High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/43001/2020allowed

Shankar v. State Of Haryana

2021-09-09Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

!!!"#$%$!&'(!)*++,!'-!.++.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!%,%! !"!## #######$%#&'(#'$)'#*+,-&#+.#/,%012#1%3#'1-41%1#1&# # # # # ##*'1%3$)1-'## # # ########### *-565#%78#9:"";#7<#!"!"## # # # # # # 3=>?#7<#@?ABCB7DE#"F8"F8!"!;# # GH=DI=J## # # # # # # # K/?>B>B7D?J# # # L?JCMC# G>=>?#7<#'=JN=D=# # # # # # # K-?CO7D@?D># # *+-15#E# '+%P2Q(#5-8#0,G&$*(#1-,%#5+%)1## # !"#$#%&'('

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

J*''

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

Z#+"%#3'65:%$#?'75"'&0#',#&.&.5%#"'$:A;.&$'&0+&'&0#',#&.&.5%#"'.$' .%' 6:$&53=' $.%6#' JI*LM*JLKN' .*#*' +?;5$&' G' =#+"$' &U5' ;5%&0$' &05:/01' .%' A#&U##%1'5%';#3.6+?'/"5:%3$'0#'U+$'/"+%&#3'.%&#".;'A+.?'A='&0.$'T5:"&'5%?=' 75"' +' ,#".53' 57' 75:"' U##B$*' 80#' ,#&.&.5%#"' 3.3' %5&' ;.$:$#' &0#' .%&#".;' 65%6#$$.5%'#+"?.#"'+%3'&0#"#'.$'%5'"#+$5%'U0='0#'U5:?3'35'$5'.7'"#?+$#3'5%' A+.?'3:".%/'&".+?1'+"/:#$'&0#'65:%$#?*'''

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

G*",%*<'H)")*'@(B%-*C?'!(>*#*,?'(..(-*-')!*'/"$C'.C*"5'A*'-B/=$)-')!")' .*)$)$(%*,' ="D' ),D' )(' $%+CB*%@*' )!*' >$)%*--*-' -$%@*' )!*' ="))*,' $-' (+' -*,$(B-' %")B,*5'80#"#'.$'#4#"='?.B#?.0553'&0+&'0#';+='#4#%'+A$65%3*'

!!!"#$%$!&'(!)*++,!'-!.++.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!%*%! I5'

J'!"#*'!*",<',*-.*@)$#*',$#"C'@(%)*%)$(%-'(+'C*",%*<'@(B%-*C-5'' N*'

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

T5%$.3#".%/'&0#'54#"+??'$6#%+".51'65:,?#3'U.&0',"5?5%/#3'3#&#%&.5%'57' ;5"#'&0+%'75:"'=#+"$'+?"#+3=':%3#"/5%#1'U.&05:&'65;;#%&.%/'5%'&0#';#".&$' 57'&0#'6+$#1'&0.$',#&.&.5%'.$'+??5U#3*'D'+;'57'&0#'4.#U'&0+&'%5':$#7:?',:",5$#' U5:?3'A#'$#"4#3'&5'B##,'&0#',#&.&.5%#"'.%'7:"&0#"',"#4#%&.4#'6:$&53=*' KK*' ' ' 2665"3.%/?=1' ,#&.&.5%#"' .$' 3."#6&#3' &5' A#' "#?#+$#3' 5%' A+.?1' 5%' 0.$' 7:"%.$0.%/' A+.?' A5%3$' +%3' $:"#&=' A5%3$' &5' &0#' $+&.$7+6&.5%' 57' ?#+"%#3' &".+?' T5:"&1'U0#"#'0.$'6+$#'.$'A#.%/'&".#3'+%3'.%'6+$#'&".+?']:3/#'.$'%5&'+4+.?+A?#1' A#75"#'?#+"%#3'3:&=']:3/#1'+$'&0#'6+$#';+='A#*' "F8"F8!"!;# # # # # # # R1JMD#57DT=V# 4$'

]:3/#'# # WH?>H?J#CO?=IBDTXJ?=C7D?@#E## 4?CX%7# WH?>H?J#J?O7J>=YZ?#E# # # 4?CX%7!