Mandeep Singh Chhabra And Others v. State Of Haryana And Another




    
 


 



 !

"

## !! "

$"%"

!! &' !

## " !"

    !"#$%&'" #"% 

( #

"!(# )*$"

"

+, -!& !

!! ") )!

+.)))+ %/ ) )0!,+, -!& " ! )1) #"% 

( ##
)* "!!!  " &.%-! 341) ) '  &  5%"

 &   )678 !1)77)1974 "! % "-! "3:4#+;1;+398698
! .-!! + +

.  <!

..!

"% "5%! - "" & 0  "" &- 0 0"!

"

 &- &, - '0%!%.

- "!!7):)1917=>% #1?)

5%"! <" ! "! '- 0.!#" !

 )1    !

  ,"! !   - 00-  !

 )   <,+  <!

 !

!,!  &"-! ."+&..'!

!",!"!!.0! '" .,!

!""%!+< "!& 0!

- 0 0") !

"" &!

"0+!

!! ", *  ! < & " %! '' !- !%!  &!

" - "< %.  &%!.>-" %" & -"" &!

 %!!

%"+!

 5%"! ..!

"% "5%! - "" & 00'

 5%"

!

!"! &/%"!-) " %!, "!:)77)1917-!! !"!

 & !


..5@%!' "!!& -  "!!0!"+"

- ! & !

 %!!


..5@%!' "!!<"." -! ! "!" !)
%"%-! !

"0+.
+ "!  !!11)71)1917! !

" %!)A!

 !"

"." >   ."!!0!" &- 0.!"!B%+--%"@!! " 



+0!

 /

-   C)71)1917  .   <!

 "!!0!  &  
 /  

 -    76)71)1917) !

"" &!

"!!0!"+.
+  "

- -.%!

 !!

!!"!

!!

,!!  - 0 0", .%!.'!

!!

"  !

--%"!

"!

-"    !

!  !! "@--%"  ,   !    -.   -.0 &&!

"-")
 , .- %".& !

!"+%"!

-  !

 !"! '.
+ )  %". &"!!%! ' ,"  &!

341) ))< %. "

<!

!!



 %!0'0*"%-  "+"0' -""'!

,&&-!! ' %!

"  ! ,! %" &!

 -""

&' %!  !

<"! "-%!

" &/%"!-)-! ;19) )) "5%..'.,!& - "! +< "- "!

 -%& - 0 %  &!

 &&-"%!


 . )

+ B ,<!

!% & &&-".. .'- 00!! !

&-!!

! ,0- .'"!!.!

"%!+!

- !%!  &-0. "-%! < %. &%!.>-")  D . %0 %!%0  &-""-.% 
 



    

 

 B.S.Joshi and others ,"State of Haryana ,-)
+ %./)0.)

12& .. < '!

" %! %..- -" &3.*4,)%5-, -)6%7.89,-):1
+ 2 ,.!

<!

  "! , .,!

"!-""!!.!

.<) &!+ D .%0 %!Gian Singh ;State of Punjab and another
  %./)0.)++&%!

.!

<!

""%!

..<"!!. '!

%0 %!& 5%"

&!

State of Haryana ;Bhajan Lal: %.//
%++2)

87 &!

/% 0!""%(#




 

  









 








 

 !

  


"





#







   


 




 
  




$


%&'




 

  








 (







 "



 



 


 

 )*
+ ,


 
#

-

+

,


 



 


(




  
 
 

   
 !
(

"

 










 



   




 

 

 



  (


  
 -
 
"





-








 
 

(


 
 



 
 

 

(



.
-
 -


(-
 




 (










/


( 










$




  

 




  

 ( $

 (-
(
  


 






  




 

 

.
0








1 


 


(








 .



 

(-
 *


 
 
( 

 


  




 
2 

 
 
  (
 3

 (


  




 



 




 
-


  (




  
   -
   -


-


-
  



.
 

 






  (  



 (-
 




(





 





(
  




 





 


 








  (

  -
  

(


  

 -  


  


 





-




(

 





 .
 






 
 
 
 

 



# 

"


#


 
  

 
(





 






  




  











  -




 


 

 
  

  (

 


#



 




 
 

 








 
 
  
 

 


 






  


 





   

 


 
#

-

    


 








 

 


+ ,


 

-







#






 4 .' .<"!!. ' D .%0 %!.!

&/% 0!"!

"

 %!+!"!!

!< !

, !! - 0 0"+!

- !%!  &!

 - "< %. 0.' %" & -"" &!

 %! '.. < --! ' &!

!! " '5%"

< %. "-% " & /%"!-+< "0.'!

/-! &!

. ".!%-! % -! 341) )) ""%.!+!

" %!&"!

!!

-" "5%.'&.."

<!

!

0 !0!""!!. '/%-.-!" -+

 )678!1)77)1974 "!%"-! "3:4#+;1;+398 698
! .-!! + + ..!

"% "5%!

 - "" & 05%"

5%!

!! " !

""

&!

- 0 0")

.""! "'!

!!

!""

..0 % '

!0"- ! " &!

- 0 0"!

"!!0!"- 

& !

- %! . <)

!! "!".. <) 
 #"% 

( #    #$<"

 .%-*'

!

"* @" ( "@ !

  ! .( "@