Shine Buildcon Pvt. Ltd v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!"#"
$" %"
"" "
$ "
$& '
()
*
+ ),) )-
'
)
+ ),) )-
'
)
.
+ ),) )-
'
) /
.0
+ ),) )-
'
) "1*
2#31 !
4 44"
$""3"
! "
#$% &! ! "
'''
44"
$""3"5!6 &7 %
" ( ) * +,-.!+..,!
+./. +/01,2304 & " & ! 5 ! $
6 ( ) * +,-.,2307
# % 4 & & " $ " 02 859(" %" 4 !
8 $ 8 !,23+: ; ,23+ <= "" &&
->" " 3.>" " ?" % & $ 5 $ &
% &
5& " & 5$ 4
@ 4 !30-@: ; 30-@ <= &
33 3, ,23+ "
$ "
" " A/2 & 8 $ & /01@ 5 8
! - 30-@ &
,3 ,23/: ?
,= & / 32 3, ,23@! & &
$ " - 3, ,23/ 5,.B 3- " 5 "
% " " 0 3, ,23/ : ?
+= $6 " ,7 4
! 5 8
! & & " - 3, ,23/ : ?
@= " &6 " ( 0& $ & 5 "
( 0
;
4444
& " 50/ @3 4 & ! $ 6 5 " % "
" C ! 5! 8"* ,11 2-73,7,23/ 8A )6 &
"
? " & $D ()& & " 6 " E$ D$ 5( % 4 !& " $ 6 "
& C$ " !
$
2-73,7,23/ < % " " & !& $ " - / ,231: ?
.=$&8% 5 $ + @ ,231&&
$ +2 / ,231&&
" $ " , 8
! " 31 ,231: ?
/=&
$ " & 02 ,23+ ! "
" 303 - 3, ,23/- / ,231 -+!0,!3/37&
" " $! " &" $
% " & "
$6
$ " " & " ""
,/ 3, ,23/ A5 "
5 " % $ " " $ 3, @ ,231
/ $ " &
65 "
02 ,23+ & "7 " +@ 30-@ ; &89
)F) " " $ 65" ! (
" &
& " " 65"
$ "
" " " &"
&" 6 ! " "
$ "$ ?" " " " &$ "
$ ?" < $ 11& $ (
" " &
$ "
5 &
" $ "5 $6 " $ 5 $7 :,=
11 ,23+ ;00 &89
( 9-
)&
'
- ) )&9 ",:
8;:3=G65& +2! (
" " &
$ "
5 &
" $ "5 $6 " $ 5 $7 :,= :,= "
"
! $ " "
! $ "
" "" !
" "
& /@&
$ $
" $ " "
" & & "
$
6 ""
$7 :3= /@
5
$ " !& &
"" &
! " " &
< " 0 & !$ " $ 6 5 " *5 $ & " & " $ " % " &$ " $ :,= 11 & &" " ! &
"
" "" ! (
" " &
% ! & $
$ 6 " &
" A "
$ " "
"
&':<&& '&
:
+) 4& &8& & & ' :
) 6/7 67 &
6 "5 & " +@ 30-@
;1
% 4 &
. & "
65" +@ " "
" +@ !
; 7 ) " " $ 65" ! (
" &
& H " I" 65"
$ "
H
" " " &" & " 6 !
" "
$ "$ ?" " " " &$ " $ ?" I " +@ 6 " " $ 65" ! (
$ 5" &
& ->" " & 6
$ "
" +3 ! (
65 &
33 4 " " &
$ & "
" 5 &
$ 5" " " $ 5 & " " "
!
4 " (" ( & 30 &
$ $
0
" 5 C !,220:,=8(8 :( =,21 ,220:,=8 3-1 :,22/=0((@.1 $
$ ( E$ " 5 & " & & " 33 $ $ & 6
"
$ ,+:3=!,+:3 = ,+:,= "
$ +@ % & 4 $ " $ (
+3 % D
5
6$ 5
" "
$ (
$ 5" " &
$
! " " " "
"5 % 5 ! ! & $ (
+3 $D 5
"!& & " & & " 6 & !86 B
C :,221=,((@/3
" " "
4 &&
65$ "
"
-
" ! ""
65 " " " " &$ 4
" B*
.1/ .0.!& * -& ,.
/ ,22@$ " $ " 30 ,22@ " B* .1/& " B* .0.! "" $ !&$ " " $ !,22.
% "
& " &6
" 5 +@ ! & " $ " $ 65"
! ->" "$ $
&
" $ " " $ " & " &" 6 3.>" $ " ?" " " " % " $ $ ( E$ " ( 4, '
'& 6/7 6700* 6704 "3@ D
5 $ $
;J " &
& " " $ 65"
4 $ " & " " 4 " 5 5 & &
$ " K
&
$ % $ " $ 4 "
" 5 " &
" & "
" +@ < 4
$ ! " 8 " * +
" 6
" " " & ! ? $ " " ! $ " ! $ 65 " & ! $ 5 " " %
$ &" & " "
&
< $ :$ -9
",:
8+)4,=:>4 ?:
@ :
).6.745& $ " ?(
" $ && "$ " &
(
6 " "$ 65 &
& " "$ ! $ " " ! $ "
" "" ! (
" " 8 ( & " $
"5 &
8 "
% 4 ! 65& " " " !
& G ?
!
4 "
33!6 & & 5 33 & ! 3,:,= ! (
5 & " " "
%"!& & +3 !6 (
" " &
$ " &
! 5 & !
65 & !
! (
$ & " "$ " &
" $ " & !$ 5&
& &$ " D $
" ! & " & !
(
6 " "$ 65 &
& " "$ ! $ " " ! $ "
" "" ! (
" "
" $ 6 (
6 " !&
" $
$
% 6 ! 5 +@!
& " " $ 65" ! "$ -" " 3." " %$ " $
$" "" & " 5$ " ! $ % $
( < 8
! "
" 4 $ $ D
5 &':&<&2)(&) 6),-&7 % ? &$ "
$ $ " " $ $ "
& " "
5& 4
" & $
" ,@ - ,23.: ?
0=
$
( 9 ( ! 8 5 " & 4 & ""
$ & ! ! $6 $ !
$6 $ "5 &
( + ;+
! $
" &
$ & & $ 5 4 5 8% % " " 5 4 $6 655 & " " $
& 9 "
" $ & ! 4 G : G=
$ & ! ! $6 $ !$6 & ! $ 58%
%
$
& " < " &&
$ -: ?
,=&
" $ 5 " 6 " ! & "
5 5 & " &
" 6& "" "" 8
! 5 ? $ $ $ " 5 ! " &"
&
%
" ->"
" " " ( ) +..,,230!
$ 8
!
" " &" ->" $
$ " 3.>"
&
$ &&
&"
" !
"" 3,>$ "
!& ,&85 6 44"
$""3"7 =& !,'?
) " 65 L * ) "$
L *