Shiv Shanker v. Vijay Kumar And ORS.



 

   

         





  
 !"
#$$%% &"'
&()
*'+"
 
"



#
$ 

     

  ,"  "
'" "
-"./
 
"

$$%% 

000

1"
"$""

%%
$$"
+)
2
%%3



('.+ 4


5
2
" ""


"$""
"
4

6
1"

('.+ 
'%
2
"$"
 .4

000



"%
'
%
2)

$%


3
"
2)

"%
'"

('.+ 
 
"








$$%
$" ""
. 


"
%
 
3
+






5

3/
 


2 "

'"/


".'%"
 
$$%

,"


%/
" "/
3'%
2
" ""

2)
"
". %
$ 


'

7
"/


'
%
2)

$%

/
)
$")

"

"
"
$"+ 
 ('

 /
"" .


"+
 " .
 )
$"

"

!"+



3/
3

"
%'"
 
+"!

89



$%
$$ 
3

$% 

 
%

"

 

"+ 

 
'$
 "
+'" .
 :
6;
<

;/
'

"

!"+

7
3



 ""

$%



$'"
=
"


$%
.
6
! %/
+$"

!%%
 >?@/

 > ?

/
'


"

*!$'"/
"+
 
*"$%
 .


 .
7
3
+  

"
%")
<

"
+'"
!"+



3


+
3

$%


$'"


$%
5

$.
3
3

"
%'"
 
+"!

89



$% 
A'""/

$.
 

3
%


$%


$%


"+

+
"

3



3
 
2

$.
<
"+

+
3 "
$%
3
$'"
2)

$%



A'""/


$.
3
++ %)
'
2)

$%


 

$$"
"
"$ 
$%


 

$'"

% "+
 


/
( 


$.

B' /




  
3




3
") .

 "
'$


$.
2)
" .
%%.%
 "' 
,%


"B'




'
 )
 
'$


$./
2'


 %
5'/

'


 /

3
$%/
 "
%/


"
.

! %
@
+"%
3
%


$%


'
 !%%

 

"
+'" .

+"%
3
%
'
 !%%
 

$.
+'" .
 

3
3
. 


$%


"'.

 "

!%%
 /
!%%

 !%%

"'

"+
"

'
7
3
+  


!%%

3
3
2)
%"
89
 





9

C
3

!"+
 



3
6D
!"+

,'"' 

%


@

 @6/
<'
  '"
 
$%

/
)
3"

.

% 
+'" .

! %
 @
+"%
'


!"
'+2"
3

 
3
$.
"+

 "


!%%
5'/
3


2"! !%%


2


$.
"+ 
@
!"+
 



5
+$%

! %
@
+"%/
$%


"B'"
6
!"+
 
% .

!%%


"
%

+ .
$"
!%%



!"+
=
/

"B'"

2

$

". %
3 "
 
"

 %' .

$.
A'""/

". %
3 "
%
%

% 
+'" .

! %
D
+"%

 /
'

!%%
 @> /
 

"+ .
"
+'"
+"%
3
% 

E";

 "


3 "
7
3
+  


3%%
3
 "'
 "

"
.
=
!"+

!%%

 
=
!"+
3
% '
3"

$.

. 
'$$"


3%%

7
3
 ""


% 
+'" .
@
! %/
3
2)
%"
F*C



$% /
 

"
'

"

$.
3
6D<
GD
+"%
7
3
%+

 


 "'

3%%
"'



"
$'"
2)
+
 



 "
'$
 )
"

<


%+ 



 "

+"

'
 

  

""/

'"
2%3
'



". %%)
*"$%
 .
 

 
3"

3 "


$"$")
 $'

,%



$'"
"
$%
"+
*"$%
 .

1"/
 


$'"

$%
"+

 

*"$%
 .

%


@

 @6/
C<,/
<'
  '"


$%

/
"

"
<

!"+
$.


"

/
3
.
'$


!"+
 

'"


3"
!%%
 @>@
 
%
".
'$


!%%
'+2"
5

%

3
%
.


2)
8%
 .
 
'!
 .
 


*"$%
 ./
 

 

5" "/

3
 %'

"
<

$.

3

!"+

3
 3'%
%
'$
!%%
 @>@
5

$.
3
'%)
$



$%
C<,/
+"!

89
7 /
"
3

$'

"."

< 



$.

"+
$ 


8
H3 "/
"+
$ 
8

9/


3"
$'"$"

 
 "
'$


$.
2)
 "' .

3%%
 (
*'+"
%

I%
9++ "/


"$"
C<, /
 

$%
C<,/
$" 

 
'
2)

 
 $.
"+
$ 
*


5

"$"
'""
" %



"'%

 
'/

$.
3
"'



 
@
 
 
" "/

3%%
.
=


.
3
%
 "'
2)



 


"'%/

$.
 

"

!%

3
 "
2)

 

"
$%
5
2 .
/

3
 %'

 


 "
'$

$.

B'
2)
 "' .

3%%
%%.%%)
 "2%)

+'
/

 !"
1
 


"?<+  /



"

'"

"

"


$%


$%

/
"
<

"

H
%
+

"


'"



3
3



$%
C<,
 
+"!

8

9
H
'""
+

"
8

9
3
 

3
 3'%
%


% 


$%



H
%
 


"
3



$%
C<,
 
+"!


3

'


$
%%
'""/

%
+


"
3

+"!




$%
C<,
 
3

98
3
%

'


$
 

3



"
3



5
2 .
/
 

 !"
+


"?<+ 

< 


"


$/

$'"$"
2)

$%


 
3



$% C<,
 
%
+

)
3"
 "' 
3%%/
3

I%
9++ "

 (
*'+"
%/
 /
"


$
5
"$"
'2+
2)

I%
9++ "
C<, 
 


$%
$$ 
"/
$" 

 
'
2)

 
'$

"
'% %)/

'
3
"
5
$$%



%
. 


"/
2)
 
/
%
 
3
" .%)
+
7
 
"
%"


'

%
"

$$%% 

% .
 
$"'


$$"
2!
I"


'

%
"

$$%% 
+$%)
!

""

'2+ 

3"
  
2 "

'"
2%3
 
"(
 "

'
 
+$"  
 " 

"
".'+ 
3
  



'
 
'. '%
 " +"

'/
7
+


 "
3


  $$%

3%%)
 

+"
 

'/
%2%

2
+
"

" 

"
2 .
""
" "
%

"/
"
$%



'/
)
3"
"B'"

'2 


 

 
 "
'$

$"

$.

B' 
5
"$"
'2+
2)

I%
9++ "
C<, 
% .
3

$%
C<,
$" 


 
 
 "
'$

$"

"
"+
$ 
*

/
$



$% 
A'""/


"'%


 
'/

3


$.
3
"'

:
<
@;


3%%
.
=


.
3
'



 
2  "'
2)

 /
"'% %)/

"
+'"



"+
$"


$.
 

"
+'"



3

$"


!%
3
+".
2)



$%
5
2 .
/
 
3
".%)
"


"+ 

 
'
'$

$.

 :
6;
<

;/
'



!"+
3
">$.
I"


'

%

"

$$%% 
'%

$ 
'


3

 %' 

3"
 '"" %)
""
2)
2

'"
2%3
3"
"
 "")


$
""
"
'

"
"+
 )
+"%
%%.%)


3!


$ /


'
2 /
"
"%)
<
 )
."'

/
%
$%'2%

%3/

 "

"
3

"
2 .
%


$" 
$$%

B'
%3/
+'
%
 )
'2 %
B'
%3/
"
"
 " 
$$%
2 .
 

+"
/
" .%)/
+
February 9, 2015 Rajan
( Arun Palli ) Judge