
+8
&2

!/"
:$"9
!/ !
!/","
$%
&
*",$!
$&
!/"
%6+*$%%$&


, 49 ,-
+6!
,#"
$&
!/"
#&!"&!$&

,; 4-
,-
&#"
!/"
, !"
/ % 4," 2;
+""&
%"!!4"2
!

?-?.7=
,
!/"
)",$2
=-
(1
# &&! !6,&
,6&2
&2
! 8"
!/"
+"&"$!

2$","&!
, !"%
+;
%*"
!/", #&!, #!,-
) ,!$#64 ,4;
9/"&
!/"
"&!$,"
%6))4$"%
$&
,"%)"#!

!/"
,2", )4 #"2
/ 2
+""&
,"#"$:"2
+;
!/"*
&2
,$0/!4;
%-
!/"
,+$!, !,
2"#4$&"2 !/"
,"4$"

*

!/"
:$"9
!/ !
!/"
+>"#!$&%
9","
&!
 44$&0
9$!/
!/"

," 4*

("#!$&
3

??.
#! !
$%
&9

%"!!4"2
4 9
!/ !
$&
9/ !
#$,#6*%! &#"%-
!/"
9 ,2 / %
!
+"
$&!",","2
9$!/
/"
E6"%!$&-
9/$#/
$%
&9
, $%"2
$&
!/" ,"*"&!$&"2
))" 4-
/ %
4," 2;
+""&
&%9","2
+;
!/"
&F+4" (6),"*"
6,!
$&
# !"&

>620*"&!%-
9/","$&
$!
/ %
+""&
4 $2
29& !/ !
6&!$4
&2
6&4"%%
!/"
9 ,2
%6",%
,*
$44"0 4$!;
%
%! !6!,$4; ),"%#,$+"2
6&2",
("#!$&
3

!/"
#!-
!/"
% *"
# &&!
+"
$&!",","2 9$!/
&
!/$%
#&!"D!-

$&!"&2
!
,"",
!/"
>620*"&!%

&F+4"
(6),"*" 6,!
$&
))*+',- .+(/-&) 0) $-(1+ $-2-(34-5, .,1&+,6

  '5/ '2/'6'

'))

5,-&,'+54-5, ,/ 0)

  49+5-)

   :8; &
!/"
,"*"&!$&"2
>620*"&!%-
!/"

&F+4"
(6),"*"
6,!
/ 2
#644"2
6!
!/"
, !$
2"#$2"&2$
+;
/42$&0
!/ ! 6&!$4
&2
6&4"%%
!/","
$%
",,,
)) ,"&!
&
!/"
 #"

,"#,2
,
!/" ,+$!, !,
/ %
&!
449"2
%! !6!,;
4"0 4
)%$!$&-
$!
$%
&4;
$&
!/"%" #$,#6*%! &#"%-
$!
9642
+"
>6%!$$"2
$&!",",$&0
9$!/
!/"
9 ,2
/"
$0/ 6,!
%/642
&!
#!
%

6,!

))" 4
&2
," )), $%"
!/" * !",$ 47":$2"&#"
&2
"*+ ,8
&

) !/
+;
%6+%!$!6!$&0
$!%
9&
:$"9
$& %6)),!

!/"
,+$!, !,F%
:$"9
!
$%
&!
!/"
# %"

!/"
))"44 &!
!/ !
!/" 9 ,2
$%
0 $&%!
!/"
)6+4$#
)4$#;
,
/ %
:$4 !"2
!/"
),$&#$)4"%
 >62$#$ 4
)), #/-
*6#/
4"%%
0 $&%!
!/"
%! !6!"
&2
!/",
),:$%$&%
 ("#!$&
3

!/"
#!
/"
,+$!, !,
/ %
2" 4!
9$!/
!/"
2$%)6!"-
9/$#/

9 %
#&!"*)4 !"2
&2
9 %
9$!/$&
$!%
%#)"
/"
) ,!$"%
!
!/"

 / 2 ) ,!$#$) !"2
$&
!/"
),#""2$&0%
&2
9","
0$:"&
),)",
&!$#"
&!
&4; 9$!/
,"0 ,2
!
!/"
))$&!*"&!

!/"
,+$!, !,
+6!
:$%= =:$% ),#""2$&0%
&
*;
:$"9-
!/"
9 ,2

!/"
,+$!, !,
2"%
&!
%6",
,* &;
$44"0 4$!;
$&
%
*6#/
%
!/"
,+$!, !,-
9/
$%
"D)",!-
/ %
2" 4!
9$!/ !/"
* !!",
&2
2"#$2"2
!/"
#4 $*%

,"%)"#!$:"
) ,!$"%
!
!/"

 &
*;
:$"9-
!/"
9 ,2
," 2
%

9/4"
$%
>6%!-
 $,
&2 ," %& +4"
!
$%
&9

%"!!4"2
4 9
!/ !
!/"
,+$!, !,
$%
!/"
%4"
>620"
 E6 4$!;
&2
E6 &!$!;

!/"
":$2"&#"
+","
/$*
&2
2"#$2"
&
!/"
+ %$% 
!/"
: $4 +4"
":$2"&#" &
*;
:$"9-
&
",,,

4 9
,$%"%
,*
!/"
9 ,2
/"
% *" $%
)","#!
&2
>6%!$$"2 /","
$%
&
*",$!
$&
!/"
))" 4
/"
% *"
$%
##,2$&04; 2$%*$%%"2
-3,-49-&

#

:

!

"  &'4-)1

$%

"1-,1-& )3-'<+5=>&-')5-/ ?-)> "1-,1-& -3&,'9(- ?-)>