← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23885/2019allowed

Bhupinder Singh v. Director General, Crpf And Others

2025-03-10Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj10 pages



       CWP-23885-2019 

 ! ""# BHUPINDER SINGH 

 DIRECTOR GENERAL, CRPF AND OTHERS   $  %&$  '( '  ) *****            

  !

   "



  !

  !#  $$$$$ ( '  )+ , -./ % &&       

        !  '()

* &" !  !

" &&

 *  *   +

% , & * &! ! 

      "  !

"      

,  !  

 !"

, !  (-  '"

 !  .

 ,&/( ! % &%&  0  1 ,& ()- 0 ! !

       ,& ()-1   !

& ! "  &&

   ! ,  !   "& 

  " " !

"  2 & 3   !  , 4

  

        

           

   

   

           

        



   

 

   

      

       

 



        



    

 



  

   !    

  "

 #

        $% 5 . ,*"     !

 ,& /( !      ,& ()- *  * .

6*&, "% ,  "  !  

 

      

           !"#$ #$$% 2 & 3   !  , 3!&  '       

(

 

  # )!  # !*+      , # 

   

       





     

 

        -       

  

 

  ,    

       

 .

     

   

   (



      

 /         0   

 #  

    

 



     

         

5 

              

   ,    

 

   (  

          

     1  









            

   ,   

                

 ,

             

   

.  

  

   

   

  

#)!  # !*+ 

 

   

1 

  

        

   

       

    

       &2    

      

  

   ,       

   

  

   

 1



,

   

     #)!  #  !*+ !) .     

   

  # )!     #  !*+  

        



     

   

   

 

 

 !) !

 '

1    

     

           3   

     

   1   



 

      

/   4   

   

      .    

  

                  

    (

 

   

  

 

    

   



!)

 '

1    

     

        



   3 /     

    

 

  

   

       (   

     ,            

   5   



     /     

 

   

.

  

 

 (   !) &  '

1    

     

               3, 

           

      

     

      

     5  5 /   

  

 

  , 

 1   

   ( 

  !) )  '

1    

     

       

 

     

3/

  

 

   

 

 (  

            

  4     

   



   

      

   1      

            

 !)  '

1    

     

        

    

      # )!     #  !*+3 .

      

     5    5

         

 

/ !

  *  ,  &"!

7

" &&

* &  && * !  ! &&  8

&    &  "&!

"   .

  .

6*&, "% ,  ! && &   !

&  "&8 " & !  !

"    &  ,&      !&   ! ,  "  ! * "!

"     !

" &&

  *

  !!  "  " !

* &,  * .

6*&, "% ,   9 (/ ! !

, " # 

          !  ,&  & 

 * .

6*&   , " % ,    ,

    "  &  ! & " &&

   *

   !&&  &&   ". ,

  ,!! !

"

   ! *  " !&  * ,&/(     ! .

6*&, "% ,    

:  % , &!

  !#    

    ,  &   ! ,    !       

!&        &!    ,      

 



,&   && " "    ,  !   

& 

   

,  !       *& !  

  7    & 

 * 

      !, ,*"   " &

* ,

    !  & '    ,    *  *  "& *!

  *

 !

" &&

  ,   !  ,& *   ;,  " 0, 1 

         , *&" 

 ! "

   /       & *  '(  &  

    " <         

 

     !

,      !   !   "&  

          !&   

"&!    &  ""*  ! !

  * ," , 

 ! *  * 

 !   ,&   &  ! ,  :  ,"    " ","   !   *

*!

 " &&

* &"!

   * % , &!

 *   ,&/) !   ,&()-& *&     

('  !     =,    *  !

    .

   

  !&   !      , ,&8  ,&   * &  *

 !    !'  !   *"  &

*!

 " &&

*7!

.

   "&      & *&  

      &,  &

- 7  "  * " &  &"   * !.

   ,&

*,&   ,&/( - > &        ,"  !       

 , ,*

 !   (' ! , "   "   

 

      

       &  '

 , !2  7   

 6)226  0 8 

   .. 7

 0   0(        

 

 ,

      

 6)226 ( 

       

 

     9)             





           

      

    

  

 4 

   4  :      

     

     

  

     ;       



 

 

 

  9 ? !

  * 

      ! " ,



 &  

 !  "&   *   ,&  ,  *     " !

"  ,  "  3  

. ,

     ,*"  * ,         ;, "     , *&"  

   * ,

,    ! ! 

? ) #    &

 % , &   * &! ! 

    &  

,  ," &*&



&, ",   * * " ,

    &   ,*" *     !

 !

"  &&

 2  ! &&    *  * 

!

 & ! " &&

2 & 3  !  , <=0 ';>#>/ .      

 0>   8   

 &!

!2 2!?     

  @  

       

 =  *+!))!?!+ 8,AB0 7 /



B8*C7 B8*C7



    

 8

 0

  DEF G!!

& 2!6

 !?&2 = *+!))!?!+8,AB07 /    D

   

 H

 0

  DEF       7

=G )*C 7 =  !CC!?) .

 #   &

I  C2    

    

         

   

  0>

 



         

!& 2!6 ;

    

 1 .G        .

 ;  0>

    ,        .  J  

    0>

     90

   9  !

!

2!C  8  *C 7 8#K 

 !

!

2!C  ;  

)      /0B   (        ,                      ,     

   

     ;        

     

             

  .     8   

&!

!2 2!?

 ;4 ;8 (

 ;

 

 8    

 

!!

) 2!?     

    ,         

    

 



 

  0

 -. (  



/ 8 . !!

) 2!)  

      &2     A 8,  0

 /    7

 0    0          )         

 &) 

'

 



  





 D  F

  

     

  !!

& 2!6   

   

 H

 0

   DEF   B*C7   .

#& I C2   

     

    

            8  ,   

    

     

 H 0

  -G.

 ;            8 

 

   

  F         

>8,AB0 7/ 



!!

) 2!?

(' 8 



 

 (

 

% ('  ,& ! "

   

! , * !

   ! &"!

" &&

, ,&/( 

&      "

,  &! #  *&   

   !

& ! * ! ! "  &&

 ,  ,& /(  * &  & *** .

6*&, "% ,  , "  !  

 

    &  ' # !      ",    

!

"   ,&  

*  



  &  ' ((  % =, &    

    &&     ",   !  '() 0

3,  :1   &

   

 2 "  "    

 &  !

     &"  !  !

 ! " &&

! &   " 8 ,&  & 

 *   .

6*& , " % ,     "  !  

 

    &  (' !

 ! "  &&

 ( +  !,& *        ! 

 "

 !

 ! !  !        !  ,  !

    !  

*  ,( '  )/ $  +""#   J  / >  7  

@89  >   *&  @89