← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3884/2015disposed of

Icici Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd Chandigarh v. Parminder Kaur And ORS

2017-11-30Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar16 pages



     !   

 "#$ %$&'(')* 

+ ,-."/%$)$/"0)(1/")&$ -2")3,#%4")%'5"/4 22$00")# 6$/(1(

"/-')%$/7"1/")%#4$/(  $(2)%$)#( /"-* )8.0$/ 1(#'&$ "9.'/:$4/";"#

/$($)#* 



           

       



!  "#  



$ % & 

'  



( <<<

"9.'/:$4/";"#= /"0 

>

 ) 

*

#



  

 +#



,+ -!

 -. / 

#



#  )

 +#



,+ -!

 -. 

  " 

 

?>

 )      

  

       +#



,+1-$2!

1-$2%



/ 

#



#  ) +#



,+1-$2!

1-$2% 

  " 

 

>

 )   



,-     3%34$3!(   

 







##

 ! )

0 0

+ "

# 

% #



 0  

 

"#)0+    5 6

7+

+#

 $ )0 

#

#



!4!3$338 0 933  

    :



"  ;  +0

 

 -3!-43$$ #' 

+ 0

0+

+

<

  

+

<



 0 $%3 0+

#0+1+1 <

+ /

 

0+

 

 0+  0+

  =>" 

#

+

 



 0+ 

 )

 

0+

 + +  



 + +

++#0?

0

+  

 

 & "@  1+

 # #

+ )

#

 0  #



 

#

 0 

 

#

 

 



 #

 

 

A9

  #



@"  



 

 B  

 #5B 6 @

C!A!3%42-

+#<+ #

1+ 

,

 < #

1 44A$!3A2-

+#

# +

+

# 

  

#

+

+  

#  #

  



 

 

1!(33" # % 1

! $ #

  #

0



 

 #

 





 

  0  0+ 7+



          / 1   

   

 #

# #

  )

#

#



 A 1

% #

+ "

#       

  #

*

     #   0

  

!

 

 

 

 

#





 # 0+ 7+

+ # 



 

?

# 

 #

#

  (      4



  

 )0+   0+ 7+



0++



+

 

)

 

 

0     

  

#     



 

     

+ "

# 0

#* #







. D

#





0C8A89(2-

+#) #0 )0+ 0 *



 + E #

 

 0 #

0

 



 

#+0  # 





0#



#+

 



#

+  #    

#

 

0

B 

#5B 6) 

#0 )

+  "

#  



0

 "

  



0

+ "

#  "

#



+  "

# 

 

0

B  + 

  2  

-

+   "

#      <    

0 

 

B    

 

  # #

#

  

0 # 0 #

0

  

#   9 @   

  + 0



 

 0

    0+ 







#   # -"

# 

)0+ 

0 *



 +

?

  +

!2A )



+ 

 7+ #



0C8$4!3F

 

 #+ 

!% 0 @

 

 0

C!$3%8%35C8$4!3G!%6))0+  #+ 

 #< '

0A4

 + #

 +)

 #

1((%93.932-0 

 

   1!333332-

 

 +#

 2#

   #

1!(33332-0 

 

  



/+  ,   

0 1$(3332- @ 

#

1((4((.932-0 <

#

)#



0 0



1(4((.932-



-# F+  ' 

1#

#

1(33333332-



  



   

)0+ 

+ "

#   

<#

#

0 #0 

,

 0 8 D +

  

-

+  "

# +0#

  0  

  

# #

#



)

 # + # #





<0+ 

00







 ,   

+0#

 



  

0   

# #



# B 



 +0 

 

++

#



 +0



#  

  +0#

0   

# ,

+

 + 1(33332-#





 +0

1(33332-#

) 0+

 #   +

@

E0+# "

    

   

  



  ) , 

       7+

+#

 

#+  0 

0+

.

) 0+

#    +

@

 

      ! " #  $%  & #  '

( 

  , 

      

 0  



+

      

  

 

+





,  +0 

$2%  

!2A 0)0+ ) + 

    +

 #

<

  

<

D!0

 @ 

 #

D!

+0#

  



  

, #

  

#



#

0



0 



   +0#

 

#

 

 ##

 +  #  

'



+0#

0    

#

  ,#

 

  +#

 0  $338

?

0$338<0   

 # #

   

     +0#



+ 







+

0 , 0 0 @

H0+#"

 )   * 

#  $%&  $       +0#   

+ 

# #





 #0

0 



0 #   

   

+0# 0

+  



#

 !3?

 



2#

+0#



0 + 0

     #  ) #0  

0

+ "

# 



 # "

0

+  #0 #

 





2#

+0#     #  I 0   #

 #  

  

#  7+ #

0> +0#

 0

       

    

  

  #      

+0



<0+  



 I  #



# 

 *   

 # 

0 00  @  

   0 



 +

>



+

@

 )   +  (,

  ,((

'

    



@

H0+#"



    !" #  $%

 & #  '

(   <

 

 #  I <

  B    



+ 

 +

  

<  0 

  

      



+0#

  0 0 0 *



 +  < 

  

# 

   < #

0,  +#

 0

  ,



  0  

 + 0 

 

#+





 #

#

@+ 

0

+

@

- 

.*/" # 0%0)  < @

   

# 



# 0

# #

)



0 #

# #

 

  

0+



 +

+

"

1)2*0 334 5  # 6

## $%0   

   #

 )"

 

 +#

 +0 

 

 #

  #   #

            



+

"

3)   ,

 ,   !4"   <





 0 

0  

 0 



#+

    

 +0   +#



 !!)





  

?

 

-  









<



+0# #0+    

 0    

      

 -

     # #

 

 +/ + 

"

1)2*0

43  !  "  " #   $  %    '

(  

   <      *

< +0





#   *

-   

,+ # 

 



7++   

#

 #

  

0+

    

    

   +  0  

 

<



+

@

3 )"5  3 6(    5 -   7)  5

8

&

8





 

0



 



 @

 0





0

 

  

  )       , #  ,# 

     







 

< 



+

@

E0 +#"

+)  +  '49  406 8    !" # ) 

 

+

 "+

0  



  *

E

E "+ @  +0#

0



0  #   *



 



0,+

#

#



 

 !$)

 

 



#







* 0





+ 

< +0#   +

@



* 

" #  $%&  $    :  

0    0    



 -# 

 +0



+ 

   +0#





0  

0

 

< 

 0



0

#

 

 

0  #

   



@+0#

+  





0

#0   0 #

 !%@



  +     0   "

   

 

  



0 +     

 #



  "

 

   # 

0   

        

  :+  

;    

 :+

; #





0 

 +    0 #



#  

  

0



+ J +

+

0



 

 # 

 



+ 

#

+ 



  

 0 0  

 0 

 

,   



 @  

0

#+



 + E #< 

  @   

 +0#

# 0  





# 

 # + ,

@

E0 +# "

 * 

#  $%;  #   @  

+  0 ,  )

"

 

+ "

#  

0+7+ 

)   0 , 



  ,+

#  + <



 

0

0 0 *





 0 , +

0+ 0 *

 

,

 +      

      +#

 

 

+  "

#    0 ,

+# 

 #

93$K  

 

0+  # #0



  0 #< #

@

* 

#  $%; #  0   



   8A89(L.4!9M9.%4.2-

+# !A  +



  # 0 0 )0+  

!2A  #

@

 3) 3      

    

-      :*

 +#0



  )  

      

    

+



0 

$2%

 #< 





 + <  # 

 

#

"

)  +





# 

-

 

# 





)

+#0





0 + 

 +

@ 

 0 @

 





 



# 

+  

     +



 



 +0+



#

 

+ ) 

    

  

   

0



  

 

 

   +

0  +

+#0

#

 0 0)0+  

!2A  !()

  

 + 0

  +

0  0  0

0 

#

"



 I +

0

+#0



) I

+

0 +0   +

"



 

@

* 

#  $%;#  0 )



+ 



 +  #*

     

?

  

  +0  #D #0



#0

  

   

 

    +       +#  )

 



 

  



+

!2A 



,   

 



 #

 9.%4.L$!9A$M4(($(2-

+# !4      +         

         #   0

  00 #

0 +



     + +



0

 

 0 ,0 + 0 "



#

0





0

  0

 



)

# 0

0

+  

0



<

 0)"

 1)2*0+ 34   0%

 5     / (

'



     

 #0 

 # 0 7+#

 J   

#

0  0





+  @ #





0

 #

+ 

)

  

 0 

 

0

+  

  !.@   

  +



    0@

* 

#  $%;#  7 0

+   

   

 

0+ 

 $(K

 0   #   

    

  )0+    

0

0

+  #  

,

#

0



0

+  

,

$(K

 0 #  





$(K 

+   

  

  #

   # 

 C  9!834   

 #





#

C9!834

+#

 

 



!9 





 #+ <  

+ #  0 





+

"

)  +

@

 * 

#  $%;#  

#+  



#0 # 0     

   

   ;#  0  

  #+ 

!% 0 0 )0+  

)

  #0



+  

  #

 

   +  

    #+    +  0 +) + 

 +

"

+

5 5+ 5 (& 

< ( 

<

+

"



 

@

  

 

    ;#    #+  +0  



+ #

@  "

 

  +0  

)#+

<  

    ;#  :0

 0 "



 

@

  

* 

#  $ %;#     0  #+   +

 

   ;#   +00



?





+

@

<0 >  

@





#+

0 "





 )



 0 "



 

@

  



 0 

 "

@ 



  !8@   #+ 

!% +00 

  



 

 

#

 #

C9!834G !%MC!34A..92-)

+ 0  0

,

1+  

#A40  0 )



,

  

1 A42-  +  



 #

+

#

 

 

#

 #

1A98.8.992- $3)



 

 +# 

  



,   0 

 

< 

+

#

  +

@



* 

#  $%;#  :  #

0





1 A33332-

 

 +# #

0



 

  



@ 

@

#





1!(3332-

 

   

 



#

  





,  +

1 !(3332- #

@

 $!



0  #







 N- !

"

  

  1A98.8.992- $ "

   

 +# 1A33332- % "

   

J 1!(3332-

 "

 

 

 ,  1!(3332- #"0*>

=?

= ?=+ @> $$)

 

   #  

0

 $%  

#



  #



0 



0

    ##

1(4((.932-

#

0 

+ "

# 

+

< #0 + # 

#

 $A)#

0  0

+  #   

 0   



 $(



0

  $4



0    )





"#)0+ #   0  # #46$-.$/=

+  : BC (4".4"

  D *

2

 - = D  0 - =