High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3862/2015allowed

Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Meenu & ORS

2019-08-01Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan12 pages

!"#$%&'( (((##

& )

&('"&

(((*

&('"&

(((##

)

&+,'"&

(((*

# $

%&$ ''$ ,'+$- ( ./ .0'1" & 2"&##

2" #"'&3"(

( (4 13. 0'1" & 2"&##

' 2" 3"( &"

(

'$( 6$& "'0

' #"

"2&." ((

2 ' " + 2 "2 ##

& !"#$%&'('

2 '"+ 2"2##

& 7 &('"& 0. 1 "&"2& '&( &(7.20 &8&7" "06+$497 "',&0&(4 :17"&'(&% 72&"2 6.,0."# '"' ' '&0'+",& #&&"' &" "2&"&") &0 , && ((&+,7'10;"#&"< 4'!" & &" !"#$0*"&97".'* !"#$ %&'( "2 & :# +, , &&" 3"(=*6>

2&2'&" &"22',1 0 , "# &"( #& "2& 0"&&1,,&"2

&"+0 0.2"26.,0 $07 . "&2 ,.

0 "6.,. 9'& #"

$&" " "?&& &&' @"$2"6'

2" 1

,:"" "&" $ ?&& '8@@ 2 $?&&1

,:" & ' & "2 9 ( 2" 8@@ ' & . &,& ' .

$ " & &'"'0. '

&"6?&&6.,. '1,& "&" $ "& 2& '"2&"'?&&. '2"&"2 "& "2&30&1 2"&"##"

&' &" + ',& ,&"2&' '+$& ,+?&&&. "# & '9,&?&"&" $ '1+$6.,' ', &&

"22', 1 0 . . #9' " & & ' "'0 ' &"

2 &.&"&'A&#9, ,& ?&&"' &" "2& "22',1 .+ 9,2" &",& ",1 ?&& "+ " &" . &&''"2. +&"&"'?&&

&"2# &06., 1''@ '''

&&"

$?&&& '&. .&

'+$&30"."2 & "& 0 ." . A&' .& & ' '? && & 3 '& $2"'&#&&" ?&& &1 ',+" '

&"& #"&'& $' "+"'$2"'&#"

?&&&#"

'&& #"&&,&&?&&" "&"2'&"26. ,0 2 $+ . &&"2 " 9'&$ ,'& ## ' &' +$ & #"

? && 2& "# &" "2

$ 2" & +$&#"

0&''+"'$. 2&'&" ="

#& 8@@2"&"# $?&&&

2&'"&" $ '&"22',1 .&9&"#"

"+$&#"

2"& #"&( "',&"&

0& '&'&9# " "&"2 "

, , "2 7&+,("% 0+"&"2&' '

"','& *3"(> '&'( ( 2"&"22 ' &"

0 ;!,',& '&( "& 0

& & ' ##'( * 3"( ' 2 ' @"& .&& &&&0 .

#"'&3"(7 "#$2 ' #&.&& &&&(

&@"&.&& &&&2 '"+ 2"2

3"( '0&$''&2 &"2 '&0".10&$ +&&'

&&&1 A &". #9'"&B& 2& '"2&"'

"&9 #"&".&

# &" ( &'0

#$'2"'

"2& #&&"(

&.&& &&&2 '"+ 2"2 #"'&3"(7 "#$0 & ' ' 1"

# $ "+@ &"

"&',&&&& ' "'&" "2& #"

$. 1"

&'( #"'&

"''&2 &"2 '&( &

+&&'&&& . "&"

',1 ''22 &1 '1, &&&"2 '&(

"& .2'( /#& .22"''

'A&"##"&& &" '1' ( 2&,"2&#& 0&/+ ' ''

3"(

21""2&#&&" ', && "

',&&"+ "2 "&+&"$, , (

3"(. ' ''21""2& #&&" , && .',&"& "# &"&"& &"2* (0> 0 <02&"+ 1,&&' '6., . A

$, ,&'1,&

2&'"&" $ '& & .'' "# &""&. ' '+$ C'&#&&"

. '&& '&" 1* (

0 0 ",.&& &&&&"2 C#2"&'&"22 ,"2#&&"&

D&"(

3"(. ' ''21""2 3"( '', && #"'&3"("

',&& 7&+. 1,1 '

'22 &1'1, 2"'1,%)0%/)0=/) =)&& &"2 '&0&2"0" "&1&""2&& ' "'&"

"2 #"

$'&9# ( )'.''&' ( (

0&/+

".'&

#&&"#& $.& "

& ',&' "# &""2* (

0 0 < ",.&& &EC#2"&'&"22 ,"2&#&&" &

& D&" &" & ( / . & "# &" &"+##"&"'

",1&.'( /##

& <#&&" < +,"2&1.&& & "# &".''. " ". ''2&&&&' '

6.,. .", $ ' #" + 2" & '&0 1 ##" '& !"&+$.$"22 ,## 9, &"2 "# &"( &"&'0 #"'&3"(7 "#$ 2 ,&&&"&"2 "# &".'' "&, '

"2 '## ( 3"& "2&##

'&"& 0."

#&## &", " (

1' ' " 2"&#& + ' ,", &",& "'( /" &+ & &&& '&A &"'&9 # " "&"2 ', ,& &"&#&"2

&+,7'1"2&"22',1 0& 'B'

&3 ;F(=1,"& &&# "2 '&0

# && #"& & '#"++ (&3 22'1& GB(;F< '#"

' " " .& & "2 &

"&',&&&"22',1 . &',"&& '"'0 2"&"2 "& '&" 2 & &1,"2 ( ( ?

&&&#9, ,& "2&"22',1 ."&."9,

"'&" ' . "& + 9, ' " ' &" . #& +$ & "22',1 '12" &",& ",1 ( & 22'1& 2& "&''&&&',&"&" $ '

"2"8@@ ''&"&" $ & "

'"& &"22', 1 '&"&,+"2&1 ",2"&"##"

'0'&". "&" $ &.&& '&( &",.

+@ &'&" ,&$ "

B&"+& '+ &$ "

'"&+

&&'"$& #"&(='" "&"'#"

$ 21""2& ' , & & ( +&& 0& 1B'8 +, *F 0." +&&'

22'1&GB(*F < &&,& ."9,4'!" & &" !"#$ ,' ""9 2&&& #"&'#&&"2&

"#$'&&1 A &" +2

$1"

1'&

( "

B&"0''&&'&& "&$ .&

"2& '&(&+,7 0." "

'1 &". ,&&&&2 & $"2 &##,&"&.&

+"B&"

'#"

&# &" '+&9. #9,&"22', 1 "&"' '(/1' '' '+$& ," +&&'( ''&"&"& ",&' "1 ,"

1' #"' '+$& 0&$1#"' '1' "#$"2 *0 "#$"2 &# 0 "#$"2 "1$""2&"22',1 '

"#$"2#"& ' &" >!(;(!(

'" & 2

$ ""+"&'& "2& '& " "&&& 3"( 7&+,. &'+$&#"

'" "# &""2 1 &,&" &#&"2 & 2" ,& '&( + "2

> $ 1' 0 & /+ $ " & + "2 ,

."9 '

"@ & ,1 & 2', && & . "2 "&+&"$ , , (/"&" $ &,","&"' "

'"&1#"

+ $ & #&' && " 1 . #9' " & "'

" ' &" 9+ 9,#9, ,& . &"&. "''+$

" & 9 & (" "., , . # '+$(/2"0& 2',"2&/+ &""

'&"&" $ '1.

" #" + 2"& '&.

'2"'.",( %' " 2"& "#$ 2'&"

&"&$

!"#$ #%$"&!+$& #B !"&0 . & . "+ 1' && A &" "2 "&+&"$ , , .+"&#& 1"

1'& '&'&"

', ,&'1,'&&. . 2"

".,& 9'"

2 & +&&+&'&"& 9'10+ & &"'1"2 2" 1,'1 1 $', ,& $( / @',& '" "& # & "#$ 2" 1"

" ( & $""2& '&&'& '& A &".&&"& 9"2&9,## "2 "&+&"$, , ( &"0& 1"& '$1' &&,'(

'$"+ 1'0 0." "

'+#"&&.&

2" & ''"&,& &&& "''&&,'(/ .&

B'+$& . "&# &&& #"&'

& &"$ "&"2 1 ( &. 2"& &" ".&&& "22',1 . "&#9'"&& '#"&""2&"'"

&&&#9, ,& .+ 9,"2&&&

&# &"$ '+&9&" &&&1 ","&"'

..'+"& 1 1,+#9'"&"'( + "2 1' 0&# "2 "&+&"$, , "&+

&'( / @',& '" "& " &" # "2 & ##

& 7 "#$$( &"&'0&##

& < '2'&"

@',&#

' >"2 >1,&& ' '0' ''"(>( +$!""'&6 "2& !"&.&. "+ 1' '-

() ) * +, - # $

. # $

/ # $

01%

)

!2#$3 45&

/2"02',"2&/+ "

3"( "'2'

' ''21""2& ', && "

',&&6.,'''"&"1

'&0'&", , "&#&"2 . #9, "2&"22',1 "&& '"'.&"&$' &"0 . ".'+$ #"'&3"(' '.& #"'&3"(( F&,'&"2',"

3"(01' &"2.

+,121""2 3"( '', & 3"(0&/+ '"+ 1'&&&+. "

',1 ''

22 &1'1, GB(* 2"'1,%)0%/)0=/) =) 1 ' # &" ( ( ' & "2 2&

&2 & GB(*0 & "22',1 . 2&&"+# '#&" >(

( ?&" #& GB(* ' &,&&&. 1 '2"&#"'2" (

( &"

(

( 0&&.$&. "&1&""2& ' "'&" "2 & #"

$+$ 3"( '2"&#"'2" ( (

&">( ( ( '""& $ "&"'22.&& /+ &&,'( F ' ',

3"(0&/+ .

&,& A& "2 "# &" ' &", &9 && & ' ' .

#"#&""2/ 9&="

+&''"& #&& "&&""2 & &&. ,* ( 0 <#"&0. . 2" & "&&& '2 '&"#"' & 1& "'

#&,&" '# "22&' , #'&"."9

& ((/' '. &9&"+ 9

' #&' "& $ ".

'&"+* ( 0 <(//+ . @ &2' '", "' '""& $ "&"'22.&&/+ && ,'(/,"2&' '. &9&"+$ (//+

'''' C"2& "&".'

2&#"

# & (=".10&

".&", ' 1."2&"&$ 3

!4#6$

#%$! & 1& &$0 C"2&"& &"+'''

&".'

2&#"

# & (:",&&&"& $ ""2&' '

&9 * ( 0 H0 I* ( 0 <(4#,1.&+ "2'#'& 0&/+ . @ &2'9,'' &""2 <& &".'

# " ' 1,B# "2&' '(:",&&& '#' $"2 " "&&"* ( <#"&0

'#' $ " "&&"* ( B I* ( 00 <( //+ ' &# "2 >0. 9#, 1.&,"2&' ' +#"# $ '(:",&&& "# &"#$+ " "&&"* ( 00 B >I 00 <( //+ ,&'* ( 0 < 2 B# * ( 0 <&".'

"2 " "&'* ( 0 < "

"2 "1 ' 22 &"( =".10 1. "2 & &" "2 &"&$ 3

#0&

&& '&",& "# &"' "1&" '

(( * (

0 <" "&"2 "

"2 &&0* ( 0 <&".'

"2 " "&'* (

0 < 2 B# 0&"& * (> 0 <(/ &"& "# &" " "&&"* ( 00 H> 0 I0 0 <( //+ .'' "# &""2* (

0 0 <( / '&"* (0 0 <( 1."2&+"1'

+2"'&"+, &$"2

', , .", $#9,"2 &"22',1 "&"'.&"&&9,

$# &"$

0 +,'10 #"'&3"(+,". ' #"'&3"(+, "2&"22',1 @"& $'

$ + &"#$& "# &""&(/ "#$ + &"'2$ #"'&3"( '.&,'&" + &$&"

#$ "# &"&"& "1"

&""2&& '

"'&" "2 & #"

$ + 2"' &" + &( &"0& "

"1'&+$&/+ &&&. "2 "&+&"$, ,

"+ & '( &"0 & & & .'' E C #

".&", '(/ ."

'+&& '&",&& & E>( C#2"&'&"22 ,"2& #&&"&

D&""2&"&"2* (0 0 <( &"& + '0&' &" .&,'&" "2 "# &""&&"

&'"'2'#"#"&"& $( F& "'2 &" 0+"&& &'#& $

".'(

(( )'$* 6@ +,,--./012

/ +,,--0-34 /