High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3778/2015dismissed

M/S Ocm Retail Shop And ORS v. Birla Vxl Ltd

2019-04-26Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur7 pages

# $%& '( (

)* $+ ),-- &

. )/0112 "/"

(

.* 3 "/"

(

( 5 1 (

56( 7*1"8"2(56( 59 (:* 56(

* 2( ' (5 % "##!( (

((5 85 1 8 5

< 5 " 2 5

(4(

(18 2(( ( ##

1* 68 (1*

< 6 (1*

"*80( 68 * * (8* 25 1* 6(*

=%8 6<2 1(

* 6

80 1( 68 * 8* "

" !

58* 11 ' >* "

( 68 2 856(

"1/(5

1<2 8( *8 "

"# !

65 56(

4(8* 856( ( 2 256(5"/2;!

5 (5 (62 :?

4( :* 8 8 (2 ;!

(:* 1"(

*58 ( ( 2 ;!

5 8 8 (2 5 18 52 *(8"2( ((

2/2(

5 1@ (22/ (

>** (<2 *58 ( ( ( 8/ :*

(

( ( 59 1 (:* "

2(( * 2 8 ;

" 5* ( (

/ 6 2(8 1(88 * *5>* 6(6 2(2(

:* <2 1(18 ## " (5 2((2(5 "2 /6"2((:

! ## ( "(5( 9* 5 (18 2((( 6:

2 / 2

; 4( 7*1"8" 1( 1*8 2 * 1(*8 "( ((:* 1*

156 ( (8 8 (8 8 ( 59 * ' ; ( 5 1 8 5 "1/ 1(

(

*58((8 *1 56( 7*1 * 5 (6 2<*58( 5/(9* 8/ 18 (5 6*(18 "( 1 56 52* 52(*9* <*58( "(18 2 ## 2/ 6 2 /: 2A2/"(5 5 (18 2((2 / (( 5 14( "( 5 5< *58( ?9*2* * (% %/ .* "2

(2284(2((:*

56( 2((8 *1 (5 < *

(*58 "

! "# $%$&

!''

$$ !&&"! $ ()*+*,-%.

'!% $$)/ ! . " ( "2( *

(8 *1 "*58( ( :*

2 2( 8 "( (:*

;

<(/( ( *( *8

4(1 ( *8 8 5 2 ;!

4( 5 1 ( 5

"* (

( *

5 (5 (/ 15 (*1( 1 "2((2 /50/(24( 5 1 *8 (/(5

1 6 1 (8:?

4( 82 2560 1 * ((*

12 * (8(5 856(

( 6( 1

/* (84(5 2 "

"# !

5 56(

9 6 / 6 :* 2

56(?( $ /2(

( 2( 59 (:*

* (% %/ .*"2( 1(85 59 2(' (4(59 28 56(:* 1*56(8 *1

(1* ((59 " 6"5 * ( #

1 5( (

(

2* ( ( :* 1 * 56 ( 8 *1 ( 8(59 (8 8 5 <1* (( 7*1"8(

( 2 2 * ; (% %/ .*(2( (:*

56( 2(((8 *1

(5 < (

5 12/1/ (

56(5 ( / / * 9*"2( *( *58 1( (22 56(5(

2(( 6/ / ' < ( 6 ( ( :*

; 2(( 1"(

(0 59 / 5 (8 (5 (59 "( 7*1 8(*"(2/"(:* 85 8 2 * 8 (:*

* ( * ((59 1 (2 * /* ( <1*(* :* (5 8 1* (59 0 ( (/5 8 56( :* 1*2(( * 5 "(8(5 8 8 6 (1* ((

*1((/ 59 * ("2( ( 1((59 85

1 5( ( 2* 1*((/2* 6

* (

( 5*(6 5 6( * 6

5 (5 "

( "(50 * (/ / 5 ( 2"2((( 258:*5 < ( (%*"(

86 (

56(:* 1*4(5 % "##!

8 % "2(( 2 5 (

* ( 5 18 < ( "( 52( 5 88 /(

( 56 1 (*1(1 2((2 / 50 / (2" ( " ( 5 2

*8 (/(/ 15

4((2(2 8 : < ( 6 11/1 (2

56* 6

5"( (8 5( 156 (11/ 26 159 /*

' (5 (7*1 (. %*2(

(8 (4(59* 0

6 (59 2( ( * 56 :

19* 5 ( ( 6* 5 ( (2" * * (2

//* (59 8 6" (

( (/ / ( 86 * ' ; (

5 ( :* 1 * 59 ( :* " 2( 8 1559 * ( 4(

5 (862* (/5 59 * ' ( 6 1((/ 5 5 (:* 1* ; (

* 29*18 & $

$& !''

&" $ # $%$ ' !

$01 ")*+)(2,( ,-32 4$5%.6!% &"

$# $%$ !&&$% &!'.& "&"&! )**2 (/,( ,+*24( *( 2 2 & $

$&!''

$$($%.

,(2(

(1 2 /( 6(8 "2* 8* 8 2(( / ' ('8 6( 2 4$5%.6!% &" $($%.

*"2( (5 ( ( 2/ (

8 (5 6(5 *A2/"(* (/5 1* ( 1(2 (5* ;

(4( "(9*18 * 56( (

5 ( % >* 6" 1

86 (8 *1 "(

8 .

)7)*+8 (

, B(( 0 1$ C