← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6136/2013disposed of

Union Of India & ANR v. Bharat Enterprises & ANR

2016-08-02Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages



       

 ! "# "$

$$ $$#"%# "%& '()

*!+,-'-.

$$$//,, 0. (1-../.!""22!3." 4! -5 ,'-.

$$$ /* "$

$$ $$##  "%& '()

*!+,-'-.

$$$//,, 0. (1-../.!""22!3." 4! -5 ,'-.

$$$ /*   

   !"

#$

.

(.$-+6 7.,!*8!

.-//,,9--//,$ (.$(-.:,!*8!

../*$"9--//,$ ;;;;;  !"

 -.*.7-,,*/+ $$ $9.

$## *#"%# "%-77< ,+* 8,8*9--//,$ (.$-+  6 7.  ,!  ,.*   ,  .  - //,,4 *-*-/.=.+-. .*+.*

,7$29=-.9..$-. .*!--...*,  $ $ -.,3/.,.,>.5 .44., "??2 97-,7$2.@.-.

,* + 79,*!- ! .

- .. 4*-*  - .9..  < ,7 $2 *  +,,    -.*. *.

-,, $ (.$(-.  :,!  ,.*   ,  .  ./*  $"

97--/.7....-//, *.3 %A-.9.*,!"??#.,7*$- .  .//,!7 -,-.7-.-.9..

.4//.-+8+./9,$,,*,+-- .9..    ,+=  ./.  -  .7  *  *    - .71.*!-..!-+.*!+-,./. -.7 **!* ..7=,, ,=*/.8.=!7 - ,-9B+.,, +--.,73%2"??#   *!  - !  .

  -   .  .  .7  -  *   *.

-,, $

-8-.*-,.* ,.-/.!//.* -//.95*-8+--..- 97 (.$,$ .-59.8=!.,8, - .7 .*- C  

     





! "# !$

!$  #

$!%&'!$ 

(!)(

!$! " $## *    & $  $+, (!  $$( 

*

 * & $               ,      '     -# $ "!

* (  *(       $  !     !  ./ 

*

(! 0# 

$!%&'1

* 0#  $#*

 1 2 3

!$

* # *

 !$  & +$ $+*#"

% *# !$* *! !*,  2 4* ! * 

,$  ( (!(  

$(!



$5  1 /,*7/,,

-.!8* --*C/+. D, *-* 1 *// 19$ -..,* *,7$2. !?2!E14./=7, * !  , *  @ $  -  .9..  +-,  ./.  - .7*, ! 8-,,+ * 03# # 6 *  2

 ! () !$!* 2

 *   "$ ,$   

 5  *" # #2 !     , *"  #(  "#      #     #*       #  -  *      5    ! #  (78(99999* #     #* !./ & 9## :6;<9 %=8699+ %:(8 (99/99 & 6## :

9> %=6999+ %:6;(<99/99 ???????????

#  #:

 (78(@99/99 ????????????1

& B @/-/.8,+-.7* *    -  .  *  -  *   9=  -  .9..!   . -9 *.7*./-.7* *-.$-..*,7@.. /=7,* -/C+. D8 * ,$ 7-8+--.9..-7./.*- .7**-.1 .7!-..!* < ,7$2-.9=4*$< ,=!* < ,7$A   #"%# "%*,7$E  $##  "%!

+--..*,7$2!.,.B*$ -  - //,  . */*    -  .7* .7$ '(')*

"

   !  +,-.)/

#$ !/.*/.+ )0.,123(4+.,)3.5 6.)4 !/.*/.+ .0+*,78. 6.)4