Tata Aig General Insurance Co Ltd v. Surjeet Kaur & ORS
! "#$ %#&'( $) " ( !$ *****
+'&"
,- "
( ../0,
!!1 2"345.. 663311 7 829:2; 66$3
+'&"
,
"
!!1 2"345.. 663311 7 <;98.=;; 66$3 ,
+'&"
, "
!!1 2"345.. 663311 7 9.:2; 66$3 >,>0
+'&"
,> "
!!1 2"345.. 663311 7 $?.:2; 66$3 -
!!1 2"345.. 663311 7 8<9.:2; 66$3
"$/ @'5 $
" $&'
$8 $A
!
"
# $# %
&
'( ))) $9<.8;BC&1 !
(
(* $#
( (*
( #+
*(*
# (* # !
(+
,-
.//0 .123
!
* +
!(
++
4 .
.1256+ +
+
+ # + 7 ( +++ &
$ ( + + &8)21)%9).5/0 # + ( ++ (+ (* + :* (
(
+ *# ' ( ++ )1;)7<) ;=5> ++ $ #
(
#
&# #
$ ## 6+
+
,
+##(# + 867
##
7 ( +# # - #
( +,$ 53 .
.125
+ ! %
( + 2
+
+ $ ( + #
#
(*
/ (* #
## (*
-(+ # $#
+
+
- *
4
( # + + $ ! $#
* +
!
?
#*7 ( +
:)=4( !+
$ ) +
# 7 (*
+ (* $#
*
+ !(#
#
=5;;=11')%$ % % 2/3 .125 .
350.//.')%$ % % 2>/ .12/ =
/;2..1')%$ % % 2>3 .125
/;22.1')%$ % % =11 .125 /
2;>52/=')%$ % % =.1 .125
>
7 $#
*$#
( (*!(#
+# $ @#
! $ @# *
$#
* # $
*
%
++
( (* $#
* $ ,
+
(
: +#+ * +# (*#
!(#
++
( + $#
* ! +
*
+ + + + !* # *(?
!!(#
*+ * * #
(* $ !
(*
$ +
! # ##( *
$#
* # # (*!(#
! $#
*
* (
$#
*4 # 7
(* !(#
( ! * # ( # $#
*#
+
- # $#
* #( +#
.=
+#
2;0; A +#
2;0;A $
@# A
A $ *# #
*(
4
#(
%# # #+ 7A( # %# A.;8.=;?.1 2"345..C
$"$ ".?.1 - @+
## # #+
(* &B %#
A$D;!21..;2=;5$?89.?:2;@ .
2.
.12;
C#
@# # $#
*
(*
++
#+ $
* + 7# +# ? + (+ + #
+#
++ %#
#(
(
# #+++ * (+ +
$21 5.<.1.4E 1.<.1.4 2"34/ !
#+4 #+ # %# *
*
## * ( # * + + $
( * 4 # # # # ! # * ( + + # *
B #
!
2;=1 2;00(+
*
7
$ 4
# " 2;00 # * .12;4 #+ + !
+ #
* D * + * ## * #* * (+ + +( *
( * ! *(+( E+ +F (+ #( ( (* " ? (+
# # # # #* * $
*
+
# $
+E+ +F 4 ? # *
! +
# #E+ +F
G$ G$$
+ !# # $ E+ +F + - * +
# # E+ +F E+ +FE+ + *F (#
# +#
* ! (#2=5
+ < +
# 4 2>0
+ #
+# ! E+ +F ( *( # +# *@#
* 7 +( #
*4 +
# #E+ F *
(
* #
*+ + # ! ( *( #
# E+ +F 7# (
*E+ +F *4#+ *
(
# #
! "
232 ? #
E7) ) # F ! E #
F +
+ ##+ *#
+(* 235 + # * 4(# (+
! E
#
! #*
#
* 7 ##
# !#
E
*F
+ ? # *
+ 4 @# ( + (* +
#
+# + 235
(* 23/ 233 !
#( > %4 3.. ;=.?2 ;2C 2 + *+ *
(+ # +
# #
(
* +## # +# #
#
#
# +##
*(
. $ *
# #() 2
(@#
+##
( # *+ + 21 ;?;.1 *
= : +###
+# # (
# *
(+ # #
( # #
* #
"1. .<21G 2 < * (* -
< H # %
!(#
%
%
!(#
# *(
# # +#
+ ( *#*
+# # +
-
*
* +(
9?
I,
#((*
?
J
+ ( *#*
+# # K #
#235
. %
!(#
##( ( < *
(
(
%
=
(@#
(
%
!(#
# I
( 6#+ 7+%# ( ( &6#+ @#
7+%#6#+
&6#+
5 :%
!(#
# *
< * (* +
+#
(# (# +
331.. 3.G 2
+# # #() 2 23/ *( I
(* # #*4 ( (* *4 # (*
*
4 (* +# #(* #
*
*(
*#
( (
(
(
# # 235 # # 25;
( %
!(#
.
9*
##() 2
(
%
!(#
+ # # %
!(#
#
(#
#
(#
#
#
*( ( =
( # ? # L 5 ! %
!(#
*
# M 2/;L
# L / + *+ *
(+ +
#*
# # #
#
*?# #* L #
+# + ( *
* ( ++E# F
#(
# !
*
* *+
!? @# *# B !
2;00F $ E " 2;00F .12;
7
* : !
B # +
# *4 # E+ +F # ## * " $ E, #
F * (
+ #
* 4
(@#
7
## E
F * # 4
(?
+ +
?
+ ## E, F
* ! " $ *
# #* # *
!
#
#$ " 4
B *( ? #
# (
$ # 4
(+
+
D23/!(#
@#(#
#
+ E# F + + + # 233
+
(*23/ + + +
! E# F * 4 # #4
* 4 + + + * (* # 7 *
# $ *
+ # @#
( #
4 *4 *+ +
+
+ #
(#
*+ +
+
+
+# + 235
?
+ +
#E
*F *
(@#
+ ##E
*F !
( #
*+ ( + 21
(
*+ +
!#++ + *( 4 #*E * F
*+ + +?
# (# +
4 ! #
#+ E * F #E * F
#
# E
F E F #4#(+ *+ +
*
,
* E
F
# ( ?
( + 4 (*
* + ! * + @#+
*) (+ + * $## #
# (* !+ * + + *#+ *(++H
! #
# (* ! *
*
( #+ * * (
?
(# #
## #?
(
+* $
#
#E
F +
( #
+(+(#( #
7
( (# 4 #4 ##
( 7 E
*F * E# F E
F4 # # + # * # (+ 7 *(
4 # )# E
F ?
4 * !# *4 # *E
*F (4 * 4 #
>
#4 E# F
*
+ +
+#E
*F
4@# + + 7# (@# *
( + ?
!
+ + *# (+ # 7 (*
* +
( ?
#
!
( ( *( #
+ + + # # ( #
*( # +) # $# $#
(
* ( # #*
@# #+ +
7 *+ +(*
) @# ) # + #
$# ( +#
# + (*# (* # (
! + +
( # *
(
# * (* " (+ # +
(
+#
#
@# +#+#20=20/ ! +
+#+#
( *?
+ # #
#
?
* * #@#
$
# ( (+ +
$# #
( +E
F # #
( 4(# ( (+ + & # (
*( ##
? * (*
*+
E,#
+F !
# ( *( # #
253 " ( * $#
# * *#
#* *
* (*# !
* $#
2/2 #* * (
* # # ! 25> 3 #* $#
* # #* * + *
2/1
* $#
*
$# #
*? * ( (* +
+
B * +# # *
* +(* @#
#+ # #H
# #+ ! #
+ + + #+$# (+ +(*2>1
#
#* $# *
# * # # $#
# !+ +
*4
# * # +
*
+ #4#
( (# 4(* + 4 @#
#
(*
# 7 #
+ (# ## * *+# #*
(*2/1
5.<.1.4.;3" + #
(
#%# + #(
+# #
#
* !
# *?
#+# 7(
# +
#
*
7
( !(#
:)= +
#
+ +
+ 7 +
*
+ (+ + +
# *
(
# *4#(+ * ! * 7 ( +:)=#4 # ?
(* 7 + + # ( (#+# * *
# 7 + ?
# + + + #
*
#+ (#
#+
+ (*
( !(#
?
! (*
(# *#
(* +
*#)(#
9 $#
*
* (#
#+ +
+ -4(+ *
+ + $ #(# #( #
(* + 7 )$#
*
+ *
#(*
#
* # # (*
!(#
8 (./ 8 # $#
* #( & $ #
(
!# # +#
.= +#
2;0; ## F,(. 7;.1. ! +(
#
# # *
K 7%# ##( +# #( +#
.= (
+#
# (((* + 4 *(
+ + # * # ! # A
A *# *+
#
+ @#( +
(#+ (#
@# #
* A
A *
+
*A
A
'+ (
+*
* (
+* @# (* #
# ( #
? #
# (+ <
(
(
-
(A
A ! # (+ )) $
(
* ( *
(?
# 4
#+ A
A
*?
(* #
* ! #(*
(+ *? (
$ A
A +#
* (
# *+ A
A (+
(
(* $#
* $ ( # A
A( # ( *+#)
! !(#
++ #+ $
* +#
.5 +#
2;0;
( ++
*#(
? #
! +#
# ( ) F> <23<DH
*(
(# * # *
* K $ (*
+!
*
(
#
+ *
#+ *
* #
#
(* 4
(*# $#
*4
( * * *++
+
$ ) *
+ *
?
!
( * (+ *#
*+#(
*
#+ # # #+(*# %#.;8.=;@ # (*&B %#$D;!21.@ # %# (
*+# $ ( # %#
+
+ + +
(
# * : #+
7+%# (4
@# *(* #
* 7
++#
+ + (
#
(*
+ 4 #(+ * # +
!
7 %# ( #+#
$#
* *
7 +
$ # ( $
$ (
+ (#=)5 ! $ + @# 9
+ +
+ +
(
# *#
# ( $
? 7 # (
? + A# A@#
* ! +#
2;0;+ + + A A+ # *+ # ,?
A A$ + #
**
8
# + :
# (# + A+( # ( (+# $ # # # ( # B# *
# # (*
$# # ( # (+ (*
4 *
#
( +H ? ! *
+ B# (+
? (+
(*
: + $ ( *# (?
+ + (+
# # *+ #
*4 #
(*
++ ( # + +
$
#++ *+ +
# (* $
$
+ # ( ( *?
4
# ! * ( (* $#
* $
$ # + + # ( * /1N $#
7
#
#+ +
+ + +
A# A
$ (#
? ! #
( * ! $#
* ( ? >1N $#
* $ ? =1N
7
( $#
# *
#
$ 9 !(#
8 $ + * !
, *+ +
A# A $ (+ *# #
* $
# ++
+
(
# (+ ++(#
@# ! "
+ * A+ +A # !#
,
A+ +A * % A+ +A #
(# * # *
# $
+ + # (# # # #
4 + *
( (# *(
$ # # * @#@# # !#
* +* #
*
*( * +
$ * # # 8
D
8 *
# (+
(+* + # ++
+
(#+ +
* + # + +(
*
! +
# #
(* "
A
A
* (# * ( ( + $#
(# # !
(#)
(# !* *
* * #
#
*(
>
+ * $#
* >1N
$#
* =1N * (#
+#
(* $#
* (+ #
#( (
$ (
(*$#
* $
! (*
$#
? (
( ( !(
$&'
$8 $A &#(!
0,
+'
O'
O'