United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Saroj & ORS









 


 





  



  



 




 



     





! "

 $$%% 



 


 ! 
"
  
#

$
  

 %




 




  
 &


 

   

&'#%() %* ! "

 $$%% 


 '
! 
 ! 
"
  
#$
 

 !

 "#$%& !'()'*+ &!&," +**% !&," +**%-( +#*# %%*$




## ,( # 

    $ -.

#   ""*  /% * +*-( %! '$

 * #  0 %0 )#-. "$

* #  -  * ,   

#  1  2 #*   #*"(%  ""*

2$% " #*  *, *,#   34 

 (   #  ,%*,  * *,  #*"%  # 5( - *,&

676 !* -.

2#

+# +*-(  *"  

 3! 46 $  #!  38 )  ( ( $$"

! ("

 ) $ %9$ $ (% *$%*

"$( %$". (  3!

!

46: * *!  !!46 ) %" *(!  3!46 ) ( % 9$!  3!46 ) $ *!% (*,

!46 )  $

* #  -  2*, 

% "$

 !3!

46 +#$ *# %%- #;:( "/$ .<

#"%  "*%* ."





/(% #*( ""$ .#  *%=( ( "$

*$* *%. #,(+#* (-** -. "(%*

 *%. #" # %%- % %  )$ . 

! 46$ # *%% ,($ (

* #" *3 . !  $ .

-%   *%.   ( & .

/$

 *

" # >$   >"  ?  @$%. (%! *# ;

(%<*%* -% -("



"$

*
 #*$($!##  A(, &0-%



"

 #$" !


%&'
(#
)*#*
)*"+
 '
&* "#,
-./

-

/
1 +#"(-** -."(% #/$ .*

#  #"  * %* !#)(%#  ** -     $*3.  B #-( #+*-( %# %%) (% *$%*

"$( %$".:

*( # ,(

"$

**%* -% - -. $$%.*,$%* (% *$%* # (-**  -. "(%  # /$ . *

),%. %%)-* *" **"( ($$"

9 38  + -*, # #* " *! *  * ,(

" ,(% $%. #'

& .

) 

3.  ,

*

#!("#*" *$**-%*

#%*,# A(, &<-% )+&
)"


( "+
 '
&* "#
( "#$#


" #2"&
"2"& 
 '
 &* ",

-/


-

/
33 /(% $ # "% !  # " .! )(% (,

 "*

 ,  -. *, %  $". #- *  . #" -( #("

*

   . "

  - 9"%(  "$( *, "$

*  #(-** -."(%*

"$

( "  * %# # "  :# # "(% #$ *!$( #$ $6-2

#" /(% #"% #  *$(

 *%. " )*%%"* "$

*

" *%% #" 

*

,3. &0-% :* *)*#*
)*"+4#
!#  ($  #  #%

. -*  *  -.  *%.   "  $%.& .

?  ( (%# %%-("



#"$

( # 1#*"%"

!

/(%  #"% #  *$(

 *%. #" )(%- $ *%  )$ .*

! 46 $*3.  B #

*%% 

* 3 .   ,  $  *" "

" !B! 46&) !$( % #A(, )(%   %

#$9/( #    #*(

#  (%  9 *, *

"  *%. " $%.- *

9* "! *%.)(%# - % $* #9 38  #%  )$ .$ #

%$* **% )! #$* . -*

*% -%  *%. " $%.  -% ("

*"$( *,%$".+#* #*," (,, *  # "

* * "$

*

"(

(%!  *%.   * -*, $ * $* *%% ,  ($ (

*

# (% 3   #  (% $"**"

%%. *  *%. $*  $  % (% C # "*"(

"! * "

 ("

# 9 !B! 46 * %%)! (%   )(% $

 $A(*"* %%. , * # "%  "

(*, %  $* .-* )#*"# *%."  % #



# *%% ,($ (

*)#*"#"

* #-$**

(% #A(, &<-% #$ **  # 1#*"%"

$ **,"$

# *"

* *%. * - % %,*%

* )* # )"* %-A"

"#*  : *) - !* *9$* * #*  A( *"

%.38 .  - $ *   *%.  # *"

* )(% - ("

 ( "$

 &<-% * $&&++
 '
&* "#
0#
5%
"6 

''6
 '
 &* ",
.-/
 
-

/
..,
 * A(, #&*,#/( $ $%* (% *$%* # ( # #%

 * -"  $"**"     *"  "! +*-( %  # /( #(% $$%. $%*  (% *$%** ( * "(

 #(% $$%. (% *$%*  $ "**  #* /(  * # "

  )+&
)"


( "+4#
!#
-#$2"/, )"

'

 '
&* "#
0#
  7 8 " : 79#
6
)$ '"+


 #$" !

+2 6
+ & '
 '
 &* ",
.

-)/
!&<-%

 * #$%* (% *$%* $ -. #&*,#/( : # *"

! " 3. 

* ""* #+*-( %#  $$%* (% *$%*   -( # &*,# /( %%) %  $".

!

 #* ).   #- ". !%.38

( %*")

2* "*

"$( %$".

!346:5 
7'*$#$'*
 '
&* "#
0#
'+

#&"&  "
 '
 &* ",
-/

-

/
3
-)/! # &*,# /( (" # "$

* ,  -. % +# $%*  (% *$%*

$  -. # &*,# /(  )   * )* # # -

*

&*,#/( * (" #""$ $%* (% *$%* - 

#(% *$%*(-. #+*-( %)* #( *"%*, . /6 *

 D"#  #* /(  * *
"

&
 #$" !

+2 6
0#
)+&
"

+:&
 '
 &* ",




'

'

'

3 *  ""$ # A(,  # /6*

 D"#  ;

"
5$"
0#
7 < '

"
) 8*
 '
&* "#,

11


'

'

'

. )#* $%*  (% *$%* ) %%)  +# A(, *)+&
"

+:&
 '
 &* "=#
!# ($ ) "# %%, -.) .$ *$"* %% $$ %-&0-% #'($ /(  -( # $"* % %  $ * )  **     **,  #* /(  ,

*, $% # *( " "$ . $$%. $%*  (% *$%*# - * : #  " *( A(, -. &<-% "(% #*( ""$ .#  *%  "* . A(,  #%*,  #)*! *  * **"(% ""$ " *  # *( " "$ .

  )#*%

$ *,(% *$%*

**-% ,- "2 3 33. * )+&
)"


( "+4#
!# ($ 

 +# $$ % *% -. # /$ . * $ %. %%) *

 * 


3>


+# +*-(  *"  

 3! 46 #- * $ .E(! 

%"

* .%*$ @9

9"%(*, !46("

) ?
! 46  ?($ :( " '"#

46  ""(    # *"%% ( #   /(%  # *( " "$ . *   * $* A( *.("

*  46( , .

! 46 E(! 

'*" #("

)(%# -

*% -% $ . #" ! # "

 -9"%( #$($ "$( *,%$".C #"*"(

"!*" " *

2

! 46$ #* B!3!46$ (  *, %  $".  +# +*-(  *,# %. %%) ("

* $ %9$ #" 
 #" 3 . %

* ""* ! "% # %% - % -* *" **"( ( $$"

* *)("*

*% *)-.&<-% *
)+&
)"


( "+4#
!#
-#$2"/
+#" **E(%. 

+ 2*,* "*

*"9$ 

9* #""* "* %.   !!46!

-%*")(%-  !3!46

#

 8

9%* -*%* . "  !346    ("

9   $ % 9$!*"

*% -%%$"."  !3!3 46 (   !3!46   $$%.*, (% *$%* 

! %  $"."  ! 3!B46F  !3!469

G

 /$

-. #+*-( %%" *(

# )*)! ( % 9$   $

* * *  +# +*-( %#   3!46 ) $ *!% (*, * $$$*

) %

 !!46*

%%  "

#"#*%! -# =( %%. +

%"$

** !!B46 : *) - !"$

*$ .

-% #"% "

!

B46F !!B466 ! !

4638("

) "$

*

" (%

%.!"$

-.

% * (" # 9 !3 46   !3!

46 6

!

B46 : "

 # *( " "$ . # % . $ * "$

#"% !* # %%"  #9"  "% -.*%*, $$%*"

*- #+*-( % +# $$ %**$*  * 
) 7
3,
3













- 5
7%/
;>?(%

*<














H# #$ 2*,4 

.4 H# #$

-%

.4