← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5964/2013allowed

Daya Pal Singh & ORS v. Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited & ANR

2016-02-16Mr. Justice Arun Monga6 pages

   



 !"#$%$ &' ( (



             

  )'

*+)(,)-+  

  

  

"#$$

 

  %& ''''

% (    ! $ ) 

 + , - $!   + . (  

 

$  + )-+ .(/+0 -        

    

/%/0,/%.) $ $* !   .1  %2234  ! 5 %223 56 !        467    ) 

%3/.,//2 $ 

      !  $ 4 8&36  

  !

    )

          -   9$*  #   &   

     -                           $

      $!

   :     ) *  $ ) $       )    $* ) ! )    ! .1 %223 !

     

"#$$    ! 

    %&  $               !

  )          *

 !       $  *        

$)  

 $*  $   - )

 $    

       !   $     7 )      

)  )   !9 $,/%/- 

    

 $* )!

 .1 %223   $  :   !     

   #   #  ../. !,/%0   

     

 ,;/;,/%0  ) $   #        *

   !  < 5$    #   !  :

      

  

    !"#$%  &'(&)*+$)$ , +(-.   ) $  #     #    *         

  *   

 :                 !

       

 $

7  )      !   

!

      :)  

 8  ) 

  &  

  

     

  



  

  !  

 

  "    "    #$   %&'

()   *  ++ , # "

 - # 

,*  . /  #          *   0))0))0 "

 -**     

    

* " "        

 

  1     !

%  1    

   %)/)))   "

** *       

*2    3   4  

 

  "     5! *1 5      

  *  

+6 1  "



%)/)))

! * " "  0))0))0/  *  

   "  " 1*    !     " *  )%)%))7 *   -   

1

     

*2   * "    -

 *     8+)9  *

   

 1       1*    :     "   *   "

  "      

)  9    

     

 "    *      1*   

 * "  

"     " * * "   8+)    9                * "    * " "-  "  "-    "

  



**    ! 

% 

           # "               "

     

     ) *      =&& =              )!

  ! -  )

  

   #%;               !    

$ -

          $      $     !         $   !         

      !

    -    )    & ;4   "     * *    "       

 



 

 *        "           

      " 

  ;   <  "   

  = >  #    $  0))0)0/

  ,  

*   >       >     

         #?,   /

   @A4#     1   "-             /    >  > "  , ?    * 

 A         *

         * * /1  * *   , ?  9 



B*

  "  "   #$ %&'

%()/ * ++ ,/@

/ # :*     8)  9 

 * 1      0). ))C/    

 ! 

      /

 

1*   55D#1



"    * C/ # * *  

 

** *  *   5 $

* E* ))'

  1*   "  %).  :  *  * "    *  *     * 1         "     #$   %&'

%()/   *   ++ ,/   @

/ #  

   1*       "

    ,           

  !   

 *

   4 / " 

 8  )  9 

* 1           0) .  ))C  

    

1*  

"  *        " *   

1  "*  

@A4#    < -    $

   #     46

  !      

  

 !!  !

   - !       7         ,.%/,/%/  $  !

 

)         >   ) !

  ! 

  /%/0,/%.    $  )  %3/.,//2  =&& =      ( !

 $    )

( (

 

 /)-+0