High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6053/2017allowed

Avtar Singh v. Union Of India And ORS.

2018-07-19Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath4 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'() ) * * * * +"!,%'-. #"%"%'#, /& '%' '0%!!'0".#,& #&1'0#'"& 2(3 42 5 2(3 42 5 2(3 42 5 2(3 42 552 52 52 52 ,#&#'"( 2, !&,!6%'-.70+$!"#7

,".#1#"%"%'#, 2,8!970+$!"#7

,,#&1'0#'"&: 2&4!+!'8!!;977;'6!< 552 7 552 7 552 7 552 7 .#1#"%"%'#,%&.90%'-!1!&&1," *+!9%0;1" = )#>+#0!'!119%$!"%'",#&1'0#'" ' ,,# %&&;!'$# .%& 1!&&1," %' ! $>1;"#,%?#0 ,>!" # @!& -%+#' !' !11%'">#'" !'0@!&%'

,>#0".!".%&!119%$!"%'@;90<# $'&%0#,#0!

"#,19%$#+#,% %$!"%'.#,#!

"#,'* 7.#,#$#%+#0! >#&&!-# ,> ".!"19%$#+#,% %$!"%'%&!-!%'&".%>!'0.%& 1!&&1,".!&<##'$!'$#99#0 .# -,%#+!'$# ".# 1#"%"%'#, %& ".!" .# .!& '" !&A#0 ,#'#@!9 .%&1!&&1,"<#$!;&#%".!&8#""#B1%,#'= ),!".#,.!0 !119%#0"".#1!&&1,"!;".,%"8'".#1,#"#B" <"!%'%'-!$>1;"#,%?#0 1!&&1,"<;"@.%9#%&&;%'-".#$>1;"#,%?#01!&&1,"7,#&1'0#'" .!& !-!%'-"0'#".#19%$#+#,% %$!"%'@.%$.@!&".#,@%&#'",#C;%,#0"%& !9&&;<>%""#0".!"".#,#!&'-%+#' ,'"%&&;%'-".#1!&&1,"%&".!".# @!& %'+9+#0 %' ! $!&# ,#-%&"#,#0 +%0# * 0!"#0 = ;'0#,

#$"%'&

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

"#,".#!$C;%""!9 ".# 1#"%"%'#,7 ".# 1,#&;>1"%' %''$#'$# %' .%& !+;, %& @,%" 9!,-# ' &;11," .%& &;<>%&&%'7 .# .!& ,#9%#0 ;1' ! 0#$%&%' ".%& ;," ,#'0#,#0%'".#$!&# G !9+%'0#,1!9%'-. !9+%'0#,1!9%'-. !9+%'0#,1!9%'-. !9+%'0#,1!9%'-./&'%' '0%!!'0".#,&H '%' '0%!!'0".#,&H '%' '0%!!'0".#,&H '%' '0%!!'0".#,&H

=E F E%+%9F *= !'0 G !9@%'0#, %'-. !9@%'0#, %'-. !9@%'0#, %'-. !9@%'0#, %'-. /& '%' '0%! !'0 '%' '0%! !'0 '%' '0%! !'0 '%' '0%! !'0 ".#,&H ".#,&H ".#,&H ".#,&H

EF4 =7G !"%'0#,%'-.I 0.! !"%'0#,%'-.I 0.! !"%'0#,%'-.I 0.! !"%'0#,%'-.I 0.!/&'%' '0%!!'0 '%' '0%!!'0 '%' '0%!!'0 '%' '0%!!'0 !'".#,H !'".#,H !'".#,H !'".#,H E=F 4 !'0 G2!9A%8!" %'-. G2!9A%8!" %'-. G2!9A%8!" %'-. G2!9A%8!" %'-. /& "!"# "!"# "!"# "!"# !,8!'!H !,8!'!H !,8!'!H !,8!'!H

*EF4!@#,!90 ).#&;>!'0&;<&"!'$# .%&!,-;>#'"%&".!" '$#.#.!&<##'!$C;%""#07%"$!''"<#1,#&;>#0".!"!$,%>%'!9$!&#%& 1#'0%'-!-!%'&".%>#+#'% ".#!11#!9.!+%'-<##' %9#0!

"#,!9'-0#9!8 <8".#"!"#!'0".#>19!%'!'"!-!%'&".%&!$C;%""!9%&1#'0%'- ' ".# ".#, .!'07 9#!,'#0 $;'&#9 , ".# ,#&1'0#'"& .!& &;<>%""#0 ".!" ".# 1#"%"%'#, @!& %&&;#0 ! 1!&&1," * ' *=)))@.%$.@!&+!9%0;1"= )%# ,!1#,%0 8#!,&<;" ' = .#@!&%'+9+#0%'!$,%>%'!9$!&#.!+%'-<##',#-%&"#,#0+%0#

* %' ,#-!,0 " ".# >;,0#, '# 5!,'!%9 %'-. " %& ;,".#, &;<>%""#0".!"#+#'% ".#1#"%"%'#,.!&<##'!$C;%""#0%'".#&!%0$!&#8#" 1!&&1,"$!''"<#%&&;#0<#$!;&# ".#<!,1,+%0#0%'#$"%'E FE F ".#!&&1,"&$"7)J ,&.,"K".#$"3L%'@.%$.%"%&1,+%0#0".!"".# 1!&&1," !;".,%"8 $!' ,# ;&# " %&&;# ".# 1!&&1," @.#,# 1,$##0%'-& %' ,#&1#$" !'

#'$#!99#-#0".!+#<##'$>>%""#0<8".#!119%$!'"!,# 1#'0%'-<# ,#".#$,%>%'!9;,"%''0%! .!+# .#!,0 9#!,'#0 $;'&#9 , ".# 1!,"%#& !'0 1#,;&#0 ".# ,#$,0 " %& !' !0>%""#0 !$" ".!" ".# 1#"%"%'#, .!& '" !119%#0 ,#'#@!9 .%& 1!&&1," .# 1!&&1," @!& +!9%0 ;1" = ) !'0 ".# !119%$!"%' @!& %9#0 <8 ".# 1#"%"%'#, ' <#$!;&# .# !99#-#098 $!>#"A'@".!"".#.!'0@,%""#'1!&&1,"&@#,#<#%'-1.!"@.%$. @#,#!9&$!99#0''>!$.%'#,#!0!<9#1!&&1,"!'0".#>!$.%'#,#!0!<9# 1!&&1,"&!,#<#%'-%&&;#0.#1#"%"%'#,.!0".;&!119%#0 ,".#$.!'-# .%& ''>!$.%'# ,#!0!<9# 1!&&1," " >!$.%'# ,#!0!<9# 1!&&1," <;" ".# ,#&1'0#'"&.!+#,# ;&#0"%&&;#".#1!&&1,"'98'".#-,;'0".!"".# 1#"%"%'#,@!&!99#-#098%'+9+#0%'!>;,0#,$!&#%'@.%$..#.!&".;-. <##' !$C;%""#0 <;" ".# !11#!9& !-!%'&" .%& !$C;%""!9 !,# 1#'0%'- .# <6#$"%' ".#,#&1'0#'"&%&'"&;&"!%'!<9#<#$!;&#".#1,#&;>1"%' %''$#'$# ".#1#"%"%'#,%&@,%"9!,-#!

"#,.!+%'-<##'!$C;%""#0%'".# &!%0$,%>%'!9$!&#!'0%'".%&,#-!,0,#9%!'$#$!'<#19!$#0;1'!0#$%&%' ".%&;,",#'0#,#0%'".#$!&# 2!9A%8!"%'-.E;1,!F 2!9A%8!"%'-.E;1,!F 2!9A%8!"%'-.E;1,!F 2!9A%8!"%'-.E;1,!F%'@.%$.%".!& <##' .#90 ".!" ;'"%9 !'0 ;'9#&& !$C;%""!9 %& $'+#,"#0 %'" $'+%$"%'7 .# @;90<#0##>#0"<#%''$#'"!'0'".%&-,;'0".#1!&&1,"$!''"<# 0#$9%'#0%>%9!,%&".#%&&;#%'".#$!&#& !9+%'0#,1!9%'-.E;1,!F

!9+%'0#,1!9%'-.E;1,!F

!9+%'0#,1!9%'-.E;1,!F!'0

!9@%'0#,%'-.E;1,!F

!9@%'0#,%'-.E;1,!F<;"%'".#$!&# !"%'0#,%'-.E 0.!F;1,!

!"%'0#,%'-.E 0.!F;1,!

!"%'0#,%'-.E 0.!F;1,!7777%"

= .!&<##' .#90 ".!"".# 1#"%"%'#, >!8 &##A 1#,>%&&%' ,> ".# ;," ",!+#9%'-!<,!0<;"".#1!&&1,"$!''"<#0#'%#0 .;&7A##1%'-%'+%#@".#!

,#&!%0 !$"&!'0$%,$;>&"!'$#7 !> ".# $'&%0#,#0 1%'%' ".!" ".#,# %& !' #,,, ' ".# 1!," ".# ,#&1'0#'"& %' '" %&&;%'- ".# 1!&&1," " ".# 1#"%"%'#, !'0 .#'$#7 ".# #'0,&#>#'" 0!"#0 ' ".# !$A'@9#0-#>#'" 9#""#, 0!"#0

%&.#,#<8&#"!&%0#!'0!0%,#$"%'%&%&&;#0",#&1'0#'" " %&&;# >!$.%'# ,#!0!<9# 1!&&1," " ".# 1#"%"%'#, @.%$. %& +!9%0 ;1" = )@%".%'!1#,%0 0!8& ,>".#0!"# ,#$#%1" $#,"% %#0 $18 ".%&,0#,.#1#"%"%'#,@;90<##'"%"9#0"",!+#9!<,!0! "#, <"!%'%'-1#,>%&&%' ,>".#;,"@.#,#".#!11#!9&!-!%'&".%&!$C;%""!9 !,#1#'0%'- E552 F E552 F E552 F E552 F ) * * * * .#".#,&1#!A%'-D,#!&'#0 ( #&D .#".#,#1,"!<9# ( #&D