High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6264/2017disposed of

Pala Ram & ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2019-07-22Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi4 pages

"#"$"%"

&'$(

&& $( )$(*( +&"&,"$-"

&'$(

(. &(

$( &

"0('"0('1"& ,$&'.&& $(

/$ + "0('# "$-"

/$ + "#2"1"&,$$(.

"#$%&#"' %'() *+)%, #"- / 45, !

$ &' $"( ( % & &'$ / ( "##2 "

$(. &( &5"$$&&.#" $$%"(&$($1$$$ 6,$&'.*&-%%(( $ 5 !

7 884, &'.$( &2$&.&& &'.$"-$2'''"(6 %" 6-&'.&& $((&'"&$& (691 &&'$(. &( && $.#"&'.&& $(2'"$2$0 9 "#-2"9(2&'&'("% (&,%.#-("

&'-('*#6"##2& *&##&'$9*#"$ %.#-("$".. &"9" (&&'.(& 2''&'-"$2$0

*$&'$.$"-$'"(6 %"6-&'.&& $(&'"&2 , !

8&' $(2''"1('"$9&'$*&('"1 &6 $#"(&'$

("#"$-

:"$ * (# ,$ $(. & 3 "$9*( &'"& &' $( 2$ 2$0 9 "#- 2"9 6"(( "

&'*9' &' $%% "& 2"(%"&&'91& &9$"

&&("..$1"#& * &'% ($16*& ( "%,$2"$,$%&'91& &'$ ".& 9&'$%% "& $# 9&'("% (+&"& & 9$"

&&'"..$1"#&'($1(,&'.&& $(2$( *

:"$ * (#,$&'.&& $(1'% &#-"$9*(&'"& &' .&& $( "$ 6 9 $.#" 6- "

&'$ (& , "#- 2"9( %.#-(2'' 2*#91""*(,"& &&'.&& $(& "..$"'&'(*$&

(&'/* ."#%%&&"$" 9"$'(&$&%6"#"

;$(. 3'"("#$"-$%% &'"(,$&'9$"

&, <& ( ,($1,&'"#-2"9(%.#-( &'/* ."# %%&&"

&'("$%% "& ((&##. 9 ($"&

2&' &' 91& &'$,$ $(. & $&$ $6"

:"# ( "$-"

" ( $& & &"0 "..$.$"& ( &' $%% "& 2'''"(6 ( &6-&'/* ."#* #,$&' 9$"

&,<& ( ,($1(,&'"#-2"9(%.#-(2'"$ 2$0 92&'&'/* ."#%%&& :&"

"..$.$"&( &'$%% "& (%"6- $(. 36&"0 6-$(. 2&' ".$,&'$ % &'(,$%&'$.&,$&,.-,&'($$ 7'"&1$(

(&"0 6-&'$(. ('"##6 1-&&'/* ."#

%%&&2'&'$",&$2## ,$%&'.&& $("6*&&'("%( &'"&&'-"

"1"#"..$.$"&$%-"9" (&&'("% "(&' ("$((

7&'$9"$&&'#"%,&'.&& $(,$9$"

&,("#"$- , !

8&'$("(.*&6&2 &'."$&( :"$ * (# ,$&'.&& $("$9*(&'"&&'.&& $('"16 **(#- 2$0 9 &'*9' &'$ %9'& & 6 "

- 9$"

& ,$% &' %.& & "*&'$&- '(""1$% &(%"6-&'#"$ * (#,$&' $( &'9$* &'"&&'.&& $('"16 %"$0 9&'$ "&& "

&'6%&$$$ :"$ * (#,$&'.&& $( (&"&( &'"& "( &' "&" ,$% &' %"(&$ ($1$ ( 6&" &' & & 2'''"(6 $"( 6'"#,,&'.&& $(&'"&&'- "$ **(#-('"$9 9&'$*&(6*&(&##"$ &6 9.",$ &'("%2##6.$1

:"$ * (#,$&'$(. &((&"&(&'"&&'"&",$% &'%"(&$($1$2##6.$( &6,$&'.*&-%%(( $ %6"#" 5 !"

(""&"2##6('2 &&'.&& $("#( 2'"

"#("..$"'&'.*&-%%(( $ &'(""& "(&'.&& $("$"6#&.$( &&'$*% &(

(*..$&,&'$#"%&'"&&'-'"2$0" "$ &&#,$&'("#"$- &'"&"#(('*#6.$( &6,$&'.*&-%%(( $ &' (""&2'",&$"(((( 9&'"&"&"=*% &(2##"(& 2'&'$&'.&& $(2$('"$9 9*&($ &"

"$ &&#,$ ("#"$-,$"

-.$ .*&-%%(( $ $(. 52##

."(("

"..$.$"&$$2&'$9"$&2'&'$&'.&& $("$ &&#,$("#"$-"

-.$,$2''&'-'"1('"$9&'$*&( $ & "(,$%&'"&"&&$"

(.$(&'"&&'.&& $("$2$0 "

,$&'"&.&& $('"1 &6 $#"(("#"$-"

"..$.$"& $$6."((6-&'.*&-%%(( $$& 9$(. &$#"(&'("#"$-,$&'.$2' &'.&& $('"16 ('2

&6.$( & &'"&"6*&'"1 &6 .",$&'("%.$ '( $& &$(. 36-&'.*&-%%(( $('*#6,$ $#"( 9&'("#"$- "&%6* %"

>. 9 12 &' "61 #"$ * (# ,$ &' $((&"&(&'"&'( &2('&.$((&'.$( &2$&.&&

-,*$&'$

'.$( &2$&.&& ((.(, &'",$("&$%(

/ ! 0

1! !

( 7'&'$(."0 9=$"( (= 7'&'$ .$&"6# (=