National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Sunita And ORS

  
     

 !"#

$%& '&()*)+, 
 

     

  

", - ." / /  .

0&*&+%, "0/$+'&&1/20)3'4($%& 0%5&$11&66$+%  $7&*5 )+'$6  5$66&+8&)+%5&10&*&+%$11&$6)*%%5&$9$0' %5&"%0 (()'&+%6$):*0);2+$63 5)9$+) 0*50%3-%5&0);2+$6-#395&0&;<+ $((2+%    :%0  4&5)(26$0  $(()'&+%3  $:)6<  %5& '&(&$*&'  5$*  ;&&+ 80$+%&'(:1&+*$%)+ +%5&($*&)+5$+'3"2=&*53959$*> <&$0* $8&$%%5& %):& $(()'&+%3')&'$*$0&*26% 0$'$(()'&+%+  %9$* (6$):&'%5$%5&9$*90=)+8$*$:$*+$*9&66$*$80)(26%20)*%&$0+)+8 $;2% 
3?@1&0:+%55&0);2+$6395)6&$**&**)+8%5&:+%56< )+(:&$% 
>3A?@$+'$'')+8B+$((2+% 2%20&10*1&(%*$+'

%5&0&$ %&0  '&'2(%)+8  ?>%5 +  $((2+%    1&0*+$6  &C1&+*&*3  $'')+8 (:1&+*$%)+  +  $((2+%    6**    (+*0%)2:  $+'  80$+%)+8  2+&0$6 &C1&+*&*$9$0'&'%%$6$:2+% (:1&+*$%)+ 
 33>?@%)*%5)* $9$0'395)(55$*;&&+):128+&';<%5&+*20$+(&:1$+< .&$0+&'(2+*&6 0%5&$11&66$+%*2;:)%%&'%5$%%5&0&)*+ :$%&0)$6+0&(0'%*59%5$%'&$%5 "2=&*59$*+$((2+% %5& $(()'&+%)+D2&*%)+&')&'$%5:&5&0&9$*+1*%@:0%&:0&10%0 :&')($6&4)'&+(&)+*2110%%5&0& & 20%5&0*2;:)%%&'%5$%)+(:& %5&

  '&(&$*&'  5$*  ;&&+  %$=&+  9)%52%  %5&0&  ;&)+8  $+< &4)'&+(&  +  0&(0'
20%5&03$'')%)+ B+$((2+% 2%20&10*1&(%*9$*2+@($66&' 0$* %5&)**2&5$*;&&+0& &00&'%6$08&0 &+(5;<+-;6&%5&/210&:&20% &  20%5&0  *2;:)%%&'  %5$%  %5&0&  )*  ($6(26$%)+  &000  )+  %5&  $:2+%  

(:1&+*$%)+$9$0'&'3$*B 
>3A?@926'(:&% 
3>>?@3 95&0&$*%5&0);2+$65$*%$=&+%5&*$:&$*
3 ?@3$*$(+*&D2&+(&

95)(5%5&0&)*$')

&0&+(& 


3AA?@  %&05&$0)+86&$0+&'(2+*&6 0%5&$11&66$+%3'+% )+'

$+<:&0)%)+%5&*2;:)**)+*:$'&5& $(%%5$%"2=&*5*2

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

<&$0*$ %&05)*'&$%5%5&09)*&$6*3%5&6)+=

'&$%5 "2=&*59)%5%5&$(()'&+%)*D2)%&&4)'&+% 0:%5&:$%&0)$6+ 0&(0'3+$:&6<3%5&$(()'&+%+  3:&')(@6&8$6&C$:)+$%)+)+ &+&0$6*1)%$63 5)9$+)+%5&*$:&'$<$+'0& &0&+(& %5&($*&

"/35%$=)+(0)%)($6(+')%)+35)*$':)**)+)+"/35%$= 0:

  %   $+''&$%5+  35&+(&3%5&(+%&+%)+0$)*&'

;<6&$0+&'(2+*&6 0%5&$11&66$+%)*9)%52%$+<:&0)%$+'0&7&(%&' 4&+%5&%5&0)**2&0$)*&';<6&$0+&'(2+*&6 0%5&$11&66$+% )*%;&+%)(&'$+'0&7&(%&''2;%3%5& $:)6< %5&'&(&$*&'(6$):&'

%5$%5&9$*&$0+)+8
3?@1&0:+%53;2%*%)66%5&0);2+$65$*:&0&6< %$=&+5)*)+(:&$% 
>3A?@1&0:+%5395)(59$*&4&+6&**%5$+ %5& :)+):2:9$8&* $*=)66&'6$;20&0$%%5$%%):&&9$*:$)+%$)+)+8$

$:)6< *)C1&0*+*)+(62')+85):*&6 35&+(&3$**&**:&+% 5)*:+%56< )+(:&;<%5&0);2+$6($++%;&*$)'%;&+5)85&0*)'&

 *0&8$0'*$'')%)+ B+$((2+% 2%20&10*1&(%*)* (+(&0+&'3 +'2;%%5&:$%%&05$*;&&+0& &00&'%6$08&0 &+(5;< +-;6&%5&/210&:&20%3;2%6&$0+&'(2+*&6 0%5&$11&66$+%5$*+% 0& &00&'%$+<72'8:&+%*59)+8%5$%&$06)&072'8:&+%*+%5&)**2&$0&+% %;& 669&'%)66*2(5%):&%5&0& &0&+(&)*'&()'&' *0&8$0'*($6(26$%)+&000)+$**&**:&+% (:1&+*$%)+)* (+(&0+&'3%5&%%$6&

&(%&4&+$*1&0%5&($6(26$%)+:$'&;<6&$0+&' (2+*&6 0%5&$11&66$+%)* 


3AA?@5&$11&66$+%3) *$'4)*&'3($+ *&&=(00&(%)+ %5&($6(26$%)+&000;& 0&%5&0);2+$6+6<
0%5$%3 $11&$6($++%;&&+%&0%$)+&')+%5)*(20%$*+6&8$6)**2&$**2(5)* )+464&'
0%5&0&$*+*:&+%)+&'$;4&3'+% )+'$+<:&0)%)+%5& 10&*&+%$11&$65&*$:&)*3$((0')+86<3')*:)**&' )*:)**$6 10&*&+% $11&$6  9)66  +%  5$4&  $+<  ;&$0)+8  +  %5&  $11&$63  )  $+<3  )6&'  ;< %5& (6$):$+%* $7&*5 )+'$6#  2'8&

 :=