High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/339/2018disposed of

Dharamvir v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2023-07-24Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil10 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()*+,+

) -./ + 0 /0 // . ****

!"#

!

$%

& %

' () 0($!!1 "2$3&45 + *+,

$

%

& - ." /" "

((0 /

"

1 % " % " 2" -

+3 +( (4+5 * 7(4, %

(5 (4+8 * 7++, % % % % - -

-

-

9

. -

- -

2"

% % / -

:"

&

-

2"

" - 6 / -

</ ; %

(( +4 +33= %

(5 (4+8* 7++, *(,

>

- % %& - < %

?

> % " "

%

- 2 - +4 +33= $

;

- "

</

+33= %

</

(( +4 +33= ; 8444@7 % %

2"

%

?- % ( "

. - -% "

%

9

- -

$

";

"

-

(4 +4 (444 / ?-

* ,

4A (44+

% &

6 43 (44+%

2" % %

-

% % ' )0

- -

43 (44+ % % & -

- -

-

(8 4= (44A 2" - $ & -

-

%

9 (8 4= (44A (( +4 +33= $

*),

< "

";

2"

"

; "

- ?-

@:"

2"

% -

2" %";

; ."

" -% -

-

% ;"-

-

4( ++ (4+5 ;"

9 </

"

1 " ";

- 3 -

%

-

+3 +( (4+5* (4, %

(5 (4+8 * ++, 9 -

. - ; % % %

" " "

; '<

(0 (4+0 -

"

+3 +( (4+5

- ;

*8,

1 " ";

-

% % ;

%

. - -

;

"." % " % % "-

+3 +( (4+5* (4, ;

" % %

% % 1 %

"

% %

% - -

- " -

*A,

< "

6

"

"- * (, %"

%"

2"

/ % ;

;

%

& % "

"

"

" "- ;

% "

-

" ."

*0,

'

% "

++ 4+ (4+= ""

' ()

%

+0 4+ (4+3

- 4 - *5,

& %

' () ";

+3 +( (4+5 * (4, % % - 9

. - ; " -

67- ;

%

?> (+ +334 ;

% " ;

2" % + ( %

- ;

@

</%

) "

;

)4@(A C

?- @

% 2" ;

2" ;

@ " ";

C

$

;

-

() 344) 4A 34 % ; " ;

% ) %

< / ; @

2"

;

% % "

. - - % @ " %

;

@ %

9

-

* 7+, *=,

< "

' () "

/ " *1,

4= 4A +33A "

D ;

2" / 7111

6 "

"

6 2" ;

/ 71

6 2" - "

- 5 - "

D%

% "

) %

</ ; (( +4 +33=* 7), %

%

9

-

%

;

*3,

";

. - >@/

(4 +4 (444

%&

43 (44+;"

;

$

- ";

"

(8 4= (44A2"

- ' (=A@/?@

4A (44A % 9 %

(8 4= (44A

-

*+4,

< "

-"

$ /

! ?

"

(44)% % ;

" % -

1

(4+8 ' 85A@/?@

(5 (4+8 ' )88@/?@

4= (4+A

% 9

. - ;

-

&

"

?2" %

"

2" %";

2" * 7+5,; -

2" ;

;

/7 /

- 6 -

@ % E

" - % ;

C

$

!/< )5

-

4( ++ (4+5 -

% C

$

"

'< "

"

' / A(@?/ 7(A43

(0 (4+0

&

"

9 </@

" - " "- ;

*++,

;

";

;

' ()

;

. B" !" >- -B B"

B"2" 6

4( (444+4 4+ (44)+3 (448+3 (448

$ "

+3 +4 +334 () +33(

; %

E/*, *,

% -

E/ *,

*,

++ 4A (445(5 (4+4

*+(,

<

2"

- - - "

"

% % %

-

(5 (4+8 %

% F"

*+),

"

- "-

- 7 - *+8,

/

& " (5 (4+8 9

. - %" "

-

4= 4A +33A% % ; > 4( 4= +33A * 7+, -

(5 (4+8 * ++,

%%

%

(( +4 +33=</* % % "

; , "

7/ -

+ /

%

4+ ++ (44=

+4 -

. - </ (( +4 +33= $ % "

% - </

%%

>- -

B" B B" . B" ?

% ; -% 0 "

"

" 4= (4+A* +0, "" ; 7 ." %

"

48 4= (4+A

% & ;

-" 2" - - % 9 </ 2"

- "-

- % -

;"

2" % -

*+A,

$

-" % - ; /

! ?

"

(44) "

- 8 - 3*, % %

@ ;

" 2"

G " "

" ;

"

- -

%

@

;

; % ;

%

I

; " - -

% "

! @ "

"

"

;

;

"- ;

-

- ;

1 %

- - "

;

- - / ;

%

; % ;

< - " ;"

%

"

"

"

"

)43 /

"

"

"

)43 /

"

$"

$ /

! ?

"

(44)"

" %

"

"

;

"

"

"

- - @ %

;

% ."- " /"

*+0,

:" - "- * (4, 2" * +5, % "

- 9 - -%

;

- "- " - " 2" < "

7' - "

" - %

;

- "- " - 2"

- *+5,

1 %

;

"

"

" ."

$ 2" & -

" & $

% %

- " " ;

% ." ;

" - 2"

"

;

% "

" ."

% ;

"

" ."

"

;

% " $ /"

J % ;

"

% - " -

;

7 % - - "

% ."

"

- ;" 2"

/"

% "

" ."

"-

$

%

"

"-

2"

- 10 - - -"

; ;

2"

(44+ *+=,

-- "- "

"; "

7"; ;

"

&

- %

- "

;

6/" /" %

" ."

"- * (4,

"

3*, (44)"

"

" ."

- "

+3 +( (4+5* +5,

$

% % %

" ."

; -

" -

*+3,

;

(8 (4() 0($!!1 "2$3&4

2$3!

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No