← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5880/2017allowed

Usman And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2023-12-08Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil6 pages

 

       

 !"#$!%&'&"()**+  

     

    )  ,-. * / ./ ..

- ****

 

     

!"

#$ $

!  

%    

%&   

' (  /($!!0 "1$2&34 * )*+

 $

 %- &"

 ."

"

 $ //0 ."1      "   

    "

   

- 

   $

2 $-    $     /33( )

*+ $-   5"

$6  )/+

 $ 6 #"

*778 6

*778

 "-"  "6

%      $   9 )  ' *+     ,"6

$$ $ *:

*778 

  (3 ** *770   " $ "     ;6"

 ."

      *7 /33* 

"

' *$-



  " 83<6 %     

- 2 - )(+

1    

   !      $   /33()

=*+     $

  >     (3 /33( 

 

2   ,   $   /33(        /8 3:

/33? )

=/+  

 !            *@ /3*: )

=(+   

 $  ):+

   

   

2 $- $   /33( )

=*+

  *@ /3*:)

=(+6"

   $-$   /33( 

    

// 3@ /3*: 3* /33( )8+

;

 " $    "$$$  $$     $  )

=*+  

"     *778

"     "  

(3 /33(  "

"

-  !   $    *@ /3*:)

=:+

$  

     

 

    -      "  $   /33( )

=*+   ,

$  4      $   /33( )

=*+

" = 

    



  

!  



 !

    "#

$ %& ##"





 !

 "#

$ %& ##"

%  

- 3 -  



!   & !



 ' '

(

(

'

    

    

!

 )!

 '

&



! * '

     '

+# 

 

 

'

%*



!

'

  

%  '  '

% %

&

%*    % 

 

'

 ,  

   - !&

'

%*

 !

%  

'

'

 

* %

'

  &

!

 





'

  '

%*





  '

"# 

"

   



.

  

!  



 !

  

   "#

$ %& ##"





 !

 "#

$ %& ##"

%  

 



! 

 !



 ' '

(

(

'

    

    

!

 )!

 '





! * '

     '

+# 

 

 

'

%*



!

'

  

%  '  '

% %

&

%*    % 

 

'

 ,  

   - !&

'

%*

 !

%  

'

'

 

* %

'

  &

!

 





'

  '

%*





  '

"#  /

)0+

1"

-"

$   6

 

6  ."

   5++ 6 7189 :'* /  ! "# 9;( 9'* 3?

/3*8)

=8+

$$ < -!=>16:'*/  !"#9;( '* *7 /3*8)

=0+

."

 $

= $6$   

 $-$  /33(



- 4 -     





   !"#$% &' (  ;

$   "6     $ $ "

 

 &"       $

 6

 3* /33(      6

        "$$$-$$

5"   $  /33( )?+

'  "

// 3( /3*?



  3:

/3*@ 

      3:

/3*@ 0

 $ 

. 2 $ '

-

. )##3#45  1    - 

    $-  





='-     A B   "- ;

 ' 8?/  /3*7             '

 ! )  !)!* $  !)   +

, -

 ./  +

 ,  A B      -     6 -    "-   6"  

  6

$ -$ #"-    3:

/3*@ 6"   

5"

"$&"   $ 

    $-6$  -" 5"$  "$ $ 6$ 

,



2$ 

6

4    $      

  

 

$



6"

 $- 6 %

"



  6  &"   

 6   -$  #"-   -

-- )@+

1 "$ 5"



C    6  6 

B  // /3*7 



 &"

    $-           

-  

- 5 -

 $$ -  6 

"

"

;

).+' *?8@*/3// )7+

 $6 $

' ( "-#  9"

.  

  " $.   D 66

$  (* /3*7

6

  -  $$



 

   *778 $ E,"6

$$    =  "

=$6$        "$  6  

 

2 " $  /33()

=*+  *3 3/ /33:

)*3+

1$"6 $$$$ $      *77?  /33:     

  &0, &  12-

34-,# (%"&

!,

$ 

/8 3:

/33? -  "$6  

 

 -   "

=$6$    /33( "   6

 $ )**+

;$  $ $ 

 ' (  -"

      "- $ 4 -    6 -$  "-  

$ %--   



 6

 $ $  

%- $  

  %     &"-  4."

567&62 -

  +

 $ & *$  

2 $ "6  6   " 

"6      

"6 %-

- 6 - )*/+

' -"  6

 6 $    

$ )*(+

 $ $       - "- 

)*:+



- -

2

      $   /33( )

=*+  $

 6



6."

 +



 +

# 8 9$":*:9 !)% *7 /3/(

."

 $ $-

 $  "  &"   $    6  " "  $  "

."

"

)*8+

-$  

  $ $$

      





 

2 

$  /33(   3/ /33:"

 !   )*0+

'

$       6   

 "

   +

. )" +$$6 $ 6$ 



$$6 6" $  

 "



  

$$ )*?+

  -$ *?

3?

/3/( 2 2

/($!!0 "1$2&3

1$2!

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No