High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3832/2015dismissed

P.R.T.C v. P. Shanmuga Raja Nadar @ Shanmuga Raja P. And ORS

2018-11-14Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa9 pages

!!"

!"# $% & !"#

$ %'!

$%" &'()*+ % ,-./$+ .+/'

+% -/'0&

&/'

( ) " *#+%,'-.'

! ) !/* +%,'-.'

'% '0'1 .+/'

+% -/'0&

&/'

- )003455607 ,*/'.!, " "%*!*-*'+ ..*-* - ! 8 !'/'-'%'%9'.:3%9 !! '--

%* .**#!*

9 * '/% 9* -'%'% )* ! '% '

*'! .*%!*

**#!/ %%%10065604

%89!)+ # +)'!*%/! 89-'" *'"''.

55+4:+45;<!

8/ %%*.,'

'.!-*" < '% '0'1! * ' .'

*'! !, 9' -'.*% ! -' '. ! * # =" '.

-'" *' *..- "98'*-%!!

!'%-*"**' .*%% -*'0::'.!)''

!*-- >*#-'" *'

'!'.

0- '--''.%!'. !'> & !'> ? # % /!' * % ' !, %*% * --*% ' 04;5601*" / !!

8%%/'"*'

-!*% '.! %- %/

%!'!..%98'047 )%- % **' *%*#''%-*, -'' 8*#% *,89! !

8% %/!*!9/ '!@* > * '%+ 8 8 *#

#* *'' 61 AA:0-". %%8*#% *,*

!%#*#" + ->#* ! *#! *%'.! -''

'.!--*%%- %.'/ ! *#! *%%! *#!# -

!%89! /!'.!'..%*#,!*-% !/ % ##% '%* -'.069 - %/ ***9>') -'

15+!%*# !%! . / .

%' +!%*# ! # "%'03;56018 ! --"8%'!*$ *

*%* !--*%'50;5601*" !%

%!%- % !'> & !'>? #% !%-'"%! '"%/

*#)%.

'" *%99'*%-*' '-*9+ 8

* !/ ! * -'

-" / '. B*#! -%"9+ +::+ '9 + @* > %/ *#"''.

0>! "'!/ .

%*!-*"**'!%- %/ 9*#"'!9 '.

A766<* -'.! "* */!*-!!-%"9/ 8*# % / ' 9*# &

;+666< "'! .'

! *%* --'""'%*' !-*"**'!,*#8-' %+ *8 -'

%% .*%*#*.,'

'.!-*" # !%#*#% *,*# !!% '. " *#!+% *, '.!'..%*#8 %!!%!'.

!'> !%'--

%*!--*%*,',*#!'..%*#8 -!

.*%*# '% -!#*!* .

%89!

*!'/ '.!'..%*#8 '. -'" *'"'* -'- %+! "/

-'"% 89 ! *8

55+4:+45;< % / --%

.''/ (

' %

-*' *C

%"'!9*-'"

06+666< ) **C 76DE*C8','8*- %*!"'.

. -

06+666F

7+666G

07+666< ***C 0<1 % '. E**C 8', %%-%

' H '.%- %

07+666

7+666G

06+666< *,C '" *' . "** '. I0:I *

06+666H05H0:G

0A+56+666< ,C B'

'. ', % ..-*' '. "'! %

- *9'-*" '5%1

0+66+666<E*

76+666< -!C ,*C B'

'.-' *"'-*"'0

0+66+666< ,**C )%*-H

0+60+45;< ,***C

57+666< '-'" *'/ %% % 1#21#3 ' *#!'

*'! #%! !-'" *'"'/ %%* '!!*#! *% *-%- % 119

'%!*"'.--*%%/ ."'9%+%%**' **-'"'/ . - '#!'!,8# %&46D * %'.76D *-/ -%89-' '!$%#"'.! H'

!""#!

$ '-'%!' "'.

36+666<'#!'!,8/ %%% !-',*'!% * '

'.-' *"+'

'. %. H +/! ! *8 ! / %% "'.

5+57+666<% !-',*'!% ) " *# %-' ! % *#!-'

'.! *#.

* !% --*' ' -'% ! !-'" *' "' 89 .''/*# ! "

*%%'/*

'()*+,+*

-)./!

* * .

$+!""#!

' 0

- E C '#! ' 8

0A+76+666< 'H*"9 * % '.

55+4:+45;<!! 8/ %%89! *8

-' +) !/* %-' *#! -*" < '% '0'1! -'%%! ! ** - .'

!-"'.-'" *' '

'. -! 8"*

*'+** % ! ! *8 ! -'"9 ', ''>% ! -' *8*' '. !'

/*.<"'! %/!*-!!% ''8

%*"' 9 "

% %%%'!"'!9*-'"'.

06+666<!! 8

%89! *8'--''.! *#-%"9* #%!*!- '.12

$ +!"'!9*-'"'.!%- %/!'/ !'

/*.!%8

1+666<* *''--*%!!%>-*! 9 0A;0+) /'%,!"9 #! *---*%*! .- '.!* - !%>-*!9 5601+*/'%8.* - '

* "' 9 "

! ' '. ! %- % !'

/*.<"'!

:+666< "'! ' .'

! * !,8! %#! , !'#!+ ) " *# % -' .'

! '

*' ! -'%% ! ! /'% 8' -' .'

!-"'.-'" *' '<-

'8$-*' !,8.*% 89 ! -*" >*# !-" '. -'" *'+ 9+ * ! -' *% % ,*/ '. !* '

! -*" - - *9 %.% ! ="'.-'" *'/ %%89! *889'**#'9

'"*

*'*!/ %+/!*-!+*.+>''./'%%'-'- *' !! * ' =* "' %-!"'/ %% -'" *'

%'8%9+ ! -*" ! * E '% '0 ' 1C !, ' -!#%!/ %'.! *8 !9'

*89/ '## *,% '.!-'" *'"''.

55+4:+45;<!/ / %%89! *8! *"9+" 9'--''.!.-!!-*"

!,'*%%9-!#%!/ %/*'-'"*!* /9'.

%.%*#!-'" *'/ %%+''! # '% -! ''

**' * .'%% ',* *' -'*%* % 40 11'.!'%'.

*,*

'-% %/!*-!8 -'

/!*-!'#!'!,8

%89! *'

%'"> -!

! '

'! '

% !- "9 =* +,*.+! '% !% '.*%9'

'8$-*' !* # % . -"98 "%'!%-* *''.!H'

*"5 6

%# /7 (

!""#! ,+%/! ** !% .''/ (

# $%&'()*

+ #

& #

& !

# # &

# *

, - .('$

# +&

* ,

. ('$

0 1 &

+ &

, # # #

# 2

& #

)3#&

# )

4 %, *#8->'!.- '.! - +! 8"*

%,-%89-' *#!'

*' - *9 " *'

! *8/!*-'"*#!-'" *'"'!

/ %%%%**'**-'"'/ . - '.!%- %& 76D *-%- %/ 119

!*"'.--*%%/ .

"'9% - '$-%89!-*" +46D*- '/

. - '#!'!,8/ %%89.''/*#! "

* 0 - E C ,!"''.

5+57+666</ %% % !-',*'!% * '!H-

*, *%%

36+666<'#! '!,8/ %%'/ '

'.-' *"+'

'. %. H - !'! !%+-' .'

!-*" < '% '0 '1! ''*%'# *#'"*

*''! '.! *8! "'!9*-'"'.!%- %! 8

06+666</!* -' *% *# ! ! / *# -%"9 % !% ' %%-% ,*%- .-*#9"'. .'

! "* */!*-!!-%"9 8*# *8! '

%*"' 9 "

! '!! %- %/ %* -! #*#*!--*9'.!'

/*.<"'! ! "'

*!- '.8 6)

9 7

'()*+,+*

-)./!

*,* : 4 )

, !""#!

$!%>!*-'" '. ! %- % * %9 8'

'" # *- 8'

> &

1+666< "'!%%%% "'.

0766< "'!'/

!'%/'

>%--'

%*#9

%!"'!9*-'"&

4766< "'!! - ,*.!* '

/ '8#*%%89! $%#"'.!H'

*120 - E C"''.

1+666< "'!!, 9 /'% =* '8%%%'! "'!9*-'"'.

06+666<! %9 %

%89! *8 -!+*.!'*-'"* >

01+666< "'!* %'.

06+666<%899*#! "

## %%.'

!89 -' .'

*'!-'" *'"'

*,% /'%8

54>!

'H*"9 --*'*!* # %/'% !8 .''/ (

' % "' 0 )'!9*-'"E

%89! *8C

06+666< %%**' * *-'" '/ ' '.

/*.<"'!

1+666< "'!

1 '"'!9*-'"

01+666< 46D %%**' * *-'" '/ . -

7566< 01+666F7566G0;+566< 0<1 % %%-*' '/

' % *,*# H '.!%- % :6::< 0;+566:6::G05+014< : "'. 9*#"** '.0:

05+014H05H0:G51+5A+35;< ',*'!% *'

'.-' *"+'

'. %. H - 36+666< ;

'-'" *'"' 51+5A+35;F36+666G

51+AA+35;< !H'

*"5 6 0 - E C!%!% !/! * .*%-!#*#!="'.-'" *'+ *

-*,'./!'.* +! ' *-'

!*#!

* 'H"*!.- 899*#! , *-* +% "*

5 !$ -'" *'%*.-'" *'% "*%* !*#! +!+! -'" *'/ %%89! *8!*#!'

!'/! +*.+** 89!-*" %%* "*

!+*.+** 89! '/ <*

9.''/*#!%*-"*%%'/*"5 6 0 - C *-!! 8 .

%89!'/ '.!'..%*# ,!*-%!-'" *'"'% "*%89!* '

* !*#!

!!"'/ %%89! *8+! /'%8' -''.

%-*' '. ! -'" *' "' % ! -' =9 *

%* "*

% !-'" *'"'/ %%89! *8,*%/ %%10065604+* ..* "% * %* "*

%*!.'

*% "

.+/'

+% -/'0&

&/'

, 0+ #

->9 J!! >*#< '%( <'

J!! '

8( <'