← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3736/2015dismissed

Shri Ram General Insurance Company Ltd v. Rambati And ORS

2019-09-03Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan6 pages

  

    





#$% &'()* ***%%

+  !

,( )$( ***



,( ***%%

+  !

-  )$( ***



 !"#  $

 %&$  ''$ .

(/ *.!

(0 1)2$"(

3$(

( 

3$

(4$*  

*!(!%(1)2$"(

3$(

(  

3$



 '$( $ !))*#  !"#)

 +" , !"#) 6   "($ !

 "($ '(($ "( 3$"$ )$ $3)

&$3)&  3 )* $(  $ 

($

"($  (

))

&$3)&  3  ( ) "$ )$

)*



- !"#). /$0/

 +" , !"#). /$0 -&( $) 1 

) %$ $3(9$ * * 

3

)$ 3$3%%

(:

#$% '()* ) 

3

)$ 3$3%%

(:,(19" 2 

$!($3( "")

(* - & (( )13"( $3( "  (($ ""$!

($3) ($3 ;  7 $($2 "!

"")

(19"($$<% "

* *  (,$!(/ %**  $3 

$ )&"$$

7 #$9<1. 9 1 (( &$ ""$!

($3 

7

()2 7$3(!"< , 7   7 (($  4$*8    3(    )  ($    (

$33

72

,&

:- 1 $( (*,( ),$!7("

% (($ !

 "($ $3( $($+

"( 7 (

( * *- :$9

))2 1=(:$9



#$% & '()*:  !  $3 ( $33

1"

 7"$%

(!

" * $("

1  

 (  (

 

(  )  %% )   )( % (($ * !

 ( 9 3 )*.( 9

 33$) )) >!( $%%$(!

( ($

) 2)

"$ ! $ $3( $($"")

( #  6,!

. 9 3(  )($ ( 9

$9 7( % (($

%( &2) 9))(

* 19) )"$%

< $ 79( (?@%

!3$( )( $33 % (($

(

"(! A($ (%&,

,&(

( =$

&*

(B% (($

B"

((*,(,

2 9  ((  (  "$%

 9) )  ($     9  $  ) 1   %%$" )( #$!(,&9&$33 7

< 7

($3 "$%

* $(  )1

(4$*:

$!

($3"$%

9) ) $ 7  )  $3

4$("

9  !

)($(

( 19$ %!(  ($!7"$!

2  )

)"$!

%( ) 7$ ($!7( "$)* &  $3( 2)

))!"

( %("!

&) %$ ($ $3 9(

.C.!  7  (!

3 7((;  7)) ))!

($ =!  ! (

$($ "!

"")

(19"($$<% "

)!

($ 

7

()2 7$3  $33

7  2

 ,&  

(  4$* *  C

 "$ 7  ($  ( ! $  (<

($2 93$ DE*. )(

3"(((

) $(%% 9(

,$E($ ,!((

 ( )(<

,&( ( *!"3 7 "$) ),&( =! (3 $ 3

9( "

)3$* 4$9"$ 7($( >! (!$3"$%

9

) 79((( % "( (<

7 $3) )($,  & ) $ & "$   * 1 B* 3 ( 7 $3)

)1((9 "$ "( &(<

,!( $($ "$ ) (<

    * 1 B    $  (   ) *  '

 3$  (

%%

(B"

(  )($ !97 %&,

,$! (( $38& 9* *3*0 !& 1  $9 9  *1 B% $ ((

2 (( 2  $ (9 (() )9 9$< 7  ,$!  7 *1 B% $ (  9  $

 , )  9

  $3  (  3 &*  6 1    2 9  $3  (

 !  97  % 2

(  (  (  

2 (  ( 1  (   "$  $3  (

) 

)  *1 B*  6,!

   $(  )   &  ))($  ($9)  3!(!

%$ % "( * 2 9$3( ($$3!($(& 

  

 



 !"## $"

%9

) )9 

3 % $& )$$ 3E )  &1 ))($ $3 @ $3( (,   "$  $!

) ($9) 3!(! %$ % "( 9

) )9 ,

$9( 7 $3 &  *F$ $ "$ ) ) (<

  * G H *1B*

(  $3( ($$3!($(&    

 

 &  '

          (  

% )"

## $"9

) )9 ,"

$1) )!"($ ($9) 

3

E%

 ($, (<

  B*F$ )

"&$3"

  "$ $!(($ * B% $ (1

! )

"&"$ $!(($  * E H *

1*  !

)!

(% $3 19"<

% 7

2 9( 7 ) ) ,

%$% &!

)*F$

"$%

%&,

"$ $!(($ *

E H11B*

 2 9  $3  (  ($  $3  !($(&   

  

 

!%1( (

((

)($7 ("$%

!

"$

($  ) * * *

1 B$

""$!

(  $3  $  $3  ((   )   *

1 B    3!

E%

1  ($(

 * 1 B*6 ($( "$%

"$ $!(($ *11G 1 H 1 1B*  9) )"$%

1 1 B*  

)($ *1 1B*6 (9$!

((

)($ ( (?* @%

!$

)$!

($3"$%

$3 *1 1  1 1 1 3$( )( $33

(

"(! A($ $( (   )"$ )($ 72

!

 

&($(

)$!

( 9

C( !"$)3"($  

3

)$ $3( ( 

)%( &9("$ ( * 6$!7 

 %% 7  3$  (  %%

(  :

& "$

)((( 2

>!

($ 9  $( 2 72 )$!( % ( )(   )"$ )($

"&9 2$ ( )1( &, ( , $ $3(  , (&$ "$2 & 7( , 7 ) ($ (*8$9 1

"$!

( 2

&"$ ) !""$

($  ((

 ((( &) $(

& 2)

(( 7)3$ ((  $  !

 (!"< (( "(9 ) ") )7 ((

"$% &* 3(  7

)"$!

%( 13 )(((

!, $  $  )  ,&

 3$ (    "$% "

$(, ""

%( )*% !  "$)7$ ($ $9((($!7

9((

 ((

(

(: &)(<

!%%

((

)2 9  $($ 72 ) "(2

)2 7 "

 (  (  (  $3 "")

(   )  (    )  "$ )($  $3 %$ "&9 2$ ( ),!((3

)($))!"

& 2)

(( 7)*(=! ((

%$ "& )"

$ )(  2)

6,!

&  $3( 2)

))!"

( "$

! $ ((( )2 9 2 72 ) "(2 )2 7 "

(( ( $3"")

( )

( 4$* )2 $(2$ (    )  "$ )($  $3  (    %$ "&   )  3!(   

"$% &  ,

($ 3&( $9

 ""$) 9((  $3(

%$ "&*)$ $(

&  $ ($)33 9( !"3 "$) ),&( * #$

>!

&1  

 3

)  $  , 3  $3  (

& ( ) )  )* **  .'$0 -=   1223345678

5 12233639: 5