High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5966/2013disposed of

Ram Phal v. Vikas & ORS

2019-05-20Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh6 pages

!#$$ "%& '()

!#** "+& '()

(

,-( . . /(-

#$ % !"

( !"

# ) ****

/(-0 & 12) + $ #,-..#/012 ,-33# /014 ! #

130,/012

() "" 5 +( (

$()" ( ""# () !" "" "1,10/011

,-..#/012 (# ()

$### !"

) "6( 7 62-6 8./3$ (# ()"

" #"

!#$$ "% 5# $ # (# # 9 " )# () )" "" ()

!### !"$ () :" ) ;

! (# < "" #

$ ) () :" ) ;

) 1-83 (= $ # ():" ) 7

$(9 $ )

!### !"

"" ! "" ! " )!#"

# :" ) 7 # ""( <#

((

!( " " # "") # )"

() )" ()$ # #"

# " # () " " # "

) ($ 5 ) " )

# $

! ""

!# ""# :" ) ;

<# $ # # ""$ " #" " +( ) 9 " " ) # () ) " !$ # !#%"14-/ # "" 1-33> "> < ! "# (

" " )

! " ) $ ##

?/@()$ )#9

"#!

9 "# /

2# ##

#$ + < !

#7 % #

; +

;"7 ! ) (! !"

#B) /011< ! ! ""#

$ () +##"7 7$ !

"" ! !"< !!# "" # +##" 7 #

$ ( ! !" +

$ $ ("

" ()"$$ ) !

(! !"

# !

"" <"9

()"# )

! "" $ ) () :"

) ;

7 ) !#) # "

"6 "# ""# ;

C 5# ) # " )

(

!#)""# ) ()$"

$ $ ?

#7>(% 5 34

1 31131 5 2 41 - 0 "%&+)

&62) 7%0 ##" # ) # ( " " # "") )"

() ()$ )# #"

# # # #+( ) ! ( )" ) (! # () )"

# ##" ! $ ###

!"$ () ! ) ( )" "

<!$#$ ( " (# ) #

!#** "+ ++( . ,, .40@6

( # 9

2 .. 000@6 :##" ""# () / /4 .40@6 ; () #

.0 000@6 ## "

,000@6

5 # @"

$ () +( !

9" ( # 9 )

= " <

(1-) ##

()9#41D(+( # " )# 1/ 430@6()" " # !" ,200@6 5 ) " )

()+( ;+ % ?/$ 9

% " )7 7 # 1,10/0110.11/011

# 1308/01///08/01/ " # # (1

& !$ # " $ # ()!" # "# # $!

" )$# (

# ,0 000@6# ## 7

10 000@6#" !"#

+ +( 2 .. 000@6 $ 9 ( (

## ;+ $ 9

! ()## () !" () "#"

E934 7 2110/01/ 96 ) $$ $ 30D#

! # ($" ## # + ()$ 9 # 41D + +( " # !"

,200@6 ( # $

# $

()+( # ##" # / /4 .40@6" <!$#

9# ()## ()!"

(1-) "

$ # ( ()

#" ()9#41D ( " # ##" "" ) # #" = () 4 .- 2.3@6,20091/9139 41D + +( # .0 000@6 $

() #

## + "

( # ,000@6#9 7 1 ##

" + " 10 .0 2.3@6

4 04 8/3@610 .0 2.36. ,, .40 ($F 8,D #

# A (! #9 # #) + ) #

/(-

? (