High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19863/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. Mwo Sushil Kumar

2024-11-06Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

!"#!$%&%"'(

! "

# ##$%&'(%)&* +

)( *+) ,,

, -

*+) , ,, , ) -",./0 % 12

-3425$,6 72 3+

9 %.3 :2 /"32:2$,6 728 +

;;;;

, -

. )3 "-33

2 4 +

$3+

2$ +2/ 8 3

- 2 , 8 3 , ,2, # #

=" >$ 2 +2 , ./ 3 52 , :, 7 ) ."

,$43./ 3752 : 8 +

8 3-2 2.

42 255 4,

$ /0$123"/'4

, 7

28 2 83253"

-37 " 83 6 7$3

7",3 2.

/ 8@,)++ , 5 +6".

,42 , 732-,8 : 6 7

3 : 732-$3 , 2.

/42 2 ,A

B8 5 8./3%, 2, )3, 2.

/5: 752 : 83 +

42 ?7, ./3 :+ "3

/$3"

3- ,323 "+2, 2.

42 32

-2--262,./

2/ 6 7

8 5, 8 2++25 ,2,

& 46$3 2:42 ?7,./3++552 ::

6 , ,2,

)328$3 "-3 +

8 5, 7

2++25,2,

$."3 2:32 25 . ?7,./3 ++552 ::

6 , ,,2, #

D 5

-2-- 6,$ +

8 5,$.8 3 52 , :, 7 ) ."

25 7

,$ 43./ 3 72 2 73255 - 328 2 ,?7

,)3 2 ,$.72: 4,6 , ,,2, # #

)3 +2 6+2 83 2

, =27,3

"# $

!" #

$ % &

"#"''#"() 5

-2-- 6,8 :328 2 ,2 +2 ,"+

3< "+2>$./352 ,:, 7 ) ."

257

,$3

8 232 8 5,32-2

2 4 +

.8 3 " '#!3!'$!&"# 9%&"/3 # C8 + 7,

- :2E2 887 62,?", 72

3+ 4 +

$ 2" 8"52 2 78 ,:

-433 3.8255: /, 2 6 F6 /::. 83,8 +

5$."+ 3 .

55,

32:/$, + 23

2-$"+

- ,$2 2::. 837 :.22 ,8 7 2.5 3: $233 2::2

,7,$/3 2++

$3" + : 3 7.

-7

"2.5 . 37

25 .

-7

"2.5 :2--262, .

2 :

7$3" 27G"

,$8 :$3+

+5 3

3?",-: ,,./3&

H.5+= "$

72 5, 2 '(

) ( % #

$ $+ ,

*+ , )

- )3 562 +22-2+3 8 3 2 , 6, 7 2 =27, 3

28 '

% %

* + -.

'#0 %

! &

1 2 3

"4'5

6/77,2 "89-

7 % &

:2 ; <2 "(,-=

-> ,

,2 - %-7

:2 "(, -= ,%-7

:"(,-= ,% -7

:"(,-=B ,%

-7 @

/77 5C

,@ - '##' D 51 + C

8 4

% 9#

% %

62,

-< > 832.

6=27,+

+5 $ 3 "-3+

,5/,752$3243 2, 2.

/.7 : 2 5,"+

/::. 837 :.22 ,8 7 2.5 3: $2 ,43 73

3 = 8

B 6$ 3"+

$ 3 "-3 2 / "73 , 2.5, ::. , .

,, 8 :3:/$."/ 3

, .2 ,3. 8 8, 2.

35 $32 : 8, 2.

/ ::. 837 :.22 ,8 7 2.5 3: $43 : 2 5,

D 3 2 , 2.

2 G"2 ": 8

B :

$ ." :+2 65/ G"

2 ,7522

8 : 3 %, 725 C 2,$ 23 72 ,5/

-323 2 ,22

,, 2.

-2

-2--262,./:

7)3 2 ,,7522

: ?

,./31 2 3

"4'5

6/77,2 "89- "3:

$3 "-33

2+ ":+

, % /F/% 3 ,+3/ 7252 ,: 253253 /::. 83 ,8 7 2.5 3: 7

,$ +7 255/43 23 2- 83

55,$3

7 ,2.

-. 32 /, 2 % 6$3 "-33

3 25 28"3 + ":+

$ 32 43 2 / ,

3 $ 3" 77"

". G" 5/$ 3./ 3 2 , 32++

- 8 ,

< >

- /, 2 $23 .+ ":, .2 G"5 83

- 6 7 2 2 ::. 8 3 ,8 7 2.5 3: :+2 65/$3

" 8 +

-3

4: G"2. 8 < "+2>% /F/% 37

,$." ,

3:+5 /$2

72 $3 2

" :2

, 732-,$3"+

$3752 :2 .7 : 5, 7 6, 2.

% 6$2553827 , 7 7": 2 7 2 ,2 3

8 6 7 ./ 3

,$2 .75 5/ 7"

I,$3" 8 ,752

-4333

/, 2 6 F6 37

,$ 2 G"5G"2

8 :

2/ 6 7 2 ,9 3 2: .

- 2--262, ./ .

2 :

C322 :2/$3

: 25 8 328"3

+5< >32/372 .,

25 8, 2.

,$."

5/"+

0 2>3 : 8277+2 7 837

2/ 6 7$ :

- .7

-7 ,,./3%, 2, 6 26 3 .

- . 4 3 2 , 2 43 46$.7 : 7

75",, ./

-3 : , .> / 8"3 ,

3 8 $ :2/ 25

". G" 5/.7 :7

75",,./3%, 725C 2,$

2 8 :

8 :

2/ 6 7

2 :

7$233 2:.

-2

25, 2 "3$ 83:, 725

3 5, 323, 2 7 "5,

326. ,7,

:, 725=2:

837

:2,$3" +

- ,

6 7$3"+

$3 2:4 55

.,:, 3262 ,"

- 6 7$/

< "+2>$3%, 725C 2, , 232

75",

- % 6$ 25 ,752,

"+2$32 :2 ,2 / 3%, 725C 2, 8 43-"

52 ,,

32+

83J1"

, %, 725<% 2/

KJ* 5: 0 1 25

+5 J )38 $ 32 .

4,:

,433

: 32.

+5 $43323 : 8 : 83+ +

3:/$3" 282+5

2/:, 725=2:

# .

-:2, % //% 3253$3" 2

.72:7 ,,2.

:, 2 .

-3 :2 ,9 433 :

.72:2++ ,, 323 2 ,, 2 42

2, :2 2-% 6$ 25

, .,:

,$8 :3827 232 ,$4333 72" 25 ="

3"+

83, 2 $2 ,9 3

3 8 $

3 +

$3" + 3

55: 83+ +

- +527$ % //% 3 27 6

./ 3 : 7$43./ $3 ":2/7

75",323

3, 2 ."2342 2 G"5 83

- 6 7

3:/ ,2 "7342 2 ."2.5 .72:2--262,./3

7 D 2,,

$ 25 , .-23,8 :3 7 , $4333%, 725C 2,$,

255/+ 7, :2E2 ,2 5,

62 7, 25737E$+2 7"525/2++2

- 3 2,6 83, 2 $3 "-3:+5 /: 82 8:, 73

G" $ 3" "

- 3 .5 7E 732

- 7 7

$ 438 : $233, 2 .72: "7,% 6$ 83 2 :+5 /: 82 5 "52 5/$3./ :2/.7 :7

75",,G"2 "+

3 8$3" ". G" 32++

: 2E

+527$2342

25." 4,

7. , .

-2

-2--262, ./+8 :2 7 8:

2 5/$ 83 "+2:+5 /, 73

G" 23 2- 82++

: 2E

-+527$3" ./3 %, 725C 2,7

,$52, 27

75"

$323223 :2

7 /, 2 $."/3 2 ,, :2 , 2

-3 : /+

32:/$ 26/

7 "52 5/3 ". G" 27 6,7

9"+

3 8 $ ,"

-37 " 8

7$."4 "5, 2"255/ 52, 24557

75"

./3%, 725C 2,$32 27 6"+

." .72: "7, 8 : 2 887 6 72" 25 - 7 7

43./ 34 "5,.,

25 8, 2.

& 46$

3 2 , ,26 "$3 " , .=27

-37

$2 .72:7 ,,./3 52 :, 725.

2, ./$ $. .0 123 43'$ 5 6.&' 2 "2552

+ 83 2.

/4 36 77

34 2.

/ ."2.5

6 7<L9> --262, ./ 6 7<L9>

7, 3 6 2

972" 9+7

7 7

2 +

6 7 <L9> L* 2.

8 , 2.

+27 2 ,

32,22

,52/ 2-

2: $ 2, 3 2 , 2

6 7

+2796, +279+

9</ >&

2 ."2.5

2--262,N + 22 <32+ !> 8 1%N<% >

O # 2,

- 837 , 625 3223 : 83 C*)* %*'') )L*<'> *$ M

2++

: 2E

-+52723

.72::2,

83+

+5 < "+2>,752,./3&

H.5+= "

72 5,2 '(

) ( % #

$ * +./3%, 2,$32 :, 2 43 733 46$,

8 .

,3+ +

$ : ,

3:/$, ,:2E +5

- 8 $ 3 ,7522

8 524

?",-: < "+2> 32

3./ 3 2+ ":+

323

- 83 2 ,, 2 42 2 G"5 8

8 6 7$ , .826 "2.5/ 4,6 26 3 +

)3 "-3 3 2 , + ":+

."2.5."3

" 52,6 7 ."3 2 ,+ ":+

.72: 72 "+

3 +

& 46$ 3 2 , 72 6 2,,"7

-, 732-

" 6 26 3 +

$238 7 - 5/ ."

-3 2 ,+ ":+

$." 2"255/25 , ,72 2

,"/25 "+

3%, 725C 2,$ -2- 58

3 ,26 " 23

-$ 3 "-3 :+5 /: 8 3 2 8 .5 7E 732

- 7 72" 25 7

G"< >$ 43./ :2/ .72: 265,323

- 83, 2

32:/+

5$ .72: "7,8 :2 7, 25- 782:

5/3 /% 6$ 3./ 42 25 , . 2,

3:, 725

$32 3, 2 ."8 24558 :,2

2342 27

25, 2 ,.72: 32--262,./

.72:2 :

2/ 6 7 & 46$22,

- 8

< "+2>$, 32 32 . 7 ,,

2 /+,8 :2

326. 7 ,, 3 = < "+2> 2,5/$

6 7 ." 3 + ":+

< "+2>32 . 5,./3+

$3./ $3 "

, - 6

4 -32- 3

83:, 725.

2,$ 2 =27, < "+2>

" 5/$ 3./

7, 7 72 . , 3 "+2 55

:,2

$. , 3./ 3

83, 2 72

. 2 , .2 G"5 7, 25- 82:

5/3 /

2 5/$ , .,752, 8

7 2,,

$ , .,752,

.2 ."2.5

-2--262,./

./3+ +

% 6$3 "-3 2,3

323, 2 < >

77",43 5 6 7.72:+8 :,./3,8 7+

5 23

2+2722$."

=+ :2 ,2

3 562 -"52

$43 73:2E 3

- 83, 2 < >

+2722$

.-28"3 G"5322 "73$ H

- ,

2 8 :3

.72:2--262, ./

83:

7 7

G" 7$3527E 83 2 =+ :2 ,2

3 -"52

$ , 7

3 "

75",$326 83

- 83 2 ,, 2 < >"+

3 + +

3" 77",

2+2722$3./$3 2

- 2 . ,752, .7 : 2--262, ./ .

"3$

: 83?",-: ,,./3 += "$

72 5,2 7#

$ % &

! )

,-8 43

$2,7522

:2, 3 = $323. 8 8

- 88$2332 : 4, 37

, "52 5/25 3"

, 2

,82 .5 -3 .72: 6 ,

3 + +

8 3 E

- G"2 3 2++

- 88.

-:2,

3 826 "

*6 34

7 3 ,7522

8 524 :2,

6, 7< "+2>:2E 3 2 ,,7522

.2 =+ "52

8524

:$3./ $3=+ "52

8524

:$2 :2,

6, 7 < "+2>25 :2E 33"

, 7

8,. 8 6 26 3 ,8 7 +

5 7

,$ $

$ 25 5 3

,$3" 22 / : E3-2

- 83 4: 2 :2,3"

, $2 ,32

38"55 7 :+5: $2 +5 3"

, $. , +7 6 83.2$ /$ 8,52/2 ,5273

)38 $ 3 -2

- 8 3 . 8 8 3 2++

- 88$

: 836, 7< "+2> ,,./3) ."

,$25 ,

"888 :2 / 55-25 /2 , . "+35,

%'0 34!3"# 9%&"/3

28:23$3 "8

34 +

,4 3 . 62

6$3 2: , ,

)3 :+"- , ,$2 +2 ,./352 ,) ."

,$ :2

,2 ,288 :,

D , 825

-4 3255+

-2++5 72

< >$ / 5,

, -

5, , )6

33 +2E

-92

, L 9

33+ 2.5 L 9