Gaurav Makkar And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Another
!"# $%&%!'())
*+
), , - !" !#!$ %&!$ '( )(*!$ $ !)!! !+%*(!$ %&!$ ' , ....
, -/)01 ( & -., ' ( / ' /0!" & (!1'" '2!(*' 3 ,4 ! ,56-,6,,$ * &7-$-,6$-84$-8.! -4'(3 !!" / $!"&!&.$ &! !1! ! !""&2!"
& * !* ('0$ ( 1! ' &0 0 !% ! 1#( ! , ! .6.,6,7$ ( ! # & !
!1'("! !"/93""!2! !*!$'**( !0 & : ! ( * ' ( &0 0 3 &0 "!&('$ '/%"; *<;
=&0; &!" !*!3 /"!$! !1!1 $ ! ,76.,6,7$(!1&% $#($(! 1& (!( !(!%" ( !0&!1")#(!)
,
'"&$&& ! '(!&& (!%1 &"! ! &"!0 '' 7 >! &"'( (!'(" ( + *0'( 0/(&!'
$ $& (!%(''& &-,6$-84$ -4'3/&!12!( (1!'&0 0 - ("0!!0$1+&%! *!"'!"*!")0 &&"(&!"&'"&>!#2 ")(! " (!%'*(#(!&((+ &(*( )$*( "'! "1)! (*(& (01)("*!")0( &%" !(&'"&1## !$(!%*"% '(&!" $&!"(!0)(&)!&( &!1" ' 0*%( !"( 1)&0 0$'
&$&0*#(&!"*!"&2&!#"" #%$( &0!" &!")&(0"%")# ! ( 0 ' ( & $ &2& ! ''& ( &0!"!& &!(''&! &2&% ( &) ! "!* ('$ ( "!# &1 (0$ %
(0! (?0 (0$&" * !( !")' &0!"!& @
#%$0'((&%" &'"& ' # ! !'0 (0"% &0!" ! & ('$("*!")0 "!)0 "%(&'"&1# # !:#((! !A'*(!(! %0 !&'
7
2!&)!"!*00B C""(& ! "%(&'"&1## 1) *('$% (&0!""!#2 *% *! (#('( ! &*B*( & "")$(3 !"*!")0!"
% '&*B*(&0 01## '!&0!"
&7,6//!?
%(*! ( &") % '&0 * *(!"$1 0 &0 *%!!
""!%!"!* #%1)%) ! ! & $ & 7,6 // &! 1 ( " ):
#( ( &* ! &0 0 1# ( ! (!%:
&!"): 1 &' ( & "! ") ( ''&
&1 (3 !!"/ (!!"0''&
&1 3/%(''&?*(3/# 0!! '000$0!A*(?*''&1 "*(*! %#0 !"' ''''&!1* &* %#'&("*&!"! %!&0(&!! 2( '"A*1) &7,6//&*( &0 01#( ! C0!!(!&)'
( & &1 ' &0!" !": ( !" / &! 1
0 !%"1) (& &1 (! &
&( '%A*&-.,//1)( *(/ 8 C$!1% !1%$(#('") !( &0!" #" !"#!)1''&0!!&0!"!" %#'( !$"!1"''&:(& &#" (!%"' 2!(&)!"!*('(''&&00 1)
-
%"% *%!&! 0!'!&2*''&!" # #("?&*''& #&!1 0 1&0 0 >A#$ % ( ''& %"%* ") # %! $ 1 '"&* !%)'&(!!&%"%*&!*!""' "'&!*!""' )1)? *00(!'
" ' "': &! 1 0 1 &0 0 ?& ( !1%0 *!% ''&$ ( %) ! (! !"" ( ''&(" 1 0 1&0 0 1)(/&(
''''&1'(/$!*!#" %"%(& &'(
! $(''(/ 0(!01 &0 0 (( !#" "!)&A (/ (!&2!"'!&& 1)1%*(! 0!'&0!" +& %('! 0!'&0!"+& '&(&B"!! ! (&A * 1 "!) /1%(+&)0#" !"#!)1(' +&"':(!(&0 01#( !&*B ! ( &B0!0 ! &00 (!"'()0' ! 0!'+&$!"!$2!(''&$#(&((' &) 01&0 0 4
D1" ( 0 / (! !0 ") &"!' ( "*!"
&*B*&0 0*(&!' !"# $ %& '& $! (!1% ! E
@
!
"
#
$%&
'
!
()* +
"
*
+
'
' !
' , !
,
'
'
-,,
',
'
.
'
#
' #
', '
-/
0
'
-
' )
'
1
'
'
,
'
,
,
,
,
-
'
',
'
8
'
' , '
,
,
'
-
" !
"
'
,
'
"
"
,
* +
,
"
2 . ( &! '!""!)'(?& %!* !1% &$%#'( '/%"; *<;
=&0 ; &!" !*! 3 /"!$ ! !1!1 $ ! ,76.,6,7$ 0!
!&'( ! .6.,6,7 ! 1)(/$(/ '"(!'" #" 1% 1)A *( & * !"%3#""1('+&$'("0!&( 1# ( !!&& 5 && *")$( !""# 3 ,4 ! ,56-,6,,$* &7-$-,6$-84$-8.! -4'(
4
3 !!"/ $!"&!&.$ &! !1! $! !""
&2!" & *!*('0$!(1)2!( 2!(
(1!'&0 0!% !1#(
! ()) 0 , -3
!%A0! F((! 9 !A*G
9 F(( !1"G
9