High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3748/2015allowed

Bharti Axa General Insurance Co. Ltd v. Amar Singh And ORS

2019-05-02Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan10 pages

!"#$ "%&'&#()

+ ,!&-"(", .('/, (%"#0!12+ (1&3 ,+ 44".. (!

5",'/'

6 ,7&(3+ (1#!+",'

"'4#(1"(!'

,"'"(!

, 89&,7&(3+215#% !"$#,!+" 44".. (! ,:/( . ; ,215#% !"$#,,"'4#(1"(!' <<<<

+" ; ,11 !"1 *

24 ''"19=#!#,%%&1"(!. &6'

,&9/( .2 ,&1 9 1$#,'+#,!>!+",&9/( .>+ '9""( '' &."19=!+"&('/,", #$!,#.. 9" ,&(3,"3&'!, !&#(#?@*?**$#,'+#,!>#$$"(1&(35"+&%." 9"&(3 33,&"5"1 3 &('! !+" A/ (!/6 #$ %#64"(' !&#( ; ,1"1 /(1", 7"%!&#( @@#$!+"#!#,B"+&%."'%!2 *

$#,'+#,!>!+"%!>29=!+"

,&9/( . +"9,&"$$ %!'("%"'' ,=$#, 18/1&% !&#(#$!+"4,"'"(! 44" . ,"!+ !#( @ *

2C '+:/6 ,2 3"1 =" ,'; '%#6&(3$,#6 /,3 #(!# ,&1 9 1#( 6#!#,%=%."9" ,&(3,"3&'!, !&#(#? :?

(+&'; =2!+"#$$"(1&(35"+&%.", 66"1&(!#+&'6#!#,%=%." (1 C '+ :/6 , '/'! &("1 3,&"5#/' &(8/,&"'2 ;+&%+ 4,#5"1 $ ! . " ; ' '+&$!"1!#'& (#'4&! .2 ,&1 9 12;+","+"; '1"%. ,"19,#/3+!1" 1 # 1 !"1 *

; ',"3&'!","1 3 &('!,"'4#(1"(!(# /(1",

7"%!&#(' *2 ? (1 !#.&%"7! !&#(7/, 8C/(1 %. &64"!&!&#(/(1",7"%!&#( @@#$!+"%!; '$&."19=!+"

4 ,"(!' (1/(6 ,,&"1'&'!",#$!+"1"%" '"1(!+"%. &64"!&!&#(2&!; ' 4." 1"1!+ !1"%" '"1; ';#,C&(3 ' 7 ."'D"%/!&5"&(E' 07 ."'

(17",5&%"'0!12+&'' . ,=; '%. &6"1 '

E?9/! '4",!+"' . ,= %",!&$&% !""D+&9&!"1+"; '3"!!&(3' . ,=#$

E? (1&(!+"6#(!+#$ 7"4!"69",

2 +" ,"%"&5"1 ( 6#/(! #$ 2

E?2 ;+&%+ &(%./1"1

E?$#,' ."&(%"(!&5" +",&9/( . $!",%#('&1",&(3!+"$ %!' (1 44,"%& !&(3!+" "5&1"(%" 11/%"1+".1!+ !!+" %%&1"(!; ',"'/.!#$, '+ (1("3.&3"(! 1,&5&(3#$!+"#$$"(1&(35"+&%."+"&('/,",#$!+"#$$"(1&(35"+&%."; ' +".1 .& 9." !# 4 = %#64"(' !&#( +" ,&9/( . ''"''"1 !+" 6#(!+.= " ,(&(3'#$1"%" '"1 ' 2

E?F G$/!/,"4,#'4"%!';"," ; ,1"1F E,1 1"1/%!&#($#,'".$"D4"('"'; '6 1"F !#! .'/6#$ *2

E?; '

; ,1"1&(%./1&(3

E?$#,.#''#$.#5" (1 $$"%!&#( (1

$#, $/(", . "D4"('"' +" ,&9/( . #,1","1 !+ ! !+" %. &6 (!' '+ .. 9" "(!&!."1!#&(!","'!H*G4", ((/6$,#6!+"1 !"#$$&.&(3#$!+"4"!&!&#(&$ !+"4 =6"(!&'6 1";&!+&('&D!=1 ='$,#6!+"1 !"#$4 ''&(3#$ ; ,1 (1 &(% '"&('/,",$ &.'!#6 C"!+"4 =6"(!;&!+&(@ 1 ='2!+"&(!","'!, !"

;#/.19"

G4", ((/6 " ,1." ,("1%#/('".$#,!+"4 ,!&"' (14",/'"1!+","."5 (! 1#%/6"(!'4,#1/%"19=!+"6 0" ,("1%#/('".$#,!+" 44".. (! ,3/"'!+ !!+",&9/( .",,"1 &( ''"''&(3!+"6#(!+.=" ,(&(3#$1"%" '"1 ' 2

E?#9/!!,"''+&'

,3/6"(!2+",".&"'/4#(!+"4 ='.&4'#$!+"1"%" '"1$#,!+"4",&#1$,#6

/.=

!#7"4!"69",

(1'! !"'!+ !!+"' . ,=#$!+"1"%" '"1; '

E? (1#(.=&(!+"6#(!+#$7"4!"69",

2 ( 6#/(!#$ 2

; '4 &1 '+"; ' ; ,1"1!+"' ."&(%"(!&5"#$

E?" .'#. ='

%+ .."(3" !# ; ,1&(3 #$ G ' $/!/,"4,#'4"%!' " ,".&"' /4#(!+" 1"4#'&!&#(#$I (C 87+ ,6 2 , (%+ ( 3",#$E' 07 ."' 7",5&%"0!1 ,&1 9 1 (1 44#&(!6"(!."!!",;+","&(&!; '6"(!&#("1!+ ! C '+:/6 ,; '9"&(3 44#&(!"1#(%#(!, %!9 '&'$#,$&D"1!"(/,"&" $,#6 @

!&'$/,!+", ,3/"1!+ !#/!#$

E?2

E?&'!#; ,1'

%#(5"= (%" ..#; (%" ;+&%+ &' ,"&69/,'"6"(! #$ !+" "D4"('"' +" 3,&"5 (%"&'!+ !!+"1"%" '"1; '/(6 ,,&"1 (12!+","$#,"2J1"1/%!&#($#, '".$"D4"('"''+#/.1+ 5"9""(6 1"&('!" 1#$ E,1"$/,!+", ,3/"'!+ !

!+" 6#/(!/(1",!+"%#(5"(!&#( .+" 19" ; ,1"12 '4",!+"1"%&'&#(#$ 7/4,"6"#/,!&(

#$ %

# "&

' % "(

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

,#6!+"4",/' .#$!+"4 ='.&4'2&!&'$#,!+%#6&(3!+ !$,#6

/.=

#(; ,1'2!+"1"%" '"1; ',"%"&5&(3' . ,=#$

E?!; '

#(.=&(7"4!"69",2

!+ !' ."&(%"(!&5"#$

E?; '4 &1!#+&6 +","&'(#!+&(3#(!+","%#,1!#'+#;!+ !' ."&(%"(!&5"; ',"%/,,&(3 (1 ; '!#9"4 &1,"3/. ,.='4",!+"4 ='.&4'2 4 ,!$,#6!+"9 '&%' . ,= 5 ,&#/' ..#; (%"'%#('!&!/!"1!+"' . ,=!&'"5&1"(!!+ ! ..!+" ..#; (%"' ;"," $&D"1 (1 ;"," 9"&(3 4 &1 "5",= 6#(!+2 #(.= !+" %#(5"= (%" ..#; (%"% ((#!9"6 1"4 ,!#$!+"' . ,= '&!; '!+","&69/,'"6"(!#$ !+""D4"('"'9"&(3'4"(!$#,%#(5"= (%"$#,!+"1/!=4/,4#'"' #, !+" ," '#(' 6"(!&#("1 9#5"2 6#(!+.= &(%#6" #$ !+" 1"%" '"1&'! C"( '

E? (1

E?,"%"&5"1$#,%#(5"= (%" ..#; (%"

&'1"1/%!"1&"%#64"(' !&#('+ ..9"% .%/. !"19=%#('&1",&(3+&'' . ,= '

E? ,#6!+"4",/' .#$!+" 44#&(!6"(!."!!",2&!&'$#,!+%#6&(3 !+ ! !+" 44#&(!6"(! ; ' $#, $&D"1 !"(/,"F !+" 1"%" '"1 % ((#! 9" %#('&1","1+ 5&(3 4",6 ("(!8#9(5&";#$!+"1"%&'&#('#$!+"7/4,"6" #/,! &( ' % "( !"

$ (1 "# .

#$ %

)*+/ ) '

0/*1 G$/!/,"4,#'4"%!' ,"

; ,1"1 'A/ (!/6#$%#64"(' !&#(&',"5&'&!"12!+" 6#/(!/(1",!+" %#(5"(!&#( .+" 1 ," ; ,1"1 '4",1"%&'&#(#$7/4,"6"#/,!&(' % "( !"

$+"%. &6 (!' ,""(!&!."1!# 2

E?" %+$#,.#''#$ "'! !" (1$/(", ."D4"('"' +"7/4,"6"#/,!&(% '"#$ "# &

(" 2"(

$ $

(" )**3 )+ + '3&5"(

! 9."$#,1"1/%!&#(!#9"6 1"#$'".$"D4"('"'(% '"#$9 %+".#,2J 1"1/%!&#(&'!#9"6 1"$#,'".$"D4"('"'!&' 3"(", .,/."9/!&!; '+".1 !+ !&(% '"';+","!+"," ,"," '#('!#1"5& !"$,#6!+"' &11"1/%!&#(2!+" #/,!'% (1#'# 7/4,"6"#/,!&( ' % "( !"

$ ;+&."

%#(%/,,&(3;&!+!+"1"%&'&#('#$7/4,"6"#/,!&( "# !"

6 # (# &

(" )*+-7 00, & "(# 6 #

(" &

(

(" )*+73 4-+ '+".1 '/(1",)?

! "#$%

( & )* +

,- )%& &'

% . / &

0& 1 .

- 2*3 4 +- 2*3/4 /5 -2*364 '

@ * 7

( & 6)8 &'

9 && 24 & : !

(

+% &

6)8

& '

6)8 0

& & - &

- - ;

' 4", 4 , 2 !+" 4",'#( . (1 .&5&(3 "D4"('"' 6 = 9"

,"'!,&%!"1&(% '"#$ 9 %+".#,!# E,1&(%",! &(% '"'(!+"4,"'"(!% '"2 !+"1"%" '"1; ''/,5&5"19=4 ,"(!' (1/(6 ,,&"1'&'!", 3"1

=" ,' ." 1&(3' (1!+""5&1"(%" 11/%"1&' 4#&(!",!#!+"$ %!!+ !!+"1"%" '"1 9".#(3"1!# '!, ! #$'#%&"!=;+","!+","9"&(3 (/(6 ,,&"1'&'!", !+#6" +"6 =(#!9"&( 4#'&!&#(!#'4"(1 G$#,+&'4",'#( ."D4"('"'('/%+ %&,%/6'! (%"'2&!;#/.1(#!9"1""6"1 44,#4,& !"!#&(!",$",";&!+!+" E,1 1"1/%!&#(6 1"$#,'".$"D4"('"'9=!+",&9/( . +"7/4,"6"#/,!&(% '"#$ "

' &

(" )**3+7 +)7+ '+".1 '/(1",)?

*/ ( *3

( 7

% !

% < =

&> 0 ? & 6*

? > ! 0& 7 & & & & *)

7 & . & ! 7 !

& @

% .

#('&1",&(3!+"$ %!'#$!+"4,"'"(!% '"2!+"%#64"(' !&#(&' % .%/. !"1 '9".#;)?

" # $ #

( ( )

* # + ! , #

-.// 0 .'$ !

. ! , #

% 1

2 '$ +" ,&9/( . ",,"1 &( ; ,1&(3 %#(1&!&#( . &(!","'! +" 7/4,"6"#/,!&(

6"(5 (& &

(" )**0) 7,*2+".1 '/(1",) * 3 11 # ) * 3 & # 52 +

# 2

# *6

! 7* 8* 2 # * #

# #

* % 2

# ! # #

6 5 %

2 *

# 3 11 # 3 & # 2 6 3 2 # ! # # #

* 2

2 !*

# # 2 :* 1

2 # * # * #

! ; ' +".1 !+ ! 1&,"%!&#( $#, ,"!,#'4"%!&5" "(+ (%"6"(! #$ &(!","'!&(% '"#$(#(4 =6"(!,"'/.!'&( ( %!&#((#!"( 9."19=%! I+&."&''/&(3(#!&%"#$6#!&#(#(

2!+"$#..#;&(3 #,1",; '4 ''"19=!+&'#/,!)?

KDDDDDDDD

<6. # 2

6 * #

"(%"2!+" ; ,11 !"1 *

&'6#1&$&"1!#!+""D!"(!

!+ ! 6#/(! #$ *2

E? ; ,1"1 9= !+" ,&9/( . &' ,"1/%"1 !#

E?+"%. &6 (!''+ ..9""(!&!."1!#!+"' &1 6#/(! .#(3;&!+ &(!","'!H*G4", ((/6$,#6!+"1 !"#$$&.&(3#$!+"%. &64"!&!&#(!&.. ," .&L !&#(#$!+" 6#/(!

+" 44" .&'4 ,!.= ..#;"1&(!+" $#,"' &1!",6' *) *- )*+3

## 2

I+"!+",'4" C&(3E," '#("1 "'E# I+"!+",,"4#,! 9."

"'E#