Harbans Singh v. Ld. Financial Commissioner Punjab And Others

  
    
 

 !"#$  

%& !$'$()$&* +  %!,%$ -.$/0 &.&.$!

1! '

.$%$(.%2
)). .$!'$3%,4
.".2-(!&%!.%&4 '$3%,4
0%$#./%!0%$#&0!   5$#$&
6*7 86-

-    


 
 




 
 
 
 


!




 

! "

-  4 
#





 


#
 
 



$ 



%& '( (%')
*+  ,"-

'

#


! '
 #



#



%( '( (%'&
*+  ,.-

(

#



 (/ %'

(%'.
*+ 
,(-

.



 

%( '( (%'&
*+ 
,.-



! (


 




 

  

 
%& '( (%')

'

  1










 
 
3 



2 

 4 
5
!
6
7



3

  

#
2 



#
 





#
 





  


 



1#


 



 
#


3 

2 





8
7 
7 4



!4
 
 



7

#

5
3 




9#






8 


6

!


 

2 

  




4#
  





 

 #





7  


6
 !









 


 






 

2 

: 








 #

 
:




#
 

0;7 ! ''%<%"

%) (%%"
#


1#




! "


"&&<"")<"&=<"&)<"&/<")'<'(%,1

;8 #
#


0;7
! >"<>&

%"

%& '>/&

 '")<'"/<'"><.(.

;8
#


3 


 



?
#
  


 #


:

 






 



! "


8

#
 

 #
="




'%







;5;

0

 5
1


#
%"
4
'%




 4 
*  -
3

#
(





%) 4



4 
3 

:


 
! ",1#

#
"&





#
>


1


#
%>
4
%"





4  *  -

%.
4


4 
*3 
-


%& 4



1
6
*  -
2
6
8
 
 



 



 
1#


 "



 

  

  



2 






 (/ %'

(%'.




 


#
 ,
  






 


 

8


7
6
7


 #




8



#


 





%( '( (%'&





 
8










  





6
8

(/ %'

(%'.
 





2 





 

! "






'&
 
 
2
7 

'//)



0 8


 


! '

2
0 8










 
"

 




6
8 
(/ %'

(%'.




%& '( (%')
3


 

8 

#




#


: 2
 




 
 






 

2 
 

! "

#
,


 
3






 
#

   



#

6
8
 






 

1#
  "


2 



3



 


 







 8


3






8


, 





#


 
 


 

 
3





! "
#


 0;7
! ''%<%"

%) (%%"


 "&&<"")<"&=<"&)<"&/<")'<'(%,1

;8


6
8
 
 
# 






3




 
8


 





8
 
 




 




8 
(/ %'

(%'.







2 
 




%( '( (%'&
3
 




 ! "
#






! '
#
 


'

3






  



! "
#



0;7
! ''%<%"
 %) (%%"

 


 

 




# 

3




$ 


! "
 $ 
 (/ %= (%'(
# 






 

 ! "
# 
 



3






8

  



 

 



4
 



3









8  

 
 

8






  






2 



3 





0
8





 
#






8



#

  



 


0
8

 




 

#

#
 
 




"

2
  










8 
 ;
 

    



<4

=> 
=
.".2> 

; 
  
 

 

 <48  +   +
3





 


 












#
 










2 

    

 


! "

 






 



3
  





 








 



! "
#
 





 
#
>


3




 

! "
 
 

0;7
!
''%<%"

%) (%%"
#

 
(/ %= (%'(



8 

$ 

! "






3






! "
 $ 



8 

#

$ 




? 
$ 

 
 





! "

3 




! "


 




   



#




8
3 





8








 




8
3





! "
  










#



 #
3






0
8




 






8





 



6
8

3







# 

8


 
 


 

 








 

+
 
 
#

 
 





3 




#







#

  

 


 
#
3




 




 



 

;



 





  







 





  










 
 #
2 




2 
  
3 





7


4 
5
!
6
7
# 
1




! "
 


  

#

,
5

 




 




! "
#
  


 
#
#
"&




>



+








#




 ! "


#




4 
*  -

#
 4 
*3 
-
5


 


 ! "
#



0;7
! ''%<%"

%) (%%"

 "&&<"")<"&=<"&)<"&/<")'<'(%,1

;8


 

 

 
5 



#
$ 



8 

9 ;8  





(/ %= (%'(





 

5
3@ 
6
1


8 


  







 






 8




#

 


2 

 







 
   


 8 



#

 





 $ 







 


 


2 

7
! "
 
#



6
8


  


 

2 

#




0;7 



5




! "

 

 


 


 

#

 8


 


 



4

 
 
5

#

'%


#
 ! "
#
>


5
 





 











:
# 










#


8 
 




6
8
 

 3

 




6
8 

0
8





5





 
8




+






 






5








8
4

#







 

#
  



 


8
 



+ 




 
#
#
 
#






 









6


=-  >  

+  



4< 
A<!


  
A<!