← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2725/2010disposed of

Darayao Singh v. Haryana Land Reclamation And Dev. Corpn. & ANR.

2016-01-11Mr. Justice M.S. Sullar15 pages

 

   

     

 

   ! " #$%& '''''(()** $+ 

 !" $ , $- ).* / +#$ $- )0)*(/)$+!(! +#$  $+&)!'''''

)1($-)$+1  2' 3,

     4&)+&)!!)(!+)!1*. *$)51( ()!1/ "6) **5)-+ 1))78-%/)$+9  6)!))!!)-+!)(!+)!1!$+9  : 4&)+&)!+&)78-%/)$+1&8*-6)!)(!+)-#$+&)#%)1+9    

  !

 ""##

$   "



  ; ! * %& #

""##  

# ' ()       *    "

  +  #   ! #  



   ( #,# 

  ,

 ' ()          - - * "

  +  #   .

#   (  /  

0  #,#    +  )

%& #

 #     # ")

' 

1 ##   (  "#

 ""##  

    ( 

 2   3  4 #)  

 #")  ."  / 

    5234.60 ,

78  )  

( 

( (

9

    7.9::;  7   <.  . 

(    #

 

( = "

 > "



#

##(   ,   , "    (

  ."  #,# ) --*      

    ---  $  )  ! 

! # ( ?

9

234.#,#

#  <  ---,  

  ""#!+) +

! 

@A"

)  ! ) +  "  <  ---  "

#  +     

#! =   # # B ! 

@A"

)   ""#       !   =    #,#   ;

 ---  -C:  )

 

 , ""#       ,

<- )

!2!3.#,# <;)

? 9

234.#,#, ""#

 # ""# !2!3.  

 

1 !   1 , # +#  + 234.#,# ! = + # +  $  D  )

(  < ;

  $ ,

 # 2

 ,  

   # 

 !, + # E4

;C"+( ) 

+( ") " #(  ) "#

 7

 

""#, ) # ,  

   

" : -   ++ +

! 

@A" 3 %:& B "#

 ##(   "#

# ,  

   ##  (1  !  = # )   

#

(1     $     (   ")

   "

(  

   

: )" #"

 #,# , 

#

## (1   =

D 

( "#

, #   -   $ + "" #  "#

,  

%;& #

#  +)    ) + 

## 

  =  ( )

  

##(   #,# # +, 

)

, "" ,## +,

 +

(")" #

#

  +)     "



  ##   =   $ )"   

 +# 1    = 

,

CF 

#) 4

::C*;, +" +  "#

 CF, +" + !

  (234.

#,#

    C  B    ") 

, )"  (

 "#

 2   "#

  ## (   )"

) ,





.

#7

%C& B  ,   +    ##

9 )    +  )   

! 

@A"

)  ! ) +    ""#  , ! =

  #  #,# 

(4+ --- ?   ,+

 

  , $ )+ --- B  )"  #   ""# 

 )  

!, 

 #,# ;

 --- (

  

B   $ 

" 

; ) #   )( ) ()  

     #

   A"

 ""#  %&  ##(   "#



  ##  ) #,# + # +   ) + 7"



(@



  C :



B "#

 #   #  

! #  # #; <C)

!"4+ 

#

C:

<C %<& ! ,   

,

  "#

 <  , 

 ,

 A"#

,  

4

:::*;

 " C:

<C)

 !       "   )        :    +     ) )

  

 B "# "#

 ,  

   "#

,  #  "

+#  

(+#

(

 ! # ""#

 =  ,  

 +    "  

": - , ++ +

! 

@A" )  ! ) +

%*&

## #



, +""  

  CC(

 "#

 7 7

( !



 (+#    

)

4

:::*;,  

 +  ) "#



,       

    C   ,

 ,  ( ""  ) ?   

C %-&  +

"#

 " ##,

 ,) 

     :

  

        

        

  



 

    

      



 !

 "

     #  $ %%

& '  

         

     

   

& ( 

     !

 

&  )

 %& B +  " # 

D

$  ,    ")  



 B   "#

  

#    #     C     < <  

      +

##(# ##

 ##(    "

 

)(

 "#

  #   ##)

(C:

<C )

!   "   "

 +

,

+  ) "#

    ,  "      (       #    )  B   #  ##(   "

"#  # '

 

+ )"

# ,    ,   

,

 ,

,  #  "#   +     "#

        " # 

(, # (

 "#



%& B #. 

 

$ (

 "#



B  ,  # )



+#

 +  

  7  *  ..  

  $  :    ;  ,  

 "

 +  

4 # #  ,

)

 

' ()      :

- *"

 +.

 (/ 

0#,#

%& G#

( ((   (

   ' ()    "#

 # ""#+ 3,!""## .   )  # +

)

 

' ()     *   B 3,!""##.#

))  "    ""##  

#

,      #  ""#(

    (

(   H9  

  "#

  ), A  ": -   #  

B   )"  "  "#

, 



 # )



)  .  #+# (  ,  "

"#  #'

  + )"# ,     , ""+  "   #, %:& B "#

 )    ,   

,

  )+  (

(  + " #,

)"  " ) !"#,  # + ) ""

  

(,      ) 

( 1  B "#

 

( 



A)

     )        ""# (

   ,  # + .  )

D   +        # ""#  

      +   + ,   

""# ,

   +  

 + .  )

< I   ,

  ##,      #  ""# + .  )  - *  "#

"#      ))+      

%;& B 3,!""##., # ))

("         "#

  +        ,    ""    )       )   ,   (   "   # + )+  )"   

, #     +    )

%C&    

)   3,!""## . 

( 



 ""#   # 

) , #+# "#

,

 # + )

) 7 ;/ 07"

4# !

 -:   ""#,

)

%& B   "#

    )#  ##,

(  +  # 1

#,( $  (

""# #



.    

*

   

 !*    

  + ,-)&%./. .($0    1   "       

*  

*  &/ 

2   !* 3. /   -





    !* 

 .

  

  &/ 

2   !

 "

   

*   



       

 !* &   !       

 &/ 

2   

 *   "



*  *   "  

 .

 

!

 

 



      





 !

 *  "

 



*   

 .

 "  

*    * !* 3. /   -

 

 

*  &/ 

2

  !   ! " 



*      

   

%<& D    #  

# ""##

%*& 3  

#       "#

    ) # (    )"

" #,



##     "#

)   ## !  =  + 

(")

 "

( #

#"

+  ),   +  $ 

 # 

  

,



( ),  

) (C)

  A #,#

3  

# #  " @A " 

  )

( , 

   " ":  ##,

( 

#

)  C :



   "  7 8  *  ' 39   ! 

 !* 3   :



 8  *  ; 39 !* 3  

"

 9 3   

    *  39 <  39  &/  

*  

 = > %-& 3  

# "#

# (  

"

   (    2  

     

-

 D #,#  )  #   C )

 

   

 )  ,   A  # ( ,

+

 + "#



 ."  #,# B "#

   # ; <C)

! "4+ 



,

C:

<C)

#,   # 2# (  



  "

  ) C)

 )   !  #  "  4+    ,  ##  '  

,   1 )   "#

  +

) = D

, "

+ ,   )   

 + "#

  $ #,# 7

 

""#, )  # ;

 ---

  ,

(   ,   # ( 

,

! = #   +  =    A  4+    )

     ##

(!   ; <C)

"4+ 

#    +  +



"

##,  )  #C)

#,#

%& 3  

# "#

""## # # " @A     , 

  A

,

( (+C)

 # 2  #   "  A)

 



    I  7   7 ) 4( # (234., 

    )    

""#!, ) # (   

 "#



   ,#  #  ) #+ 

  

,

,)

B   ,   +   7"



(@



  C :

 B 

 , # ## +  "#

   #   ## 1  

 =

": -   ,   



  "#

 +     $      )"

   " #  

::C*; "  )  :  +   +" + "#



%&  

" 

) @A   +   ,

"

+   ) #,# # C)

! I, #""

(



 A)

    )     !, 

    $ )+--- 1 , -C:)

B  ,

   )   #,#.    # = ) 

,  "     

2  # )   B  ,

#  )    "#

  1  

#   -  

(")

"

(  #

 ,

'  +  7"



(@

 *   "@A J

%&

,       #  

#  "#



#   

 #    + )" "  "#

  "#

  ) ##



##  ! =

 %:&           #  

#       "       (     

(      ,  

( ") #) 

)



+#   

+#    + 

)

    

 

  #  @   

       "#

  ,   + + 

,  

 B 

"

# 

 #    



 # "  , #" 

(

 "#

 ") ## B  ") # 1  ,  # 

,

 "#

,   ""

 

(  ) #""  ,

 )   

,   

,

  )+ ." ,

,  #"# #

  #  )    ,  

) 

(""#(

  !

  (

 

( ""# "  #

# @    "#

  +  ( # (  + 3, !""##  . 

    A    

(    

(   ") #""#

%;& D     A)

     )  ,       ) #  ,  +     .  G)     " #   " 

  C :

D      )   = #,#,  #C)

!,

, + # +    B  ""#, )  # ;

 ---+  )    ,

( " 

##(   #4+ ", #

,

 

# = +)  !

(

  ) 

 C)

  ""#) #,#, -C:

)

,

"#

   # 

C <C )

,

)(

##  )

 C)

 ") #   

 ) @A  ,

(  ) C)

 "  " 

  ")

%C& B  "  )  + #  + +     .  +#, ,         @A @A  @A  B  ) I # )  A)

 



+(      "

 

""#, )  ;

 ---

  "#

,

+

  ##  

+  

 ,   +   7"



(@



  C :

 ! ,   

 

:::*;  ,  )        "   )       :  

%& ! " #            "

       ,   ) #,#. 234.,  

+ C)

I 

+ # " :     , ) 4

:::*;  +

)"  

  

C:

<C)

  "  )  :   B  

  + "#  +  $

" : ; 

 #

 A)

 



  ,

 



(    

 .   + )" 

 D     +  +(   )   

:

 . ",    

 -C:)

  + 



 , #

)"

(" #

 )

)

(#

 I    #   

           C:

<C  )

     :    + 

 

   # (   )    #,#   #       C  )

 

"  

(      @A        

  # 

 " 

# "+#



@A   

+ 



 + . +#,, # 

(

 

$  @   ") # ""#   +  "  +   "#

 ##   ##(#  ,

" 

 

(  ") #  " 

   + 

 

 

# +   ,# + +



 "  

#  #'

B  A 

  +)  ) #     +

 +   ,## + ., #

(,   

   !"" #  ,  A  #(  (  72 

"@A  B  ""#) #,#. , +   )   "

C)

D  ""#)  #,#, +   )    , A

""# )  + +  "#

,    # ; <C )

# )   "

C)

7

 # ""#) #,#, -C:

)

 1 

,   A

;

""# "#

 # +" # = 



 #

## # ""#,



( A)

 



7 7  7 )4( # (234./I0 , +        ( , ""    ##    

 "  :   !

" #      ,  

(   +  #. ,## + 3,!""##., #

( # 

 %<& 7 #  ,      

+          ."  . +#,

""



( 

"

#,#  + C)



(

    # ""#   -C:)

 

  #  ; <C  )

 

  ,#  )     ##(#   

    #,    "           1

 + 

#  7 - . .

  

%*&

,  D) 

,  # . ++# (  

   

) 

   "

## #

(,    "

 )   #,#  ,   # ""#) 

+       "#

    ##       

 D

,      #

) 

 +(

+  #. ,  "#

  ## ))  )

 #    

 (

 # "

#,# 

B  # . 

 #  1  (

 

( ,    

C

"

#,#,  A)

 ,     ) #   H2, # ""#-C:)

"    ")  #<-)

) 237., # )#     ,   

  "

234.#,# B  # . ###  

  )# " ""# ;

 ---  "

##  ,         )     A     

"

  #

# = ! =

,    ,

(,  ",



 %-& I    

(D) 

   #. 

 ) (

(



   

 $   



(    ) #     D  # (   D 

  )"( ' ()     "

 + . +#, )

  #  

   



   

 

"

("   ' ()

%:&     ""+ #.   

      $8 !";< !

'#