High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2579/2010dismissed

Surjit Singh v. Jay Aar Trading Co. And ANR.

2018-02-02Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

!"##$%&%'( #)*+!*,- .

+*/%"%'01 22#33!'"

4#*&+& !,!**!5%'0 !'"1#* #&2'5#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.&

*#&#'"( *!%'%-56$!"#- *"1#!22#33!'" *71!33!-56$!"#- *"1#*#&2'5#'"& 88888 *)+%,'

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

<!'5"1#'#:3,$'&"%"+"#5%*@:!&'"*#0%&"#*#51#$$+'" )D&5%5'")#!*!',$#*"%%$!"#!+"1#'"%$!"%'),'$@#!E!'5 !3#&!E+"1*%"%#&-:1%$1:#*#*#F+%*#5")#2*6#51#!$$+'"

)D&:#*#!)*%$!"#5),"1#*#&2'5#'"923!%'"%&!'5#E2#*"*#2*"%'"1%& *#0!*51!50'#+'*#)+""#5-,#""1#+*"&!)5%$!"#5%'5#$*##%'0"1#&+%" #+*"1#*&+)@%"& "1!""1#"*%!3+*"5#$*##5"1#&+%"), %0'*%'0"1#"#&"%@', !""!'G+@!*2!*"'#*-:1-%'$*&&9#E!@%'!"%' !5@%""#5"1!"!33"1##'"*%#&@!5#%'"1#!$$+'")D&1!5'")##':*%""#' ),1%@'92*5+$"%'"1#!$$+'"!'":!&!3&!"!3""1#$!&#1# +*"&)#3:1!6#:*'03,1#35"1!"!&2#*5$+@#'"&E

!'5E - "1#%*@:!&%'#E%&"#'$#&%'$# -)+""1#2#*+&!3E

&1:& "1!""1#%*@:!&%'%"%!33,*#0%&"#*#5),"1# #0%&"*!* %*@&%' 9

!'5E :!&2*#2!*#5%' 9 !'5*#0%&"#*#5' <1#&+%"'

"1#)!&%&+'*#0%&"#*#52!*"'#*&1%25##5:!&'"@!%'"!%'!)3#!'5-"1+&- 2*!,&*!33:%'0"1#!22#!3),*@+3!"%'0"1#&+)&"!'"%!3F+#&"%'& 3!: *71!33!- 3#!*'#5 $+'&#3 *#2*#&#'"%'0 "1#*#&2'5#'"9 23!%'"%&&+)@%"&"1!"$'$+**#'"%'5%'0&$!''")#%'"#*#*#5+'3#&&!'5 +'"%3"1#*#%&!0*&&%33#0!3%",!'52#*6#*&%",-:1%$11!&'")##'2%'"#5 +"-*-"1#23!%'"%&1!6##E!@%'#5 H9 !""!'G+@!*!'5 H9 !/%6 !31"*!!'5!3&"#'5#*#5%'#6%5#'$#5$+@#'"&E

"E ;# &+)@%"&"1!"1#1!&2*5+$#5E ;&"!"#@#'"!$$+'"2*#2!*#5),1%@!& 2#*!$$+'")D&- D!*-!&19)D!'53#50#*9)D2#*"!%'%'0""1# ,#!*& 9 " ;9- #'"*,5!"#5 E :*%""#' ),

!""!' G+@!*- "1# D!*9)!1% *#0!*5%'0 )**:%'0 ;.-=9 ), "1# 5##'5!'"-E A!'5E $**#&2'5%'0#'"*%#&%'"1#$!&1)D!'5"1# 3#50#**"1#,#!* 9-E .$2,#'"*,5!"#5@!5#), 1%@ *#0!*5%'0 )**:%'0 =9- E !'5 E

$**#&2'5%'0 #'"*%#&%'"1#$!&1)D!'53#50#*9)D1#$**#&2'5%'0#'"*%#&%'"1#

/ $!&1)D!'5"1#3#50#**"1#,#!* 9!*#E !'5E 1# #E2#*"#E!@%'#5),"1#5##'5!'"1!5!5@%""#5"1!"1#5%5'""!D#"1# 21"0*!21&*@"1#*%0%'!35$+@#'"&-)+"*@"1#21"$2%#&1# +*"&)#3:'2*#2'5#*!'$#"1##6%5#'$#+'5"1!""1#23!%'"%& 2*6#5"1#*#$*5"1##'"*%#&:1%$1:#*#%'$'&%&"#'"!'5-"1#*#*#- $!**%#5!2*#&+@2"%'+'5#*#$"%'<;"1#'5%!'6%5#'$#$"!&%"@!, '")#!$'$3+&%6#2*#6%5#'$# '*#)+""!3-*!%'%1!&*#3%#5+2'"1#/+50@#'"*#'5#*#5), "1%&+*"%' 0 1 234451670

0 8, 9

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

223,!&%":!& ! $!&#:1#*#'3,"1#)!1%#'"*%#&:#*#)*+01"'*#$*5!'5'""1#$!&1 )D&!'53#50#*9)D&#$"%'<;"1#'5%!'6%5#'$#$"2*6%5#& "1!"!'#'"*,@!5#%'"1#)D&!$$+'"*#0+3!*3,D#2"%'"1#$+*&# )+&%'#&&%&!*#3#6!'"!$"-)+""1#,@!,'")#!$'$3+&%6#2*'"1# 2*#&#'"$!&#-"1#3#50#*9)D&!'5$!&1)D&1!5!

9 *#$*5"1#*"1!'"1# D!*)!1%& 4%&9!96%&"1#)/#$"%':%"1*#0!*5""1#@!%'"!%'!)%3%","1# &+%"!&"1#%*@:!&'"*#0%&"#*#5-!@"1#6%#:"1!" *@&BC!'5CC !*# -:1#*#!&"1##!*3%#*2!*"'#*&1%2%*@:!&*#0%&"#*#5'

<!&'#"1#2!*"'#*1!55%#5!'5"1##'"*,:!&@!5# #0%&"*!"%'

"1#%*@1!5!3*#!5,)##'2*6#5!'5"1!"%&:1!"1!&)##''"%$#5),"1# 7:#*22#33!"#+*":1%3#5#!3%'0:%"1"1#)/#$"%'

*"1#*#!&'&&"!"#5!)6#-5'"%'5!',%33#0!3%",!'5 2#*6#*&%",%'"1#/+50@#'"&!'55#$*##&*#'5#*#5),"1#+*"&)#3:- :1%$1!*#)!&#5'!22*#$%!"%'#6%5#'$#0*+'5*%'"#*#*#'$#%& @!5#+"&+)&"!'"%!3F+#&"%'3!:!*%&#&*5#"#*@%'!"%' 22#!3&"!'5&5%&@%&&#5 ;<8,= *)+%

042 '(-.& +2:24>1 ?4

@4?

+2:2 :<!

@4?