← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6048/2017dismissed

State Bank Of Patiala v. Permanent Lok Adalat(Public Utility Services) Rewari And ORS.

2017-05-23Mr. Justice Krishna Murari5 pages

  

      

   !"#"$%& '()

*   $+

"

 - ""$ . /#

3 *4 ." $2.# - #6$2 $#  &%  71&  *&&* 88 

. # $%8 &.9:;< )2=!

 .: 6 ""$ . 88  *   $+

"

:

#", 2: 6. # $5."6 ""$# +"$>  ?;

#: .2 . 2  2  ! 0@ .  )   3 $$ A;.  4 6 ## 2 @'

3 *4) .") > "$#: 6 ""$ . $+:,2"$> . #6$2 $5",,@ ,"

@, 0 + 6 '0 $ "# 2 @' :  6 ""$ . $2 2". ! 2 :  6 ""$ .  . , #  0.> > 2 # !;."'  . . != ."$> :  ;# $2"$> @ $!  : . :

+ 8= . .> # ."  !#. , = $.: 2 !"#"$: 6. # $5."6 ""$)

. $ .0 :  . !.2) .  :

 . #6$2 $ $ "# !

..'"$> $ :  @;#"$ ##0",,"$>)0 $; !;."$> $26.2;!"$ 2"@, ",#"$: $ 0 

 

$2#', &B# <" ", $2 $ .

,&",,#"$

< #:

$:

2 = ", 2 !. 2"  !","' .0 :  6 ""$ .  $+ !06."# 2   #: . 2" '6: !

"$1"0" # C!.. ##"$! ;>;# )  #6$2 $  66," 2.: . $ 5 ,:  #:. 2"1"0"="2  66,"!

"$2  2 * 6 0@ . ) C: # "2,"0"5 #. $ 5 2="2 ,  . ..

$> 0 $  2 $;

.') . 6 ."2 0$:# $2: # 0 5 #. ?;". 2  @  . 6 "2 # 6 . :  . 6 '0 $ #!: 2;,  0 $"$ 2 "$ :   .0# !$2""$# 5": :  # $!"$ ,  .   #: . 2" 1"0"  :   ,  #: . 2"1"0"5 #(!.. # #6$2 $!, "0 2:

#: 5 #.! 2 .

$# .: !

#:!. 2","0"  $+5: . : .

 "$ . #"#

D 6 . $$;0 5:"!: "# , ## . :

$ :  .

   "$ . # !:

.> 2 @' :  6 ""$ . $+. ?; #5 #0 2 .!,#;. : !

#:!. 2","0" . , # : 6.6 .'2!;0 $#>"= $ ## !;."'5":: 6 ""$ . $+ : 6 ""$ . $+5.  ,  .2  26.", () :

.!,#;.  : !

#:!. 2","0" $2. , # : 6.6 .'2!;0 $#)! .

"$6 '0 $# 5 .   @  0 2  # 0 $"$ 2 "$ :  ,  . 2  2 6.", ()  

#6$2 $="2 : .,  .2  26.", C) . 6," 2:

:  0;$ ="$> ,.

2'@ $2 6#" 2)$6. 86 '0 $!:

.> "# 66,"!

@,  ##;!: . ?; # . . , #   :  6.6 .' 2!;0 $# 6.="2 2 # # !;."' 5 . " .

 2   :  6 ""$ .  ", 2  . , #  :  6.6 .' 2!;0 $#  . #6$2 $.5 $6 '0 $@ 0 2 @'. #6$2 $:  6 ""$ . :  $ $ 1+ 2  : ,2 :

 . #6$2 $#  $2 ( #:

,, $ @  ,"

@,   0 +  6 '0 $  6. 86 '0 $ !:

.> #B + = . .> #, =" 2@': 6 ""$ . $+2". !"$5 #"##; 2:  $+

 . , # : 6.6 .'2!;0 $## !;."':

="$>@ $+ 6@'. #6$2 $#  $2("$: !;#2':   .. != ."$>: !:

.> #)" $') 3  

!

 "

#

$%&) : . :

$ :  6. 86 '0 $ !:

.> # B + = . .> #ECD > "$#. #6$2 $# $2(5":"$(2 '#.0:   6 ##"$>:  .2 >>." = 2 @' :  2". !"$  :  $ $ 1+ 2  "$ . #.

"$"$> :  6 ""$ . .0 . != ."$> :  6. 86 '0 $B +  = . .> #): @ $+:

#", 2: 6. # $5."6 ""$ : 0 "$!$ $"$, .$ 2!;$# ,.: 6 ""$ ."#:

: 6 ""$ . $+"# $", 26. 86 '0 $!:

: .

 CD : = .8# $2"$> 0;$.0 #6$2 $$ !!;$ +"$>= . , $B !

#: !. 2" ,"0" @'    # 6 . ,  .  ..

$> 0 $ !, ;# (: &$ .' ,"!' 8 C:  # .=  $+$2"

. ,  # $,'  , ='  6 $ ,'  6. 86 '0 $   .0 1 $# !"$> , "$>.

 "$ . # $2# ="$> !!;$# $2$ 66,"!

@, :  !

# . #6$2 $5:05.+"$>!

6"

,@'5 ' #:. 2" 1"0" 5 ,,5 2 @' :  6 ""$ .  $+ "$ :  $ 0   : . #,  6.6." .#:"6!$! .$). #6$2 $(  6 .;# ,  :  "06;>$ 2 .2 . "$2"!

 # :

 :  ,  . 

..

$> 0 $A

F2  2 $;

.') :

#@ $!

. ;,,'6 .;# 2@' :  5:"!::

#@# .= 2:

@': :

$285." $,"$ # "$!, ;#  )":

#@ $"$!.6.

 2:

: 6 ""$ . $+5",,@  $", 2  .> #ECD$:  ,, 0;$5: .

#2!;0 $# "$: .">"$ >. 0 $$ = .!$ "$ 2: # "26, "$!, ;#  :  > $ .

,  .0# $2 !$2""$#  :  2!;0 $# 5:"!: 5 .  #;66," 2 @'

 6 ""$ . : "0 . $ 5 $2: 2!;0 $#25$, 2 2.0 ",)2"2$!$ "$:  @= # "2!$2""$ $ !!;$ @# $! 

$' :

$285." $ 6"$ "$ !, ;#    :  > $ .

,  .0# $2 !$2""$# 5:"!:5 ##;66," 2@': 6 ""$ . : "0 . $ 5 ,A A ) :  6 ""$ .  $+ 5 # : ,2 $ ,"

@,   . != . 6. 86 '0 $ .> #B .> #ECD "::  ##"# $! , .$ 2!;$# ,.: 6 ""$ .:

=  >$ :.;>:: & # .".!;, .$;#0 .* .="! "$ $+#)"##; 2@'

# .=   $+  $2"

  : .  "#  #6 !""! 6.="#"$ 0 2  "$ :  # "2 !".!;, ."$6 5:"!:2 ,#5":, ='# .="! !:

.> #

 :  !".!;, ..

2# #,,5#%88  

 

    



     

       

                

    

 

 

     

    

      

       

       

          

             

 

   

 

  

 

 

   

!

     

         G # 6 . 6    :  ".!;, .) 5:"!: 2 ,# 5": , ='  . !,#;. !:

.> #B6. 86 '0 $6 $ ,'$, "$>.

  .0, $#)":

' @ $, "2:

@ $+#5",,$@ 6 .0" 2!:

.> . !,#;. !:

.> #B6. 8 '0 $ 6 $ ," # $ ,, , "$> .

   .0 , $# # $!"$ 2  "$2"="2;

@..5 .#$6 : ".!;, .) 2="! :

#@ $>"= $: @ ,,5 ;$".0) ". $2.

$#6 . $6."!"$>6,"!' $2$2"#!."0"$ @ 5 $: ".!;#0 .# :0 @.

$!: $2$$8:0 @.

$!: # $ =" 5  :  @=  # "2 !".!;0# $! #) :"# ;. "#  :  6"$"$:

: 6 ""$ . $+"#$ $", 2 $'. != .' + 8= . #:  $".  0;$2; :

2 ,.

2'@ $6 "2: 6 ""$ .  :  !$2""$ . . != .'  !:

.>  E CD :

# @ $ ",, > ,,' "$!.6.

 2"$:  >. 0 $>.;$2"#0 2 ;"$ . . "$:  .2 .6 # 2@'. #6$2 $  :  6 ""$ "# 2"#0"## 2  :  6 ""$ .  $+ "#2". ! 2  !06,'5":: 2". !"$#:  5":"$ 6 ."2 $ 0$:  .: . ! "6! ."" 2!6': .2 . & '()

3&&*4 # $< '   : : .#6 +"$>B.

#$ 2%  #B : : .. 6.

@, %  #B