High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2617/2010dismissed

Punjab Wakf Board v. Harvallabh Parkash

2016-11-28Mr. Justice Arun Monga10 pages

!

"# $!%&'&"( ) *++

!

"

#

)

, - + .- $ % &'

"()

% ' ')

* +, -----

.-/

+

01 .

/''

""

'

''"

0 ( '

* ++

'"

1'' / '"2'

% ' 03

( 3'' % &'

"() '"

/''

3' '

( '"'

/ '

03 '"4 +,3

3 '"

* ,54) ''"."' ) )3 ' 3( ' % '3

'.

'

0 ( ' ' 2 3 26 * ' '

747++48+ (

0 )

)

'"

'"0 ')('

3'

' ( ' ( ( ''"

'"

0

0) / ' ''

"

1''1 ''(

4

'0

#. )+49: '

;+49: ;!

3' "3 0

('

"' "3 0 ; 31 '

2(30 -1 ($ (" 2!0 4+ 5' 2(

"0$ "# 6'1&7 .8# ($ " 2!0'

9 &4&1 :* /( ' < 31

= ''(

>)8?9

)+449( '3 ' )( 1''1 3

( ( ' @

''A B

3' 31 (

0' '"

>8

'

)

1''1 (

B '( (' .

') ( ' 3

' '" ' '

)(' 1''1 B

'

( '

1 ''"

' +4 ( ,:

"3 ' (

$/ @+4 B(

'

"3( ""'

'

='

(' B '

' 3 '' $ @++

(

'

(

'' ' ' '

'"' '

3! (

0 C )(30 ' 0 '

( ''"('

=

+,.

(/ ' '

'' 0 '

'' C

'3(

C

0

'3'0

.

'' 0 '

'' '

C ' 0 ( C

'

)C '

"

'

'0 '' 0 C '

'0'

0 .

( '

'

(

'

''

0

'' <

'

+:'

''0

0 .

' ('

( .

' (

"

'

( '' (

30 "

' ' '

3 B ( ' "')C

''

< (

' '0'

B .1 % '

()

/ &"

1 @.

'

3'

'' D

'' < '

'0'

'" 3 '

3 ' (

'' '

"

) '' C '

'

33

' 0 (

0

'0

' ('

,:.

''

'

)

( ''

3

( )'"' ' '

)

) C

' '3 (

3 3' '

' 3 ( 3 '" 3

3

'

'3' ' '"

(' ' C '

.

'(

'

'' '( 32 '"0 '

3

2 '3

!) '

'

' 0 '' ( ) ' ''"

3

''

(' ' 3'

.

'B

'

'

'

'0 ''

''

0 '

>

8

( 00 '

.

'

' '

%

) '

)(

"'0 '' ) =

( '

'

.

'

'C ' 03'C(' 3 '

0 "

''

B

'

) ' '( ' 3

3'

)"

'"0 ' ' (' E )''

'' ( ' ( '(' ' '

'' ( 3 ' 3A #

' F

"3

1 ' 2&4 20( 4+ &((%&1 "77&''&"(!0/ 0;( ($ " 2!0'

9 9 &4&1 :9/( '

88 :!

!

. 0 )+??8 3 '( (

' 9 ?

) 1''1 ( 1 )

) ''"

0

( 1''1 0 ''

0

''0) '

' 0 '

' )% ' ') '"

* +, 3'

'

,'"(' '''

( '0

#. )+49: )

' ( 3

' ' # )+??8

' ; ;;

; '

4

' '"

( ' 0 " 0

3 ( 3

'

"

'

0

( 1

' 1 ' '

D 5+::

1''

(

"

'"2'

% '''(

''" 0 ( ( 0 0 ''"0

'

' .

''"

(

* ++ 0 '

'

1 '

#

/ " C'

0

) 3

' 0 "

'

'' +49: 1''1 ( B

'

' '

'7 -1 4+

0'2( -1 ($ " 2!0'

/ * &4&1 9+ B

'

( ' 3''030 33 ) < 31 '

( #;

! '

>)8?9

)"3

0 '

.

'3

)(

4

+49: '" !)( (' / ' ( $/ <=

-&>&1& ;

"# !(( "

>!

0!5!% !$

+!* ('

'"

0 '" ''0 (

'3'"'

(

3 C (

/

'!'

3 (

''! ' 0 " 0('

' ' G

'''!'

'

33 3

G

'! ')

' )('

' ' ) ' 3 ' 0' 3

C 3 0' '0'( '

I 'G

! ) 3 ' 0'3 ( )

' '

' G

H 0

I

' ( 0

0 )

' 0

3 G

'! 0

I

' (

0

0 )

' 0

3 G

''! C J'0

) '

')'

0 '"

0

1

' '

3 '3

0 / ( //F

'''!

3 '

33 3

) 0'

03

30 (' '

( 3

3

'

C '

)'

'" '3 0

H

,!* ('

'"0 '" ' '

'

30 (

'0 '0( 'C

3'

' $

'

0

3(

3' '

0'

0 ( '

' C

3( 0 '

( $

' '

(

3

( 3)

C '

'( ' '

3

' ' 0 (

'

'3 ' '

'

'0

3

33 '0

3 3 ( //

'0(' 0

' ' 0

'

' 3'" 0 '3A B

3'

( '

0 ; 3 1 ( '

' '

( 3''''0

'(' ' '

)

.

'

('

B

< 31

3 ''

'

'

>8( '0 1''1 .

'30 ''

''" 0 ; 31

0 '

3

' '(

'

4''.

'

'

40

'"

"3

1

'" 3

)

1''1 (

'

' "

' '

'"

'

4B'

'" '

)

0 '

' '

'

3)

)

( "

'"

(' '"

=

1''1 '

'' ' '1 ;

! 3'

0' (' '3 '" '

'

9?

. 0 )+??80' '"

88 :!

!

( $/ 881 ' "'60 3/ +!

,!

:!.

('" '

' '') 3'01 1

"'6

0'

3 (' 0

'3'"

' '$

( 3 '

'1''1 G

' /

+!( ' ' "'60' ''1''1 ' 3

0 '03

/ '

3' 001 ) 1''1

'

3

'

'

='

0D BB)

+7) 1''

1 '

'

I

,! ''"

3' '(

C +)777

3 ' '

3'

' '

88 :!F'

2

. 0 )+??8)' 30 '

"

'

H

FB.2D

!

!

! ! ' 0 '

'3 '"

0

0

'"

I (' !

( (' ' 0

B )'(

< ''0 ' ''0

/ '

:

88

'"

'")% &'

"()

"3 0 < 31 '0$0 ?2( ($ " 2!0'

4+ ;!$ 5761 ''( ! 2 ($ " 2!0'

&4&1 9= ('"

3"'

0

'"

'''

3'

)'

)( '(

0 ( B

3' '

( '' 0 +444)

) 1''1

)

3

) 0 '

B3 '"

3('

3'

3'

( '

' '

'

3

)' '

( K'

K2'

% ' 03

0'

3C5K4 C5K+7 D

) '

( ''" " '( "0 '

(0 B 30 ''

) "3

% &'

"( '

0'"( (

)'

0 3'

'

0 B'(

'

3 ' )B3

'( ''"

' 0 (

'" 1''1 ' 3'

0" ' .

3

''(

4

+49: 0 '

'

3'

.-

"4!7>!0 */

' '"K

L K*

L K*