High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3561/2015disposed of

Kuldeep & ANR. v. Poonam & ORS.

2026-03-05Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan11 pages

-1-

#$% &

*++#$% & &

*++#$% & & ,-#'"

#$%

,-#'"

#$%

,-#'"

#$%

,-#'"

#$%

.& & .& & .& & .& & /0

&&&,, &&&,, &&&,, &&&,,

&&& &&& &&& &&& % 40 3& 3 / 5 % 40 3& 3 / 5 % 40 3& 3 / 5 % 40 3& 3 / 5

$(%

& '2 '!

#62$('7 $+# "!#*'(

& '(926 3##"7 "!#*'(

+:6'

'6';'$7 "!#*'(

--'$(& & 1'$"'$'

'-6#( '7 "!#*'(

#&$2 '$*

(6 #2=6 1 / 57 & / 57 & / 57 & / 57 & &

+$!#-!

% &

?56

= #

:+-#= '<

>2+

$"#

*(7 @AA *+)9+$=

*'$ #,

? '$,# ( BC

?56

( '+-

>2+

*#!

<#(#

$(CB

( '*(# ( #--

''+-

*# *($

8' "

"'( .& & E7 ,'

**+"

-'+< +D2$'-7 3#$ ,'(7 (hereinafter referred to as the 'Tribunal')

D97

( '*(# ( #--

)'(

-2-

#&$2 '$*

F#$ *#$( '*(2'-

*#$( '*( &

D + ) )'*(7 & & 7

<#(# *9*-+(

* " +;

6+(

#&&

2-('$(-97

<#(# *9*-+( ) -- "#8$

= #2$"

2('+$ +$;2 +

2-(+$= 6+ '(6

,#(& #&E. "'( & &

=+(

*(+#$ .@7 .

$"+'$ $'- #"

#-+*

3('(+#$ 3'"' 7 3#$+,'(7 ' 9'$'& E&

='-

* )+- *-'+< (+(+#$ '='+$(

#)) $"+$=

'--#8 2< &@77

G '8' "

*#<, $'(+#$ '-#$=

+$(

.&I

'$$2<&

--'$(/2-"

( '*(#

--'$(#=+$"

3+$=6

( '*(#

"+ *( ,'9

*#<, $'(+#$&

F#$

,'9 *#<, $'(+#$

*# "+$=

)#--#8+$=

'#$% &

!+"

'""2*

*#<,'$9 #&7 "2-9 , #!

"'(

+& & & 7

6'!+$= !'-+"

)) *(+!

#)) $"+$=

F,-+*+(

2'-

,#+(+#$ 5

/2<' 7 86# *+)+*'--9 ,#

F& +2 )'!#2

3*##( #(# *9*- '

'*(# &&

$#$( '$,# (

F* ,( (6+7

$# #(6

$"#

=' "+$=

,-9+$= '$9 #(6

+& ( '$,# ( 2 (6 5

",'- ,# "2 +$= 6+ * # F'<+$'(+#$ (8#

-#'"

2=' *'$

(62 ( '$,# (

2$;'D 0'8 ,# (

-3-

@ (+(- 32D6'6 6'$"

#(6

3'(9'

'$+ #(6

@ (+(- 32D6'6 6'$"

#(6

3'(9'

'$+ #(6

@ (+(- 32D6'6 6'$"

#(6

3'(9'

'$+ #(6

@ (+(- 32D6'6 6'$"

#(6

3'(9'

'$+ #(6

2$;'D ' 9'$'

+=6 #D

( '$,# (

)+$

>2+

*+'-

$"#

*(+#$

*(& )

$# *+'-

$"# $(7

8+--

"2-9

<':

6+<

+ $('-

0+<+( & 6'$" '6 :' '$'$"

#(6 @@.7

0+<+( & 6'$" '6 :' '$'$"

#(6 @@.7

0+<+( & 6'$" '6 :' '$'$"

#(6 @@.7

0+<+( & 6'$" '6 :' '$'$"

#(6 @@.7

" '8 ( '+-

*'2 2*6

( '*(# ( '+-

*'2+$=

8#2-"

D2( =##"

( +) D#(6 ( '+-

+$2

8#2-"

+$"

<$+)9

'='+$(

*-'+< ' ++$= #2(

( '+- 2'-

,#-+*9 F6+D+( E

$# <+2< ,'+"

9& -+'$*

(6+

=' "

*'$ '-#

#D !'(+#$ <'"

#&.

(+(-

#&.

(+(-

#&.

(+(-

#&.

(+(-

$"+'

2 '$*

0+<+( 3#6'$ 0'-

$"+'

2 '$*

0+<+( 3#6'$ 0'-

$"+'

2 '$*

0+<+( 3#6'$ 0'-

$"+'

2 '$*

0+<+( 3#6'$ 0'-

#(6

& #(6

-'8 -'+"

"#8$

*+('(+#$ )2--9

',,-+*'D-

)'*( *+ *2<('$*

6'$"

'-#7

#)) $"+$=

(8# -#'"

2=' *'$

'$"7

',,'

6#-"+$= !'-+"

( '$,# (G=##"

*+)+*

$"#

>2+

#D('+$

*#<, '2(6# +(97 (627

#& 6'!+$= !'-+"

#)) $"+$=

(+<

"'(

'-- =

'$"7

#& +$2 '$*

*#<,'$9

+$"

<$+)9

+$2 <':+$= ,'9<

*#<, $'(+#$

*-'+<'$(& &

2 (6

)+- *#,9

D+-- F6+D+(

#)) $"+$=

'-#

, #"2* 2'-

6#8 #=+$"

3+$=6 #&

,2 *6'

#)) $"+$= 627

-4-

#)) $"+$=

(+<

(+#$&

<,6'+ 2,,-+ " &

' $ *#2$

*#$( $"

8 #$=-9

( '*(# ( #-- 6'!+$= !'-+"

$"#

*'$

,-9 '$9 #(6

+& ( '$,# (

' $ *#2$

-+'$*

(+(- G ';';

#& 0("&

G ';';

#& 0("&

G ';';

#& 0("&

G ';';

#& 0("&

'<D6'

&&&

+!+- & '<D6'

&&&

+!+- & '<D6'

&&&

+!+- & '<D6'

&&&

+!+- &

( 2D<+((

+$!#+*

F& 7

<#"

7 <'$2)'*(2 #6$

$"+'

!(& 0("&

*6$+*'- *+)+*'(+#$

<#"

'!'+-'D-

D+(

*#<,'$97

(#('-

/+-#= '<&

*#$( '7 ' $ *#2$

#&$2 '$*

2D<+(

*' 9+$= =##"

,-+

( '$,# ( 2*67

+=6(-9 )'(

# 2,,- 6+ ' =2< $(7 ' $ *#2$

-+'$*

-'8 G& '(8'

' +:6

#& 0("& 3('(

G& '(8'

' +:6

#& 0("& 3('(

G& '(8'

' +:6

#& 0("& 3('(

G& '(8'

' +:6

#& 0("& 3('(

/' $'(':'

+!+- & /' $'(':'

+!+- & @&

*#$+"

2D<++#$

,',

D##:& K2 #& K2 #& K2 #& K2 #& ?56

= #

:+-#= '<

>2+

$"#

*(7 @AA *+)9+$=

*'$ #,

? '$,# (

F#$

)+ (-9

$"#

( '*(#

-5-

*'$

'$,# ( 2*67

*#$"+(+#$

,#-+*9

!+#-'(

6#-"+$= !'-+"

)) *(+!

(':

2<,(+#$

+$!#-!

'$,# ( &

)+$"+$=

#$(+(2(+#$'- $*6

, G ';';

G ';';

#& 0("&4

2, '&

#& 0("&4

2, '&

#& 0("&4

2, '&

#& 0("&4

2, '&

)#--#8+$= *+)+* *#$+"

'(+#$

#$(+(2(+#$'- $*6% ?56

6#-"+$= '$ 01

= #

(6'$ .7

*(+#$

"7 *+)+

L0+=6( M7 *'$

L '$,# ( M 8+(6#2( #D('+$+$= *+)+*

'2(6# +N'(+#$

*(+#$

1 *(7

*+)+*'--9

L '$,# ( M *-'JB

*#$*-2+#$

)+$"+$=

#$(+(2(+#$'-

$*6

% ?

6#-"+$=

0+=6(

*-'7

*(+#$

= #

:=7 <+(( #,

L '$,# ( M 8+(6#2(

"+$= '""+(+#$'- '2(6# +N'(+#$

*(+#$

*( *+)+*'--9

L '$,# ( M *-'& # $+$=

,2 ,# 01 '$,# (

$(+ -9

*-'

$ #!

-',

F+( (8

(8#&

*+'-

-+=+D+-+(9

>2+ 8+-- 6#8

*#$(+$2

',,-9 )# 7 +$(

'-+'7

*' (7

+*:6'87

*' 9+$= 6'N' "#2 =##"&

*#$"

,' ( *(+#$ 7

<,6'+N

* +(9 *+)+*

>2+

O '$,# ( 7M "#

)+$+(+#$ 01 , #!+"

*(+#$

1 *(&

'""+(+#$'-

-+=+D+-+(9 * +( +'

*+)+

1 *(

1 2-

= '--9 L( '$,# ( M 8#2-"

',,-9

-6-

(6#

+$( $"+$= #,

= #

"+$= .7

:= +& O< "+2< =##"

M7 O< "+2< ,'

"+$= .7

:= +& O< "+2< =##"

M7 O< "+2< ,'

"+$= .7

:= +& O< "+2< =##"

M7 O< "+2< ,'

"+$= .7

:= +& O< "+2< =##"

M7 O< "+2< ,'

M7 O6 '!9 =##"

M O6 '!9 ,'

M&B M7 O6 '!9 =##"

M O6 '!9 ,'

M&B M7 O6 '!9 =##"

M O6 '!9 ,'

M&B M7 O6 '!9 =##"

M O6 '!9 ,'

M&B

<,6'+ 2,,-+ "

<,6'+ 2,,-+ " &

$*6 *#

:+--

F, *(

<'(

'--

2$+!

=' "-

)'-- +$(# ? '$,# (B

# ?#$ '$,# (B *'( =# 9& ( '-# +)

= #8

8+(6+$ .

:+-#= '<7

6#-"+$=

0+=6(

01 *-'

<+(( #,

?( '$,# ( 8+(6#2(

'""+(+#$'- '2(6# +N'(+#$

*(+#$

*(7 @AA& &E

#<+$=

)'*(

+$!#+*

<#"

$2<D

7 <'$2)'*(2 #6$

$"+'

!(& 0("& ( '-# "+,2(

(#('-

/+-#= '< /+-#= '< /+-#= '< /+-#= '<

*6$+*'- *+)+*'(+#$ =+!

6#8$

2,-#'"

D+(

#<,'$9& &

'(+#

)'*(

(6'$ .

:+-#= '<7 *#$*-2"

6#-"+$= !'-+"

)) *(+!

(+<

$(&

*# "

='--9

2('+$'D- &

3+<+-' -97

'(+#

-+ 2,#$

G& '(8'

' +:6

#& 0("&4

2, ' G& '(8'

' +:6

#& 0("&4

2, ' G& '(8'

' +:6

#& 0("&4

2, ' G& '(8'

' +:6

#& 0("&4

2, ' ',,-+*'D-

#$(+(2(+#$'- $*6

, G ';';

#& 0("&4

2, '& G ';';

#& 0("&4

2, '& G ';';

#& 0("&4

2, '& G ';';

#& 0("&4

2, '&

-+ 2,#$

*#2$

32D6'6

6'$"

#(6

2, ' 6'$"

#(6

2, ' 6'$"

#(6

2, ' 6'$"

#(6

2, ' '-# "+(+$=2+6'D-

)'*(

-7-

"2 +$=

!'$( +#"

$"#

$(+(-

<#(#

#(6

(6'$

'$,# ( &.

'#$7 (6+ #& '$8

='(+!

6'!+$=

6#-"+$= 01

0+=6(

*'$ #,

? '$,# (

( '*(# +)

= #

:+-#= '< +&

(6'$ .

:+-#= '<

8+(6#2( 6'!+$= '""+(+#$'-

$"#

=' "+$= '2(6# +N'(+#$

*+)+*'--9

>2+ ? '$,# ( B&

K2 #& K2 #& K2 #& K2 #& &

*#$"

<+$'(+#$ % ?

( '+-

>2+

*#!

<#(#

$(CB &

' $ *#2$

*#$( $"

+=6(-9

F#$

+D2$'-& )

*# "

+D2$'-7 ' $ *#2$

'+ ,#+$(

+$2

+$2 "&

)

<'"

(6+ .

. @@ (+(-

@@ (+(-

+ $('-

0+<+( 6'$"+=' 6 ' '<;+( /'2

+ $('-

0+<+( 6'$"+=' 6 ' '<;+( /'2

+ $('-

0+<+( 6'$"+=' 6 ' '<;+( /'2

+ $('-

0+<+( 6'$"+=' 6 ' '<;+( /'2

(6 (6 (6 (6 & &

*#$( '7 ' $ *#2$

)2 (6

*#$( $"

*'$$#(

"+*6' = +$*

+$2

(##:

( '*(# & )

, ?6

#9'- 32$"' '<

0+<+( 3<(& #$$'<<'

#(6 BJ

0+<+( 3<(& #$$'<<'

#(6 BJ

0+<+( 3<(& #$$'<<'

#(6 BJ

0+<+( 3<(& #$$'<<'

#(6 BJ

&&&

+!+- ...7 &&&

+!+- ...7 2D<+(( +$*

<'+$ *'2

( '*(# 7 ,2--+$=

<#!+$= ( '+- 2*67

-8-

( '*(# 7 +(4 +$2

F( $"

*'2

2-(+$=

'(6

* "& &

"# '=

2D<++#$ '+ 6'-)

#<,'$9&

#9'- 32$"' '<

0+<+( "4

2, ' #9'- 32$"' '<

0+<+( "4

2, ' #9'- 32$"' '<

0+<+( "4

2, ' #9'- 32$"' '<

0+<+( "4

2, '

+$2

*'$$#( '!#+"

-9 *'2

( '+-

-9

+$2 "&

#D !'(+#$

'"<+(( )'*(

+$*+"

#**2 86+-

+$2

( '+-

86# "2

'$ 2$)# (2$'(

$(7 ) -- #))

( '+-

,2--

D9G" +!

D9G'(('*6

( '*(# 7

2-(+$=

'(6 2*6

#$& &

2$"+,2( ,#+(+#$

( '+-

,2-- D9G'(('*6

( '+-

$(7 (2 $ (2 (- G2,(2 $ "7

2-(+$= 6+

'(6& #<

'D#!

+$2

$(& (

*'2

)'2-(

,' (

( '+-

('$"'-#$

6',, "& #

F,-'+$7

<'9 =+!

F'<,- % 6'"

( '+-

('(+#$' 9

'#$7 #!

(2 $ #

<+6', 6',, "7 8+(6#2(

( '+-

*+)+*'--9 +$2

,, 8#2-"

,'97 D2(

<'+$ *'2

,2--+$=G" +!+$=G<#!+$=

( '+-

2*6

$(7

( '+-

2,(2 $ "& 627

*'2

( '*(# 7 "2 +$=

*#2

$G,2--

( '*(# 7

#**2 "& & 627

( '*(# G+( +$2

F( $"

*'2

2-(+$=

'(6

* "7

(6 #2=6

( '+- 6+

,#+(+#$

, +$*+,-

<'$'(+$=

( '+-

-9

=+(

-9-

*#<,'$9 <':

8#2-"

',,-+*'D- #

F( $(7

)'*(

*- ' -9 "+(+$=2+6'D-

*+(

' $ *#2$

--'$(&

=+-'(+#$ +& &7

1 *(7

)+*+'- -)'

# + $'(2

P+$='<<'

!& $+(

P+$='<<'

!& $+(

P+$='<<'

!& $+(

P+$='<<'

!& $+(

$"+'

#& 0("&7

@ 3 . J $"+'

#& 0("&7

@ 3 . J $"+'

#& 0("&7

@ 3 . J $"+'

#& 0("&7

@ 3 . J / '<9'

!& '(+#$'-

/ '<9'

!& '(+#$'-

/ '<9'

!& '(+#$'-

/ '<9'

!& '(+#$'-

#& 0("&7

3 $-+$

3 A7 '$"J

#& 0("&7

3 $-+$

3 A7 '$"J

#& 0("&7

3 $-+$

3 A7 '$"J

#& 0("&7

3 $-+$

3 A7 '$"J 36+!'-

36+!'-

+!++#$'- '$'= $+( $"+'

#& 0("&7

+!++#$'- '$'= $+( $"+'

#& 0("&7

+!++#$'- '$'= $+( $"+'

#& 0("&7

+!++#$'- '$'= $+( $"+'

#& 0("&7

$-+$

3 Q $-+$

3 Q 2-(+<'( -9

##( *'2

( '*(# 7 +$2 "7 (6+ * 2*+'- )'*( *'$$#(

-#( #)& #

)2 (6

*-' +)+*'(+#$7

<+=6( +--2( '( % +) '$ +$2

6+(

'$#(6

(2 $ 6+( (6+ "

$(+

*6'+$ $(7

8#2-"

##( *'2

*'2

2-(

'*(+#$

*6'+$

*'$$#(

= ='( #

*#<,' (< $('-+N "& # #!

(6+ "2(9D#2$"

<+$")2-

= #2$"

'-+(+

#2 $'(+#$ *'$$#( , '*(+*'-+(9

6'"#8 *6$+*'-+(9&

<,6'+ 2,,-+ "

<,6'+ 2,,-+ "& &E

"+*2+#$7 (6+

*#$+"

#,+$+#$ (##:

2*6

6'!+$=

+$2 *'$$#(

= #2$"

F#$

#<,'$9&

*#<+$=

#,,#+(

6+(

<#(# *9*-+(7

*'$$#(

'D#-!

= #2$"

*+)+*'--9 +$2 "7 *+'--9

)'*(

#**2

"+"

(':

'D#!

"+*2+#$

'(+#

#9'- 32$"' '<

0+<+( "4

2, '

#9'- 32$"' '<

0+<+( "4

2, '

#9'- 32$"' '<

0+<+( "4

2, '

#9'- 32$"' '<

0+<+( "4

2, '7

=#+$= #'"

*'2

(##:

+$!#-!

( '*(# 7

*'$$#(

F#$ '**#2$(

9( '+-

-10-

-9 +$2 "& **# "+$=-9 (6+ '-# '$8

='(+!

' $ *#2$

'-#

-+'$*

2,#$

('( ,+--+#$ +"

<#(# *9*-+(7 '-

5 86# ('( (8#

-#'"

2=' *'$

( '*(# &

' $ *#2$ )2 (6

2D<+((

'(('*6+$= (8#

( '*(# 7

*#$"+(+#$

,#-+*9

!+#-'( <# #!

+$2 "& &

' =2< '+ 6'-)

6#-"

'$9 +(& (

<#(# *9*-+( 6+(

9& (

*+)+*

*-'+<'$(

<#(# *9*-+( 6+(

+ ( $)# <'(+#$ ,# (

$$ F2 7

)

( '*(# ( #-- *#<+$=

#,,#+(

D2(

)

(8# 9& 3+<+-' -9

F'<+$'(+#$+$*6+ )7

8+($

5 =+!

'$9

)

*#$"

9& $-9

"2 +$=

* # F'<+$'(+#$7

8+($

+$( #"2*

*#$"

2*6 ('( *'$$#(

'** ,( 8+(6#2(

F,-'$'(+#$ 2*6

+<, #!

$(& # #!

+(6

*-'+< (+(+#$

*-'+<'$(

'-- = $#

8 +(( ('( $(7

(':

2*6

(8#

( '*(# & &

#$ $(-9

'D#!

"+*2+#$7 (6+

*#$+"

#,+$+#$

)+$"+$=

,'+$=

#2& E&

**# "+$=-97

'** ,( "7 )+$"+$=

'+"

,'9

*#<, $'(+#$ '8' "

D'+

-11-

*#$( '*(2'- -+'D+-+(97 (6#2=6

;#+$(

'-& 15.

'<#2$( '8' "

6'-- '(( '*( +$(

.&I

'$$2<

"'(

)+-+$=

*-'+< (+(+#$ (+--

'-+N'(+#$

$(+

'<#2$(& #8

*-'+<'$(',, 6'--

$(+(- '$9

+$(

+#"

-'9 )+-+$=

<'+$ '-& &

32,

' <+$"

3+$=6 !& #$ #9'-

3 7 ' <+$"

3+$=6 !& #$ #9'-

3 7 ' <+$"

3+$=6 !& #$ #9'-

3 7 ' <+$"

3+$=6 !& #$ #9'-

3 7 '<#2$(

*#<, $'(+#$ '8' "

6'--

( '$)

#&$2 '$*

'$:

**#2$(

*-'+<'$(',,

8+(6+$ +#"

(#"'9&

,' (+*2-'

D'$:

'**#2$(

'-#$=

>2++(

"#*2< 2,,# (

6'--

)2 $+6

*-'+<'$(',,

#&$2 '$*

*#<,'$9 8+(6+$ +#"

(8#

(#"'9

")2- 6'--

"#$

#&$2 '$*

')(

+)+*'(+#$

8+(6+$ +#"

)#2

')(

'-#$= 2,(#"'(

+$(

*#<,-+'$*

6'--

,# (

'$:

*#$* "& 17.

Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.

& &

P / 5Q P / 5Q P / 5Q P / 5Q !('

':+$=

% #

,# ('D-

% #